Bagels and Cream: Your New Favorite Bagel Shop on the Upper West Side

Bagels and Cream Introduce

New York City is a global icon for many things, but few are as quintessential to the city's identity as the bagel. A perfect bagel isn't just a round bread with a hole in the middle; it's a testament to tradition, a morning ritual, and a comforting staple that fuels millions of New Yorkers daily. It's this culture and passion that a new gem, Bagels and Cream, is bringing to the vibrant Upper West Side neighborhood. Located conveniently on Amsterdam Avenue, this fresh new spot is already winning the hearts—and stomachs—of locals with its dedication to quality, cleanliness, and friendly service.

In a city teeming with bagel shops, finding one that truly stands out can be a challenge. Bagels and Cream, however, is quickly making a name for itself by focusing on the fundamentals: a perfectly cooked bagel, made with care and served with a smile. Whether you're a long-time resident or new to the area, this new shop provides a welcoming atmosphere and a menu that promises to satisfy any craving, from a simple schmear to a hearty breakfast sandwich. It’s a place where the community can gather, grab a bite, and start their day the New York way.

Bagels and Cream is strategically situated at 924 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA, placing it in the heart of the Upper West Side. This location makes it an ideal stop for residents of the area, students from nearby Columbia University, and anyone passing through this bustling part of Manhattan. The shop is easily accessible by foot for those living in the surrounding blocks, and its Amsterdam Avenue address means it's well-served by public transportation. The M104 bus runs along Broadway, and the 1, 2, and 3 subway lines have stations at 96th Street and Broadway, just a short walk away. This makes it a convenient and practical choice whether you're heading to work, taking a stroll through the neighborhood, or simply need a quick and delicious meal. The ease of access is a significant draw, ensuring that a fresh, hot bagel is never far away.

When you step into Bagels and Cream, you’re greeted with a straightforward yet robust menu designed to cater to all tastes. Their offerings go beyond the standard bagel and cream cheese, though they certainly do that exceptionally well. The variety ensures that every visit can be a new experience, or you can stick to your tried-and-true favorite.

Services Offered:

Freshly Made Bagels: A wide selection of bagels baked fresh daily, with classic options like plain, everything, poppy seed, and sesame, as well as specialty varieties such as onion.
Homemade Cream Cheeses: A diverse range of cream cheeses, from plain and scallion to lox and more, all prepared in-house to ensure maximum freshness and flavor.
Breakfast Sandwiches: Hearty and customizable sandwiches featuring eggs, cheese, and a choice of bacon, sausage, or turkey sausage on your favorite bagel.
Coffee and Beverages: A full menu of hot and cold drinks, including freshly brewed coffee, to perfectly complement your meal.
Catering Services: Providing platters of bagels and spreads for local events, office meetings, and family gatherings.
Online Ordering and Delivery: Partnering with popular delivery services to bring their delicious bagels directly to your doorstep.

What truly sets Bagels and Cream apart, however, are the small details that make a big difference. The shop is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's an experience built on quality and community.

Features / Highlights:

Impeccable Cleanliness: As a relatively new establishment, the owners have prioritized a clean and hygienic environment. Customers have noted the pristine condition of the shop, which adds to a comfortable and pleasant dining experience.
Friendly and Welcoming Staff: The owner and staff are known for their kindness and excellent customer service. This welcoming attitude creates a positive atmosphere that makes patrons feel valued and appreciated.
Perfectly Cooked Food: The kitchen takes pride in preparing each item with care. For example, breakfast sandwiches are cooked to perfection, ensuring the bacon, sausage, or turkey sausage is crisp and the egg is just right.
High-Quality Ingredients: The use of fresh, high-quality ingredients is evident in every bite. From the perfectly chewy bagel to the savory spreads, the focus is on flavor and quality.
Local Community Focus: The shop aims to be a local hub, providing a convenient and delicious alternative to larger, more distant establishments. This commitment to the neighborhood is a key part of their business philosophy.

For those looking to visit or place an order, here's the essential contact information for Bagels and Cream.

Address: 924 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA
Phone: (212) 457-9328

In a city that moves at a frantic pace, finding a local spot that feels like home is a treasure. Bagels and Cream is quickly becoming that place for many New Yorkers on the Upper West Side. It's a testament to the idea that a great local business isn't just about the product—it's about the people, the service, and the community it serves. With its delicious food, friendly staff, and commitment to a clean and welcoming environment, it’s a suitable choice for anyone in the neighborhood.

Whether you’re in need of a quick breakfast before work, a hearty lunch, or simply a delicious snack, Bagels and Cream delivers on all fronts. As one customer noted, it "hit the spot" and is a perfect "yummy and local" alternative to ordering from further away. The positive feedback from new patrons, who rave about the quality and the kindness of the owner, highlights why this shop is set to become a long-standing favorite. If you live in the Upper West Side, or find yourself in the area, a visit to Bagels and Cream is a must-do. You’ll not only enjoy a fantastic bagel but also support a local business that is truly dedicated to its craft and its community. It's more than a bagel shop; it's a neighborhood cornerstone in the making.

Bagels and Cream Food & drink

Omelette Platters
Garden Omelette US$11.00
Broccoli, mushroom, tomato, peppers.
Western Omelette US$11.00
Ham, onions, peppers.
Three Eggs Any Style US$7.50
Three eggs, plain or with your choice of poppy, sesame, onion, garlic, whole wheat, multigrain, cinnamon raisin, egg, French toast, pumpernickel, or everything.
The Bronx Omelette US$11.00
Bacon, onion, peppers, American.
Healthy Omelette US$11.00
Egg whites, broccoli, mushroom.
Avocado Omelette US$11.00
Tomato, pepper jack and avocado.
Greek Omelette US$10.00
Olives, tomato, spinach, feta.
Spicy Omelette US$9.75
Spicy. Jalapeño, tomato, cheddar cheese.
Steak Omelette US$13.00
Steak, onion, peppers, mushroom, tomato, cheddar.
Cheese Omelette US$8.50
American, cheddar, Swiss & mozzarella.
Nova Omelette US$12.00
Nova lox, onions, scallion.
Italian Omelette US$10.00
Tomato, pesto & mozzarella cheese.

Açaí & Pitaya Bowls
Nutella US$9.50
With banana, strawberries, granola, coconut & Nutella.
Supreme Açaí & Pitaya US$12.95
Mixture of acai & pitaya, topped with banana, strawberries, granola, chia, coconut flakes.
Wake Me Up US$8.50
With banana, coconut flakes, honey.
Chia US$8.50
Banana, coconut flakes, granola, chia, almond butter.
Peanut Butter US$8.50
Banana, granola, peanut butter.
Power US$8.50
With strawberry protein, banana, granola, peanut butter.

Bagels with Spreads
Butter Or Jelly US$2.00
Bagel with butter or jelly.
Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese US$4.00
A plain bagel with creamy, smooth cheese spread. Choose between toasted or not toasted.
Bagel With Tuna Salad US$8.00
Plain bagel topped with tuna salad. Choose toasted or not toasted.
Bagel With White Fish Salad US$11.00
Create your own Sandwich. Bagel topped with smoked salmon (lox). Add additional options
Bagel With Chicken Salad US$9.00
Bagel topped with chicken salad. Choose toasted or not toasted.
Bagel With Smoked Salmon (Lox) US$12.00
Create your own Sandwich. Bagel topped with smoked salmon (lox). Add additional options
Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese US$4.75
Bagel with your choice of flavored cream cheese, including scallion, veggie, lox spread, garlic & herb, jalapeno, walnut raisin, bacon & cheddar, peanut butter, or Nutella.

Egg Sandwiches
Eggs On A Bagel US$6.00
Scrambled eggs with your choice of bagel including plain, poppy, sesame, onion, garlic, whole wheat, multigrain, cinnamon raisin, egg, French toast, pumpernickel, everything bagel, roll, wrap, or panini.
Egg & Cheese US$6.75
Scrambled eggs paired with your choice of American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Provolone, Feta, or Muenster cheese.
Bacon Or Sausage Egg & Cheese US$7.50
Savory bacon or sausage paired with fresh egg and your choice of American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Provolone, Feta, or Muenster cheese.
Bacon Or Sausage Egg US$7.00
Bacon or sausage with egg.

Iced Drinks
Iced Tea US$3.00
Black, green, hibiscus.
Iced Chai Latte US$4.75
Cold Brew US$3.75
Flavored: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Iced Coffee US$3.00
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Macchiato US$4.75
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Latte US$4.75
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Iced Tea Lemonade US$3.50
Iced Nutella Latte US$4.75
Iced Cappuccino US$4.75
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Iced Lavender Honey US$4.75
Caffeine-free.
Iced Matcha Latte US$4.75
Iced Lavender Vanilla US$4.75

Fresh Squeezed Juices
No Pain US$7.00
Pineapple, carrot, kale, turmeric.
Immune Booster US$7.00
Orange, apple, lemon, ginger.
Citrus Explosion US$7.00
Grapefruit, orange, lemon.
Sweet Immunity US$7.00
Beets, orange, pineapple, ginger, honey.
20 Vision US$7.00
Mango, & carrot.
Heartbeat US$7.00
Beet, ginger, carrot, chia seeds.
Light & Green US$7.00
Apple, cucumber, celery.
Sweet Carrot US$7.00
Apple & carrot.
Sunny Day US$7.00
Carrot, apple, mango, lemon, ginger.
Super Vision US$7.00
Carrot, orange, turmeric.
Sweet Green US$7.00
Apples, kale, cucumber, spinach, lemon.
Super Healthy Green US$7.00
Spinach, kale, celery, cucumber, lemon, apple, ginger.
Pineapple Zinger US$7.00
Pineapple, apple, lemon, ginger.
Zinger US$7.00
Carrot, apple, lemon, ginger.
Shine On US$7.00
Mango, orange, pineapple.
Beachy Greens US$7.00
Pineapple, apple, cucumbers, kale, spinach.
Sunrise US$7.00
Grapefruit, carrot, apple.
Detox US$7.00
Apple, beets, carrots, lemon, ginger.

Avocado Toast
Avocado Toast US$8.00
Choice of bread or bagel, served with tomatoes & everything seeds.

Hot Drinks
Cafe Mocha US$4.25
Nutella Latte US$4.50
Chai Latte US$4.25
Cappuccino US$3.50
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Macchiato US$3.50
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
London Fog-Earl Grey Latte US$4.25
Coffee US$2.75
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Turmeric Latte US$4.25
Caffeine-free.
Lavender & Honey Latte US$4.25
Caffeine-free.
Lavender Vanilla Latte US$4.25
Matcha Latte US$4.25
Hot Chocolate US$3.50
Tea US$2.00
Black, breakfast, chamomile, Earl Grey, lemon zinger, mint, jasmine.
Latte US$3.50
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.

Bagels
Single Bagel US$2.00
Choose from Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Onion, Garlic, Whole Wheat, Multigrain, Cinnamon Raisin, Egg, French Toast, Pumpernickel, or Everything.
Baker's Dozen US$18.00
A selection of 13 bagels: Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Onion, Garlic, Whole Wheat, Multigrain, Cinnamon Raisin, Egg, French Toast, Pumpernickel, Everything.
Half Dozen US$9.00
A selection of 6 bagels: Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Onion, Garlic, Whole Wheat, Multigrain, Cinnamon Raisin, Egg, French Toast, Pumpernickel, Everything.

Cheese
Grilled Cheese US$6.00
Choose from American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Feta, Muenster, Pepper Jack, Provolone, or Swiss cheese.
Mozzarella, Tomato, Pesto US$7.95

Smoothies
Mango Strawberry US$7.00
Mango, strawberry with milk.
Tropical Vacation US$7.00
Piña colada, mango, milk.
Berry Peachy US$7.00
Mixed berries, peach & milk.
Feel Good US$7.00
Banana, avocado, chia seeds, peanut butter, almond milk.
PB & Chocolate US$7.00
Peanut butter, chocolate, banana & oat milk.
Kale Crush US$7.00
Kale, avocado, pineapple, mango & almond milk.
Zoomer US$7.00
Banana, pineapple, milk, oats, protein, honey.
Mango Madness US$7.00
Mango, banana, orange juice, & milk.
Morning Cleanse US$7.00
Banana, berries, flax seeds, chia seeds.
Banana Berry US$7.00
Mixed berries, banana & milk.
Strawberry Banana US$7.00
Strawberry, banana & milk.
Mixed Berry US$7.00
Mixed berries & milk.
Nutty Yummy US$7.00
Mango, banana, almond butter, honey.
Grape Goodness US$7.00
Grapes, peanut butter, yogurt, & banana.
Island Breeze US$7.00
Pineapple, banana, yogurt, orange juice & honey.

Sandwiches & Panini
BLT US$9.00
Turkey bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Eastchester US$12.00
Grilled chicken, turkey bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Caprese US$11.00
Mozzarella, roasted pepper, tomato, pesto. Add chicken for an additional charge.
Blondell US$12.00
Chicken cutlet, marinara, mozzarella, tomato.
Mediterranean US$9.00
Hummus, lettuce, peppers, onion, cucumber, feta & honey mustard. Add chicken for an additional charge.
California US$12.00
Grilled chicken, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, avocado, ranch.
Veggie US$10.00
Spinach, broccoli, tomato, olives, mushroom, peppers, red onion, mozzarella, avocado, balsamic.
Chicken Caesar US$12.00
Grilled chicken, Parmesan, mozzarella, romaine, tomato, Caesar.
Precinct US$11.00
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Pastrami US$13.00
Pastrami, red onions, pickles, mustard.
Bagels And Cream Special US$15.00
Sliced lox, scallion cream cheese, avocado, onions, tomato & everything seeds.
Supreme US$11.00
Chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo.
Bagels & Cream Classic US$14.00
Lox, scallion cream cheese, onion, tomato, capers. Choose from various bagel options like plain, poppy, sesame, onion, garlic, whole wheat, multigrain, cinnamon raisin, egg, French toast, pumpernickel, everything.
Tunacado US$12.00
Tuna, pesto, cheddar, avocado, tomato.
Tuna Melt US$10.00
Tuna, cheddar, onion, tomato.
Grandpa US$10.00
Turkey, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Spicy Chicken US$11.00
Spicy. Grilled chicken, pepper jack, hot sauce.
Chicken & Avocado US$12.00
Grilled chicken, peppers, onion, avocado, lettuce, tomato.
Just Cheese US$10.00
Mozzarella, cheddar, American, Swiss.
Italian US$11.00
Grilled chicken, mozzarella, tomato pesto.

Treats
French Toast US$10.00
Cherry Danish US$5.00
Flaky pastry with rich cheese filling, topped with sweet cherry slices.
Muffins US$4.90
A moist treat with your choice of Banana Nut, Cranberry Nut, Blueberry, Corn, Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, Lemon Poppy, or Raisin Bran flavors.
Apple Danish US$5.00
Flaky pastry with rich cheese filling, topped with sweet apple slices.
Cheese Danish US$5.00
Flaky pastry filled with rich cheese filling, topped with a hint of sweetness.
Pancakes US$10.00
Three pancakes served with syrup.

Bagels and Cream Photos

Bagels and Cream Location

Bagels and Cream

New York New York County New York Amsterdam Avenue

924 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA

Bagels and Cream Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 29 user reviews.

eggturkey sausagecinnamon raisin bagellox

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

My partner and I had a fantastic breakfast this morning! He got a turkey sausage, egg, and cheese on an onion bagel, and I got an onion bagel with cream cheese—it was delicious!! We’ve been ordering from another bagel place further downtown on uber eats, but with prices soaring, we need something yummy and local and this hit the spot. We will definitely be back again!
April 16 · Bennett P
This place is AMAZING! The owner isextremely kind and the staff is very nice also. The food is amazing they cooked my Bacon or Sausage Egg & Cheese perfect. If I could give this place 10 stars I would. It is extremely clean and they told me they are brand new an had just opened. I will definitely be returning here. I would recommend this place to anyone.
May 05 · courtney hauser
I recommend giving their bagels a try - I stopped here 3 times this week! Everything bagel turkey bacon, egg, and cheese; (turkey?) sausage egg and cheese; and a veggie cream cheese.
April 26 · Adriana P
Friendly new place to grab a delicious and fairly priced bagel sandwich. Start with the Classic. They don't skimp on the lox! Bagel has a chewy but not too dense inside. Variety of house-made cream cheese. The owner is also super friendly and excited to be new in the neighborhood.
July 09 · Prof. Dr. J
Fantastic bagel and very kind staff but genuinely terrible London Fog Latte but it’s rare to find a place that does it well. Definitely stop in here but stay clear of the London fog latte.
June 30 · Mya Zepp