Duchess Cookies: A Guide to the Best Cookies in Plainview, NY

Duchess Cookies Introduce

Are you a New Yorker with a craving for something sweet? Sometimes, nothing beats the simple, comforting pleasure of a freshly baked cookie. While the city itself is a mecca for amazing food, a short trip to Long Island can lead you to a hidden gem that’s quickly becoming a local favorite: Duchess Cookies. Located in the heart of Plainview, this charming bakery offers a truly unique and delightful experience that’s worth the journey for anyone in the Tri-State area. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with the irresistible aroma of baking and a friendly, welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. This isn't just a place to grab a quick treat; it's a destination where passion for baking and a genuine love for customers come together to create something special.

Duchess Cookies has built a reputation not just on its delicious treats, but on the personal touch that makes every visit memorable. The team, often including the owner herself, is dedicated to providing an exceptional experience. They are known for their warmth, their deep knowledge of their products, and their willingness to go the extra mile for their patrons. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a regular, you'll be treated with the same kindness and attention. This commitment to customer care, combined with an outstanding product, is what makes Duchess Cookies stand out from the crowd. It’s a true local business success story, built on quality, community, and the simple joy of a perfectly baked cookie. New Yorkers looking for a sweet escape will find it here, where every cookie tells a story of craftsmanship and care.

For New Yorkers on the go, finding a convenient and accessible spot is key. Duchess Cookies is perfectly situated at 331 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview, NY 11803, USA. This location is easily reachable by car from many parts of Long Island and the greater New York metropolitan area. It's an ideal stop for those running errands, looking for a quick treat, or planning a special family outing. The bakery is located on a well-known street, making it simple to find using GPS or a map. Parking is available, which is a major plus and eliminates the typical stress of navigating city traffic and finding a spot. The convenient location ensures that a delicious cookie is never too far away, whether you're coming from Queens, Brooklyn, or further afield. Its position in a bustling part of Plainview means there are other shops and services nearby, making it easy to combine a cookie run with other activities. The ease of access makes it a go-to spot for locals and a great destination for anyone looking to explore the culinary delights of Long Island.

The accessibility of Duchess Cookies extends beyond just its physical location. The team prides itself on creating a welcoming environment for everyone. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make it a comfortable place to stop in, whether you're alone or with family and friends. This welcoming vibe is a core part of the Duchess Cookies brand, ensuring that every customer feels valued. It's a place where you can relax, take a moment to enjoy a treat, and feel a part of the local community. The bakery's easy-to-find spot and welcoming nature make it an inviting destination for anyone with a sweet tooth. New York residents looking for a pleasant and stress-free dessert experience will find that Duchess Cookies checks all the boxes for convenience, accessibility, and a friendly atmosphere.

Duchess Cookies offers much more than just a delicious product; it provides a range of services designed to enhance the customer experience. From the moment you walk in, you'll be impressed by the thoughtfulness that goes into every detail. The team at Duchess Cookies is dedicated to ensuring that every visit is special, whether you're picking up a single cookie or a whole box. Their services are tailored to meet the needs of a diverse customer base, from busy parents to people planning a celebration. The bakery’s commitment to quality and service is evident in every interaction, making it a reliable and beloved local business. They don’t just sell cookies; they create sweet moments and lasting memories for their customers. The variety of services on offer ensures that everyone can find exactly what they’re looking for, making Duchess Cookies a versatile and essential part of the Plainview community. This dedication to service is a key reason why so many customers return again and again.

In-store shopping with a wide variety of fresh-baked cookies available daily. The selection is constantly changing, so there's always something new to discover.
Expert advice and recommendations from knowledgeable and friendly staff, who are happy to guide you through the different flavors and options. They can help you find the perfect cookie for your taste.
Custom orders for special events like parties, birthdays, and corporate gatherings. Whether you need a dozen or a hundred, they can create a custom cookie platter to suit your needs.
Special consideration for dietary needs and allergies, with clear separation of cookies containing nuts and attentive staff who can provide guidance. They take safety seriously, ensuring a comfortable experience for everyone.
Recommendations for enjoying cookies warm and gooey at home, including specific reheating instructions. This ensures you can recreate the fresh-from-the-oven experience whenever you like.
Samples of seasonal treats, such as refreshing sorbet, on hot days. This adds a fun and unexpected touch to the visit, allowing you to try something new.

Duchess Cookies is known for its many standout features and highlights that set it apart from other bakeries. The attention to detail and commitment to quality are evident in every aspect of the business, from the ingredients used to the customer service provided. These highlights are what make a visit to Duchess Cookies a truly memorable experience. It’s not just about the cookies themselves; it’s about the entire package. The bakery has cultivated a reputation for excellence that is built on these unique qualities. Locals rave about the friendly environment and the creative flavors that make Duchess Cookies a must-visit spot. These features are a testament to the passion and care that goes into every single treat, ensuring that each visit is as delightful as the last. For New Yorkers looking for a truly special dessert experience, these highlights are a major draw.

A diverse and impressive selection of unique cookie flavors, including popular options like Oatmeal Raisin, Brookie, White Macadamia Nut, Red Velvet, Pistachio, and Cinnamon Roll. The variety ensures there's a flavor for every palate.
A warm and welcoming atmosphere created by passionate owners and staff, who make every customer feel like part of the "cookie family." This personal touch is a major part of the bakery's charm.
High-quality ingredients and a dedication to baking each cookie to perfection, resulting in treats that are described as "a work of art, both in looks and taste." The quality is evident in every bite.
A clear commitment to customer safety and care, particularly regarding food allergies, with thoughtful separation of nut-based products. This provides peace of mind for families with dietary concerns.
The helpful suggestion to warm the cookies at home for an extra gooey and fresh-baked experience, adding a special touch to the enjoyment. This advice enhances the overall customer experience.

To experience the magic of Duchess Cookies for yourself, you can find them at their Plainview location. Their friendly team is always ready to welcome you and help you find the perfect treat. Whether you have a question about their flavors or want to place a custom order, their contact information is readily available. Reaching out is easy, and you’ll find their team is responsive and helpful. The bakery’s commitment to excellent communication is just another way they show their dedication to their customers. Getting in touch is the first step to enjoying some of the best cookies on Long Island. For New Yorkers looking to plan their visit, having this information handy makes the process seamless. The team looks forward to hearing from you and sharing their passion for delicious, freshly baked cookies.

Address: 331 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview, NY 11803, USA

Phone: (516) 303-0927

In conclusion, Duchess Cookies is more than just a bakery; it's a cherished local institution that offers an exceptional experience for everyone who walks through its doors. For New Yorkers, this Plainview gem is the perfect destination for a sweet escape. The combination of its convenient location, a fantastic variety of gourmet cookies, and an incredibly warm and welcoming atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for a quick treat or a special outing. The passionate owners and staff truly set this place apart, making you feel like a part of their family with every visit. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply treating yourself, the quality and care put into each cookie is evident. Locals appreciate the dedication to customer service, particularly the attention to dietary concerns and the personal recommendations that make the experience feel unique and tailored. Duchess Cookies is a place where you can find not just a delicious dessert, but a genuine sense of community. It’s a business built on love, quality, and the simple joy of a perfectly baked cookie, making it a must-visit for anyone in the New York area. The reputation they have built is well-deserved, and it's clear why so many people can't wait to go back for more.

Duchess Cookies Vibe

Cookies
Chocolate Pistachio Dubai Cookie US$6.50
A rich, chocolatey delight filled with creamy pistachio & Kaitifi goodness topped with crumbled pistachios for that perfect crunch!
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip US$6.50
Enjoy our spin on a classic chocolate chip cookie, this time loaded with savory homemade oatmeal and dashed generously with semi-sweet chocolate chips.
Strawberry PB&J Cookie US$6.50
Our take on a PB&J sees one of our delicious peanut butter cookies filled with a luscious strawberry jam and topped with pink sprinkles. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz apiece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Unicorn Cookie US$6.50
A creamy strawberry cheesecake finds a home in one of our delightfully colorful rainbow sugar cookie and sprinkled with sparkly edible magic. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
S'mores Cookie US$6.50
Another childhood favorite dressed up as a cookie. Our traditional chocolate chip cookie gets a twist of cinnamon and a healthy heap of marshmallows on top to round out this campfire favorite. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Funfetti Cookie US$6.50
Funfetti is a traditional sugar cookie with sprinkles baked right in. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Cookie Monster Cookie US$6.50
Our traditional chocolate chip cookie gets dressed up here in a shockingly blue sugar cookie. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Cinnamon Toast Crunch US$6.50
Experience the nostalgic joy of a beloved breakfast cereal in cookie form. This delectable creation features an irresistible Cinnamon Toast Crunch exterior, giving it a delightful crunch and a burst of cinnamon flavor that's then stuffed with a heavenly cinnamon cheesecake filling.
Brookie US$6.50
Two delectable flavored cookies fused together to form a beautiful starburst pattern. A chocolate chip cookie twisted with a chocolate cookie studded with white chocolate chips, and filled with brownie batter. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Banana Nut Cookie Butter Cookie US$6.50
Our delicious brown sugar banana cookie gets a healthy handful of crunchy walnuts and is jam-packed full with Biscoff Creamy Cookie Butter. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are 4.5-5oz apiece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Cinnamon Bun US$6.50
Our delicious cinnamon bun cookie is flavored with a generous touch of cinnamon, has a thin layer of sticky glazed baked right into it, and is then topped with a gooey vanilla glaze.
Sea Salt Caramel Cookie US$6.50
This classic chocolate chip cookie is stuffed with a rich caramel filling, sprinkled with high-grade sea salt, and topped with a savory pretzel.
The Coosant US$8.99
This delectable spin on breakfast features a buttery, flaky croissant stuffed with mouth-watering chocolate chip cookie dough, and then topped with miniature chocolate chip cookies.
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$6.50
Our version of this crisp and gooey traditional family favorite is made with the finest quality semi sweet chocolate drops, and baked to perfection. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie US$6.50
A twist on our traditional chocolate chip - who doesn’t enjoy some extra crunch in their warm and gooey chocolate chip cookie? Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Coconut Dubai Cookie US$6.50
A delicious toasted coconut cookie filled with white chocolate ganache and knife crunchies. Topped with coconut and toasted.
Blueberry Cheesecake Cookie US$6.50
Our delicious sugar cookie has a heart filled with warm, creamy cheesecake and is dotted with delicious plumped, dried blueberries. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Banana Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie US$6.50
We took our chocolate chip cookie, added bananas, and replaced the semi-sweet chips with creamy milk chocolate. This cookie is literally and figuratively bananas. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Red Velvet White Chocolate Cheesecake Cookie US$6.50
These treats feature a classic red velvet cookie with creamy white chocolate chips and are filled with cheesecake. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Grape PB&J Cookie US$6.50
Grape PB&J is a our homage to a classic flavor, melting together a delicious peanut butter cookie, purple sprinkles, and luscious grape jelly. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Churro Cookie US$6.50
Our traditional snickerdoodle cookie gets a punch of Latin flavor with a creamy warm dulce De leche center. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie US$6.50
A classic favorite, oatmeal in a brown sugar cookie with sweet and fruity raisins throughout. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Almond Raspberry Cookie US$6.50
A sweet and savory sugar cookie loaded with almonds and a delicious portion of raspberry filling. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are 4.5-5oz apiece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Oreo Cheesecake Cookie US$6.50
Our Oreo cheesecake cookie is the ultimate triple play. Not only do you get one of our delicious dark chocolate cookies but you also get large chunks of real Oreo pieces, and if that wasn't enough, it's filled with a warm creamy Oreo cheesecake. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Cotton Candy US$6.50
Our cotton candy cookie is a delicious cotton candy infused cookie, dotted with magical cotton candy morsels and lightly dusted with an edible glitter.
Triple Chocolate Cookie US$6.50
We wanted to make sure we had all our chocolate covered here, so we made a place for each of them. This is a dark chocolate cookie mixed with the finest of white and milk chocolate chips drops. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Lemon Poppyseed Cookie US$6.50
A bright and delicious lemon poppyseed cookie.
Rainbow Cookie US$6.50
Our version of an Italian Rainbow cookie. These multi-flavored cookie layers include raspberry and almond, all enrobed in a crunchy chocolate fudge shell. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookie US$6.50
Our chocolate peanut butter cup cookie is dark chocolate and is studded with Reese's Pieces and filled with a creamy peanut butter. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Pistachio White Chocolate US$6.50
Two delectable flavored cookies fused together to form a beautiful starburst pattern. A pistachio green and white sugar cookie overstuffed with a creamy pistachio and white chocolate ganache. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Oatmeal Apple Pie Cookie US$6.50
This fall favorite is warm delicious apple pie center encrusted in our crispy gooey cinnamon oatmeal cookie. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.
Churro Nutella Cookie US$6.50
Our traditional snickerdoodle cookies marries beautifully with its nutty and creamy Nutella center. Like all of our full-size cookies, these are sold as singles, and are 4.5-5oz a piece, made with the highest-quality ingredients, and are baked to order. All of our cookies are also made in a kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy, tree nuts, and peanuts, among other common allergens, and as such, we can't guarantee any of our products are completely allergen free. If you have an allergy or dietary question and are ordering, let us know in your order notes, and we'll be happy to accommodate if able. And as mentioned above, all our cookies are made with high-quality ingredients and as few preservatives as possible, so should be considered perishable, and it's best to enjoy them or freeze them as soon as you get them.

Energy Elixirs
Perfect Palmer US$6.99
Black tea • energized lemonade
Raspberry Lemonade Spritz US$6.99
Raspberry energized lemonade
Lavender Love US$6.99
Lavender • energized lemonade • green tea
Jolly Rancher US$6.99
Granny smith apple kiwi. Red lotus energy blue lotus energy
Twilight US$6.99
BlackBerry blueberry pomegranate purple lotus energy

Duchess Cookies Details

Service options
Delivery
On-site services
Takeaway

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

Duchess Cookies Photos

Duchess Cookies Location

Duchess Cookies

New York Nassau County Plainview South Oyster Bay Road

331 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview, NY 11803, USA

Duchess Cookies Reviews

An average rating of ★4.8 from 215 user reviews.

cookie monstercheesecakechocolate chipto choosenutoatmeal raisinsorbetcroissant cookiescookie doughcrumbl

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I stumbled upon this cute little bakery by accident. I was actually headed to a well-known spot nearby, but this place caught my eye. The cookie selection was amazing (seriously hard to choose!), and I really liked the whole 'vibe' of this place. The best part though was Isabella! She was the sweetest host, who welcomed us as soon as we walked in. She gave us a great rundown of the treats. We mentioned that we have a nut allergy in the family and right away, she pointed out which cookies to avoid and that the ones with nuts were completely separate from the rest. She offered us samples of their refreshing sorbet, which was perfect for a hot, muggy day. Can’t wait to come back next time I’m in the area!
July 13 · Shainu Thomas
We had the sweetest experience at Duchess Cookies!The owner’s passion and warmth made us feel like we were more than just customers—like we were part of the cookie family.Each cookie was a work of art, both in looks and taste. Our family tried the Oatmeal Raisin, Brookie, White Macadamia Nut, Red Velvet, Pistachio, and Cinnamon Roll, and they were all simply divine.We followed the ‘350 for 4-8 minutes’ advice and let me tell you, it was the perfect touch to enjoy these treats warm and gooey.Can't wait to go back for more! 🙌"
August 17 · Dahlia Verma
So my boyfriend and I have only been to the Plainview location twice but each time the employees are SO welcoming. They are the nicest people no matter who it is and every time we visit they offer us something different to taste without us even asking! We truly cannot rave enough about them and express how grateful we are for our experiences! The cookies may be a bit pricey for some but we think it is appropriate as they have a gooey center, are very flavorful, and not your average cookie! Plus, the more you purchase, the better the deal you get and honestly you can't go wrong with trying all the different flavors they have! We tried the two types of dubai chocolate, lemon poppyseed, and blueberry cheesecake cookies and absolutely loved them all. (We ate them all so fast we forgot to take pics of most of them...lol sorrryyy). They say you can pop the ones without a chocolate coating in the oven for a few minutes to warm them up, but we didnt even feel the need to do so and they were still soft and delicious!! All of the cookies are fresh and just as tasty as they look! Next time we pass through the area, no doubt we will stop again and try another flavor from their menu!! We are fans of chip city, but we absolutely agree that Duchess Cookies are better!!
April 08 · Amanda Lospinuso
Cookies were freshly baked, good variety and tasted great. They were a little pricey...$5.50 each.
March 18 · Barry Asman
After reading reviews online, went yesterday to buy some cookies. I bought 6 different cookies and they gave 1 free. :) 😀 cookies taste very delicious and it's mouthwatering. I bought triple chocolate chip , red valvet ,blueberry , Strawberry flavors. Strawberry cookies just melt in mouth. They have different varieties of cookies. Great place for cookies lovers. Shop is very nice and clean. They have few tables and chairs also to enjoy .Definitely recommend this location and going back again for other cookies.
June 01 · jaswinder singh