Cake A Fare Introduce
For those of us in Pennsylvania, especially in and around Lebanon County, finding a local bakery that truly understands the art and importance of a special occasion cake can be a real game-changer. Look no further than Cake A Fare, a beloved Myerstown establishment that has earned a stellar reputation for crafting not just cakes, but edible masterpieces. Specializing in custom creations, particularly wedding cakes, Cake A Fare goes above and beyond to ensure that your dessert is not only visually stunning but also incredibly delicious, leaving a lasting impression on every guest.
What sets Cake A Fare apart in the bustling Pennsylvania dessert scene is their unwavering commitment to both aesthetic excellence and unparalleled flavor. Many local patrons describe their cakes as "the best tasting cake they ever had," a testament to the skill and passion that goes into every single creation. Whether you have a specific vision in mind for a grand celebration or need inspiration for a more intimate gathering, the team at Cake A Fare works collaboratively with you to bring your dream cake to life. This personalized approach, combined with their ability to deliver on big expectations, makes them a standout choice for residents throughout our community.
Operating right here in Myerstown, Cake A Fare understands the importance of local service and reliability. They are known not only for the quality of their baked goods but also for their seamless customer experience, particularly when it comes to crucial events like weddings. From the initial consultation and taste testing to the meticulous delivery and setup, customers consistently praise their professionalism and ease of working with them. For any Pennsylvanian seeking a bakery that combines artisanal talent with a dedicated, stress-free service, Cake A Fare is undoubtedly a top-tier option, promising a sweet ending to any significant moment.
Cake A Fare is conveniently located at 498 E Lincoln Ave, Myerstown, PA 17067, USA. This central Myerstown address places the bakery in an easily accessible spot for residents throughout Lebanon County and neighboring areas in Pennsylvania. East Lincoln Avenue is a primary thoroughfare, making it straightforward to find, whether you're a long-time Myerstown resident or visiting from a nearby town like Lebanon or Reading.
The strategic positioning of Cake A Fare on a main road ensures good visibility and ease of navigation. For those traveling by car, parking options in the vicinity are generally accommodating, which is a practical consideration for customers picking up larger custom orders like wedding cakes. The bakery’s presence within the local business landscape of Myerstown means it’s part of a community that values local enterprises, and its accessibility contributes to its strong reputation among Pennsylvania residents looking for quality baked goods without having to travel far.
Myerstown itself is a welcoming borough in Lebanon County, known for its friendly atmosphere and local businesses. Cake A Fare's location contributes to the convenience for locals who appreciate being able to support a high-quality, hometown bakery. The ease of access makes it simple for clients to visit for consultations, taste tests, or to pick up their exquisitely crafted cakes for any occasion.
- Custom Wedding Cakes: Specializing in creating stunning and delicious wedding cakes tailored to each couple's vision, from design inspiration to flavor combinations. They handle delivery and setup at venues.
- Specialty Cakes: Crafting custom cakes for a wide array of celebrations beyond weddings, including birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, and other significant milestones.
- Taste Testing Consultations: Providing opportunities for clients to sample various cake flavors and fillings to help them select the perfect combination for their custom order.
- Collaborative Design Process: Working closely with customers, including reviewing inspirational images and discussing ideas, to ensure the final cake perfectly matches their expectations.
- Delivery and Setup: Offering convenient delivery directly to event venues and handling the professional setup of cakes, particularly for larger events like weddings, ensuring a worry-free experience for the client.
- Variety of Cake Types and Flavors: Providing diverse cake sizes, shapes, and a wide array of mouth-watering flavors, frostings, and garnishes, with options for custom flavor requests.
- Baked Creations: While specializing in custom cakes, they may also offer other baked goods such as cupcakes, pies, and dessert tables, often seen alongside their main cake offerings for events.
- Exceptional Taste and Quality: Consistently praised by customers as having the "best tasting cakes," with specific mentions of delicious and incredible flavors. This focus on taste, alongside aesthetics, is a key highlight.
- Stunning Visual Appeal: Cakes are described as "beautiful" and "gorgeous," with the ability to "nail" designs provided as inspiration, ensuring they are visually impressive centerpieces for any event.
- Easy and Stress-Free Collaboration: Clients consistently highlight how "super easy" it is to work with the team, particularly Jamie, praising their responsiveness, helpfulness, and accommodation throughout the process.
- Reliable and Professional Service: Customers commend the bakery for its smooth execution, including timely delivery and meticulous setup at venues, removing any worry from the client's shoulders.
- High Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty: Reviewers express immense satisfaction, stating they "loved it" and "would use for future events," indicating a strong loyal customer base and high recommendations.
- Value for Money: Mentioned as offering "good price" for "best tasting cakes," suggesting that Cake A Fare provides excellent quality and service at a reasonable value for the Pennsylvania market.
- Creative and Custom Capabilities: Demonstrated ability to take a picture or an idea and "bring vision to life" or "deliver in a big way," showcasing their creative talent and adaptability for unique requests.
Address: 498 E Lincoln Ave, Myerstown, PA 17067, USA
Phone: (717) 866-9324
For residents of Myerstown and the wider Pennsylvania community, Cake A Fare represents the epitome of a local business that truly understands and delivers on the needs of its patrons. When planning special occasions, from intimate family gatherings to grand wedding celebrations, the dessert is often a centerpiece that needs to be perfect. Cake A Fare consistently proves its suitability for locals by providing not just beautiful cakes, but truly delicious ones, a combination that is highly valued in our region.
The feedback from fellow Pennsylvanians speaks volumes. Customers like Crystal and David explicitly state that Cake A Fare offers "the best tasting cakes in Lebanon County," a powerful endorsement from local users who have experienced their quality firsthand. This level of praise for both taste and visual appeal means that locals don't have to compromise when choosing their celebratory desserts. Furthermore, the ease of working with their team, particularly for high-stakes events like weddings where stress reduction is key, makes Cake A Fare an invaluable local resource. The ability to simply provide an idea and trust that the bakery will "deliver in a big way" and handle all setup is a service that provides immense peace of mind.
Beyond the product itself, choosing Cake A Fare means supporting a local Myerstown business that contributes directly to our community. This bakery has clearly established itself as a trusted provider, with customers expressing loyalty and planning to return for all future cake needs. For anyone in Pennsylvania seeking a reliable, talented, and customer-focused bakery that will make their special moments even sweeter and more memorable, Cake A Fare stands out as an ideal choice right here in our backyard.
Cake A Fare Details
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Cake A Fare Photos




Cake A Fare Location
Cake A Fare
498 E Lincoln Ave, Myerstown, PA 17067, USA
Cake A Fare Reviews
birthday cake
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Jamie did awesome with our wedding cake!! It was beautiful and incredible!! Crystal and I loved it and everyone said it was the best tasting cake they ever had!! If your looking for a good price best tasting cake’s in Lebanon country this is your place to go to!!! For our future cakes this is the place we are going to!!! Working with her was super easy, we taste tested told her what flavors we wanted and gave her an idea what we wanted and she delivered in a big way!! She set everything up for our wedding and delivered the cake to the venue and not once did I have to reach out to her about anything and we didn’t worry one bit.. She’s awesome and did a wonderful job!! Thank you love Crystal and David!!!
August 01 · Asset Protection InvestigatorDelicious and gorgeous cakes! I provided a picture as inspiration and she nailed it!!
February 17 · Stacy SThe birthday cake we ordered far exceeded our expectations. It was absolutely outstanding in both appearance and taste. Jamie was great to work with. Highly recommend!
July 09 · Rebecca MadonnaOur wedding cake was absolutely incredible! We ordered a wedding cake to look like birch wood, and so many people gave us compliments and told us how real it looked. We LOVED it and it was exactly what we were looking for. It also tasted AMAZING. Highly recommend! Jamie ensured everything was perfect not only with the cake, but the whole cake table. Super easy to work with, professional, and responsive! So glad we went with Cake A Fare!
October 08 · Emily JamesJamie did an amazing job with our cake and cake flavors. It was exactly what we wanted for our wedding. The apple spice cake was devine and the carrot cake was out of this world. Both so moist and light and not overly sweet. 10/10 would return
November 20 · Shakira Tassone
More Bakery Near Me
Rise and Shine Bakery5.0 (6 reviews)1359 Hilltop Rd, Myerstown, PA 17067, USA
Philly Pretzel Factory4.0 (34 reviews)1355 E Lehman St, Lebanon, PA 17046, USA
Walmart Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)1355 E Lehman St, Lebanon, PA 17046, USA
Cinnabon4.0 (23 reviews)2210 Camp Swatara Rd, Frystown, PA 17067, USA
Dottie Feathers Cakes4.0 (23 reviews)416 E Guilford St, Lebanon, PA 17046, USA
Sweets and So Much More5.0 (2 reviews)Lebanon, PA 17046, USA
Mahoski Gourmet Foods0.0 (0 reviews)618 Canal St, Lebanon, PA 17046, USA
Cakes by Moraima & Cafe4.0 (123 reviews)443 Cumberland St, Lebanon, PA 17042, USA
Debbie-Jo's Bakery/Choanies Bakery5.0 (11 reviews)317 S 6th St, Lebanon, PA 17042, USA
Panaderia y Reposteria Ceballos Bakery4.0 (436 reviews)381 N 9th St, Lebanon, PA 17046, USA
Zigs Bakery & Deli4.0 (12 reviews)35 S 8th St, Lebanon, PA 17042, USA
Baked With A Twist5.0 (32 reviews)718 Poplar St Suite G, Lebanon, PA 17042, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Baldwin Bagel Cafe3.0 (381 reviews)
Hot Bagel4.0 (457 reviews)
Daisies Sweet Treats4.0 (29 reviews)
Cafe Fresh Bagel4.0 (302 reviews)
Elim Bakery4.0 (282 reviews)
Cinco de Mayo Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
