Bagels on Main: Huntington's Local Gem for Fresh Bagels & More

Bagels on Main Introduce

For many New Yorkers, a bagel isn't just a breakfast item; it's a way of life. The perfect bagel is a symphony of flavor and texture: a crispy, chewy exterior giving way to a soft, doughy interior, and all of it crowned with a generous spread of cream cheese or a delicious filling. In Huntington, Long Island, one name consistently comes up in conversations about where to find this quintessential experience: Bagels on Main. Located right in the heart of Huntington, this beloved local spot has carved out a reputation for delivering on that promise of a classic, satisfying bagel every single time. It's a place where the familiar aroma of freshly baked bread greets you at the door, and the friendly faces behind the counter make you feel right at home. More than just a place to grab a quick bite, Bagels on Main is a community hub, a morning ritual for many, and an essential part of the local food scene. From the moment the doors open early in the morning, a steady stream of locals flows in, all in search of their daily bagel fix. Whether it's a simple toasted bagel with butter or a more elaborate breakfast sandwich to fuel a busy day, the quality and consistency here are what keep people coming back. It’s a true taste of New York, right on Main Street in Huntington.

Bagels on Main is situated at 87 E Main St, Huntington, NY 11743, USA. Its prime location on East Main Street makes it an incredibly convenient stop for anyone in the Huntington area. Being right on one of the town's central thoroughfares, it's easily accessible whether you're walking, driving, or biking. For those driving, there is often street parking available nearby, though like any popular Main Street location, it can get busy during peak hours. The shop's spot is also ideal for those commuting, as it's a perfect place to grab a coffee and a bagel before heading to work or a train station. Its central position also means it's a natural gathering point for locals meeting up for a casual breakfast or a quick lunch. The location is easily found using GPS or a map, and its visible storefront makes it simple to spot. The accessibility of Bagels on Main is one of its major draws, ensuring that a delicious, fresh bagel is never far away for anyone living or working in Huntington and the surrounding communities on Long Island.

Services Offered:

Freshly Baked Bagels: A wide variety of bagel types are baked fresh daily, including everything, plain, sesame, poppy seed, and more.
Generous Cream Cheese Schmears: Known for their ample application of cream cheese, ensuring a satisfyingly thick layer on every bagel.
Breakfast & Lunch Sandwiches: A full menu of hot and cold sandwiches, made to order with your choice of ingredients on a bagel, roll, or bread.
Coffee and Beverages: A selection of freshly brewed coffee, teas, juices, and other drinks to complement your meal.
Catering Services: Options for platters and large orders, perfect for office meetings, parties, or family gatherings.
Online and Phone Orders: Convenient ordering for pickup, allowing customers to skip the line during busy times.

Features and Highlights:

The “Schmear” Factor: Customers consistently rave about the exceptionally generous amount of cream cheese applied to their bagels. This is a defining characteristic of the shop and a major point of pride, ensuring a rich and decadent experience with every bite.
The Everything Bagel: The everything bagel from Bagels on Main has a dedicated following. Customers praise it for its perfect balance of toppings, including a hearty sprinkling of poppy seeds, sesame seeds, garlic flakes, and onion flakes, providing a burst of flavor in every chew.
Freshness and Quality: The commitment to freshness is evident in every product. From the bagels baked daily to the high-quality ingredients used in their sandwiches, the focus is on providing a superior taste and experience.
Local Vibe: The atmosphere is authentically local and friendly. The staff is known for being efficient and welcoming, contributing to the feeling of a true neighborhood bagel spot. It's a place where regulars are greeted by name and new customers are made to feel like part of the community.
Customer Reviews: A significant portion of the positive feedback centers on the sheer abundance of cream cheese and the exceptional quality of their bagels. While a stray review might mention an occasional error in a take-out order, the overwhelming consensus points to the delicious food and the joy of a perfectly made bagel. This is a business that takes pride in its craft, and it shows in the loyal customer base.

Contact Information:

Address: 87 E Main St, Huntington, NY 11743, USA

Phone: (631) 673-1902

Bagels on Main is more than just a shop; it’s a cornerstone of the Huntington community. For locals, it represents consistency, quality, and the comforting familiarity of a truly great bagel. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, this is the kind of place that embodies the spirit of a neighborhood institution. The dedication to making a superior product, from the famous schmear to the perfectly toasted bagel, resonates deeply with New Yorkers who know and appreciate the difference. It's a place where you can rely on getting exactly what you want—a delicious, filling meal that hits all the right notes. The friendly service, combined with the excellent food, makes it a welcoming spot for families, students, and professionals alike. When you're looking for an authentic bagel experience without leaving the convenience of your own town, Bagels on Main stands out as the clear choice. It's a local gem that has earned its place in the hearts and stomachs of Huntington's residents, and it will likely continue to do so for years to come.

Bagels on Main Vibe

Panini Palace
Bees Nest US$13.99
Honey ham, honey turkey, alpine lace, cole slaw, Russian dressing.
Reiss' Rave US$8.99
Fire roasted grilled veggies with Mozzarella.
Glen Head US$13.99
Cracked pepper turkey, roasted peppers, Cheddar, onions, mayo.
Andy's Delight US$13.99
Roast beef, bacon, Cheddar hot sauce, bbq sauce.
Bubbalicious US$13.99
Breaded chicken cutlet, Cheddar, bacon, bbq sauce.
Big Willie US$13.99
Honey turkey, alpine lace, bacon, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard.
Madison Avenue US$13.99
Grilled chicken, Mozzarella, roasted peppers, pesto.

Bagels
Dozen Of Any Bagels US$23.00
Dozen of any bagels
Plain US$1.95
Sesame US$1.95
Cinnamon Raisin US$1.95
Salt US$1.95
Our Famous Rainbow Bagel (Each) US$2.45
Pumpernickel US$1.95
FLAGEL US$2.75
Egg US$1.95
Mini Bagels US$1.45
Egg Everything US$1.95
Garlic US$1.95
Blueberry US$1.95
Everything US$1.95
Bialys US$1.95
Poppy US$1.95
Honey Whole Wheat US$1.95
Marble US$1.95
Onion US$1.95

Boars Head Signature Sandwiches
Corned Beef US$10.99
Salami US$8.99
Turkey US$11.99
Pastrami US$10.99
Cheese US$6.99
Roast Beef US$13.99
Brisket US$9.99
Ham US$11.99

Sandwich Maker
Classic Tuna Salad US$12.50
Lite Veggie Chicken Salad US$11.99
Breaded Chicken Cutlet US$11.99
Honey Mustard Tuna Salad US$11.99
Spinach Egg White Salad US$11.50
Classic Egg Salad US$10.50
Egg, Onion & Mushroom Salad US$10.50
Chicken Cutlet US$13.99
Fresh Chicken Cutlet made fresh daily.
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato (BLT) US$12.99
Baked Salmon Salad US$12.50
Whitefish Salad US$12.50
Lite Veggie Tuna Salad US$11.99
Chicken Salad US$12.50
Chicken Waldorf US$13.50
Spring Time Tuna With Apples & Cranberries US$11.99
Honey Mustard Chicken US$12.99

Panini Palace
Reiss' Rave US$13.99
Fire roasted grilled veggies with Mozzarella.
Bees Nest US$13.99
Honey ham, honey turkey, alpine lace, cole slaw, Russian dressing.
Big Willie US$13.99
Honey turkey, alpine lace, bacon, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard.
Andy's Delight US$15.99
Roast beef, bacon, Cheddar hot sauce, bbq sauce.
Bubbalicious US$13.99
Breaded chicken cutlet, Cheddar, bacon, bbq sauce.
Glen Head US$13.99
Cracked pepper turkey, roasted peppers, Cheddar, onions, mayo.
Madison Avenue US$13.99
Grilled chicken, Mozzarella, roasted peppers, pesto.

Bagels with a Schmear
Fruit Flavored Cream Cheese US$5.69
Cream Cheese US$4.99
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese US$5.69
Nova Spread Cream Cheese US$6.50
Vegetable Cream Cheese US$5.69
Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese US$3.50
Scallion Cream Cheese US$5.69
Butter US$3.99
Veggie Tofutti US$6.99
Chocolate Chip US$5.69
Plain Tofutti US$6.49

Specialty Side Salads
Red Bliss Potato Salad US$9.99
Per pound.
Israeli Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Pasta Primavera US$11.99
Per pound.
Old Fashioned Cucumber Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Cole Slaw US$9.99
Per pound.
Classic Macaroni Salad US$9.99
Per pound.
California Broccoli Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Tomato & Onion Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Greek Pasta Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Health Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Tuscany Bean Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Sun Dried Tomato Pasta US$11.99
Per pound.
Cucumber & Tomato Salad US$11.99
Per pound.

Breakfast Wraps
Greek US$10.99
Two eggs Feta, caramelized onions, and home fries.
Schwarznegger US$11.99
Two egg whites, honey maple turkey, spinach and alpine lace.
Jose's Quesadilla US$9.99
Two eggs, bacon, sausage, cheese, home fries and hot sauce.
Basic US$7.99
Two eggs, cheese, and home fries.
Breakfast Burrito US$8.49
Two eggs, bacon, salsa, Cheddar mixed peppers, and grilled onions.

Hot Off the Grill
Western Omelette US$10.99
Three eggs, diced ham peppers, onions, home fries, and a buttered bagel.
2 Eggs With Meat US$7.49
Specify meat and type of bread.
Challah French Toast US$9.49
The Hungry Man Platter US$12.99
Three eggs any style, bacon, sausage ham, cheese, home fries, and a buttered bagel.
2 Eggs With Cheese US$6.59
Specify cheese and type of bread.
2 Eggs Cheese And Meat US$8.99
choice of bacon or sausage or ham or turkey bacon
Greek Omelette US$10.99
Three eggs, Feta cheese, caramelized onions, home fries, and a buttered bagel.
2 Eggs On A Bagel US$5.99
Buttermilk Pancakes US$9.49

Bagels
Marble US$1.95
Our Famous Rainbow Bagel (Each) US$2.45
Salt US$1.95
Cinnamon Raisin US$1.95
Mini Bagels US$1.45
Egg Everything US$1.95
Pumpernickel US$1.95
Bialys US$1.95
Honey Whole Wheat US$1.95
Sesame US$1.95
Everything US$1.95
Plain US$1.95
Egg Onion US$1.95
Blueberry US$1.95
Poppy US$1.95
Garlic US$1.95
Onion US$1.95
Egg US$1.95

Chopped Salads
Chopped Salads US$9.99
Any six items.

Boars Head Signature Sandwiches
Turkey US$12.99
Corned Beef US$15.99
Salami US$12.99
Pastrami US$15.99
Cheese US$7.99
Brisket US$6.99
Roast Beef US$15.99
Bologna US$11.99
Ham US$12.99

The Salad Maker
Greek US$10.99
Two eggs feta, caramelized onions, and home fries.
Chefs Salad US$14.99
Tossed Garden US$10.99
House Salad US$9.99
Crisp romaine lettuce covered with grilled chicken, goat cheese, mandarin orange, craisins, and walnuts.
Classic Caesar US$10.99

Signature Sandwiches
Bonaccorso's Italiano US$13.99
Salami, ham cappy, pepperoni, Provolone lettuce, tomato onion, oil and vinegar.
G.I. Joe (American) US$13.99
Ham, turkey, roast beef American cheese lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Main St. Monti Cristo US$13.99
Grilled ham, turkey, Swiss, coleslaw on our egg battered challah bread and Russian dressing.
Reuben US$15.99
Reuben pastrami, corned beef, Swiss your choice of cole slaw or kraut on our grilled rye with Russian dressing.
Rolf's Royale US$15.99
Roast beef melted Mozzarella.
General Lee US$13.99
Cracked pepper turkey, Pepper Jack cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
The Commack Bomb US$13.99
Chicken cutlet, melted Cheddar, bacon, bbq sauce.
Christine's Combo US$13.99
Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, alpine lace. Lettuce. Tomato, honey mustard.
Big Bird US$13.99
Breaded chicken cutlet, melted American, lettuce, tomato, and Russian dressing.
Jon's 6 Pack US$13.99
Chicken cutlet melted Mozzarella smothered in our homemade buffalo sauce.
Big Dan US$13.99
Blackened turkey melted Mozzarella.
Gabby's Fave US$9.99
Turkey, Swiss cole slaw, russian dressing on our grilled whole wheat bread.
Sweet Sandy US$13.99
Honey maple turkey, alpine lace cheese, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard.

Signature Sandwiches
Main St. Monti Cristo US$13.99
Grilled ham, turkey, Swiss, coleslaw on our egg battered challah bread and Russian dressing.
General Lee US$13.99
Cracked pepper turkey, Pepper Jack cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Christine's Combo US$13.99
Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, alpine lace. Lettuce. Tomato, honey mustard.
Big Bird US$13.99
Breaded chicken cutlet, melted American, lettuce, tomato, and Russian dressing.
Bonaccorso's Italiano US$14.99
Salami, ham cappy, pepperoni, Provolone lettuce, tomato onion, oil and vinegar.
Rolf's Royale US$15.99
Roast beef melted Mozzarella.
Jon's 6 Pack US$13.99
Chicken cutlet melted Mozzarella smothered in our homemade buffalo sauce.
Reuben US$15.99
Reuben pastrami, corned beef, Swiss your choice of cole slaw or kraut on our grilled rye with Russian dressing.
Gabby's Fave US$13.99
Turkey, Swiss cole slaw, russian dressing on our grilled whole wheat bread.
Chicken Caeser Salad Wrap US$14.99
Grilled all‑white‑meat chicken breast, crisp romaine lettuce, and shaved Parmesan tossed in our house‑made, zesty Caesar dressing, wrapped snugly in a soft flour tortilla. Finished with a sprinkling of crunchy garlic‑herb crouton crumbs for that classic Caesar bite—portable, satisfying, and perfect for lunch on the go.
Big Dan US$13.99
Blackened turkey melted Mozzarella.
Sweet Sandy US$13.99
Honey maple turkey, alpine lace cheese, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard.
G.I. Joe (American) US$13.99
Ham, turkey, roast beef American cheese lettuce, tomato, mayo.
The Commack Bomb US$13.99
Chicken cutlet, melted Cheddar, bacon, bbq sauce.
California Wrap US$14.99
Hot grilled chicken, avocado, bacon, chipotle mayo, lettuce & tomato in a whole wheat wrap.

Sandwich Maker
Honey Mustard Tuna Salad US$11.99
Breaded Chicken Cutlet US$10.99
Chicken Club US$13.99
Whitefish Salad US$12.99
Spinach Egg White Salad US$11.99
Lite Veggie Tuna Salad US$11.99
Lite Veggie Chicken Salad US$10.50
Classic Egg Salad US$10.99
Chicken Salad US$11.50
Baked Salmon Salad US$12.99
Spring Time Tuna With Apples & Cranberries US$10.99
Honey Mustard Chicken US$11.50
Classic Tuna Salad US$11.99
Grilled Chicken Teriyaki US$6.99
Egg, Onion & Mushroom Salad US$11.49
Chicken Waldorf US$11.99
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato (BLT) US$12.99

Hot Off the Grill
Buttermilk Pancakes US$9.49
Challah French Toast US$9.49
Western Omelette US$11.99
Three eggs, diced ham peppers, onions, home fries, and a buttered bagel.
Bacon Egg & Cheese US$9.29
Classic New York Bacon Egg & Cheese
Greek Omelette US$10.99
Three eggs, Feta cheese, caramelized onions, home fries, and a buttered bagel.
2 Eggs With Cheese US$6.59
Specify cheese and type of bread.
2 Eggs With Meat US$7.49
Specify meat and type of bread.
The Hungry Man Platter US$13.99
Three eggs any style, bacon, sausage ham, cheese, home fries, and a buttered bagel.
2 Eggs On A Bagel US$5.99
Brian Special US$10.99
Classic Bacon Egg & Cheese, with a hash brown and grape jelly. Comes on a toasted & scooped everything bagel.

Chopped Salads
Chopped Salads US$10.99
Any six items.

Muffins
Assorted Freshly Baked US$3.99

Flagels
Plain US$2.45
Poppy US$2.45
Whole Wheat US$2.45
Everything US$2.45
Sesame US$2.45
Sunflower US$2.45

Flagels
Poppy US$2.70
Sunflower US$2.70
Plain US$2.70
Everything US$2.70
Sesame US$2.70
Whole Wheat US$2.70

Smoked Fish & Appetizing
Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon (Bialy) US$13.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Sable Plate (By The Lb.) US$48.00
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Premium Whitefish Fillet (Roll) US$11.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Atlantic Belly Lox (Bialy) US$13.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Sable Plate (Bialy) US$8.50
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Premium Whitefish Fillet (Bialy) US$11.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Baked Kippered Salmon (Roll) US$11.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon (Roll) US$13.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon (Bagel) US$13.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Atlantic Belly Lox (By The Lb.) US$62.00
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Atlantic Belly Lox (Bagel) US$10.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Sable Plate (Bagel) US$8.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Premium Whitefish Fillet (Bagel) US$8.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Baked Kippered Salmon (Bialy) US$11.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Sable Plate (Roll) US$8.50
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Premium Whitefish Fillet (By The Lb.) US$25.00
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon (By The Lb.) US$62.00
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Baked Kippered Salmon (By The Lb.) US$55.00
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Baked Kippered Salmon (Bagel) US$11.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.
Smoked Atlantic Belly Lox (Roll) US$13.50
Crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onion, plain or lite cream cheese and a crisp pickle wedge garni and side salad.

Assorted Fresh Baked Goods
Black & White Cookies US$3.99
Homemade Old Fashioned - Fresh Bakery Cookies US$17.99
Per pound.
Cinnamon Rolls US$3.99
Crumb Cake US$3.99
Homemade Old Fashioned - Assorted Rugalach US$18.99
Per pound.
Cinnamon Fruit Danish US$3.99
Cinnamon Raisin Danish US$3.99
Cheese Danish US$3.99
Chocolate Cigar US$3.99
Croissant US$3.99
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies US$3.99
Apple Turnovers US$3.99
Brownies US$3.25
Linzer Tarts US$3.99
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$3.99

Specialty Side Salads
Pasta Primavera US$11.99
Per pound.
Greek Pasta Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Classic Macaroni Salad US$9.99
Per pound.
Cucumber, Tomato & Onion Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Old Fashioned Cucumber Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Three Bean Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Sun Dried Tomato Pasta US$11.99
Per pound.
Cole Slaw US$9.99
Per pound.
Red Bliss Potato Salad US$9.99
Per pound.
Cucumber & Tomato Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Health Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Israeli Salad US$11.99
Per pound.
Chicken Salad US$18.00
California Broccoli Salad US$11.99
Per pound.

Coffee Bar
Tea US$3.50
Gourmet Coffee US$3.50
Hot Chocolate US$3.50
Columbian Coffee US$3.50
Iced Coffee US$4.50
Cold Brewed Iced Coffee US$6.00

Delicious Duos
Sandwich & Salad US$24.49
Sandwich & Cookie US$16.94

Bagels with a Schmear
Plain Tofutti US$6.49
Scallion Cream Cheese US$5.69
Butter US$3.99
Nova Spread Cream Cheese US$6.95
Cream Cheese US$4.99
1lb Plain Cream Cheese US$14.99
Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese US$5.69
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese US$5.69
1lb Scallion Cream Cheese US$15.99
1lb Veggie Cream Cheese US$15.99
Veggie Tofutti US$6.94
Vegetable Cream Cheese US$5.69
Strawberry Cream Cheese US$5.69
1lb Lox Cream Cheese US$23.99

The Salad Maker
Tossed Garden US$10.99
Chefs Salad US$14.99
Classic Caesar US$10.99
House Salad US$8.99
Crisp romaine lettuce covered with grilled chicken, goat cheese, mandarin orange, craisins, and walnuts.
Greek US$10.99
Two eggs feta, caramelized onions, and home fries.

Assorted Fresh Baked Goods
Cinnamon Rolls US$3.99
Cheese Danish US$3.99
Apple Turnovers US$3.99
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$2.95
Croissant US$3.99
Crumb Cake US$3.99
Linzer Tarts US$3.99
Brownies US$3.99
Homemade Old Fashioned - Rainbow Cookies US$18.99
Per pound.
Homemade Old Fashioned - Assorted Rugalach US$18.99
Per pound.
Chocolate Cigar US$3.99
Black & White Cookies US$3.99

Coffee Bar
Gourmet Coffee US$2.99
Hot Tea US$3.00
Hot Chocolate US$2.00
Deli Lemonade US$3.78
Iced Coffee US$3.00
Cold Brewed Iced Coffee US$4.00
Deli Iced Tea (Sweetened) US$3.78
Columbian Coffee US$2.99
Arnold Palmer US$3.78
Half Sweet Tea and Half Lemonade
French Vanilla Iced Coffee US$3.78

Muffins
Assorted Freshly Baked US$4.25

Smoked Fish & Appetizing
Smoked Sable Plate (By The Lb.) US$48.00
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Premium Whitefish Salad (By The Lb.) US$28.00
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Baked Kippered Salmon Salad (Bialy) US$11.50
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Premium Whitefish Salad (Bialy) US$11.50
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Smoked Atlantic Belly Lox (Bagel) US$13.50
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Premium Whitefish Salad (Bagel) US$11.50
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Smoked Atlantic Belly Lox (By The Lb.) US$62.00
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Baked Kippered Salmon (By The Lb.) US$45.00
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon (Bagel) US$13.50
Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Smoked Sable Plate (Bialy) US$10.00
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon (By The Lb.) US$62.00
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Premium Whitefish Salad (Roll) US$11.50
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Smoked Sable Plate (Bagel) US$10.00
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Smoked Sable Plate (Roll) US$10.00
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Baked Kippered Salmon (Roll) US$9.50
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.
Baked Kippered Salmon (Bagel) US$11.50
Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad.

Bagels on Main Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Bagels on Main Photos

Bagels on Main Location

Bagels on Main

New York Suffolk County Huntington East Main Street

87 E Main St, Huntington, NY 11743, USA

Bagels on Main Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 229 user reviews.

saladegg sandwichcream cheesepricesdeliluncheverything bagelgrilledlox sandwichthumbs up

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This place definitely respects the schmearrrrr. I always have to get a second bagel with no cream cheese because there is so much cream cheese that leaks out of my first bagel — I love it!Their everything bagel is also amazing.
October 04 · Kion Noori
Ordered 2 sandwiches and 5 bagels to go. Imagine my surprise as I am individually wrapping each of the 5 bagels to put in the freezer and found the last one, which would have been first in the bag, already cut in half. Pay attention and do better for the $26.24 I paid for this order.
November 17 · Maureen Mcloughlin
Ordered a grilled chicken caesar wrap, was stuffed with lettuce and at most 2 oz's of chicken, couldnt even eat it because it fell apart as soon as i picked it up. Please do better
July 11 · Mike M
It may look like your average bagel joint, but Bagels On The Main is anything but!I wandered in with family on a beautiful beach day and was immediately greeted by the friendly staff and the incredible aroma of fresh grub. The shop was filling up quickly, and despite the volume of orders, we were able to snag some delicious bagels for the beach in no time!We ordered Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon and an everything bagel with cream cheese along with some aesthetically pleasing half and half lemonade drinks. The bagels were crisp, flavorful, and made with love. Everything worked together beautifully; I was especially impressed by the packaging and care invested into each order. By the end of the meal we were planning our next visit. We found our new spot!P.S For all of the influencers out there. This is the perfect spot for affordable, delicious, and photo-worthy EVERYTHING!
June 14 · Brittany Shoughi
Bagels are small and over cooked. Salads are pretty horrible / heavily salted. The pasta in the pasta salad was hard like a rock. Very expensive!I hate leaving negative reviews, but just maybe the owners will learn something.
March 25 · Jordan Frankel - Security Expert