Discover Bagels and Cakes by Club 86: Your Local Geneva Bagel Destination

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 Introduce

In the vibrant culinary landscape of New York, finding that perfect bagel shop can be a quest. For those in and around the Finger Lakes region, particularly in Geneva, a local gem stands out: Bagels and Cakes by Club 86. This establishment has become a go-to spot for many seeking not just a quick bite, but a satisfying breakfast or lunch experience. It’s the kind of place that embodies the spirit of a community eatery, offering fresh fare in a friendly atmosphere.

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 aims to provide a reliable and enjoyable dining option for residents and visitors alike. While the name highlights two key offerings, their menu extends to a variety of other popular items, making it a versatile choice for different tastes and preferences. Whether you're craving a classic New York-style bagel with your favorite spread, a hearty breakfast sandwich to kickstart your day, or a custom-made cake for a special occasion, this local shop strives to meet those needs with its dedicated service.

The essence of a great bagel shop lies not only in the quality of its food but also in the overall experience it provides. Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 endeavors to create an inviting environment where customers can enjoy their meals, whether they're grabbing something on the go or taking a moment to savor their breakfast. Their commitment to freshness and customer satisfaction is a continuous effort, as they work to perfect their offerings and ensure every visit is a pleasant one. For anyone in the Geneva area looking for a reliable and local spot for their bagel fix and more, Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 presents itself as a noteworthy option to consider.

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 is conveniently situated at 476 Hamilton St, Geneva, NY 14456, USA. This central location makes it easily accessible for residents throughout Geneva and the surrounding areas. Whether you're coming from the heart of downtown, a nearby residential neighborhood, or simply passing through on your daily commute, reaching the shop is straightforward. The street address ensures that it’s a visible and identifiable landmark within the community.

For those driving, ample parking is typically available in the vicinity, allowing for easy access to the establishment. Its placement on Hamilton Street, a well-known thoroughfare in Geneva, contributes to its accessibility. Public transportation options, if available in the immediate area, would also provide a means for customers to reach the shop without the need for a personal vehicle. The aim is to make the visit as convenient as possible for all patrons, ensuring that enjoying a fresh bagel or a delicious sandwich is never a hassle.

The strategic location of Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 not only benefits individual customers but also positions it as a practical choice for local businesses and organizations looking to place larger orders. Its ease of access facilitates pickups and deliveries, making it a viable option for catering office breakfasts, lunch meetings, or special events. This thoughtful positioning underscores the shop's commitment to being an integral part of the Geneva community, serving a wide array of needs with efficiency and convenience.

Services Offered:

Freshly Baked Bagels: A variety of classic and specialty bagels, baked fresh daily.
Breakfast Sandwiches: Custom-made breakfast sandwiches featuring a selection of meats, eggs, and cheese on your choice of bagel or bread.
Wraps: Including options like chicken ranch wraps, with customization available.
Burgers: A selection of cooked-to-order burgers for lunch.
Cakes: Custom cakes for various occasions, though specific details on types and ordering may require direct inquiry.
Coffee and Beverages: A range of hot and cold beverages to complement your meal.
Catering Services: Orders for larger groups and events, subject to availability and advance notice.
Dine-in and Take-out: Options for enjoying your meal on-site or taking it to go.

Features / Highlights:

Diverse Menu: Beyond just bagels, the shop offers a broader selection of breakfast and lunch items, including wraps and burgers, providing variety for different preferences.
Freshness Focus: An emphasis on preparing items fresh, from baked goods to cooked-to-order sandwiches.
Customization Options: The ability to customize orders, such as requesting "no bacon" on wraps, demonstrates an effort to accommodate individual dietary preferences.
Casual and Inviting Atmosphere: While specific details about the interior are not provided, customer reviews hint at an enjoyable atmosphere for a breakfast or lunch outing.
Local Presence: As a local business in Geneva, NY, it contributes to the community's culinary landscape and offers a convenient option for residents.
Prompt Service (for some items): The ability to quickly prepare certain items, like breakfast, suggests efficiency in their operations.

Contact Information:

Address: 476 Hamilton St, Geneva, NY 14456, USA

Phone: (315) 781-7643

Mobile Phone: +1 315-781-7643

In conclusion, Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 stands as a notable local establishment in Geneva, NY, particularly suitable for residents in the New York region seeking a reliable spot for their daily bagel fix, breakfast, or a casual lunch. Its commitment to offering a diverse menu, including freshly baked bagels, customizable sandwiches, and other lunch options like burgers and wraps, makes it a versatile choice for various cravings. While feedback indicates areas for improvement in order accuracy and presentation, the underlying intent to provide satisfying meals in a friendly setting is evident.

For locals, the convenience of its Hamilton Street location, coupled with its focus on fresh ingredients, makes it an appealing option for a quick grab-and-go breakfast on the way to work or a relaxed weekend meal. The ability to customize orders, such as requesting specific ingredients, highlights a customer-centric approach that many local patrons appreciate. Furthermore, its presence as a community business means that supporting Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 contributes directly to the local economy and strengthens the unique character of Geneva's food scene.

Ultimately, for anyone in the New York region, especially those in the Geneva area, looking for a neighborhood spot that offers more than just the basics, Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 provides a familiar and accessible choice. It’s a place where the aroma of fresh bagels greets you, and the promise of a hearty meal awaits, making it a suitable and convenient destination for locals seeking comfort food with a community touch.

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 Menu

All day Menu - Breakfast
Avenue E. US$10.00
Classic egg-frittata with sautéed peppers & onions, diced tomatoes and provolone cheese. Served with home fries and Italian buttered toast Add breakfast sausage, bacon or ham in it or on the side!
Italian Stallion US$7.99
Hot Italian sausage, sautéed peppers & onions, fried eggs, provolone cheese on a soft roll. Chips & pickle
Torrey Parker US$7.99
Fried bologna, fried eggs, sautéed peppers & onions, provolone cheese on a soft roll. Chips & pickles
Quesadilla
Scrambled eggs, diced green peppers, diced tomatoes, cheddar cheese. Side of sour cream and salsa. 9.00 Add breakfast sausage, bacon or ham in it or on the side
Huevos Rancheros US$11.50
Over easy eggs, black bean spread, roasted corn salsa, feta cheese, fried tortillas, side of salsa verde.
Avocado Toast US$10.50
Cracked wheat bread, fresh smashed avocado, fresh diced tomatoes, sunflower seeds, EVOO, salt & pepper.
Avocado Toast W/ Eggs US$14.95
Cracked wheat bread, fresh smashed avocado, fresh diced tomatoes, sunflower seeds, EVOO, salt & pepper. Add two eggs, any style.
Wheat Belly US$6.99
Egg whites & spinach, your choice of bread. Add cheese. Sub for gluten free bagel.
Oatmeal US$4.75
Made to order with the add ins you choose!
Manhattan US$13.45
Smoked Norwegian salmon, rye bread, choice of cream cheese, sliced purple onion, sliced tomato. Chips & pickle.
Eggs & Toast And More
Eggs - cooked to order. Home fries and your choice of toast. Add a side of Bacon, Ham, or Sausage
Pancakes
Single or double stack. Plain | Chocolate Chip.
Eggs Solo
Eggs - cooked to order. Home fries and your choice of toast. Add a side of Bacon, Ham, or Sausage

All day Menu - Smoothies
PB & J US$9.50
Bananas, strawberries, blueberries, honey, almond butter and almond milk.
Boost US$10.50
Bananas, almonds, cashews, vanilla protein, cacao nibs, cinnamon and almond milk.
Coffee Date US$9.50
Bananas, cold brew, cacao nibs, dates, peanut butter and almond milk.
Aztec US$10.50
Bananas, cold brew, chocolate protein, cacao nibs, cinnamon, dash of cayenne and almond milk.
Dragon Fruit US$9.50
Pitaya, strawberries, pineapple, orange juice, honey and coconut milk.
Detox US$9.50
Bananas, mango, turmeric, ginger, honey and coconut milk.
Green Sweetie US$9.50
Pineapple, apple, spinach, avocado, coconut water
Acai Bowl US$12.99
ah-sigh-EE berries, bananas, strawberries, blueberries, almond butter, honey, almond milk.
Dragon Bowl US$12.99
Pitaya berries, strawberries, pineapple, orange juice, honey, coconut milk.

All day Menu - Salad
Apple Orchard US$12.50
Grilled chicken, diced apples, walnuts, feta cheese, red grapes, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix. Steph's go to salad ;)
Black & Bleu US$14.50
Grilled steak, crispy bacon, tomatoes, crumbly bleu cheese, crotons. Made with our signature salad mix.
BLT Reto Salad US$11.25
Bacon, tomatoes, red onion, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Buff Chix Salad US$13.00
Crispy chicken, buffalo sauce, crumbly bleu. Made with our signature salad mix. cheese, celery, croutons.
Chef Salad US$13.50
Ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, hard boiled eggs, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Cobb Salad US$14.25
Grilled chicken, avocado, crispy bacon, crumbly bleu cheese, hard boiled egg, tomatoes, black olives. Made with our signature salad mix.
Crunch Salad US$12.50
Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, corn, black beans, red onion, tomatoes, crispy tortilla strips. Made with our signature salad mix. onion, tomatoes, crispy tortilla strips.
Caesar Salad US$10.00
Romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons.
Handsome Willy US$17.00
Grilled chicken & Steak, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, red & green bell peppers, banana peppers, jalapeño peppers, fried onions, crispy tortilla strips. Made with our signature salad mix.
Health Nut Salad US$10.00
Tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, walnuts, feta cheese, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Tijuana Salad US$13.25
Cooked shrimp, red bell peppers, black beans, green onion, corn, feta cheese, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Thai Salad US$10.00
Red cabbage, edamame, shredded carrots, crunchy lo-mein noddles, peanuts, green onion. Made with our signature salad mix.
Large House Salad US$8.25
Tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Small House Salad US$4.25
Tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Black Bean Salad US$15.25
Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, cheddar cheese, croutons, grilled black bean burger. Your choice of dressing.

All day Menu - Signature
Lehigh US$11.50
House hummus, cucumbers, spinach, tomatoes, provolone cheese on cracked wheat bread. Chips & pickle.
Humbert St. Hurley US$12.50
Roasted turkey, crispy bacon, American cheese, honey mustard, grilled and served on a soft roll. Chips & pickle.
Black Diamond US$12.25
Breaded & fried chicken breast, mozzarella cheese. Served on a sub roll with club 86 red sauce on the side for dipping. Chips & pickle.
Tool House US$12.50
French style chicken breast, grilled ham, Swiss cheese, honey mustard, served on a soft roll. Chips & pickle.
French Dip US$14.00
Seasoned and sliced roast beef dunked in au jus, on a sub roll. Served with french fries and a side of Au jus for dipping.
Hot Turkey US$14.25
Roasted Turkey, sliced, and served on a soft roll. Smothered with house gravy and served with french fries.
Chicken Fingers & Fries US$10.00
Three crispy chicken fingers & french fries. Side of BBQ sauce
Italian Sub US$10.25
Ham, salami, provolone cheese, roasted red peppers, pepperoncini, signature Italian dressing, served on a sub roll. Chips & pickle.
BLT US$10.75
Crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Your choice of bread. Chips & pickle. Add Cheese or Avocado.
Special US$16.00

All day Menu - Club 86
Rigatoni & Sauce US$9.00
Rigatoni's & Club 86 Sauce
Baked Chicken US$9.00
Half Chicken, Seasoned- Roasted and falling off the bone.
Chicken Parm US$10.00
Hand Breaded, fried, topped with mozz cheese and Club 86 sauce
Cheese Lasagna US$10.00
Ricotta, Mozz and Parm Cheese layered with Club 86 Sauce
Cheese Ravioli's US$9.00
Cheese Ravioli & Club 86 Sauce
Eggplant Parm US$10.00
Hand breaded, fried, layered with mozz & Club 86 sauce
Lynn's Mac & Cheese US$12.00
Just the best homemade Mac & Cheese
Stuffed Shells US$9.00
Ricotta Cheese Shells ( 3 per order)
Meatballs (Case) US$6.00
(4) Meatballs ( Grab & Go Case)
Giblets US$14.00
Chicken Gizzards, Spicy peppers, Onions, Club 86 Sauce
Medium Giblets US$7.00
Sauce (Quart) US$7.44
Club 86 Classic Red Sauce
Triscuit Topping US$5.25
Signature Hors d'oeuvre at Club 86. Spread on Triscuit cracker and broil until golden. Contains Cheese
Tomato Salad (Case) US$5.50
Pasta Salad (Case) US$5.50
Farro Brussle Salad W/ Peanuts US$5.50
Tuna Mac Salad12 (Case) US$5.50
Greens & Beans
Mac Salad (Case) US$5.50
Scallop Potato US$11.99
Fruit Cup US$5.99

All day Menu - Breakfast Sandwiches
BEC
Bacon – Egg – Cheese. Your choice of bread & cheese.
SEC
Sausage – Egg – Cheese. Your choice of bread & cheese.
Turkey SEC
Sausage – Egg – Cheese. Your choice of bread & cheese.
HEC
Ham – Egg - Cheese. Your choice of bread & cheese.
BOL-EC
Bologna – Egg - Cheese
Pprs Onion EC
Peppers & Onions – Egg – Cheese
Egg Ch
Egg - Cheese. Your choice of bread & cheese. Add Avocado and more...
Meat Only Sandwich
Meat Only Sandwich
BE / No Ch
Bacon – Egg
SE / No Ch
Sausage – Egg
Turkey SE / No Ch
Sausage – Egg
HE / No Ch
Ham – Egg
BOL E / No Ch
Bologna – Egg
Pprs Onion E / No Ch
Peppers & Onions – Egg
Egg Only
2 eggs any style sandwich
Home Fries US$2.99
Diced Fried Potatoes
Hash-Brown Patties US$2.99
Meat Side US$0.00

All day Menu - Meat Sides
Side Bacon US$2.50
Add Sausage US$2.50
Side Bacon Strips US$2.99
Side Ham US$2.50
Side Italian Sausage US$2.25
Side Grilled Chicken US$4.95
Side Crispy Chicken US$4.95
Side Turkey US$4.95
Side Steak US$7.50
Side 5X Shrimp US$5.50
Side 10X Shrimp US$11.00
Side 4oz Tuna Scoop US$4.00
Side 4oz Egg Salad Scoop US$4.00
Side Tofu US$4.95
Add Turkey Sausage US$2.50
Side Black Bean Patty US$7.25
Lox Side US$5.75
4 Oz Chicken Salad US$4.00

All day Menu - Wraps
Box Car Mary
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, cajun mayo. Chips & pickle
Coal Car
Carved ham, lettuce, tomato, Swiss cheese, garlic mayo. Chips & pickle.
Chicken Ranch Wrap
Grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, ranch. Chips & pickle.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, cheddar, buffalo sauce & ranch. Chips & pickle.
Chix Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine, parmesan, croutons, caesar dressing. Chips & pickle. Sub for Crispy Chicken.
Special Wrap

All day Menu - Pressed & Melts
Turkey Melt US$12.00
Roasted turkey, pesto mayo, roasted red peppers, provolone cheese, focaccia bread. Chips & pickle.
R&B US$12.00
Roast beef, pesto mayo, Swiss cheese, onions, roasted red peppers, focaccia bread. Chips & pickle.
Triple Decker Reuben US$13.25
Pastrami, Swiss cheese, 1000 island dressing, sauerkraut, stacked high on rye. Chips & pickle.
Tomato Basil US$10.75
Tomato slices, basil, mozzarella cheese, focaccia bread. Chips & pickle. Add grilled chicken.
Grilled Cheese
Choice of bread & cheese. Chips & pickle. Add tomato, Add Bacon. Add your choice of side.
Tuna Melt
our choice of bread & cheese. Chips & pickle. 11.50 Add any veggies!
Hot Ham & Cheese
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Chicken Salad Melt US$12.00
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.

All day Menu - Grill
Burger US$12.00
Lettuce, tomato, onion Roll. Served with French fries.
Grilled Chicken Breast US$11.50
Lettuce, tomato, onion, Roll. Served with French fries.
Hot Dog & FF US$8.00
Red Hot. Served with French fries.
BBQ Burger US$14.75
BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
BBQ Chicken US$14.25
BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
Black Bean Burger US$14.00
Housemade patty (black beans, cilantro, corn, garlic, onion, jalapeño and salsa), lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with sweet potato fries. Add Cheese.
Blues Burger US$13.00
Caramelized onions, crumbly bleu cheese, lettuce, tomato. Served with French fries.
Blues Chicken US$12.50
Caramelized onions, crumbly bleu cheese, lettuce, tomato. Served with French fries.
Buffalo Burger US$12.50
Buffalo Chicken US$12.50
Italian Burger US$12.75
Club 86 Red sauce, Mozzarella
Italian Chicken US$12.50
Club 86 Red sauce, Mozzarella
Pesto Burger US$12.75
Pesto mayo, Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
Pesto Chicken US$12.50
Pesto mayo, Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
Swiss Burger US$12.75
Sauteed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
Swiss Chicken US$12.50
Sauteed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
Walker Burger US$17.00
Avocado, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, fried egg, lettuce, tomato, onion.
Walker Chicken US$15.50
Avocado, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, fried egg, lettuce, tomato, onion.

All day Menu - Bagels & More
Bagel US$1.35
Please note this is for a single bagel, please do not order a dozen bagels by using this option. Dozen or ½ dozen bagels need to be called in thank you!
Bagel W/ Cream Cheese
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bagel W/ Butter
Bagel with Butter
Bagel W/ CC & Butter
Bagel with Cream Cheese & Butter
Bagel W/ Jelly
Bagel with Jelly
Bagel W/ PB
Bagel with Peanut Butter
Bagel W/ PB&J
Bagel with Peanut Butter & Jelly
LOX & Bagel
Bagel with Lox and any veggies!
LOX & CC Bagel
Bagel with Lox, Cream Cheese and Veggies.
½ Lb Cream Cheese US$5.50
4 Oz Cream Cheese Side US$3.80
2 Oz Cream Cheese Side US$2.35
Muffin Of The Day US$5.50
Cinnamon Roll US$5.50
Large Cinnamon Roll with icing
Scone US$3.50
Raspberry & White Chip OR Blueberry

All day Menu - Deli
Bologna
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Chix Salad
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Crab Salad
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Egg & Olive
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Egg Salad
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Ham
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Hummus
Roasted Red Peppers & Chick Pea's. Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Pastrami
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
PB & J
Peanut butter, your choice of strawberry, raspberry or grape jelly, your choice of bread. Chips & pickle.
Roast Beef
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Salami
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Tuna Fish
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Turkey
Boar's Head®, Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Veggie Sandwich
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.

All day Menu - Quick Sides
French Fries US$2.99
Sweet Potato Fries US$3.50
Home Fries US$2.99
Hash-Brown Patties US$2.99
Chips & Pickle US$0.75
Small House Salad US$4.25
Tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Side Dress US$0.00
Side Sauce US$1.50
Side Gravy US$1.50

All day Menu - Soups
Greens & Beans
Soup Size

Breakfast
Avenue E. US$10.00
Classic egg-frittata with sautéed peppers & onions, diced tomatoes and provolone cheese. Served with home fries and Italian buttered toast Add breakfast sausage, bacon or ham in it or on the side!
Italian Stallion US$7.99
Hot Italian sausage, sautéed peppers & onions, fried eggs, provolone cheese on a soft roll. Chips & pickle
Torrey Parker US$7.99
Fried bologna, fried eggs, sautéed peppers & onions, provolone cheese on a soft roll. Chips & pickles
Quesadilla
Scrambled eggs, diced green peppers, diced tomatoes, cheddar cheese. Side of sour cream and salsa. 9.00 Add breakfast sausage, bacon or ham in it or on the side
Huevos Rancheros US$11.50
Over easy eggs, black bean spread, roasted corn salsa, feta cheese, fried tortillas, side of salsa verde.
Avocado Toast US$10.50
Cracked wheat bread, fresh smashed avocado, fresh diced tomatoes, sunflower seeds, EVOO, salt & pepper.
Avocado Toast W/ Eggs US$14.95
Cracked wheat bread, fresh smashed avocado, fresh diced tomatoes, sunflower seeds, EVOO, salt & pepper. Add two eggs, any style.
Wheat Belly US$6.99
Egg whites & spinach, your choice of bread. Add cheese. Sub for gluten free bagel.
Oatmeal US$4.75
Made to order with the add ins you choose!
Manhattan US$13.45
Smoked Norwegian salmon, rye bread, choice of cream cheese, sliced purple onion, sliced tomato. Chips & pickle.
Eggs & Toast And More
Eggs - cooked to order. Home fries and your choice of toast. Add a side of Bacon, Ham, or Sausage
Pancakes
Single or double stack. Plain | Chocolate Chip.
Eggs Solo
Eggs - cooked to order. Home fries and your choice of toast. Add a side of Bacon, Ham, or Sausage

Smoothies
PB & J US$9.50
Bananas, strawberries, blueberries, honey, almond butter and almond milk.
Boost US$10.50
Bananas, almonds, cashews, vanilla protein, cacao nibs, cinnamon and almond milk.
Coffee Date US$9.50
Bananas, cold brew, cacao nibs, dates, peanut butter and almond milk.
Aztec US$10.50
Bananas, cold brew, chocolate protein, cacao nibs, cinnamon, dash of cayenne and almond milk.
Dragon Fruit US$9.50
Pitaya, strawberries, pineapple, orange juice, honey and coconut milk.
Detox US$9.50
Bananas, mango, turmeric, ginger, honey and coconut milk.
Green Sweetie US$9.50
Pineapple, apple, spinach, avocado, coconut water
Acai Bowl US$12.99
ah-sigh-EE berries, bananas, strawberries, blueberries, almond butter, honey, almond milk.
Dragon Bowl US$12.99
Pitaya berries, strawberries, pineapple, orange juice, honey, coconut milk.

Salad
Apple Orchard US$12.50
Grilled chicken, diced apples, walnuts, feta cheese, red grapes, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix. Steph's go to salad ;)
Black & Bleu US$14.50
Grilled steak, crispy bacon, tomatoes, crumbly bleu cheese, crotons. Made with our signature salad mix.
BLT Reto Salad US$11.25
Bacon, tomatoes, red onion, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Buff Chix Salad US$13.00
Crispy chicken, buffalo sauce, crumbly bleu. Made with our signature salad mix. cheese, celery, croutons.
Chef Salad US$13.50
Ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, hard boiled eggs, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Cobb Salad US$14.25
Grilled chicken, avocado, crispy bacon, crumbly bleu cheese, hard boiled egg, tomatoes, black olives. Made with our signature salad mix.
Crunch Salad US$12.50
Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, corn, black beans, red onion, tomatoes, crispy tortilla strips. Made with our signature salad mix. onion, tomatoes, crispy tortilla strips.
Caesar Salad US$10.00
Romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons.
Handsome Willy US$17.00
Grilled chicken & Steak, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, red & green bell peppers, banana peppers, jalapeño peppers, fried onions, crispy tortilla strips. Made with our signature salad mix.
Health Nut Salad US$10.00
Tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, walnuts, feta cheese, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Tijuana Salad US$13.25
Cooked shrimp, red bell peppers, black beans, green onion, corn, feta cheese, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Thai Salad US$10.00
Red cabbage, edamame, shredded carrots, crunchy lo-mein noddles, peanuts, green onion. Made with our signature salad mix.
Large House Salad US$8.25
Tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Small House Salad US$4.25
Tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Black Bean Salad US$15.25
Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, cheddar cheese, croutons, grilled black bean burger. Your choice of dressing.

Signature
Lehigh US$11.50
House hummus, cucumbers, spinach, tomatoes, provolone cheese on cracked wheat bread. Chips & pickle.
Humbert St. Hurley US$12.50
Roasted turkey, crispy bacon, American cheese, honey mustard, grilled and served on a soft roll. Chips & pickle.
Black Diamond US$12.25
Breaded & fried chicken breast, mozzarella cheese. Served on a sub roll with club 86 red sauce on the side for dipping. Chips & pickle.
Tool House US$12.50
French style chicken breast, grilled ham, Swiss cheese, honey mustard, served on a soft roll. Chips & pickle.
French Dip US$14.00
Seasoned and sliced roast beef dunked in au jus, on a sub roll. Served with french fries and a side of Au jus for dipping.
Hot Turkey US$14.25
Roasted Turkey, sliced, and served on a soft roll. Smothered with house gravy and served with french fries.
Chicken Fingers & Fries US$10.00
Three crispy chicken fingers & french fries. Side of BBQ sauce
Italian Sub US$10.25
Ham, salami, provolone cheese, roasted red peppers, pepperoncini, signature Italian dressing, served on a sub roll. Chips & pickle.
BLT US$10.75
Crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Your choice of bread. Chips & pickle. Add Cheese or Avocado.
Special US$16.00

Club 86
Rigatoni & Sauce US$9.00
Rigatoni's & Club 86 Sauce
Baked Chicken US$9.00
Half Chicken, Seasoned- Roasted and falling off the bone.
Chicken Parm US$10.00
Hand Breaded, fried, topped with mozz cheese and Club 86 sauce
Cheese Lasagna US$10.00
Ricotta, Mozz and Parm Cheese layered with Club 86 Sauce
Cheese Ravioli's US$9.00
Cheese Ravioli & Club 86 Sauce
Eggplant Parm US$10.00
Hand breaded, fried, layered with mozz & Club 86 sauce
Lynn's Mac & Cheese US$12.00
Just the best homemade Mac & Cheese
Stuffed Shells US$9.00
Ricotta Cheese Shells ( 3 per order)
Meatballs (Case) US$6.00
(4) Meatballs ( Grab & Go Case)
Giblets US$14.00
Chicken Gizzards, Spicy peppers, Onions, Club 86 Sauce
Medium Giblets US$7.00
Sauce (Quart) US$7.44
Club 86 Classic Red Sauce
Triscuit Topping US$5.25
Signature Hors d'oeuvre at Club 86. Spread on Triscuit cracker and broil until golden. Contains Cheese
Tomato Salad (Case) US$5.50
Pasta Salad (Case) US$5.50
Farro Brussle Salad W/ Peanuts US$5.50
Tuna Mac Salad12 (Case) US$5.50
Greens & Beans
Mac Salad (Case) US$5.50
Scallop Potato US$11.99
Fruit Cup US$5.99

Breakfast Sandwiches
BEC
Bacon – Egg – Cheese. Your choice of bread & cheese.
SEC
Sausage – Egg – Cheese. Your choice of bread & cheese.
Turkey SEC
Sausage – Egg – Cheese. Your choice of bread & cheese.
HEC
Ham – Egg - Cheese. Your choice of bread & cheese.
BOL-EC
Bologna – Egg - Cheese
Pprs Onion EC
Peppers & Onions – Egg – Cheese
Egg Ch
Egg - Cheese. Your choice of bread & cheese. Add Avocado and more...
Meat Only Sandwich
Meat Only Sandwich
BE / No Ch
Bacon – Egg
SE / No Ch
Sausage – Egg
Turkey SE / No Ch
Sausage – Egg
HE / No Ch
Ham – Egg
BOL E / No Ch
Bologna – Egg
Pprs Onion E / No Ch
Peppers & Onions – Egg
Egg Only
2 eggs any style sandwich
Home Fries US$2.99
Diced Fried Potatoes
Hash-Brown Patties US$2.99
Meat Side US$0.00

Meat Sides
Side Bacon US$2.50
Add Sausage US$2.50
Side Bacon Strips US$2.99
Side Ham US$2.50
Side Italian Sausage US$2.25
Side Grilled Chicken US$4.95
Side Crispy Chicken US$4.95
Side Turkey US$4.95
Side Steak US$7.50
Side 5X Shrimp US$5.50
Side 10X Shrimp US$11.00
Side 4oz Tuna Scoop US$4.00
Side 4oz Egg Salad Scoop US$4.00
Side Tofu US$4.95
Add Turkey Sausage US$2.50
Side Black Bean Patty US$7.25
Lox Side US$5.75
4 Oz Chicken Salad US$4.00

Wraps
Box Car Mary
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, cajun mayo. Chips & pickle
Coal Car
Carved ham, lettuce, tomato, Swiss cheese, garlic mayo. Chips & pickle.
Chicken Ranch Wrap
Grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, ranch. Chips & pickle.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, cheddar, buffalo sauce & ranch. Chips & pickle.
Chix Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine, parmesan, croutons, caesar dressing. Chips & pickle. Sub for Crispy Chicken.
Special Wrap

Pressed & Melts
Turkey Melt US$12.00
Roasted turkey, pesto mayo, roasted red peppers, provolone cheese, focaccia bread. Chips & pickle.
R&B US$12.00
Roast beef, pesto mayo, Swiss cheese, onions, roasted red peppers, focaccia bread. Chips & pickle.
Triple Decker Reuben US$13.25
Pastrami, Swiss cheese, 1000 island dressing, sauerkraut, stacked high on rye. Chips & pickle.
Tomato Basil US$10.75
Tomato slices, basil, mozzarella cheese, focaccia bread. Chips & pickle. Add grilled chicken.
Grilled Cheese
Choice of bread & cheese. Chips & pickle. Add tomato, Add Bacon. Add your choice of side.
Tuna Melt
our choice of bread & cheese. Chips & pickle. 11.50 Add any veggies!
Hot Ham & Cheese
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Chicken Salad Melt US$12.00
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.

Grill
Burger US$12.00
Lettuce, tomato, onion Roll. Served with French fries.
Grilled Chicken Breast US$11.50
Lettuce, tomato, onion, Roll. Served with French fries.
Hot Dog & FF US$8.00
Red Hot. Served with French fries.
BBQ Burger US$14.75
BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
BBQ Chicken US$14.25
BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
Black Bean Burger US$14.00
Housemade patty (black beans, cilantro, corn, garlic, onion, jalapeño and salsa), lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with sweet potato fries. Add Cheese.
Blues Burger US$13.00
Caramelized onions, crumbly bleu cheese, lettuce, tomato. Served with French fries.
Blues Chicken US$12.50
Caramelized onions, crumbly bleu cheese, lettuce, tomato. Served with French fries.
Buffalo Burger US$12.50
Buffalo Chicken US$12.50
Italian Burger US$12.75
Club 86 Red sauce, Mozzarella
Italian Chicken US$12.50
Club 86 Red sauce, Mozzarella
Pesto Burger US$12.75
Pesto mayo, Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
Pesto Chicken US$12.50
Pesto mayo, Provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
Swiss Burger US$12.75
Sauteed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
Swiss Chicken US$12.50
Sauteed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion. Served with French fries.
Walker Burger US$17.00
Avocado, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, fried egg, lettuce, tomato, onion.
Walker Chicken US$15.50
Avocado, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, fried egg, lettuce, tomato, onion.

Bagels & More
Bagel US$1.35
Please note this is for a single bagel, please do not order a dozen bagels by using this option. Dozen or ½ dozen bagels need to be called in thank you!
Bagel W/ Cream Cheese
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bagel W/ Butter
Bagel with Butter
Bagel W/ CC & Butter
Bagel with Cream Cheese & Butter
Bagel W/ Jelly
Bagel with Jelly
Bagel W/ PB
Bagel with Peanut Butter
Bagel W/ PB&J
Bagel with Peanut Butter & Jelly
LOX & Bagel
Bagel with Lox and any veggies!
LOX & CC Bagel
Bagel with Lox, Cream Cheese and Veggies.
½ Lb Cream Cheese US$5.50
4 Oz Cream Cheese Side US$3.80
2 Oz Cream Cheese Side US$2.35
Muffin Of The Day US$5.50
Cinnamon Roll US$5.50
Large Cinnamon Roll with icing
Scone US$3.50
Raspberry & White Chip OR Blueberry

Deli
Bologna
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Chix Salad
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Crab Salad
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Egg & Olive
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Egg Salad
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Ham
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Hummus
Roasted Red Peppers & Chick Pea's. Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Pastrami
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
PB & J
Peanut butter, your choice of strawberry, raspberry or grape jelly, your choice of bread. Chips & pickle.
Roast Beef
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Salami
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Tuna Fish
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Turkey
Boar's Head®, Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.
Veggie Sandwich
Create your own! All Sandwiches served with Chips & Pickle.

Quick Sides
French Fries US$2.99
Sweet Potato Fries US$3.50
Home Fries US$2.99
Hash-Brown Patties US$2.99
Chips & Pickle US$0.75
Small House Salad US$4.25
Tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, croutons. Made with our signature salad mix.
Side Dress US$0.00
Side Sauce US$1.50
Side Gravy US$1.50

Soups
Greens & Beans
Soup Size

Beverages - Coffee
Regular
Latte
Cold Brew
Chai
Hot Chocolate
Iced Coffee
Iced Latte
Cold Brew Tea
Iced Chai
Box Of Joe US$18.00
Decaf
Decaf Latte
Matcha Latte
Cappuccino - Espresso
Box Of Tea US$21.00
Hot Tea
Decaf Iced Latte
Iced Matcha Latte
Americano
Box Of Hot Choc. US$23.00

Beverages - Cooler Beverages
Bottled Water US$1.99
Cold Brew Tea ( Fresh)
Gatorade US$2.50
Bubly US$1.99
Orange Juice US$2.99
Bottled Soda US$2.25
Red Jacket Juice US$2.99
Lemonade ( Fresh)
Celsius US$3.75
Water Cup US$0.00
Pure Leaf Ice Tea US$2.99
Arnold Palmer ( Fresh)
Half fresh cold brew black tea & half fresh lemonade!
Tea \ Lemonade Refill US$2.00

Coffee
Regular
Latte
Cold Brew
Chai
Hot Chocolate
Iced Coffee
Iced Latte
Cold Brew Tea
Iced Chai
Box Of Joe US$18.00
Decaf
Decaf Latte
Matcha Latte
Cappuccino - Espresso
Box Of Tea US$21.00
Hot Tea
Decaf Iced Latte
Iced Matcha Latte
Americano
Box Of Hot Choc. US$23.00

Cooler Beverages
Bottled Water US$1.99
Cold Brew Tea ( Fresh)
Gatorade US$2.50
Bubly US$1.99
Orange Juice US$2.99
Bottled Soda US$2.25
Red Jacket Juice US$2.99
Lemonade ( Fresh)
Celsius US$3.75
Water Cup US$0.00
Pure Leaf Ice Tea US$2.99
Arnold Palmer ( Fresh)
Half fresh cold brew black tea & half fresh lemonade!
Tea \ Lemonade Refill US$2.00

Desserts In Case - Dessert Bars
Almond Bar US$3.99
Almond Bar W/ Blueberries US$3.99
Hello Dolly US$3.99
Kit Kat Bar US$3.99
Oreo Cookie Bar US$3.99
Raspberry Bar US$3.99
S'More Bar US$3.99
Snickerdoodle Bar US$3.99
PB & J Bar US$3.99

Desserts In Case - Large Cookies
½ Moon Cookie US$3.75
Chocolate Cake - White & Black Frosting
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$3.99
PB Chip Cookie US$3.99
Linzer
Almond flour dough, fruit jam filling and either powder sugar OR choc. drizzle topping.
Sprinkle Cookie US$3.99
Lemon Sugar Cookie US$3.99
Cowboy Cookie US$3.99
M&M Choc Cookie US$3.99
Molasses US$3.99
Snickerdoodle Cookie US$3.99
Chocolate Sugar US$3.99
Almond Cookie US$3.99
Oatmeal Raisin US$3.99
Chocolate Flourless Cookie US$0.00

Desserts In Case - Large Brownies
Fudge Brownie US$2.99
Oreo Brownie US$3.25
Peanut Butter Brownie US$3.25
Brookie US$3.25

Desserts In Case - Cupcakes Packs
Carrot Cupcakes US$6.99
Chocolate – Choc. Cupcakes US$6.99
Lemon – Lemon Cupcakes US$6.99
Chocolate Cake, White Frosting Cupcakes US$6.99
Marble – White Or Choc. Frosting Cupcakes US$6.99
Oreo Cupcakes US$6.99
Peanutbutter Cupcakes US$6.99
Red Velvet Cupcakes US$6.99
Sprinkle Cupcakes US$6.99
Vanilla & Chocolate Cupcakes US$6.99
Vanilla Birthday Cupcakes US$6.99

Desserts In Case - Gluten Friendly Desserts
GF– Choc. Chip Cookie US$4.99
GF- White & White Cupcakes US$7.99
GF - Choc. & Choc. Cupcakes US$7.99
GF - White & Choc. Cupcakes US$7.99

Desserts In Case - Cake Slices
Cake Slice - Strawberry US$3.75
Cake Slice - Chocolate US$2.75

Desserts In Case - Cannoli's
Solo Cannoli US$2.25
½ Dozen Cannoli Tray US$13.50
1 Dozen Cannoli Tray US$27.00

Dessert Bars
Almond Bar US$3.99
Almond Bar W/ Blueberries US$3.99
Hello Dolly US$3.99
Kit Kat Bar US$3.99
Oreo Cookie Bar US$3.99
Raspberry Bar US$3.99
S'More Bar US$3.99
Snickerdoodle Bar US$3.99
PB & J Bar US$3.99

Large Cookies
½ Moon Cookie US$3.75
Chocolate Cake - White & Black Frosting
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$3.99
PB Chip Cookie US$3.99
Linzer
Almond flour dough, fruit jam filling and either powder sugar OR choc. drizzle topping.
Sprinkle Cookie US$3.99
Lemon Sugar Cookie US$3.99
Cowboy Cookie US$3.99
M&M Choc Cookie US$3.99
Molasses US$3.99
Snickerdoodle Cookie US$3.99
Chocolate Sugar US$3.99
Almond Cookie US$3.99
Oatmeal Raisin US$3.99
Chocolate Flourless Cookie US$0.00

Large Brownies
Fudge Brownie US$2.99
Oreo Brownie US$3.25
Peanut Butter Brownie US$3.25
Brookie US$3.25

Cupcakes Packs
Carrot Cupcakes US$6.99
Chocolate – Choc. Cupcakes US$6.99
Lemon – Lemon Cupcakes US$6.99
Chocolate Cake, White Frosting Cupcakes US$6.99
Marble – White Or Choc. Frosting Cupcakes US$6.99
Oreo Cupcakes US$6.99
Peanutbutter Cupcakes US$6.99
Red Velvet Cupcakes US$6.99
Sprinkle Cupcakes US$6.99
Vanilla & Chocolate Cupcakes US$6.99
Vanilla Birthday Cupcakes US$6.99

Gluten Friendly Desserts
GF– Choc. Chip Cookie US$4.99
GF- White & White Cupcakes US$7.99
GF - Choc. & Choc. Cupcakes US$7.99
GF - White & Choc. Cupcakes US$7.99

Cake Slices
Cake Slice - Strawberry US$3.75
Cake Slice - Chocolate US$2.75

Cannoli's
Solo Cannoli US$2.25
½ Dozen Cannoli Tray US$13.50
1 Dozen Cannoli Tray US$27.00

Fish Friday - Friday
Haddock Dinner US$17.99
Fish Sandwich US$14.99
Broiled Haddock Dinner
Fried Shrimp Dinner US$13.99
Shrimp Tacos US$14.99
Fish Tacos US$14.99
Extra Tarter US$0.50
Extra Slaw US$0.75

Friday
Haddock Dinner US$17.99
Fish Sandwich US$14.99
Broiled Haddock Dinner
Fried Shrimp Dinner US$13.99
Shrimp Tacos US$14.99
Fish Tacos US$14.99
Extra Tarter US$0.50
Extra Slaw US$0.75

Pasta Wednesday - Pasta Wednesday
Chicken Riggies US$15.00
Chicken, sausage,hot and sweet peppers, onions, rigatoni, tossed in our vodka sauce. Served with house side salad and bread.
Chicken Broccoli Alfredo US$15.00
Grilled chicken, broccoli, Alfredo sauce, parmesan cheese with rigatoni. Served with house side salad and bread.
Club 86 Red US$12.00
Club 86 Classic Red Sauce, Rigatoni and Parmesan cheese. Served with house side salad and bread.
Rigatoni Alla Vodka US$14.00
Creamy Vodka sauce, Rigatoni and Parmesan cheese. Served with house side salad and bread.
Pesto US$13.00
Creamy pesto sauce, parmesan cheese, rigatoni. Served with house side salad and bread.
Kids Pasta
Rigatoni with classic red sauce or just butter. Slice of bread.
Vegetarian Stuffed Pepper US$12.99
Veggies, Rice, Cheese & Sauce, stuffed in bell pepper. Served with side salad.
Meat & Veggies Stuffed Pepper US$12.99

Pasta Wednesday
Chicken Riggies US$15.00
Chicken, sausage,hot and sweet peppers, onions, rigatoni, tossed in our vodka sauce. Served with house side salad and bread.
Chicken Broccoli Alfredo US$15.00
Grilled chicken, broccoli, Alfredo sauce, parmesan cheese with rigatoni. Served with house side salad and bread.
Club 86 Red US$12.00
Club 86 Classic Red Sauce, Rigatoni and Parmesan cheese. Served with house side salad and bread.
Rigatoni Alla Vodka US$14.00
Creamy Vodka sauce, Rigatoni and Parmesan cheese. Served with house side salad and bread.
Pesto US$13.00
Creamy pesto sauce, parmesan cheese, rigatoni. Served with house side salad and bread.
Kids Pasta
Rigatoni with classic red sauce or just butter. Slice of bread.
Vegetarian Stuffed Pepper US$12.99
Veggies, Rice, Cheese & Sauce, stuffed in bell pepper. Served with side salad.
Meat & Veggies Stuffed Pepper US$12.99

Steak Night - Steak Dinner Night
Steak Dinner

Steak Dinner Night
Steak Dinner

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safe space

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Cheques
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 Photos

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 Location

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86

New York Ontario County Geneva Hamilton Street

476 Hamilton St, Geneva, NY 14456, USA

Bagels and Cakes by Club 86 Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 905 user reviews.

smoothieburgergluten freedinnergreensstrawberry cakebeanspaniniweddingquesadilla

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Bagels and cakes extremely disappointing. My work ordered some food from them. A chicken ranch wrap that clearly stated no bacon! Even the slip THEY PRINTED OUT 2 times . Said no bacon. Guess what IT HAD BACON!!!! Then my burger was not ordered the first time was ordered when the wrap was taken back. This was a PAID FOR MEAL. I’m sorry can I get some fries with this burger. Petty! We will not be ordering again.
July 15 · Heather Pierson
Love the sandwich but it was so messy it was falling apart. I bet if I let it cool down more it would have stayed together better. Either way I loved the atmosphere and it was a great breakfast.
May 27 · Nico Pecora
First (and last) experience at this place. No greeting when we walked up to the counter. Cashier was just standing there looking bored so it wasn't like she was busy. And we were obviously newcomers, since we had trouble locating the bagels. They were in bins behind the counter, so we couldn't see them before we ordered - if we had, we may have changed our selection. My husband ordered a plain and a sesame bagel, I got blueberry and an egg bagel. We were getting them to go (she never asked if we wanted them sliced or asked if we wanted to also buy cream cheese) so we never saw them until we got home. The sesame bagel was Coated with seeds! It looked like the entire bagel had been rolled in seeds and the entire surface was coated. The bagels smelled And tasted like garlic - definitely Not a flavor I wanted on my blueberry bagel! Their bagels are a reasonable price but we Won't be back.
January 25 · Donna Wylie
Quality sandwich options that are anti-fast food, which is why I came here in the first place. Stop eating garbage and come eat at places like this. Yes it costs a little more. But these days, not that much more.
February 11 · Eric Haffner
Terrible if you are elderly or special needs. The cashier talked to me as if my company wasn't there. Asked if we wanted our food with sauce on it and didnt actually come with the ketchup. We felt more like a bother than a customer. Food was good. Service had A LOT to be desired. Also spot on the one side of the building with the flush sidewalk should be handicap.
June 10 · Jessica C