Borough Bagel Co. Introduce
Welcome to a culinary journey that brings the true essence of a classic bagel experience right to your doorstep in Connecticut. If you're searching for that perfect, chewy, and flavorful bagel that transports you straight to the heart of New York, look no further than Borough Bagel Co. Located in the charming coastal town of Stonington, Borough Bagel Co. has quickly established itself as a beloved local gem, providing residents and visitors alike with an unparalleled breakfast and lunch option. This article will delve into what makes Borough Bagel Co. a must-visit destination for anyone in the Connecticut region, from their delectable offerings to their convenient location and commitment to quality.
Borough Bagel Co. isn't just another bagel shop; it's a testament to the art of bagel making. Their dedication to crafting authentic New York-style bagels is evident in every bite. Customers consistently rave about the perfectly soft and airy inside, encased in that signature crispy crust – a hallmark of a truly great bagel. Whether you prefer yours plain with a smear of cream cheese, or piled high with savory fillings, Borough Bagel Co. delivers an experience that satisfies even the most discerning bagel connoisseur.
Borough Bagel Co. is conveniently situated at 22 Bayview Ave #42, Stonington, CT 06378, USA. This prime location places it within easy reach for many residents across southeastern Connecticut. Stonington itself is a picturesque town known for its historic charm and vibrant community, making a trip to Borough Bagel Co. an enjoyable outing in itself. The shop's placement within the area ensures good accessibility, whether you're commuting from nearby towns like Mystic, Westerly, or Groton, or simply enjoying a leisurely weekend drive along the coast. Its location at 22 Bayview Ave #42 suggests it might be part of a larger complex or a collection of local businesses, which often provides ample parking and a pleasant atmosphere for visitors. The ease of access makes it a perfect stop for a quick breakfast on the way to work, a leisurely brunch with family, or a delicious pick-me-up any time of day.
Freshly Baked Bagels: A wide variety of classic and specialty bagels, baked fresh daily to ensure optimal taste and texture. Expect that desired crispy exterior and soft, chewy interior.
Bagel Sandwiches: A diverse menu of breakfast and lunch sandwiches, featuring high-quality ingredients. Popular choices include the classic bacon, egg, and cheese, often served on their signature bagels.
Cream Cheese Spreads: An assortment of freshly made cream cheese flavors, from plain to savory and sweet options, perfect for customizing your bagel experience.
Coffee and Beverages: Complement your bagel with a selection of hot and cold beverages, including freshly brewed coffee, to start your day right or enjoy an afternoon treat.
Takeaway and Catering Options: Convenient for grabbing a quick bite on the go, and potentially offering catering services for local events and gatherings, although specific catering details would need to be confirmed directly with the shop.
Authentic NYC Bagel Flavor: Customers consistently highlight the classic New York City bagel flavor, characterized by a perfectly soft and airy inside encased in a truly crispy crust. This is a significant draw for those seeking an authentic bagel experience outside of the five boroughs.
Exceptional Freshness and Longevity: A standout feature is how well the bagels hold up, even on day two. As one customer noted, a quick toast makes them taste "like they were fresh out of the oven," showcasing the high quality of their ingredients and baking process.
Delicious Sandwich Combinations: The "bacon, egg and cheese on spicy everything" bagel has been specifically praised as "amazing," indicating a strong focus on crafting flavorful and satisfying sandwich options. The plain bagel with cream cheese is also lauded as "absolutely perfect," catering to both adventurous and traditional tastes.
Friendly Ownership and Service: The owner is frequently mentioned for being "so nice," contributing to a welcoming and pleasant atmosphere that enhances the overall customer experience. This personal touch often transforms a good meal into a memorable one.
Proximity to Local Attractions: The mention of being "at the Mill" suggests a location within or very near a local landmark or community hub, making it a convenient stop for those visiting the area for other purposes.
Address: 22 Bayview Ave #42, Stonington, CT 06378, USA
Please note: As a local business, it is always recommended to check their official website or social media channels for the most up-to-date information on operating hours, current menu offerings, and any changes to their services. Phone numbers for small businesses can sometimes change, or they may prefer contact through other means, so verifying directly is always the best approach.
Borough Bagel Co. is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's an integral part of the local Connecticut community, particularly for those in the Stonington area and surrounding towns. Its suitability for locals stems from several key factors that resonate deeply with the preferences and needs of residents.
Firstly, the commitment to authentic New York-style bagels means that locals no longer have to travel far to experience a truly great bagel. This brings a piece of that iconic culinary tradition directly to their neighborhood, fulfilling a craving for quality that many might have previously had to seek out of state. The consistent praise for their crispy crusts and soft, airy interiors speaks to a level of craftsmanship that elevates their offerings beyond typical breakfast fare. For busy Connecticut residents, the convenience of having such high-quality bagels close to home is a significant advantage, making it easy to enjoy a delicious and satisfying meal without extensive travel.
Secondly, the consistently high quality of their products ensures that every visit is a rewarding one. The fact that their bagels hold up exceptionally well, even on the second day, is a testament to their superior ingredients and baking process. This feature is particularly appealing to locals who might buy a dozen to enjoy throughout the week, ensuring freshness and flavor with just a quick toast. This reliability builds trust and encourages repeat visits, establishing Borough Bagel Co. as a dependable local staple for breakfast and lunch needs.
Furthermore, the positive interactions with the owner and staff create a welcoming and friendly atmosphere that fosters a sense of community. When locals feel valued and appreciated, they are more likely to support a business, transforming a simple transaction into a pleasant experience. This personal touch is often what differentiates a good local business from a great one, encouraging word-of-mouth recommendations and reinforcing its position as a beloved neighborhood spot.
Lastly, its convenient location in Stonington makes it an easily accessible destination for a broad range of residents. Whether it's a stop on the way to work, a treat after running errands, or a planned weekend outing, Borough Bagel Co. fits seamlessly into the local lifestyle. Its presence enriches the local culinary scene, offering a specialized product that meets a high standard of quality. For anyone in Connecticut seeking an authentic, delicious, and reliably excellent bagel experience, Borough Bagel Co. stands out as the clear choice, truly making it a local favorite.
Borough Bagel Co. Food & drink
BAGELS
- AS IS US$2.50
- 1/2 DOZEN US$14.00
- DOZEN OR MORE US$24.00
BAGEL SANDWICHES
- Bagel with Butter US$3.50
- Bagel with Cream Cheese US$4.00
- Bagel with Peanut Butter US$4.50
- EGG & CABOT CHEDDAR US$7.50
- BACON, EGG & CABOT CHEDDAR US$10.50
- I'M A HOT MESS US$16.50
bagel with egg, cheese, bacon, avocado & grilled tomato
- LOXY LADY US$14.50
bagel with house made lox, cream cheese, house made pickled onion, sliced tomato & capers
- HEAVEN'S TO BETSY US$8.00
bagel with cream cheese, sliced tomato & bacon
DAILY BAGEL SPECIALS
- CHEDDAR JALAPENO US$3.00
CREAM CHEESE FLAVORS
- 8 OZ PLAIN US$5.00
- 8 OZ FLAVOR US$6.50
YOGURT PARFAIT
- Yogurt Parfait US$8.00
Plain greek yogurt, house made berry compote, house made granola, maple syrup drizzle
BUILD YOUR OWN EXTRAS
- AVOCADO, BACON, GRILLED TOMATO US$3.00
- EGG, SLICED TOMATO US$2.00
- CHEESE: Plain, scallion or veggie, cream cheese, cabot cheddar US$1.50
- SLICED CUCUMBER, PICKLED ONION US$1.00
DRINKS
- HOT coffee, tea, cocoa US$3.00
- COLD; boxed water, asst Izze, coconut water, boxed milks US$3.00
- ICED Coffee or Tea US$4.50
- ICED Hibiscus Cooler US$6.50
Borough Bagel Co. Details
Service options
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Borough Bagel Co. Photos



Borough Bagel Co. Location
Borough Bagel Co.
22 Bayview Ave #42, Stonington, CT 06378, USA
Borough Bagel Co. Reviews
egg
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Classic NYC bagel flavor with a perfectly soft and airy inside encased in a crispy crust.Note: While the bagels where outstanding fresh from the shop on day 1 what was even more unbelievable was how good they held up on day 2, just a quick toast and it was like they were fresh out of the oven. amazing.
June 30 · Sasha and Alejandro del PeralFantastic bagels! The bacon, egg and cheese on spicy everything was amazing, and the plain bagel with cream cheese was absolutely perfect! The owner was so nice, and we'll certainly come back in whenever we are at the Mill!
June 15 · Joel HurleyTried a bagel and was very impressed about the quality and taste of it. I am very familiar with New York style bagels and hard to find a business that them as good as this one. Highly recommended.
June 01 · DOGRANT1Tried them for the first time. I love a good lox bagel and theirs was easily one of the best ones I’ve EVER eaten. My family raved about their bagels. Will definitely go back!
March 23 · Dennis JonesBetter than Blackseed, Pop Up, Williamsburg Bagel… hands down these are the best bagels I’ve ever had. Perfect chew, and the sandwiches are outstanding. And the service is outstanding! Highly recommend
June 23 · Ariel Mitchell
More Bakery Near Me
Sift Bake Shop Watch Hill4.0 (75 reviews)102 Bay St, Watch Hill, RI 02891, USA
Lis bakeshop4.0 (197 reviews)15 Holmes St, Mystic, CT 06355, USA
Deviant Donuts4.0 (886 reviews)27 Coogan Blvd Building 6, Mystic, CT 06355, USA
Flour Shop Bagels4.0 (168 reviews)20 Mechanic St, Pawcatuck, CT 06379, USA
Vesta Bakery4.0 (176 reviews)47 Railroad Ave, Westerly, RI 02891, USA
Black Dahlia Baking Company0.0 (0 reviews)9 Alton Bradford Rd, Bradford, RI 02808, USA
Cake by Franck4.0 (176 reviews)41u00b028'19. 71u00b057'35., 5 7th St, Norwich, CT 06360, USA
Elim Bakery4.0 (282 reviews)623 Bank St #5043, New London, CT 06320, USA
Budda Cups0.0 (0 reviews)39 New Kings Factory Rd, Wood River Junction, RI 02894, USA
Walmart Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)155 Parkway N, Waterford, CT 06385, USA
West's Bakery4.0 (349 reviews)995 Main St, Hope Valley, RI 02832, USA
Dixie Donut Shop4.0 (483 reviews)275 W Town St, Norwich, CT 06360, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Christy's Donuts4.0 (180 reviews)
D's Bon Appetit of Atlanta4.0 (36 reviews)
Cruize4.0 (20 reviews)
85°C Bakery Cafe - Gardena4.0 (2008 reviews)
Bake House on Main4.0 (87 reviews)
Panaderia y pasteleria Dulce Antojo4.0 (134 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Bake the Best Homemade S'mores Brownies
How to Make the Best Focaccia Bread with Rosemary
How to Create a Beautiful Bakery-Style Dessert Spread
How to Make Perfect Strawberry Jam for Baking: U.S. Home Baker’s Guide
5 Essential Baking Tools to Elevate Your Cakes to the Next Level
How to Make Delicious Chocolate Covered Strawberries | Simple Steps & Tips
