Bears Bagels Introduce
## Bears Bagels: The Real-Deal Bagel Experience in Hilliard, Ohio
For **Ohio** locals who believe a bagel should be more than just a round piece of bread, **Bears Bagels** in **Hilliard** is the essential destination. Located right on Main Street, this highly-acclaimed **bagel shop** has quickly cemented its status as one of Central Ohio's best spots for authentic, artisanal baked goods. Bears Bagels was born from a passion for making bagels "the real way"—a commitment that owners Charis and Lo Yost have turned into a community phenomenon.
What exactly is "the real way"? It involves a dedicated, multi-step process: the dough is hand-rolled, allowed to rest for 24 hours to develop a deep, complex flavor, then **boiled** to set the crust, and finally **baked** to achieve that perfect combination of a dense, slightly chewy interior and a beautiful, crispy crust. This dedication to traditional, time-honored methods is what sets Bears Bagels apart from many other places in the Columbus area. The resulting bagel is sturdy, flavorful, and the ideal foundation for their inventive menu.
But Bears Bagels is about more than just the bagel itself. It’s an entire experience built on creativity, quality, and community. Their menu goes far beyond the basics, featuring an exciting lineup of house-made schmears, inventive breakfast and lunch sandwiches, and locally-sourced coffee. Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast, settling in for a casual dine-in meal, or picking up a dozen for the office, Bears Bagels promises a fresh, friendly, and truly delicious start to any Ohio day.
## Location and Accessibility in Hilliard, OH
The location of Bears Bagels is both central and highly convenient for residents of Hilliard and the wider Central Ohio region, making it an easy-to-access spot for your daily fix.
The address for this popular bagel shop is:
Address: 4142 Main St, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
Situated on **Main Street** in the heart of **Hilliard, OH**, the shop is easy to find and is well-served by excellent accessibility features. For patrons driving in, the location offers a significant convenience: a **free parking lot**, **free street parking**, and generally ample **on-site parking**. This ensures that even during busy Saturday mornings, finding a spot shouldn't be a major hassle.
Furthermore, Bears Bagels is committed to inclusivity, featuring a **Wheelchair accessible entrance** and a **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**. This focus on making the shop welcoming and easy to navigate for all members of the Ohio community underscores their commitment to great service. The central location also makes it a quick visit for those looking for a fast, quality breakfast, fulfilling the need for a **Quick visit** as noted in their planning information.
## Comprehensive Services Offered
Bears Bagels offers a versatile range of services designed to accommodate modern lifestyles, from quick grabs to a more relaxed breakfast experience.
Key services available to their Ohio patrons include:
- In-store Pickup and Takeout: Allowing customers to quickly grab their bagels, schmears, and sandwiches for convenient consumption on the go.
- Dine-in Option: Providing limited seating for those who wish to enjoy their breakfast or lunch in the welcoming atmosphere of the shop.
- Onsite Services: General sales and counter service for all bagel, schmear, and beverage needs.
- Breakfast and Lunch Sandwiches: Offering an extensive menu of creative bagel sandwiches for a hearty start or mid-day meal.
- Catering Services: Providing trays and platters of bagels, schmears, and sandwiches for business meetings, parties, and community events across the Columbus area.
- Beverage Service: Featuring high-quality local coffee, including **Jennings Java House Cold Brew**, a signature **Bear Banana Bread Latte**, and a variety of canned/bottled drinks.
- Custom Schmear and Jam Options: Creating a diverse selection of house-made spreads, including savory, spicy, and sweet options like **Chili Crisp** and **Sassy Strawberry**.
## Standout Features and Highlights
What truly elevates Bears Bagels above a typical **bagel shop** are its unique features, community focus, and commitment to both flavor innovation and social responsibility.
Distinctive features that highlight Bears Bagels include:
- Authentic Boiling and Baking Process: The bagels are hand-rolled and **rested for 24 hours, boiled, then baked**, resulting in an authentic, high-quality chewy and crusty texture that Ohio patrons love.
- Signature & Creative Menu: Offering a robust menu that includes savory staples like the **Rosemary Sea Salt** bagel and inventive sandwiches like the **¿Por Que No El Puerco** and **Bears Best** (featuring hoisin slab bacon and chili crisp schmear).
- Acclaimed Recognition: The shop has received significant local and national attention, including being named among the **country's best new restaurants** by a major US publication, a testament to its quality.
- Inclusive and Welcoming Environment: Explicitly identifying as **LGBTQ+ friendly** and a **Transgender safespace**, ensuring all members of the Ohio community feel welcomed and respected.
- High-Quality Coffee Offerings: Partnerships with local roasters like **Jennings Java House** for their cold brew, reinforcing a commitment to supporting other Ohio businesses.
- Diverse Payment Options: Accepting **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments**, making transactions quick and effortless for a seamless customer experience.
- Weekend Special: The highly anticipated **Sunday Sammie**, a rotating, creative weekly sandwich that has generated a loyal following among customers who "check every Saturday for an update."
## Contact Information
To place a large order, inquire about the current menu specials (like the famous Sunday Sammie), or confirm their operating hours, residents can reach Bears Bagels using the following contact details:
Address: 4142 Main St, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
Phone: (614) 319-3561
Mobile Phone: +1 614-319-3561
## Why Bears Bagels is the Right Choice for Ohio Bagel Lovers
For any Ohio local seeking the ultimate bagel experience, **Bears Bagels** represents a superior choice that perfectly balances tradition, innovation, and community values. Choosing this Hilliard shop means investing in quality that has been nationally recognized and locally adored.
The first reason to choose Bears Bagels is the **uncompromising quality** of the base product. The hand-rolled, 24-hour rested, boiled-then-baked process is not a shortcut; it's a commitment to texture and flavor that is evident in every bite. Customers often note that the effort is palpable, offering a true "New York-style" density and chew that can be hard to find in the Midwest. Whether you opt for a classic **Everything** bagel or the aromatic **Rosemary Sea Salt**, you're starting with a product crafted to perfection.
Secondly, the menu’s creativity makes every visit an adventure. The range of specialty schmears, from the bold **Chili Crisp** to the subtly sweet **Maple Cinnamon**, allows patrons to customize their experience endlessly. Furthermore, their signature sandwiches, such as the **Goldie Lox** and the weekly-changing **Sunday Sammie**, prove the shop's ability to blend classic comfort food with unique, gourmet flavor combinations. This inventive approach keeps the menu fresh and exciting for loyal customers.
Finally, the friendly and inclusive atmosphere, coupled with easy accessibility (free parking and wheelchair access), makes the shop a true community hub. When you choose Bears Bagels, you're not just buying a bagel; you're supporting a business that values high-quality food, creative expression, and a welcoming environment for **all** Ohio residents. For the best bagel sandwiches and artisan schmears in the Columbus area, Bears Bagels is consistently the top recommendation.
Bears Bagels Menu
Bagels
- Everything
- Sesame
- Rosemary Sea Salt
- Pretzel
- Seasonal Bialy $6.00
Schmears
- Plain
- Roasted Veggie
- Toasty Everything
- Garlic & Chive
- Chili Crisp
- Sassy Strawberry
- Maple Cinnamon
- Seasonal Jam
- Seasonal Schmear
- Avocado Smash
- Butter
Sandwiches
- The Classic $6.00
- Goldie Lox $14.00
- Bears Best $14.00
- ¿Por Que No El Puerco $13.00
- Cali Cuts $12.00
- Child's Garden $11.00
- Westwood Heat Wave $12.00
- Grilled Threes $11.00
- Brunch It $10.00
Extras
- Honey Chipotle Mayo $1.00
- Buffalo Sauce $1.00
Beverages
- Jennings Java House Cold Brew $5.00
- The Bear Banana Bread Latte $5.00
- Liquid Death Still/Sparkling Water & Teas $3.00
- Assorted Soda, Juice, & Lemonade $2.50
- Hot Tea & Hot Chocolate $2.00
Sides
- Hott Duckes $6.00
Bears Bagels Details
Service options
- In-store pickup
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
- Delivery
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Amenities
- Restroom
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safespace
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
- On-site parking
Bears Bagels Photos










Bears Bagels Location
Bears Bagels Reviews
schmearbagel sandwicheverything bagelbialyrosemary bageladditionhot saucebanana breadseasoninglatte
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1We absolutely LOVE Bears. The staff is so friendly and the food is both creative and delicious. We check every Saturday for an update on what the Sunday Sammie will be. I always have to get a plain bagel to take home with me for Monday morning. This is one of my favorite places in the city!
August 03 · dave bradshawHad an excellent bagel for breakfast. There was a small line to order on Saturday morning, but moved pretty quickly. We ordered three specialty bagel sandwiches, all on everything bagels. Though it was tasty, texture was more bread like; would have preferred slightly chewier texture. Also on the pricey side.
June 01 · David ChangWhat a cool little shop! There's not much dine in space but there was plenty of people lined up outside for to gos. The shop is very small, with a couple tables, and the parking lot is limited. There is street parking available around the area!We tried a few different bagels and they were all made well, delicious, and with quality ingredients. I really enjoyed all of them. You can't go wrong with your choice, they're good. I would suggest trying to eat them while they're hot and fresh! It was a little messy to eat just because the ingredients would squeeze out after each bite but we kept them wrapped up which helpedThere was a long line when we came but they moved people pretty quickly.Staff was nice and helped us pick our bagel option per choice!I would recommend for a small group, something easy to eat, a quick meal or snack, and some yummy fuel for your day.
July 29 · V DI visited Black Bear Bagels for the first time today. There was a long queue but it went fast and I had my food hot and ready within 20 minutes. Which is incredible.Food: I ordered the Por Queue egg cheese avocado smash bagels and 2 goldi lox bagels with one goldi lox bagel having egg and cheese added.The bagels came out hot and fresh. The taste, crunch and bite of the actual bagels are delicious and tick off every box. The fillings however, I felt were lacking. They didn’t taste of anything is how I can describe it. The red onion pickles had no bite, cheese was bland, egg was not seasoned at all, avocado smash had no seasoning either and was super bland. I had to add some salt pepper to bring some of it to life.I would definitely come back for the bagels alone and make my own fillings at home.Service: AMAZING. The staff are so kind and friendly and work so well together. The line moves so quickly as they are working as a dedicated team. I made an adjustment to one of the bagels that they weren’t used to and they did it with no issue. Such sweet people!
July 27 · Aisha HashmiOhioan Opinion: Warning ‼️ A kind Midwestern girliepop who likes all food and people.Fun, cute, and delicious! I loved my sandwich which was the “Bears Best”. Great texture inside and out. I also had the Banana bread latte and it was delicious 🤤. I love the idea that this couple opened it after finding their passion for bagels during Covid and turned it into a business. If we’re being honest all of us baked things during that time but not many of us had the balls or talent to turn it into an actual successful business. I’m all about the atmosphere and the story behind things.New Jersey Opinion 😂: warning ‼️ harsh criticMy husband who is from New Jersey likes the bagels by themselves. He’s not a big sandwich bagel/“whipped” cream cheese kinda guy… he ordered a sandwich of course. He thinks he would like the bagels better with non-whipped cream cheese. His favorite Ohio bagel is still Sammy’s Bagels and resembles east coast bagels the most 🙄. Wonder if other people from NJ or the east coast agree or is my husband just a weirdo? Not sure! Anywho, he is also a harsh pizza critic.
August 31 · Bailey Cooper
More Bakery Near Me
Hilliard Station Baking Co.4.0 (131 reviews)4036 Main St, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard4.0 (119 reviews)5354 Center St, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
Bakes by Lo5.0 (100 reviews)5354 Center St, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
Daylight Donuts & Cafe Hilliard4.0 (476 reviews)5228 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
Giant Eagle Bakery4.0 (23 reviews)4001 Britton Pkwy, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
Lil Donut Factory4.0 (488 reviews)4543 Scioto Darby Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
Vanilla Cakes & pastries4.0 (179 reviews)2604 Hilliard Rome Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
Kroger Bakery1.0 (2 reviews)2525 Hilliard Rome Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
Two Dolls Cakery5.0 (43 reviews)2406 Oakthorpe Dr, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA
Walmart Bakery2.0 (3 reviews)5900 Britton Pkwy, Dublin, OH 43016, USA
Great American Cookies4.0 (83 reviews)5043 Tuttle Crossing Blvd #166, Dublin, OH 43016, USA
Cinnabon3.0 (19 reviews)5043 Tuttle Crossing Blvd, Dublin, OH 43016, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Churro Bakery4.0 (24 reviews)
Umairah's Cookie5.0 (10 reviews)
Southern Squares Petit Fours5.0 (11 reviews)
Walmart Bakery3.0 (2 reviews)
Sam's Club Bakery1.0 (1 reviews)
Patisserie on California5.0 (74 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
