Cindy's Cakery llc Introduce
For couples across the Commonwealth of Virginia planning their momentous wedding day, every detail must be perfect, and few details are more memorable and delightful than the wedding cake. In the Hayes and Greater Williamsburg area, one name consistently rises to the top for creating truly unforgettable, custom wedding confections: Cindy's Cakery LLC.
Cindy's Cakery operates as a dedicated, luxury, custom wedding cake studio. It is a business built on passion, professionalism, and a profound commitment to making each couple's vision a delicious reality. This is not a typical walk-in bakery; instead, it is a specialized service focused entirely on crafting the perfect edible centerpiece for your celebration. The baker, Cindy, brings her heart and extensive experience—over 17 years—into every design, viewing the cake as much more than a dessert—it is a reflection of your unique love story and a major focal point for your guests.
The philosophy at Cindy's Cakery is rooted in artisan craftsmanship and an unwavering attention to detail. From the precise layering of flavors to the delicate placement of realistic sugar or fresh flowers, every element of the cake is executed with care. The end result is custom buttercream wedding cakes that blend timeless elegance with classic, beloved flavors, ensuring the cake is as beautiful to look at as it is delicious to eat. Their specialty lies in creating romantic, effortlessly sophisticated cakes that perfectly complement the beauty and romance of a Virginia wedding day. They serve a wide area, including the Peninsula, Williamsburg, Gloucester, Mathews, and the Northern Neck, making this Hayes-based gem an accessible choice for a large portion of Eastern Virginia couples.
A notable specialty mentioned by thrilled clients is their decadent Hummingbird Cake. For those unfamiliar, a Hummingbird Cake is a classic Southern and Caribbean-inspired spice cake traditionally made moist and flavorful with mashed banana, crushed pineapple, and chopped nuts (often pecans or walnuts), then topped with a rich cream cheese frosting. The name is thought to come from the cake being sweet enough to attract hummingbirds, or simply because it makes guests "hum" with happiness. Cindy's version of this rich, fruity, and slightly tropical flavor is highly praised and makes a wonderful, unique choice for a wedding cake flavor, especially when paired with their perfectly smooth and creamy buttercream.
The exceptional quality is achieved by using only the finest ingredients, ensuring every bite is rich in flavor. Cakes and icings are made fresh to order using pure vanilla and almond extracts, fresh citrus zests and juices, fresh seasonal fruits, Ghirardelli chocolates, organic carrots, real cane sugar, and lots of fresh eggs, butter, whole milk, cream, and buttermilk. This dedication to quality is evident in the rave reviews from couples who praise the unbeatable taste and incredible moisture of the cakes.
The process for securing your dream cake with Cindy's Cakery is designed to be personalized and detailed. It begins with an initial inquiry to gather details about your wedding and cake vision, which leads to a scheduled private tasting consultation. After discussing design preferences, flavors, and any special requests, a detailed proposal is provided. A signed contract and a non-refundable retainer are required to officially secure the wedding date. Because every cake is custom and artisanally crafted, couples are kindly asked to provide at least four weeks' notice, as the studio is unable to accommodate last-minute requests.
Location and Accessibility
Cindy's Cakery LLC is proudly based in the tranquil community of Hayes, Virginia, operating as a custom studio. The official location is strategically positioned to serve the greater Eastern Virginia region, including major wedding hubs like Williamsburg and the surrounding counties of Gloucester and Mathews.
The physical address for this custom wedding cake studio is:
7928 Laura Ann Ln, Hayes, VA 23072, USA
While the business is primarily appointment-only and serves the wider region, the location offers practical accessibility features for scheduled visits, which may include consultations or pick-ups. These features are:
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring convenience for all visitors attending a consultation or coordinating their cake details.
The studio’s operating model as an appointment-only business means all visits, including consultations and tastings, must be scheduled in advance, ensuring that each couple receives dedicated, focused attention without interruption.
Services Offered
Cindy's Cakery LLC specializes in crafting custom, luxury wedding desserts and offers a comprehensive suite of services tailored to the needs of engaged couples:
- Custom Wedding Cake Design: Specializing in custom tiered cakes with a romantic and sophisticated buttercream style.
- Private Tasting Consultations: Scheduled consultations (in-person or virtual) to discuss design, flavors, and vision.
- Dessert Variety: Custom cakes and cupcakes are available as part of their offerings.
- Extensive Cake Flavor List: Options include Wedding White, White Almond, Vanilla Bean, Chocolate, Classic Carrot, Southern Red Velvet, Hummingbird, Coconut, Lemon, Pink Champagne, and many more.
- Diverse Filling Options: Choices such as Lemon Curd, Raspberry, Strawberry, Coconut Cream, White Chocolate Truffle, Cookies-n-Cream, Nutella, and Caramel.
- Signature Flavor Pairings: Unique combinations like Caramel Apple, Cherry Bakewell, Chocolate Truffle, Irish Wedding, Lemon Berry, Mocha Latte, and White Chocolate Velvet Supreme.
- Delivery and Setup: Professional delivery and setup of the wedding cake at your venue in the service area.
- Anniversary Cake: A special service often included for the top tier or a fresh small cake for the one-year anniversary.
- Flexible Payment Options: Accepts payments via Debit Cards.
Features / Highlights
The reputation of Cindy's Cakery is built on several key features that set it apart as a premier choice for Virginia brides and grooms:
- By Appointment Only Custom Studio: Ensures completely dedicated attention to each couple and their custom order, guaranteeing a personalized, high-end experience.
- Luxury and Artisan Quality: A focus on meticulously crafted, elegant designs, including intricate piping and highly realistic sugar flowers.
- Extensive Experience: The baker has over 17 years of specialization in creating custom wedding cakes since 2008.
- High-Quality Ingredients: Cakes are baked fresh using premium components such as pure extracts, fresh fruits, Ghirardelli chocolates, real cane sugar, and fresh dairy products.
- Exceptional Customer Service: Praised by customers for a caring, sweet, genuine, and professional demeanor, making the planning process feel seamless and laid-back.
- Signature Cake Styles: Specializes in custom buttercream cakes that are moist and decadent, with a particular excellence in flavors like Hummingbird, Coconut, and Strawberry.
- Accessibility Features: Offers a wheelchair accessible parking lot for scheduled meetings.
Contact Information
To begin the process of commissioning a custom wedding cake for your Virginia celebration, you can reach out to Cindy's Cakery using the following details:
Address: 7928 Laura Ann Ln, Hayes, VA 23072, USA
Phone: (757) 377-0997
Please remember that consultation and order placement are strictly by appointment only.
What is Worth Choosing
Choosing Cindy's Cakery LLC for your wedding dessert is an investment in quality, taste, and peace of mind. What truly makes this business stand out in the competitive Virginia wedding market is the combination of award-winning artistry and unparalleled flavor. Customer testimonials consistently highlight the cakes as "the best cake I have ever had," emphasizing both the beauty of the final design and the incredible moisture and taste. Couples rave about the baker's ability to take multiple inspiration photos and combine them into a stunning, cohesive final product, perfectly executing visions from elegant tiers to incredible, realistic sugar work like magnolias.
Furthermore, the genuine care and professional, accommodating nature of the service are frequently cited as the reason for an outstanding overall experience. Cindy’s dedication ensures a smooth process, from the first tasting to the final, on-time delivery and setup. Whether you are dreaming of a classic white almond cake, a luscious coconut cream creation, or a unique favorite like the Hummingbird cake, Cindy's Cakery promises a centerpiece that is not only a feast for the eyes but an absolutely delicious treat that will have your guests clearing the plates and talking about it for years to come. For a truly luxurious, custom, and unforgettable wedding cake experience in the Hayes, Williamsburg, and Gloucester area, Cindy's Cakery is the highly recommended choice.
Cindy's Cakery llc Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Online appointments
- Onsite services
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Planning
- Appointment required
Payments
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
Cindy's Cakery llc Photos







Cindy's Cakery llc Location
Cindy's Cakery llc
7928 Laura Ann Ln, Hayes, VA 23072, USA
Cindy's Cakery llc Reviews
beautifulflavordesignanniversaryfillingraspberry
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Cindy made the most delectable hummingbird wedding cake for my and my husband. The cake was everything we could have hoped. She did an amazing job with the sugar magnolias they were so realistic it was unbelievable. An absolutely stunning cake. She was quick to answer any questions we had and was extremely professional and sweet!
July 30 · alexandra mahlerWe had the pleasure of working with Cindy for our wedding cake, and she exceeded every expectation. From our first tasting, her sweet and genuine personality made us feel at ease. It was clear right away that she cared about making our day perfect.The four-tier cake she created was stunning—honestly the most beautiful cake I’ve ever seen. It was a true centerpiece at our wedding. We couldn’t decide between strawberry and coconut cream, so she made both flavors and it was a hit! The cake was incredibly moist, and the buttercream was unbeatable. Our guests couldn't stop raving about it.If you want a baker who not only creates a gorgeous cake but also pours love and care into making your day unforgettable, Cindy is the one for you! Highly recommend!
March 17 · Kristina MazzellaCindy did such a fabulous job on our wedding cake! It was exactly what we were looking for and tasted amazing!! She even did a custom flavor for us which was awesome. Always choose Cindy for your baking needs. She is so sweet (no pun intended) and will create the best wedding cake you have ever seen ❤️
August 23 · Anna ZielinskiCindy is a real artist and we absolutely loved all 3 flavors of cake that she made for our wedding. Our guests raved about the delicious taste and many wanted more than one piece to enjoy each flavor. The cake was not only delicious, but also beautiful with flowers added that matched our wedding colors. We definitely recommend Cindy for anyone that wants a truly memorable cake!
December 09 · Sidney HeetlandCindy's Cakes have the best flavor, design, and are truly made with love. I recommend anyone looking for a vendor to go out of their way just to try her cakes as you will not even slightly be disappointed; in fact, if you don't end up booking her immediately after trying her cakes I'd be surprised.
August 30 · Chris Ford
More Bakery Near Me
BAKED4.0 (89 reviews)1759 George Washington Memorial Hwy, Gloucester Point, VA 23062, USA
Kroger Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)7254 Hayes Shopping Ct Ctr, Hayes, VA 23072, USA
Doodles Donuts and Cafe4.0 (132 reviews)4744 George Washington Memorial Hwy, Hayes, VA 23072, USA
Kroger Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)6500 George Washington Memorial Hwy C, Grafton, VA 23692, USA
One Girl Desserts4.0 (25 reviews)3630 George Washington Memorial Hwy suite B-1, Yorktown, VA 23692, USA
Smallcakes Newport News4.0 (302 reviews)12515 Jefferson Ave #330, Newport News, VA 23602, USA
Tous les Jours Bakery & Cafe - Newport News4.0 (369 reviews)12515 Jefferson Ave #150, Newport News, VA 23602, USA
Sweet Chef LLC4.0 (15 reviews)802 Gateway Ct, Newport News, VA 23602, USA
Mochi & Mochi4.0 (63 reviews)353 Chatham Dr, Newport News, VA 23602, USA
Italian Delights Bakery & Deli4.0 (280 reviews)2643 George Washington Memorial Hwy H, Yorktown, VA 23693, USA
Ebenezer Treats! Creating delicious memories5.0 (3 reviews)Wakehurst Cir, Gloucester, VA 23061, USA
Walmart Bakery5.0 (2 reviews)2601 George Washington Memorial Hwy, Yorktown, VA 23693, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
CRÉMEUX French Pâtisserie4.0 (171 reviews)
Gourmet CupCakery!0.0 (0 reviews)
Savoia Pastry Shoppe4.0 (1581 reviews)
Garcia Bakery4.0 (8 reviews)
Panaderia Alicia's4.0 (455 reviews)
Scratch Cupcakery Coralville4.0 (606 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Make the Best Classic Pound Cake | Heavenly Delights Bakery
The Secret to Making a Perfect Lemon Cake from Scratch
How to Make Delicious Carrot Muffins with Walnuts - Easy Homemade Recipe
How to Make the Best Bakery-Style French Madeleines
How to Make the Best Rhubarb Pie from Scratch
How to Make the Best Homemade Cherry Jam for Baking
