Atlantic Bagel Co. Atlantic Highlands: Your Local Spot for Classic Deli and Signature Breakfast

Atlantic Bagel Co. Introduce

## Atlantic Bagel Co.: A Long-Standing Atlantic Highlands Tradition

For many loyal New Jersey residents in and around Monmouth County, **Atlantic Bagel Co.** is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a nostalgic hometown staple. Located in the picturesque town of Atlantic Highlands, this establishment successfully combines the functions of a **Bagel shop**, **Breakfast restaurant**, **Coffee shop**, and **Deli**, making it a versatile go-to spot for fueling up any time of day. Known for its extensive menu of freshly baked bagels and robust sandwiches, Atlantic Bagel Co. has maintained a reputation for providing quality food to its customers for years.

While the atmosphere may be characterized by the fast-paced, sometimes chaotic energy common in popular local deli settings, the core draw remains the food itself. From classic **P.E.C. (Pork Roll, Egg, and Cheese)** sandwiches to signature deli creations, the kitchen continues to churn out menu items that keep locals coming back. The variety on offer ensures that whether you're seeking a quick caffeine fix, a hearty meal, or ingredients for a feast at home, this local spot can meet your needs.

---

## Location and Accessibility in Atlantic Highlands

**Atlantic Bagel Co.** is conveniently situated at **74 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, USA**. Located on First Avenue, the shop is easy to access for both residents and those traveling through the area near the Jersey Shore.

Accessibility is facilitated by multiple parking options, a huge plus in any busy shore town. Customers can utilize the **Free parking lot** as well as **Free street parking** nearby. The business is set up to accommodate a **Quick visit**, making it efficient for commuters or those running errands. Furthermore, the establishment features a **Wheelchair accessible entrance** and **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, ensuring comfortable access for all members of the community. Inside, the shop provides a **Restroom** and options for both **Dine-in** and **Takeout** service.

---

## Comprehensive Services Offered

As a full-fledged Bagel shop and Deli, Atlantic Bagel Co. offers a broad menu that covers breakfast, lunch, and catering components, designed to satisfy the diverse appetites of New Jersey customers.

**Bagel Sales and Options**: Offering bagels individually or in bulk, including **Half Dozen** ($9.36) and a **Bagel Dozen** ($19.47). Also selling essentials like **Whipped Butter** ($6.23), **8 OZ Philly CC** ($6.76), and **Dozen Eggs** ($5.72) from the refrigerator case.

**Breakfast Sandwiches**: Features all the Jersey classics like **B.E.C (Bacon, Egg, and Cheese)**, **P.E.C. (Pork Roll, Egg, and Cheese)**, and **S.E.C (Sausage, Egg, and Cheese)**, along with a simple **Egg Sandwiches** option.

**Signature Breakfast Creations**: Includes robust specialty plates such as the **Atlantic Bomber**, **Atlantic Burrito**, **The Tradition** ($11.43), and the protein-packed **Popeye** ($11.89). They also offer breakfast **Omelets** like the **Western Omelet** ($11.36) and **Veggie Omelet** ($11.36).

**Signature Deli Sandwiches**: A full deli case and sandwich menu featuring complex specialty items like **The Atlantic**, **Beefy Blue**, **Classic Reuben**, **Empire State**, and the **Triple Threat**, alongside the standard **Make Your Own** option.

**Hot Grill/Deli Items**: Serving hot lunch options including **Philly Cheesesteak** ($9.10), **Chicken Cheesesteak** ($9.73), **Tommy Big Burger** ($8.84), and classics like **Grilled Cheese** and **BLT**.

**Sides and Snacks**: A variety of satisfying sides like **French Fries** ($4.68), **Cheese Fry** ($6.24), **Mozz Sticks 5 Pc** ($7.27), and breakfast sides such as **Home Fries** ($3.95) and **PORK ROLL 2 Pc** ($3.90).

**Bakery and Coffee**: Providing baked treats like **Coffee Cake** ($3.38), **Muffin** ($3.38), and **Croissant** ($3.12). They offer a full range of hot **Coffee/Tea** and **Cold Brew** in both small ($5.19) and large ($6.75).

---

## Key Features and Highlights

Despite challenges noted in customer service and appearance, Atlantic Bagel Co. remains a local fixture due to the quality and breadth of its food offerings and its convenient operations.

**Classic Jersey Deli**: The combination of a high-volume bagel shop with a full-service deli and grill sets it apart, offering everything from **Pork Roll** on a bagel to a hearty **Philly Cheesesteak** or a **Tommy Big Burger**.

**Extensive Signature Sandwich Menu**: The array of specialty hot and cold sandwiches, identified by names like **The #1**, **Empire State**, and **Rousing Roast Beef**, provides local patrons with numerous tried-and-true, high-quality meal options.

**Full Breakfast Destination**: Beyond simple bagels, the menu caters to a complete breakfast experience with **Signature Breakfast** platters and burritos, ensuring a filling start to the day.

**Convenient Payment and Parking**: Facilitating quick transactions with acceptance of **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments**, and providing both **Free parking lot** and **Free street parking**.

**Long-Standing Community Staple**: Despite acknowledged issues with service consistency and facility appearance in recent years, the business has successfully retained a base of **loyal customers** who enjoy the food and the nostalgia of their "hometown bagel spot."

---

## Contact Information

For placing an order for **In-store pickup** or **Takeout**, or for any inquiries regarding the menu, please use the contact information below:

**Address:** 74 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, USA

**Phone (Primary):** (732) 872-7727

**Mobile Phone:** +1 732-872-7727

---

## What is Worth Choosing Atlantic Bagel Co.

Choosing **Atlantic Bagel Co.** is a choice for authentic, well-established local flavor and an extensive, diverse menu. While some loyal New Jersey customers have expressed concern about recent drops in service speed and order accuracy, the core reason for its longevity remains the **quality of the food**. The bagels themselves are consistently praised, and the sandwiches—both the classic breakfast builds and the signature lunch combinations—are known for being substantial and delicious.

If you're a local who values a wide selection of **deli and grill options** alongside your morning coffee, and you appreciate the heartiness of a true Jersey breakfast spot, Atlantic Bagel Co. delivers on that promise. It's especially worth choosing for its robust **Signature Breakfast** items and the comprehensive **Signature Sandwiches**, which provide a complete meal. New customers planning a visit should be prepared for potential wait times and are wisely advised by loyal patrons to **dine in or double-check orders** to ensure everything is correct. Ultimately, for the taste of a classic Atlantic Highlands bagel and deli sandwich, this local institution is still the place to go.

Atlantic Bagel Co. Vibe

Soup
Chili $6.24

Signature Salads
Caesar Salad $11.89
Chefs Salad $11.89
Garden Salad $8.32
Turkey BLT Salad $11.89
Trifecta Salad $11.89

Grill / Fry
Chicken Cheesesteak $9.73
Philly Cheesesteak $9.10
BLT
Grilled Cheese
Cheese Fry $6.24
Chix Fingers 5pc $7.28
Mozz Sticks 5 Pc $7.27
Italian Hot Dog $6.97
Tommy Burger Sliders $8.84
Tommy Big Burger $8.84
Chicken Finger's $9.88
French Fries $4.68

Sides
French Fries $5.41
French Fries W/Cheese $6.50
Home Fries $3.95
Hash Brown 2pc $3.90
Sausage 2pc $4.16
PORK ROLL 2 Pc $3.90
Bacon 3 Pc $4.16
Pickle $1.82

Signature Sandwiches
The #1
The Atlantic
All American
Beefy Blue
Blazing Buffalo
Black Forest
Classic Reuben
Empire State
Hot & Spicy
Metropolitan
Paulie's Special
The Roma
Rousing Roast Beef
Sandwich Of The Alps
The Smokey
Triple Threat
Tailgate
Wrangler
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Make Your Own
Chicken Salad
Tuna
Egg Salad
Whitefish Salad

Deli Case
BLT
Chicken Salad
Egg Salad

Beverages - Refrigerator
Snapple $2.86
COKE $2.86
Can Coke $1.82
Gatorade $3.12
Water
Chocolate Milk $3.12
Yoohoo $3.64
Nesquick $3.64
Small Juice $2.60
Bai $3.64
SUNNY D $2.08
Milk $0.00
OJ $0.00
Arizona $2.60
Whipped Butter $6.23
Dozen Eggs $5.72
8 OZ Philly CC $6.76
8 OZ Temptee Cream Cheese $7.03
Vitamin Water $3.24
Gold Peap $3.76
Body Armor $3.90

Bakery
Apple Turnover $3.64
Brownie $3.38
Cinnamon Bun $3.38
Coffee Cake $3.38
Croissant $3.12
Muffin $3.38
Muffin Grill Butter $3.90

Signature Breakfast
Atlantic Bomber
Potato and egg Omelet with Pork roll on a hard roll.Quick Key Limited options.
Atlantic Burrito
Potato and egg omelet with Sausage and Pepper jack Cheese on a wrap. Quick Key Limited options.
Bambino
Potato And Egg Omelet with Pork roll, Bacon, Sausage, on a hard roll. Quick Key Limited options.
Popeye $11.89
Spinach Mushrooms Omelet with Munster cheese on a spinach wrap. Quick Key Limited options.
The Tradition $11.43
Smoked Nova Salmon, Cream cheese, Red onion, tomato, capers on a bagel.
Western Omelet Ham Peppers Onion $11.36
Veggie Omelet Pep Mush Onion Tom $11.36

Breakfast
Bagel
Individual bagels no toppings
Half Dozen $9.36
Bagel Dozen $19.47
Bagel W/
Bagel With Cream cheese, butter, specialty spreads. No egg sandwiches
Egg Sandwiches
Build An egg sandwich with al the options. Bacon, Sausage, cheese you name it!
Breakfast Meat Sandwich
No eggs here! Pork roll cheese, Bacon CreamCheese, Build it!
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Platter $6.76
No bread on a Plate. Carb Friendly Omelets, over ez,
B.E.C
Bacon Egg And Cheese, Quick Key Limited Options.
B.E.
Bacon And Egg, Quick key, no cheese, Limited options
P.E.C.
Pork roll Egg and Cheese. Quick Key Limited options.
P.E.
Pork roll And Egg. Quick Key Limited options.
P.C.
PorkRoll and Cheese. No egg! Quick Key Limited options.
S.E.C
Sausage Egg And Cheese. Quick Key Limited options.
S.E.
Sausage and Egg. Quick Key Limited options.
E.C.
Egg and Cheese. No meat! Quick Key Limited options.
H.E.C
Ham Egg and Cheese. Quick Key Limited options.
Cold Brew Large $6.75
Cold Brew Small $5.19
Coffee/Tea
H.E. $7.55
Ham And Egg. No Cheese! Quick Key Limited options.

UNCATEGORIZED
Vitamin Water $3.02
Good Source Of Vitamins
Breakstone Butter $6.76

Atlantic Bagel Co. Details

Service options
In-store pickup
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Restroom

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Atlantic Bagel Co. Photos

Atlantic Bagel Co. Location

Atlantic Bagel Co.

New Jersey Monmouth County Atlantic Highlands First Avenue

74 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, USA

Atlantic Bagel Co. Reviews

An average rating of ★4.1 from 205 user reviews.

eggpork rollareamorningsublunchbagel sandwichsmilesolidkids

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I feel like it's necessary that l do this review about my hometown bagel spot. I have been coming here since I was a kid and have always enjoyed their bagels and sandwiches. Although they do still have great bagels and food, the service has plummeted down hill over the last several years. It went from sometimes being hit or miss with getting something about your order wrong, to now usually always getting your order wrong, waiting there forever to pick up food and hearing the chaos of the workers yell about what's going wrong. I along with most people seem to do door dash pickup these days at Atlantic bagel because I would assume the thought is, it's written down for them thus hard to screw up and it will be ready when you go pick it up. Well the last two times I have done DoorDash pickup there, neither of these were the case. I still waited over ten minutes on a simple bagel sandwich order that I placed over 25 mins ago and there still wasn't things on the sandwhich, that I had paid for! It's like they're not even trying anymore and it's definitely not just me, I see it and hear it with other customers in there. It's just a shame to see such a staple of a place that has good food just continue to provide this bad of service to its loyal customers. Also the cleanliness and overall appearance of the place is just filthy and old. I know that most bagel places aren’t known for their updated appearance or cleanliness but for a town like Atlantic highlands that is very up and coming and new age, they really need to consider giving it a makeover. If you're thinking of going to Atlantic bagel, make sure you don't have to be anywhere anytime soon and you sit down and eat it in there so you can make sure everything you ordered is correct.
May 24 · Brendan Black
I felt welcomed when we walked in. The bagel I got was very hard and the cream cheese didn’t have a taste to it. It’s a very nice place. I think the bagels just need to be softer. I would definitely return to try different sandwiches. Nothing bad to say about this place. Just one or two improvements. Overall 3/5
August 31 · Andrew Galida Jr.
I have been a long time resident of Highlands. I haven’t really frequented the Atlantic Highlands area until I got older . I ate here yesterday for the first time and I was blown away by the food, atmosphere, and the customer service from the staff. As a person of color, I’m always nervous walking into some establishments in the area but the welcoming energy I received from staff made me comfortable quickly . The customer service was kind, positive, & welcoming. I had ordered a sausage, egg, & cheese with a hash brown on an everything bagel. This is my second day back and it tastes just as good as it did yesterday! You guys are doing good, keep up the good work
June 27 · Kelly Devereaux
I would like to change my review, I don’t put out bad reviews lightly but they reached out and asked for a second chance. I am conceding to that they probably had a bad day or off moment. Also despite there offer to make it right, I couldn’t make it back there to let them before I left town. I’m gonna new review at my past experiences with this place.ok been going here most of my life, today it was not good. My bagel was stale, egg overcooked poked and two very thin pieces of pork roll.it really stunk and the. made me sick. Must be new management, i dont think ill go here anymore.
June 24 · MK Fallon
I’ve come here a lot over the years but the level of disorganization has become crazy. Online order, waited 15 minutes because they don’t have a pickup line, and it turns out it wasn’t even in the kitchen yet. Couldn’t wait any more. Nobody has time for this. Would have taken an hour all-in. Won’t bother requesting a refund because I’m sure it would be another waste of time.
June 08 · Blake Deakin