Amish Country Bakehouse

For many residents of Pennsylvania, the allure of fresh, homemade baked goods, especially those rooted in traditional recipes, is undeniable. In Carlisle, a true local gem bringing this experience to life is the Amish Country Bakehouse. This isn't just another commercial establishment; it's a place where the rich heritage of Amish baking traditions meets the demand for wholesome, delicious treats. Whether you're craving a classic pie, a comforting loaf of bread, or a sweet sticky bun, the Amish Country Bakehouse offers a taste of authenticity that resonates deeply within our community.

This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of what makes Amish Country Bakehouse a must-visit for anyone in the Pennsylvania region seeking genuine, high-quality baked goods. We'll explore their dedication to traditional methods, the wide array of delectable items they offer, and the unique experience of visiting this cherished local business. It's about more than just satisfying a sweet tooth; it's about connecting with a culinary legacy that prides itself on simplicity, quality, and flavor. For those who appreciate the true art of baking, the Amish Country Bakehouse promises an experience that delights both the palate and the spirit.

The Amish Country Bakehouse is located at 527 E North St, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA. It's important for potential customers, especially those making a special trip, to understand the nature of this establishment based on available information. While the address indicates a physical location in Carlisle, some customer feedback suggests that it operates with a focus on wholesale or larger-scale production, potentially from a warehouse or distribution-like setting, rather than a traditional retail storefront for walk-in purchases. One review specifically mentions "enter the warehouse with truck, come to the dock. Park near the dock, and tell them. Through dock I have pickup."

This indicates that accessibility is tailored more towards planned pickups and orders, which is common for businesses that supply baked goods to various outlets or cater to larger individual orders. While it might not be a place to leisurely browse shelves, its location in Carlisle makes it accessible for customers in the central Pennsylvania area. Parking is likely designed for efficient loading, as suggested by the review mentioning parking near the dock. For locals planning a visit, it's advisable to call ahead to confirm their current operational model for direct sales or pickups to ensure a smooth and efficient experience. This setup allows the bakehouse to focus on high-volume production while maintaining the quality and tradition of their Amish-inspired recipes.

Amish Country Bakehouse specializes in a wide range of delicious, homemade baked goods, heavily inspired by their Amish heritage. Their offerings are baked daily, ensuring freshness and quality.

• Breads: They offer a variety of fresh, homemade breads, including staples like Honey Wheat, Jalapeno Cheese Bread, Pepperoni Cheese Bread, Cinnamon Twist Bread, Cinnamon Raisin Bread, and Dozen Dinner Rolls. Their bread is known for being made with the finest ingredients.
• Pies: A significant highlight is their extensive selection of pies, made from recipes passed down through generations. This includes Cream Pies (Chocolate Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream, Coconut Cream, Lemon Meringue, Peanut Butter Cream, Red Raspberry Cream, Pumpkin Cream Cheese, Pumpkin Custard) and Baked Fruit and Nut Pies (Apple, Cherry, Baked Peach, Triple Berry, Strawberry-Rhubarb, Pecan, Blueberry Crumb, Rhubarb Crumb, Pumpkin, Rhubarb). Seasonal fresh fruit pies are also available.
• Cinnamon Rolls & Sticky Buns: Their Iced Cinnamon Buns are made fresh daily and are described as melting in your mouth. They also offer various kinds of Sticky Buns, including plain, pecan, and sticky buns with nuts, available individually or in packs.
• Whoopie Pies & Cookies: Known for their fresh-baked Whoopie Pies (especially Chocolate Whoopie Pie) and homemade cookies, including Chocolate Chip, Molasses, Monster, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, and Sugar Cookies.
• Muffins: Available in both large and small sizes, with flavors such as Blueberry, Lemon Blueberry, Carrot, and Banana Nut.
• Fry Pies: A traditional Amish treat, these are also part of their diverse selection.

The Amish Country Bakehouse offers several compelling features and highlights that draw in customers from across Pennsylvania and beyond.

• Authentic Amish Heritage Recipes: The core of their appeal lies in their commitment to making delicious, homemade baked goods inspired by traditional Amish heritage recipes. This ensures an authentic taste and quality that harkens back to simpler, time-honored methods.
• Freshness Guaranteed: Their baked goods, particularly their breads and pies, are baked daily, promising customers the freshest possible product. This dedication to daily baking contributes significantly to the overall quality and taste.
• Wide Variety of Traditional Treats: From an extensive selection of pies, including cream, fruit, and nut varieties, to an array of homemade breads, cinnamon rolls, sticky buns, whoopie pies, and cookies, there's something to satisfy every craving. The sheer breadth of their traditional offerings is a major draw.
• Highly Praised Customer Service (for pickups): While the primary review refers to a truck pickup, the sentiment of "Very kind shipper" and "Very fast loading" implies an efficient and courteous service, even in a non-traditional retail environment. This suggests a professional and customer-focused approach, even if you're not Browse shelves.
• Reputation for Deliciousness: Products like their breads and pies are explicitly mentioned as being "known for their deliciousness" and customers are promised they "will not be disappointed," indicating a strong positive reputation for taste.
• Efficient Operations: The review highlights "Very fast loading" and "got leave in 30 minutes," which points to a well-organized and efficient operation, particularly for those fulfilling orders or pickups. This efficiency is a benefit for businesses and individuals who value quick service.

To connect with the Amish Country Bakehouse for their delightful baked goods, here is their contact information:

Address: 527 E North St, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA
Phone: (717) 906-3111
Mobile Phone: +1 717-906-3111

Given the operational nature suggested by the customer review (a focus on dock pickups), it is highly recommended that anyone planning to purchase from Amish Country Bakehouse calls ahead using the provided phone numbers. This will allow you to confirm their current retail or pickup procedures, place an order, and ensure a smooth experience upon arrival. Direct communication will help clarify whether they cater to individual walk-in sales or primarily manage pre-ordered pickups, optimizing your visit to this unique Carlisle establishment.

For locals in Pennsylvania, particularly those in the Carlisle area, Amish Country Bakehouse represents a unique and valuable culinary resource. While its operational style may differ from a typical storefront bakery, its profound commitment to traditional Amish recipes and homemade quality makes it an exceptional choice for authentic baked goods. It's suitable for individuals and families seeking delicious, fresh-baked breads, pies, and other sweets that carry the comforting touch of generations-old techniques.

The emphasis on "homemade" and daily baking ensures that every item from Amish Country Bakehouse delivers a taste experience that is both satisfying and nostalgic. For special occasions or simply to enjoy a high-quality treat, the extensive variety of pies, cinnamon rolls, sticky buns, and cookies provides ample choice. Furthermore, the efficiency and kindness noted in customer interactions, even in a commercial pickup setting, suggest a business that values its customers and aims for a smooth transaction. For Pennsylvanians who appreciate the rich culinary heritage of the Amish and prioritize quality and tradition in their baked goods, Amish Country Bakehouse offers a distinctive and highly rewarding experience right here in our community.

Amish Country Bakehouse

527 E North St, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA