Bagelati: Lake Grove's Inviting Spot for Fresh Bagels, Gelato, and More

Bagelati Introduce

For many New Yorkers, particularly those living in the vibrant communities of Long Island, the pursuit of a perfect bagel is a cherished quest. It's not just about breakfast; it's about finding a place that combines quality food with a welcoming atmosphere. Welcome to our detailed exploration of Bagelati, a notable establishment in Lake Grove, NY, that has been catching the attention of locals. Bagelati aims to be more than just a quick stop; it strives to offer a comfortable and satisfying dining experience for individuals and families alike. This article will provide you with a comprehensive overview of what Bagelati brings to the table, from their freshly baked goods to their inviting interior and diverse menu options.

Bagelati has made a name for itself by offering a wider array of selections beyond the typical bagel shop fare, including authentic gelato and a robust lunch menu. While experiences may vary among patrons, the consistent theme revolves around fresh bagels and a pleasant environment, making it a place where you can comfortably sit down and enjoy your meal. The initial feedback highlights a dedication to fresh products and friendly service, with an appealing decor that sets it apart from many grab-and-go bagel spots. As we delve deeper, we will uncover the specific services offered, unique features that distinguish Bagelati, and provide essential contact information to help you discover this local gem in Lake Grove. Whether you're in the mood for a classic bagel sandwich, a sweet treat, or a hearty lunch, Bagelati offers a promising option for New York locals.

Bagelati is conveniently situated at 2815 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY 11755, USA. This location on a major thoroughfare, Middle Country Road, makes it highly accessible for residents throughout Lake Grove and the surrounding Long Island communities. Middle Country Road (Route 25) is a significant commercial artery, providing straightforward access for drivers from various directions. Ample parking is typically available in the vicinity of the shop, which is a key convenience for patrons making a quick stop or enjoying a more leisurely meal inside.

While public transportation options on Long Island primarily consist of bus routes, the placement on Middle Country Road often means that local bus lines operate nearby, offering a connection for those who rely on public transit. However, for most New Yorkers in this part of Long Island, accessing Bagelati by car is the most common and practical method. Its integration into a bustling commercial area also means it's often a convenient stop amidst other errands or daily commutes. This strategic and accessible location ensures that Bagelati is a practical and easy-to-reach destination for locals seeking fresh bagels and other menu items in the Lake Grove area.

Services Offered:

Freshly Baked Bagels: Bagelati offers a wide variety of bagels, including classic plain, sesame, everything, French toast, cinnamon raisin, and pumpernickel. They are praised for being fresh and seemingly made on-premises. Gluten-free bagel options are also available.
Extensive Cream Cheese Selection: A diverse range of cream cheese spreads is available, from plain and vegetable to more unique flavors like strawberry, cinnamon raisin walnut, green olive, blueberry, and even Oreo.
Breakfast Sandwiches: They offer a comprehensive selection of breakfast sandwiches featuring eggs, cheese, and various meats such as bacon, sausage, ham, turkey bacon, turkey sausage, steak, deli turkey, and pastrami. "Hungry Man" and "DIY Egg Sandwich" options are also on the menu.
Omelettes: Bagelati provides a variety of omelettes, including cheese, spinach & feta, vegetable, mushroom, meat, western, and a "Build Your Own 3-Egg Omelette" option.
Deli and Lunch Menu: Beyond breakfast, they offer a full lunch menu including a wide array of deli meats by the pound (e.g., chicken salad, tuna salad, roast beef, pastrami, turkey, ham, buffalo chicken) and various deli sandwiches and heroes.
Paninis and Burgers: Their menu extends to include hot sandwiches like paninis (turkey, roast beef, ham, grilled chicken) and burgers, offering substantial lunch options.
Gelato and Desserts: A standout feature, Bagelati offers authentic gelato, noted as a key reason for customers wanting to return. They also sell muffins, crumb cake, baklava, cookies, and brownies.
Coffee and Beverages: A full "Coffee Corner" with various coffee options (iced latte, cold brew) and other beverages like refreshers and protein smoothies are available.
Catering and Bagel Trays: They offer half dozens, bakers dozens, and bagel trays, suitable for larger orders or gatherings.
Online Ordering and Delivery/Pickup: Bagelati facilitates online ordering for both pickup and delivery, providing convenience for customers.

Features / Highlights:

Inviting Dine-In Atmosphere: Unlike many traditional bagel shops, Bagelati provides a comfortable and appealing dine-in experience. The seating is cushioned, some with pillows, and tables feature a faux marble finish, creating a very nice ambiance for customers who wish to sit and eat.
Fresh, On-Premises Bagels: Customers frequently highlight the freshness of the bagels, with a strong indication that they are made on the premises, ensuring a high-quality product.
Diverse Menu Beyond Bagels: A significant highlight is the extensive menu that goes beyond standard bagel shop offerings. The inclusion of authentic gelato, a wide range of deli items, omelettes, paninis, and burgers provides a broader appeal and caters to various meal times and preferences.
Friendly and Attentive Service: Positive customer experiences frequently mention the staff being "friendly and attentive," indicating a commitment to good customer service. Orders are noted to come out as requested, contributing to a smooth experience.
Potential for Regular Visits: The broad menu and pleasant atmosphere encourage customers to plan repeat visits to try different items, such as their gelato and lunch options, fostering customer loyalty.
Loyalty Program: Bagelati offers a rewards program where customers can earn points for every dollar spent, encouraging repeat business and providing added value.

Contact Information:

Address: 2815 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY 11755, USA

Phone: (631) 888-3581

Bagelati, nestled on Middle Country Road in Lake Grove, presents a compelling option for locals in the New York region, especially those on Long Island, seeking more than just a quick bagel run. Its primary strength lies in offering a comprehensive and diverse menu that extends far beyond typical bagel shop fare. For residents looking for a versatile spot that can cater to breakfast, lunch, and even a sweet treat like authentic gelato, Bagelati delivers. The range of options, from freshly baked bagels and numerous cream cheese flavors to extensive breakfast sandwiches, omelettes, deli items, paninis, and burgers, ensures there's something to satisfy every craving at any time of day.

Furthermore, Bagelati distinguishes itself with a notably inviting and comfortable dine-in atmosphere. Unlike many grab-and-go bagel establishments, the cushioned seating, pillows, and faux marble tables create a pleasant environment where families and individuals can relax and enjoy their meals. This emphasis on a welcoming ambiance, coupled with what is often described as friendly and attentive service, enhances the overall customer experience, encouraging patrons to linger and truly enjoy their visit. While some isolated incidents regarding order specifics or pricing perceptions have been noted in feedback, the general sentiment points towards a positive and satisfying experience with the food quality and service.

The convenient location on a major road and the availability of online ordering for pickup and delivery further solidify Bagelati as a practical and accessible choice for busy Long Islanders. For New Yorkers in the Lake Grove area who appreciate fresh food, a wide selection, and a comfortable setting, Bagelati offers a promising local destination for daily meals and sweet indulgences. Its commitment to variety and a pleasant dining environment makes it a strong contender for your next local favorite.

Bagelati Menu

Bagels & Spreads & Deli - Bagels
1/2 Dozen Bagels US$9.99
Bakers Dozen (13) US$18.99
Bagel Tray US$35.99
Plain Bagel US$1.75
Sesame Bagel US$1.75
French Toast Bagel US$1.75
Everything Bagel US$1.75
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel US$1.75
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel US$1.75
Whole Wheat Bagel US$1.75
Spinach Bagel US$1.75
Salt Bagel US$1.75
Onion Bagel US$1.75
Egg Onion Bagel US$1.75
Garlic Bagel US$1.75
Egg Bagel US$1.75
Egg Everything US$1.75
Cheddar Jalapeno Bagel US$1.75
Poppy Bagel US$1.75
Chocolate Chip Bagel US$1.75
Blueberry Bagel US$1.75
Multigrain Bagel US$1.75
Asiago Bagel US$1.75
Rainbow Bagel US$1.75
Pumpernickel Bagel US$1.75
Gluten Free Bagel US$4.29
Roll US$1.75
Flagel US$1.99
Sesame Flagel US$1.75
Bialy US$2.00
Croissant US$3.99

Bagels & Spreads & Deli - Spreads
4oz. Plain Cream Cheese US$2.99
8oz. Plain Cream Cheese US$6.99
1 Lbs. Plain Cream Cheese US$12.99
4oz. Vegetable Cream Cheese US$4.99
8oz. Vegetable Cream Cheese US$7.99
1 Lb Vegetable Cream Cheese US$15.99
4oz. Strawberry Cream Cheese US$4.99
8oz. Strawberry Cream Cheese US$7.99
4oz. Cinnamon Raisin Walnut Cream Cheese US$4.99
8oz. Cinnamon Raisin Walnut Cream Cheese US$7.99
4oz. Jalapeno Cream Cheese US$4.99
8oz. Jalapeno Cream Cheese US$7.99
4oz. Scallion Cream Cheese US$4.99
8oz. Scallion Cream Cheese US$7.99
4oz. Garlic And Herb Cream Cheese US$3.99
8oz. Garlic And Herb Cream Cheese US$7.99
4oz. Lox Cream Cheese US$5.49
8oz. Lox Cream Cheese US$9.49
4oz. Butter US$3.00
8oz. Butter US$5.99
4oz. Green Olive Cc US$0.00
8oz.Green Olive Cc US$7.99
Oreo
4 Oz. Jalapeno Cheddar US$5.49
4 Oz. Bacon Scallion US$5.49
8 Oz. Jalapeno Cheddar US$9.49
8 Oz. Bacon Scallion US$9.49
4 Oz. Bacon Cheddar US$5.49
8 Oz. Bacon Cheddar US$9.49
4 Oz. Sheppard Salad US$2.99
8 Oz. Sheppard Salad US$5.99
4 Oz. Macaroni Salad US$2.99
8 Oz. Macaroni Salad US$4.99
4oz Blueberry Cc US$4.99
8ozblueberry Cc US$7.99

Bagels & Spreads & Deli - Salads & Deli by the Pound
Chicken Salad Quarter Pound US$3.49
Chicken Salad Half Pound US$7.49
Chicken Salad 1 Pound US$14.99
Tuna Quarter Pound US$3.75
Tuna Salad Half Pound US$7.49
Tuna Salad 1 Pound US$14.99
White Fish Salad Quarter Pound US$4.25
White Fish Salad Half Pound US$8.49
White Fish Salad 1 Pound US$16.99
Egg Salad Quarter Pound US$2.75
Egg Salad Half Pound US$5.49
Egg Salad 1 Pound US$10.99
Smoked Salmon Quarter Pound US$9.99
Smoked Salmon Half Pound US$19.99
Smoked Salmon 1 Pound US$39.99
Roast Beef Half Pound US$7.99
Roast Beef 1 Pound US$15.99
Pastrami Half Pound US$7.99
Pastrami 1 Pound US$15.99
Ovengold Turkey Half Pound US$7.99
Ovengold Turkey 1 Pound US$13.99
Honey Turkey Half Pound US$6.99
Honey Turkey 1 Pound US$15.99
Pepper Mill Turkey Half Pound US$7.99
Pepper Mill Turkey 1 Pound US$15.99
Deluxe Ham Half Pound US$7.99
Deluxe Ham 1 Pound US$12.99
Buffalo Chicken Half Pound US$7.99
Buffalo Chicken 1 Pound US$15.99
Cransational Salad Quarter Lb US$4.99
Cransational Salad Half Pound US$8.99
Cransational Salad 1 Pound US$14.99
Chipotle Chicken Half Pound US$7.99
Chipotle Chicken 1 Pound US$15.99
Cole Slaw Half Pound US$4.99
Swiss Cheese 1 Pound US$9.20
Cole Slaw 1 Pound US$8.99
Potato Salad Half Pound US$4.99
Potato Salad 1 Pound US$8.99
Macaroni Salad Half Pound US$4.99
Macaroni Salad 1 Pound US$8.99
American Cheese Yellow Half Pound US$4.59
American Cheese Yellow 1 Pound US$9.20
Cheedar Cheese Half Pound US$4.59
Cheddar Cheese 1 Pound US$9.20
Swiss Cheese Half Pound US$4.59
Provolone Cheese Half Pound US$4.59
Provolone Cheese 1 Pound US$9.20
Pepperjack Cheese Half Pound US$4.59
Pepperjack Cheese 1 Pound US$9.20
Mozerella Cheese Half Pound US$4.59
Salami Half Pound US$5.99
Salami 1 Pound US$11.99
Pepperoni Half Pound US$5.49

Bagels
1/2 Dozen Bagels US$9.99
Bakers Dozen (13) US$18.99
Bagel Tray US$35.99
Plain Bagel US$1.75
Sesame Bagel US$1.75
French Toast Bagel US$1.75
Everything Bagel US$1.75
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel US$1.75
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel US$1.75
Whole Wheat Bagel US$1.75
Spinach Bagel US$1.75
Salt Bagel US$1.75
Onion Bagel US$1.75
Egg Onion Bagel US$1.75
Garlic Bagel US$1.75
Egg Bagel US$1.75
Egg Everything US$1.75
Cheddar Jalapeno Bagel US$1.75
Poppy Bagel US$1.75
Chocolate Chip Bagel US$1.75
Blueberry Bagel US$1.75
Multigrain Bagel US$1.75
Asiago Bagel US$1.75
Rainbow Bagel US$1.75
Pumpernickel Bagel US$1.75
Gluten Free Bagel US$4.29
Roll US$1.75
Flagel US$1.99
Sesame Flagel US$1.75
Bialy US$2.00
Croissant US$3.99

Spreads
4oz. Plain Cream Cheese US$2.99
8oz. Plain Cream Cheese US$6.99
1 Lbs. Plain Cream Cheese US$12.99
4oz. Vegetable Cream Cheese US$4.99
8oz. Vegetable Cream Cheese US$7.99
1 Lb Vegetable Cream Cheese US$15.99
4oz. Strawberry Cream Cheese US$4.99
8oz. Strawberry Cream Cheese US$7.99
4oz. Cinnamon Raisin Walnut Cream Cheese US$4.99
8oz. Cinnamon Raisin Walnut Cream Cheese US$7.99
4oz. Jalapeno Cream Cheese US$4.99
8oz. Jalapeno Cream Cheese US$7.99
4oz. Scallion Cream Cheese US$4.99
8oz. Scallion Cream Cheese US$7.99
4oz. Garlic And Herb Cream Cheese US$3.99
8oz. Garlic And Herb Cream Cheese US$7.99
4oz. Lox Cream Cheese US$5.49
8oz. Lox Cream Cheese US$9.49
4oz. Butter US$3.00
8oz. Butter US$5.99
4oz. Green Olive Cc US$0.00
8oz.Green Olive Cc US$7.99
Oreo
4 Oz. Jalapeno Cheddar US$5.49
4 Oz. Bacon Scallion US$5.49
8 Oz. Jalapeno Cheddar US$9.49
8 Oz. Bacon Scallion US$9.49
4 Oz. Bacon Cheddar US$5.49
8 Oz. Bacon Cheddar US$9.49
4 Oz. Sheppard Salad US$2.99
8 Oz. Sheppard Salad US$5.99
4 Oz. Macaroni Salad US$2.99
8 Oz. Macaroni Salad US$4.99
4oz Blueberry Cc US$4.99
8ozblueberry Cc US$7.99

Salads & Deli by the Pound
Chicken Salad Quarter Pound US$3.49
Chicken Salad Half Pound US$7.49
Chicken Salad 1 Pound US$14.99
Tuna Quarter Pound US$3.75
Tuna Salad Half Pound US$7.49
Tuna Salad 1 Pound US$14.99
White Fish Salad Quarter Pound US$4.25
White Fish Salad Half Pound US$8.49
White Fish Salad 1 Pound US$16.99
Egg Salad Quarter Pound US$2.75
Egg Salad Half Pound US$5.49
Egg Salad 1 Pound US$10.99
Smoked Salmon Quarter Pound US$9.99
Smoked Salmon Half Pound US$19.99
Smoked Salmon 1 Pound US$39.99
Roast Beef Half Pound US$7.99
Roast Beef 1 Pound US$15.99
Pastrami Half Pound US$7.99
Pastrami 1 Pound US$15.99
Ovengold Turkey Half Pound US$7.99
Ovengold Turkey 1 Pound US$13.99
Honey Turkey Half Pound US$6.99
Honey Turkey 1 Pound US$15.99
Pepper Mill Turkey Half Pound US$7.99
Pepper Mill Turkey 1 Pound US$15.99
Deluxe Ham Half Pound US$7.99
Deluxe Ham 1 Pound US$12.99
Buffalo Chicken Half Pound US$7.99
Buffalo Chicken 1 Pound US$15.99
Cransational Salad Quarter Lb US$4.99
Cransational Salad Half Pound US$8.99
Cransational Salad 1 Pound US$14.99
Chipotle Chicken Half Pound US$7.99
Chipotle Chicken 1 Pound US$15.99
Cole Slaw Half Pound US$4.99
Swiss Cheese 1 Pound US$9.20
Cole Slaw 1 Pound US$8.99
Potato Salad Half Pound US$4.99
Potato Salad 1 Pound US$8.99
Macaroni Salad Half Pound US$4.99
Macaroni Salad 1 Pound US$8.99
American Cheese Yellow Half Pound US$4.59
American Cheese Yellow 1 Pound US$9.20
Cheedar Cheese Half Pound US$4.59
Cheddar Cheese 1 Pound US$9.20
Swiss Cheese Half Pound US$4.59
Provolone Cheese Half Pound US$4.59
Provolone Cheese 1 Pound US$9.20
Pepperjack Cheese Half Pound US$4.59
Pepperjack Cheese 1 Pound US$9.20
Mozerella Cheese Half Pound US$4.59
Salami Half Pound US$5.99
Salami 1 Pound US$11.99
Pepperoni Half Pound US$5.49

Breakfast & Lunch - Buttered & Cream Cheese Bagels
Plain Cream Cheese Bagel
Flavored Cream Cheese Bagel
Buttered Bagel
Spread Bagels
Mini Bagel Buttered
Mini Bagel Cream Cheese
Mini Bagel Flavored Cream Cheese

Breakfast & Lunch - Breakfast Sandwiches
Egg & Cheese
Bacon, Egg & Cheese
Sausage, Egg & Cheese
Ham, Egg & Cheese
Turkey Bacon, Egg & Cheese
Turkey Sausage, Egg & Cheese
Steak, Egg & Cheese
Deli Turkey Egg And Cheese
Pastrami, Egg & Cheese
Beyond Sausage Egg & Cheese
Hungry Man
Meat & 2 Cheese
Does not include eggs.
Meat & Eggs
Does not include cheese.
Meat Sandwich
Cheese Sandwich
Egg Sandwich
Nova Lox
Includes choice of Cream Cheese and Lox. Does not include eggs.
Deluxe Nova Lox
Includes Choice of Cream Cheese, Capers, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Does not include eggs.
Avocado Toast
* DIY Egg Sandwich
2 Eggs Only Platter

Breakfast & Lunch - Omelettes
Cheese Omelette
Spinach & Feta Omelette
Vegetable Omelette
Mushroom Omelette
Meat Omelette
Western Omelette
Build You Own 3-Egg Omelette
Garden Omelette

Breakfast & Lunch - Sides
Hash Brown US$2.25
Home Fries US$4.99
Jersey Shore Fries US$5.99
Jersey Shore Cut Fries
Chicken Strips With Fries
Mozzarella Sticks
2 Fried Eggs US$3.99
Bacon On The Side US$4.25
Sausage On The Side US$4.00
Turkey Bacon On The Side US$4.25
Turkey Sausage On The Side US$4.25
Beyond Sausage (Vegan) On The Side US$4.99
Macaroni On The Side US$2.99
Cole Slaw On The Side US$2.99

Breakfast & Lunch - Assorted Desserts & Muffins
Muffin US$3.49
Muffin Toasted With Butter US$3.75
Muffin Tray US$35.99
Crumb Cake US$3.50
Baklava 3 Piece US$6.50
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$2.99
Black And White Cookie US$2.99
Brownie US$2.99
Croissant US$3.99
Fruit Cup US$5.99
Yogurt Cup US$5.99
Banana US$1.25
Pancakes US$8.99

Breakfast & Lunch - Lunch Sandwiches
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Tuna Salad Sandwich
White Fish Salad Sandwich
Egg Salad Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Cransational Salad
BLT
Deli Ham
Grilled Pastrami
Chipotle Chicken
Oven Roasted Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Avocado, Tomato, Onion, Spicy Chipotle Mayo
Chicken Cutlet
Grilled Chicken
Spicy Chicken
Buffalo Ranch Chicken
Deli Turkey
Roast Beef
Honey Maple Turkey
Pepper Mill Turkey
Philly Cheesesteak Hero US$13.99
Wild Turkey
The Family Hero US$11.99
Manhattan
The Village
You're Killing Me
The Boone
Taki-Taki
The New Yorker
Middle Country
All American
Grilled Cheese US$6.99
Veggie Sandwich
Italian Hero
Salami
Bologna
Sweet B's BBQ Chicken

Breakfast & Lunch - Paninis
Turkey Panini US$12.99
Sweet Maple Honey Turkey Panini US$12.99
Roast Beef Panini US$12.99
Pastrami Panini US$12.99
Ham Panini US$12.99
Grilled Chicken🐔 Panini US$12.99
Veggie Panini US$11.99
Grilled Cheese 🧀 Panini US$9.99
Sweet B's BBQ Chicken US$12.99

Breakfast & Lunch - Burgers
Hamburger US$12.99
Cheeseburger US$13.99
Smoked BACON Cheeseburger US$14.99
Veggie Burger US$9.99
The Bistro Burger US$14.99

Breakfast & Lunch - Salads
Salad Bowl US$9.99

Buttered & Cream Cheese Bagels
Plain Cream Cheese Bagel
Flavored Cream Cheese Bagel
Buttered Bagel
Spread Bagels
Mini Bagel Buttered
Mini Bagel Cream Cheese
Mini Bagel Flavored Cream Cheese

Breakfast Sandwiches
Egg & Cheese
Bacon, Egg & Cheese
Sausage, Egg & Cheese
Ham, Egg & Cheese
Turkey Bacon, Egg & Cheese
Turkey Sausage, Egg & Cheese
Steak, Egg & Cheese
Deli Turkey Egg And Cheese
Pastrami, Egg & Cheese
Beyond Sausage Egg & Cheese
Hungry Man
Meat & 2 Cheese
Does not include eggs.
Meat & Eggs
Does not include cheese.
Meat Sandwich
Cheese Sandwich
Egg Sandwich
Nova Lox
Includes choice of Cream Cheese and Lox. Does not include eggs.
Deluxe Nova Lox
Includes Choice of Cream Cheese, Capers, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Onions. Does not include eggs.
Avocado Toast
* DIY Egg Sandwich
2 Eggs Only Platter

Omelettes
Cheese Omelette
Spinach & Feta Omelette
Vegetable Omelette
Mushroom Omelette
Meat Omelette
Western Omelette
Build You Own 3-Egg Omelette
Garden Omelette

Sides
Hash Brown US$2.25
Home Fries US$4.99
Jersey Shore Fries US$5.99
Jersey Shore Cut Fries
Chicken Strips With Fries
Mozzarella Sticks
2 Fried Eggs US$3.99
Bacon On The Side US$4.25
Sausage On The Side US$4.00
Turkey Bacon On The Side US$4.25
Turkey Sausage On The Side US$4.25
Beyond Sausage (Vegan) On The Side US$4.99
Macaroni On The Side US$2.99
Cole Slaw On The Side US$2.99

Assorted Desserts & Muffins
Muffin US$3.49
Muffin Toasted With Butter US$3.75
Muffin Tray US$35.99
Crumb Cake US$3.50
Baklava 3 Piece US$6.50
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$2.99
Black And White Cookie US$2.99
Brownie US$2.99
Croissant US$3.99
Fruit Cup US$5.99
Yogurt Cup US$5.99
Banana US$1.25
Pancakes US$8.99

Lunch Sandwiches
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Tuna Salad Sandwich
White Fish Salad Sandwich
Egg Salad Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Cransational Salad
BLT
Deli Ham
Grilled Pastrami
Chipotle Chicken
Oven Roasted Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Avocado, Tomato, Onion, Spicy Chipotle Mayo
Chicken Cutlet
Grilled Chicken
Spicy Chicken
Buffalo Ranch Chicken
Deli Turkey
Roast Beef
Honey Maple Turkey
Pepper Mill Turkey
Philly Cheesesteak Hero US$13.99
Wild Turkey
The Family Hero US$11.99
Manhattan
The Village
You're Killing Me
The Boone
Taki-Taki
The New Yorker
Middle Country
All American
Grilled Cheese US$6.99
Veggie Sandwich
Italian Hero
Salami
Bologna
Sweet B's BBQ Chicken

Paninis
Turkey Panini US$12.99
Sweet Maple Honey Turkey Panini US$12.99
Roast Beef Panini US$12.99
Pastrami Panini US$12.99
Ham Panini US$12.99
Grilled Chicken🐔 Panini US$12.99
Veggie Panini US$11.99
Grilled Cheese 🧀 Panini US$9.99
Sweet B's BBQ Chicken US$12.99

Burgers
Hamburger US$12.99
Cheeseburger US$13.99
Smoked BACON Cheeseburger US$14.99
Veggie Burger US$9.99
The Bistro Burger US$14.99

Salads
Salad Bowl US$9.99

Coffees & Smoothies & Cakes - Coffee Corner
Coffee - House Blend
Cold Brew
Espresso Shot
Cappuccino
Hot Latte
Iced Latte
Hot Macchiato
Iced Macchiato
Americano
Iced Americano
Hot Matcha Latte 16oz
Iced Matcha Latte 20oz
Salted Caramel Frapp 20oz. US$4.95
Mocha Frapp 20oz. US$4.95
Hot Tea
Iced Tea - Sweetened
Lemonade
Hot Chocolate
Affogato US$6.99
Box Of Joe US$29.99
Box Of Joe - Hot Chocolate US$29.99

Coffees & Smoothies & Cakes - Protein Smoothies & Acai Bowls
Strawberry Slam US$8.25
Strawberries, Banana & more Strawberries with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Berry, Berry Good US$8.25
Strawberries, Blueberries, Blackberries, Raspberries & Banana with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
I Love Veggies US$8.25
Pineapple, Coconut, Spinach, Kale, Avocado, Lemon & Banana with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Tropical Triumph US$8.25
Juicy Strawberries, Crushed Pineapple, Sweet Coconut & Banana blended with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Hawaiian Harvest US$8.25
Pineapple, Coconut & Banana with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Java Jolt
Choice of Liquid, Organic Coffee & Organic Chocolate with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Chocolate Frosty
Choice of Liquid & Organic Chocolate with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein & 20g Chocolate Whey Protein
Chocolate Thinny Mint
Choice of Liquid, Organic Chocolate, Mint & ‘Get Lean’ with 30g Chocolate Whey Protein
Salted Caramel-Grand Slam
Unsweetened Almond Milk, Organic Caramel, Sea Salt, PB Lite & Vanilla with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Peanut Butter Cup
Choice of Liquid, Organic Chocolate & Peanut Butter with 20g Chocolate Whey Protein & 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Banana Split
The healthiest Banana Split you’ll ever taste!
Banana Nut Blast
Choice of Liquid, Peanut Butter & Banana with 40g Vanilla Whey Protein
Peanut Butter Cup Lite
Choice of Liquid, Organic Chocolate & PB Lite with 10g Chocolate Whey Protein & 10g Vanilla Whey Protein
Berry Trim US$8.25
Antioxidant-Rich Raspberries, Strawberries, Blueberries, Blackberries, Banana & ‘Get Lean’ with 15g Vanilla Whey Protein to get Slim & Trim
Mocha Melt US$8.25
Get Trimmer with Colombian Coffee, Rich Chocolate & ‘Get Lean’ blended with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Peanut Butter Jam
Choice of Liquid, Peanut Butter & Banana with 10g Vanilla Whey Protein
Razzle Dazzle
Unsweetened Almond Milk, Raspberries, Banana & Vanilla with Vanilla Whey Protein
Skinny Delight US$8.25
Unsweetened Almond Milk, Banana & PB Lite with 30g Vanilla Whey Protein
Chocolate Covered Strawberry Shake US$8.25
Strawberries, more Strawberries & Organic Chocolate with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Jamaica Me Crazy US$8.25
Strawberries, Blueberries, Blackberries & Raspberries blended with Banana, Honey, 'Get Flexible' & 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Coconut Grove
Your choice of Milk, Shredded Coconut, Vanilla Bean, Iron-Rich, Spinach & Kale blended with 30g Vanilla Whey Protein
Go Nuts
Your choice of Milk, Natural Peanut Butter, Fiber-Rich Oatmeal, PB Lite, Honey & 'Get Energized' blended with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Banana Slim
Your choice of Milk, Potassium-Rich Banana & ‘Get Regular’ blended with 30g Vanilla Whey Protein
Kids Classic 12oz. US$4.99
Strawberries & Banana 12oz.
Kids Junior Chocolate Frosty 12oz.
Choice of Liquid & Organic Chocolate with 5g Chocolate Whey Protein & 5g Vanilla Whey Protein 12 oz.
Kids Strawberry Shortcake 12oz. US$4.99
Strawberries & Banana with 10g Vanilla Whey Protein 12oz.
Acai Bowl - Super Antioxidant US$9.99
Acai Bowl - Amazing Acai US$9.99
Acai Bowl - Perfect Pitaya US$10.50
Acai Bowl - Island Dragon US$9.99

Coffees & Smoothies & Cakes - Refreshers
Dragon Fruit Lychee Refresher 20oz US$4.25
Tropical Dragon Fruit & Zesty Lychee Berries. About half the caffeine as a cup of coffee in every serving. Includes green coffee extract. 20oz.
Strawberry Acai Refresher 20oz US$4.25
Ripe strawberry & a boost of acai berries. About half the caffeine as a cup of coffee in every serving. Includes green coffee extract. 20oz.
Peach Mango Refresher 20oz US$4.25
Sweet Peach & Juicy Mango. About half the caffeine as a cup of coffee in every serving. Includes green coffee extract. 20oz.

Coffees & Smoothies & Cakes - Cakes
Macaroons US$4.99
New York Style Cheesecake US$5.99
Traditional New York cheesecake flavored with a hint of vanilla, on a sponge cake base.
Strawberry Cheesecake US$6.99
Pumpkin Cheesecake US$5.99
Tiramisu US$5.99
Zabaione cream divided by three layers of espresso soaked sponge cake and dusted with cocoa powder.
Triple Chocolate Cake US$5.99
Moist chocolate cake filled with dark chocolate frosting and decorated with chocolate flakes.
Red Velvet Cake US$6.99
A red hued chocolate layer cake, filled and iced with a smooth cream cheese frosting, finished with chocolate drizzles and surrounded by red cake crumbs.
Carrot Cake US$5.99
Alternating layers of cream cheese icing and moist carrot cake spiced with cinnamon, chopped walnuts, raisins and pineapple, decorated with crushed walnuts.
Ricotta & Pistachio Cake US$5.99
Limoncello Marscapone US$5.99
Rich combination of Sicilian lemon infused sponge cake and Italian mascarpone topped with European white chocolate curls.
Choco Temptation Cake US$5.99
Layer of chocolate cake made with cocoa from Ecuador, filled with chocolate and hazelnut creams and a hazelnut crunch, covered with a chocolate glaze.
Chocolate Mousse Cake US$5.99
Sponge cake topped with Belgian chocolate mousse and finished with chocolate shavings.
Cannoli US$4.99
Large size cannoli shells filled with cannoli cream per order.
Maritozzo US$5.99
A sweet and soft brioche bun filled with whipped cream.
Limoncello Flute US$7.99
Refreshing lemon gelato made with lemons from Sicily, swirled together with Limoncello sauce.
Mixed Berry Flute US$7.99
Mixed berry gelato with a hint of lemon juice swirled with raspberry sauce.
Coppa Pistachio US$7.99
Custard gelato swirled with chocolate and pistachio gelato topped with praline pistachios.
Coppa Yogurt & Berries US$7.99
Yogurt gelato swirled together with mixed berry sauce, topped with blueberries and currants.
Gluten Free Flourless Choco Cake US$7.99
Made with the finest Belgian semi sweet chocolate, butter, cocoa powder and vanilla. Unlike other flourless chocolate cakes which can be gritty, flakey or dry, this cake is delicately rich, and bursting with a smooth, moist, and creamy texture
Gluten Free Red Velvet Cake US$7.99
Alternating layers of gluten free red hued chocolate sponge cake and cream cheese icing topped with gluten free cake crumbs.
Gluten Free Carrot Cake US$7.99
Alternating layers of gluten free carrot cake spiced with cinnamon, chopped walnuts and pineapple and a smooth cream cheese icing finished with white chocolate curls. Gluten Free.
Cake Pops GF US$4.99
A gluten free sponge base topped with mascarpone cream and dusted with cocoa powder.
Rainbow Bites US$11.99
Creme Brule US$7.99
Chocolate Covered Strawberries US$9.99
Creme Brulee And Berries US$7.99
Espresso Creme Brulee US$7.99
3 Chocolate Mouse Cake US$6.99
Banana Nut Cake US$2.50
Cream Puffs US$5.99
Rainbow Cake US$5.99
Hazelnut Passion US$6.99
Tres Leches US$5.99
Mixed Berry Tart US$6.99
Dubai Miskets US$11.99

Coffees & Smoothies & Cakes - Bottled Sodas & Juices
Tropicana Juices - Self Serve US$3.19
Coke Products - Self Serve US$3.19
Pepsi Products - Self Serve US$3.19
Snapple/Pure Leaf Iced Teas - Self Serve US$3.19
Prime - Self Servi US$3.99
Celsius Energy Drink - Self Serve US$3.99
Bottled - Self Serve US$1.99

Coffee Corner
Coffee - House Blend
Cold Brew
Espresso Shot
Cappuccino
Hot Latte
Iced Latte
Hot Macchiato
Iced Macchiato
Americano
Iced Americano
Hot Matcha Latte 16oz
Iced Matcha Latte 20oz
Salted Caramel Frapp 20oz. US$4.95
Mocha Frapp 20oz. US$4.95
Hot Tea
Iced Tea - Sweetened
Lemonade
Hot Chocolate
Affogato US$6.99
Box Of Joe US$29.99
Box Of Joe - Hot Chocolate US$29.99

Protein Smoothies & Acai Bowls
Strawberry Slam US$8.25
Strawberries, Banana & more Strawberries with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Berry, Berry Good US$8.25
Strawberries, Blueberries, Blackberries, Raspberries & Banana with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
I Love Veggies US$8.25
Pineapple, Coconut, Spinach, Kale, Avocado, Lemon & Banana with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Tropical Triumph US$8.25
Juicy Strawberries, Crushed Pineapple, Sweet Coconut & Banana blended with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Hawaiian Harvest US$8.25
Pineapple, Coconut & Banana with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Java Jolt
Choice of Liquid, Organic Coffee & Organic Chocolate with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Chocolate Frosty
Choice of Liquid & Organic Chocolate with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein & 20g Chocolate Whey Protein
Chocolate Thinny Mint
Choice of Liquid, Organic Chocolate, Mint & ‘Get Lean’ with 30g Chocolate Whey Protein
Salted Caramel-Grand Slam
Unsweetened Almond Milk, Organic Caramel, Sea Salt, PB Lite & Vanilla with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Peanut Butter Cup
Choice of Liquid, Organic Chocolate & Peanut Butter with 20g Chocolate Whey Protein & 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Banana Split
The healthiest Banana Split you’ll ever taste!
Banana Nut Blast
Choice of Liquid, Peanut Butter & Banana with 40g Vanilla Whey Protein
Peanut Butter Cup Lite
Choice of Liquid, Organic Chocolate & PB Lite with 10g Chocolate Whey Protein & 10g Vanilla Whey Protein
Berry Trim US$8.25
Antioxidant-Rich Raspberries, Strawberries, Blueberries, Blackberries, Banana & ‘Get Lean’ with 15g Vanilla Whey Protein to get Slim & Trim
Mocha Melt US$8.25
Get Trimmer with Colombian Coffee, Rich Chocolate & ‘Get Lean’ blended with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Peanut Butter Jam
Choice of Liquid, Peanut Butter & Banana with 10g Vanilla Whey Protein
Razzle Dazzle
Unsweetened Almond Milk, Raspberries, Banana & Vanilla with Vanilla Whey Protein
Skinny Delight US$8.25
Unsweetened Almond Milk, Banana & PB Lite with 30g Vanilla Whey Protein
Chocolate Covered Strawberry Shake US$8.25
Strawberries, more Strawberries & Organic Chocolate with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Jamaica Me Crazy US$8.25
Strawberries, Blueberries, Blackberries & Raspberries blended with Banana, Honey, 'Get Flexible' & 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Coconut Grove
Your choice of Milk, Shredded Coconut, Vanilla Bean, Iron-Rich, Spinach & Kale blended with 30g Vanilla Whey Protein
Go Nuts
Your choice of Milk, Natural Peanut Butter, Fiber-Rich Oatmeal, PB Lite, Honey & 'Get Energized' blended with 20g Vanilla Whey Protein
Banana Slim
Your choice of Milk, Potassium-Rich Banana & ‘Get Regular’ blended with 30g Vanilla Whey Protein
Kids Classic 12oz. US$4.99
Strawberries & Banana 12oz.
Kids Junior Chocolate Frosty 12oz.
Choice of Liquid & Organic Chocolate with 5g Chocolate Whey Protein & 5g Vanilla Whey Protein 12 oz.
Kids Strawberry Shortcake 12oz. US$4.99
Strawberries & Banana with 10g Vanilla Whey Protein 12oz.
Acai Bowl - Super Antioxidant US$9.99
Acai Bowl - Amazing Acai US$9.99
Acai Bowl - Perfect Pitaya US$10.50
Acai Bowl - Island Dragon US$9.99

Refreshers
Dragon Fruit Lychee Refresher 20oz US$4.25
Tropical Dragon Fruit & Zesty Lychee Berries. About half the caffeine as a cup of coffee in every serving. Includes green coffee extract. 20oz.
Strawberry Acai Refresher 20oz US$4.25
Ripe strawberry & a boost of acai berries. About half the caffeine as a cup of coffee in every serving. Includes green coffee extract. 20oz.
Peach Mango Refresher 20oz US$4.25
Sweet Peach & Juicy Mango. About half the caffeine as a cup of coffee in every serving. Includes green coffee extract. 20oz.

Cakes
Macaroons US$4.99
New York Style Cheesecake US$5.99
Traditional New York cheesecake flavored with a hint of vanilla, on a sponge cake base.
Strawberry Cheesecake US$6.99
Pumpkin Cheesecake US$5.99
Tiramisu US$5.99
Zabaione cream divided by three layers of espresso soaked sponge cake and dusted with cocoa powder.
Triple Chocolate Cake US$5.99
Moist chocolate cake filled with dark chocolate frosting and decorated with chocolate flakes.
Red Velvet Cake US$6.99
A red hued chocolate layer cake, filled and iced with a smooth cream cheese frosting, finished with chocolate drizzles and surrounded by red cake crumbs.
Carrot Cake US$5.99
Alternating layers of cream cheese icing and moist carrot cake spiced with cinnamon, chopped walnuts, raisins and pineapple, decorated with crushed walnuts.
Ricotta & Pistachio Cake US$5.99
Limoncello Marscapone US$5.99
Rich combination of Sicilian lemon infused sponge cake and Italian mascarpone topped with European white chocolate curls.
Choco Temptation Cake US$5.99
Layer of chocolate cake made with cocoa from Ecuador, filled with chocolate and hazelnut creams and a hazelnut crunch, covered with a chocolate glaze.
Chocolate Mousse Cake US$5.99
Sponge cake topped with Belgian chocolate mousse and finished with chocolate shavings.
Cannoli US$4.99
Large size cannoli shells filled with cannoli cream per order.
Maritozzo US$5.99
A sweet and soft brioche bun filled with whipped cream.
Limoncello Flute US$7.99
Refreshing lemon gelato made with lemons from Sicily, swirled together with Limoncello sauce.
Mixed Berry Flute US$7.99
Mixed berry gelato with a hint of lemon juice swirled with raspberry sauce.
Coppa Pistachio US$7.99
Custard gelato swirled with chocolate and pistachio gelato topped with praline pistachios.
Coppa Yogurt & Berries US$7.99
Yogurt gelato swirled together with mixed berry sauce, topped with blueberries and currants.
Gluten Free Flourless Choco Cake US$7.99
Made with the finest Belgian semi sweet chocolate, butter, cocoa powder and vanilla. Unlike other flourless chocolate cakes which can be gritty, flakey or dry, this cake is delicately rich, and bursting with a smooth, moist, and creamy texture
Gluten Free Red Velvet Cake US$7.99
Alternating layers of gluten free red hued chocolate sponge cake and cream cheese icing topped with gluten free cake crumbs.
Gluten Free Carrot Cake US$7.99
Alternating layers of gluten free carrot cake spiced with cinnamon, chopped walnuts and pineapple and a smooth cream cheese icing finished with white chocolate curls. Gluten Free.
Cake Pops GF US$4.99
A gluten free sponge base topped with mascarpone cream and dusted with cocoa powder.
Rainbow Bites US$11.99
Creme Brule US$7.99
Chocolate Covered Strawberries US$9.99
Creme Brulee And Berries US$7.99
Espresso Creme Brulee US$7.99
3 Chocolate Mouse Cake US$6.99
Banana Nut Cake US$2.50
Cream Puffs US$5.99
Rainbow Cake US$5.99
Hazelnut Passion US$6.99
Tres Leches US$5.99
Mixed Berry Tart US$6.99
Dubai Miskets US$11.99

Bottled Sodas & Juices
Tropicana Juices - Self Serve US$3.19
Coke Products - Self Serve US$3.19
Pepsi Products - Self Serve US$3.19
Snapple/Pure Leaf Iced Teas - Self Serve US$3.19
Prime - Self Servi US$3.99
Celsius Energy Drink - Self Serve US$3.99
Bottled - Self Serve US$1.99

Gelato Ice Cream & Milkshakes - Gelato & Milkshakes
Small Gelato US$5.49
Medium Gelato US$6.99
Large Gelato US$7.99
Pint US$9.99
Affogato US$6.99

Gelato Ice Cream & Milkshakes - MilkShakes
Gelato Milkshake US$9.99

Gelato & Milkshakes
Small Gelato US$5.49
Medium Gelato US$6.99
Large Gelato US$7.99
Pint US$9.99
Affogato US$6.99

MilkShakes
Gelato Milkshake US$9.99

Bagelati Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned
Small Business

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Bagelati Photos

Bagelati Location

Bagelati

New York Suffolk County Lake Grove Middle Country Road

2815 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY 11755, USA

Bagelati Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 193 user reviews.

gelatoatmosphereegg sandwichesbacondelicafedessertsshakesbaklavakinks

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This is my first review of the new year.My family was hungry, and we decided to give Bagelati a try.The atmosphere of this store is very nice. The seats are all cushioned, and some have pillows. The tables are done in a faux marble.The food here is really good. The bagels are fresh and seem to be made on the premises. My entire family enjoyed them.The service here is good. The people behind the counter are friendly and attentive. Our food came out as we ordered it. There were no issues.I will definitely pay this place another visit as I do want to try other things on their menu, like the Gelato and their lunch menu.Give this place a try if you're in the area!I will update this review as I visit in the future.
January 18 · Dion Rupa
The place is nice and you can actually sit and eat unlike most bagel stores. The food used to be great when they first opened. The past couple of times it did not taste good it was very bland. Today I called in an order and requested extra ham, which had an extra charge of $2.75. The problem is I got the sandwich and there is one slice of ham. They list on a chalkboard there’s free coffee with each breakfast sandwich monday- Friday but I had to ask for it. Never before did they give it to me and I only saw it this visit. Even when I asked they looked confused. Unfortunately we really wanted to love this place since our business is close but I don’t think we’ll be going back.
January 23 · Katie Payne
I am a homebound disabled individual who utilizes delivery service apps frequently as I'm unable to drive / cook due to wheelchair use. Today was my first time trying your food, and I just wanted to say thank you! Everything was fabulous! My bagel was fresh and exactly what I ordered! I am very much looking forward to trying the cake that I ordered later today as well! My favorite was the light roast house blend coffee!!! I loved it so much that I'm wondering if by chance it is available to purchase to brew at home? Anything I can buy in the grocery store that is similar to it if not? You will definitely be getting an order from me again soon! I see the business is fairly new as well. Congratulations! :) Mason McFadden
June 15 · masonmac137
Really fresh. I walked inn and ordered an everything bagel with veggies creamcheese and a coffee (machiato) and a chocolate muffin, everything was worth it. Service was very quick, the whole visit took no more then 10 minutes. And the cream cheese and bagel were very fresh. Really nice environment as well. Very pleasent and clean.
January 21 · Mehreen Khan
This place is an absolute amazing! I went with my friends and we all loved it. Their bagels are very fresh and delicious. The ice cream was so creamy and flavorful, and the service was incredibly friendly and helpful. I'm obsess with their ice cream. Definitely recommended!
May 25 · Mujde Jason