Carletta's Pies

Introduction / Overview

For residents across the Ohio region, particularly those in the heart of Columbus, Carletta's Pies represents a true taste of home and a dedication to timeless, Southern-style baking. This local establishment is not just a bakery; it is a specialist, focusing on crafting pies that evoke nostalgia and comfort, made with premium ingredients and a depth of flavor often associated with family recipes passed down through generations. Carletta's Pies has quickly become a standout in the Central Ohio dessert scene, earning a reputation for quality and authenticity.

The primary draw and signature offering is their Sweet Potato Pie, often hailed by customers as tasting "just like Grandma's"—a high compliment that speaks volumes about the quality and authenticity of their baking. This commitment to traditional, satisfying flavors is what makes Carletta’s Pies a cherished fixture in the Columbus community. While the focus is firmly on pies, their offerings extend to other Southern favorites and classic cream pies, demonstrating versatility while maintaining a high standard of quality across their entire menu.

As a specialized local business, Carletta’s Pies understands the importance of being more than just a retail counter. They cater to both individual cravings and large event needs, offering dessert tables and customized orders that bring a uniquely personal and comforting touch to any Ohio gathering, from family dinners to major holiday feasts and corporate events. By staying true to their roots and focusing on a few items done exceptionally well, Carletta's Pies offers a distinct and delicious experience that sets it apart in the bustling Columbus culinary landscape.

Location and Accessibility

Carletta's Pies is conveniently located in a vibrant area of Columbus, Ohio, making it accessible to a wide clientele across the city and surrounding areas. The address for the bakery is:

E 11th Ave, Columbus, OH 43211, USA

This location on East 11th Avenue places the bakery within a well-known area of Columbus, allowing for relatively easy navigation for local customers. When planning a visit for store pickup, especially for pre-ordered pies, customers will find the location straightforward.

In terms of accessibility for all Ohio users, the business ensures practical convenience by providing a Wheelchair accessible parking lot. This is a valuable feature for customers needing extra assistance, managing mobility devices, or simply handling large pie orders for family or group events. While the specific storefront and in-store access details should be confirmed directly with the business, the provision of accessible parking underscores a commitment to serving all members of the local community.

Services Offered

Carletta's Pies provides a range of focused and high-quality services centered around their core product: the pie. These services are tailored to meet the needs of individual customers as well as large-scale events in the Central Ohio region.

• Signature Sweet Potato Pie: The flagship offering, available in various sizes, often including individual 3-inch portions and full-size pies.
• Classic and Seasonal Pie Menu: Offering traditional favorites such as Lemon Meringue Pie and Coconut Cream Pie, in addition to rotating seasonal flavors to keep the menu fresh and exciting for repeat Ohio customers.
• Custom Dessert Tables: Specialized catering services for life's sweetest moments, including events like weddings, corporate gatherings, and large parties, with a full menu of pie options and complementary treats.
• Online Ordering and Store Pickup: Providing the convenience of placing orders online for guaranteed pickup directly at the E 11th Ave location in Columbus.
• Local Delivery Service: Offering local delivery options for pies and catering, which typically requires a minimum order threshold, such as a minimum of 10 individual 3-inch pies for delivery to a local address.
• Retail and Distribution Partnerships: Selling pies through various local outlets and cafes, such as BIG MAL'S LINDEN CAFÉ, G'S SHEPARD SPRINGS CAFÉ, and the CLINTONVILLE FARMERS MARKET, making the products more readily available throughout the Columbus community.

Features / Highlights

What sets Carletta's Pies apart and makes it a favorite among Ohio residents are its unique culinary features and commitment to a traditional baking philosophy.

• Authentic Southern-Style Baking: The primary highlight is the focus on true Southern pie flavors and techniques, which provides a unique and comforting taste experience in the Central Ohio area.
• Premium Signature Sweet Potato Pie: Known for their Sweet Potato Pie, widely celebrated by locals for its authentic, high-quality flavor that is consistently described as being "just like Grandma's."
• Flexible Sizing for Individual and Group Needs: Offering options ranging from single-serving 3-inch pies, which are perfect for quick treats, to full-size pies and custom dessert tables for major functions.
• Active Local Market Presence: The strategic decision to sell pies not only at their main location but also at popular local markets and cafes increases accessibility and convenience for a wider Columbus audience.
• Commitment to Quality: The brand promotes its pies using the phrase "Better get two 'cause one won't do," a playful tagline that highlights the irresistibility and quality of their premium, made-from-scratch products.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking: A commitment to physical accessibility that serves the convenience and needs of all local patrons.

Contact Information

Ohio residents interested in ordering a pie, arranging a dessert table, or inquiring about available flavors at Carletta's Pies should note the following contact details. Due to the specialized nature of the business, direct phone numbers are often reserved for operations, and online inquiry is the preferred method for complex orders.

Address: E 11th Ave, Columbus, OH 43211, USA

For placing custom and large orders, the most effective method is to utilize the dedicated online ordering system and inquiry forms found on their official channels. This ensures that all details regarding flavor, size, date, and delivery/pickup are communicated accurately, streamlining the service process for both the customer and the bakery staff.

What is worth choosing

Choosing Carletta's Pies is worth it for any Ohio user seeking a pie experience that is genuinely comforting, deeply authentic, and superior in flavor. If you are a resident of Columbus or the surrounding areas, and you have a craving for a premium, Southern-style dessert that tastes homemade, this is your premier destination.

The decision to specialize in pies, particularly mastering the complex and beloved Sweet Potato Pie, means that Carletta's is a true expert in their field. You are not just buying a dessert; you are purchasing a meticulously crafted item that respects traditional recipes. This is especially valuable for holiday gatherings or special family meals where an authentic, soul-satisfying pie is essential.

Moreover, the business has made its products highly accessible to the local community through multiple channels: direct pickup at the E 11th Ave location, local delivery for larger orders, and availability at various local markets. This commitment to convenience, combined with the proven quality of their signature products—which customers consistently rave about—makes Carletta’s Pies a dependable and celebrated choice. For your next event or even a simple, sweet indulgence in the Ohio area, opting for the homemade taste and quality of Carletta's Pies guarantees a truly satisfying and memorable culinary experience.

Carletta's Pies

E 11th Ave, Columbus, OH 43211, USA