Eli's Bagel Shop Introduce
For many New Yorkers, a day simply doesn't begin without a fresh bagel. The perfectly chewy interior, the crisp, slightly-browned exterior, and the steam escaping with the first bite are more than just a meal—they are a tradition. In Spring Valley, New York, a local establishment has been serving this tradition with dedication: Eli's Bagel Shop. More than just a place to grab a bagel, Eli's has become a fixture in the community, providing a welcoming spot for locals to start their mornings or grab a satisfying lunch. This article will provide a comprehensive overview of what makes Eli's a must-visit for anyone in the area, offering insights into its menu, location, and commitment to serving the community.
Eli's Bagel Shop prides itself on the freshness and quality of its products. They are known for their hand-rolled bagels, a process that ensures each one has the classic New York taste and texture that sets them apart. This isn't a factory-made product; it's the result of skilled craftsmanship and a commitment to preserving the authentic bagel-making tradition. But Eli's offers much more than just bagels. Their menu is extensive, catering to a wide range of tastes and meal times. From classic bagel sandwiches to a variety of spreads, salads, and even hot dishes, there's something for everyone. Whether you're in the mood for a simple toasted bagel with cream cheese, a hearty egg sandwich, or a full deli platter, Eli's delivers on both variety and flavor.
What truly sets Eli's Bagel Shop apart is its role as a neighborhood institution. The shop is a hub of activity, a place where people from all walks of life come together over a shared love for good food. The atmosphere is often described as fast and friendly, a testament to the staff's commitment to great service. They understand the rhythm of a busy New Yorker's day and strive to provide quick, efficient service without sacrificing quality. While a recent customer review noted a less-than-perfect experience with a specific meal, the general consensus and the shop's longevity speak to its overall commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. It's this dedication that has earned Eli's a loyal following and established it as a go-to spot for fresh, delicious, and authentic New York bagels.
Eli's Bagel Shop is conveniently located at 58 N Myrtle Ave, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA. This location makes it an ideal stop for residents and those traveling through the Spring Valley area. The shop is easily accessible by car, and its presence on North Myrtle Avenue places it within a bustling local commercial area. A key feature of Eli's is its drive-thru option, which provides a level of convenience that is highly valued by busy New Yorkers. This allows customers to quickly grab their orders without having to get out of their car, perfect for a fast-paced morning commute or a quick lunch break. For those who prefer to walk in, the store is easy to find and navigate. Its accessibility, whether you're driving or on foot, is a major advantage that makes it a practical choice for a daily stop or a weekend treat. The address isn't just a place of business; it's a central point in the community, easily reachable and a staple for many in the surrounding neighborhoods.
Services Offered
- Hand-Rolled, Fresh Bagels: The core of their business, offering a wide variety of fresh, hand-rolled bagels, baked daily.
- Breakfast & Lunch Menu: A diverse menu that includes breakfast sandwiches, omelets, and a selection of hot and cold lunch items.
- Homemade Salads and Spreads: A variety of fresh salads, including tuna, chicken, and egg salad, along with multiple cream cheese flavors and other spreads.
- Gourmet Deli Sandwiches: A full deli counter offering classic sandwiches like pastrami, roast beef, and turkey, made with Boar's Head meats.
- Catering and Platters: The ability to order large platters for events, including sliced lox, whitefish salad, and a variety of deli meats and salads.
Features / Highlights
- Authentic New York Bagels: Eli's is dedicated to the traditional bagel-making process, ensuring a product that is chewy, flavorful, and truly authentic.
- Convenient Drive-Thru: For those on the go, the drive-thru offers a quick and easy way to get your order without leaving your car.
- Fast and Friendly Service: The staff is known for their efficiency and pleasant demeanor, making every visit a positive experience.
- Diverse Menu: Beyond bagels, the menu is extensive, offering everything from classic breakfast items to specialty sandwiches and catering options, all under one roof.
- Kosher Certification: Eli's Bagel Shop is a certified kosher establishment, serving a specific and important part of the Spring Valley community.
For all inquiries, including placing an order or checking their hours of operation, you can contact Eli's Bagel Shop directly.
Address: 58 N Myrtle Ave, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
Phone: (845) 425-6166
Whether you are calling to place a large catering order or simply have a question about the day's specials, the staff is ready to assist you. The provided mobile phone number, +1 845-425-6166, is also available for direct communication.
In conclusion, Eli's Bagel Shop is a true staple of the Spring Valley, New York community. It's a place where the simple pleasure of a fresh, hand-rolled bagel is elevated by a commitment to quality, a diverse menu, and a strong connection to its local patrons. For New Yorkers in the area, it represents more than just a place to eat; it's a trusted daily stop that provides comfort and familiarity. The convenient drive-thru and central location make it a practical choice for busy mornings, while the extensive menu ensures that there's always something new and delicious to try. The mix of classic and innovative items, from traditional bagels to a variety of salads and sandwiches, caters to every palate and occasion. Eli's Bagel Shop is a great example of a local business that not only serves its community but is also an integral part of its identity. Its dedication to the craft of bagel making, combined with its accessibility and friendly service, makes it an ideal spot for anyone seeking an authentic and satisfying New York bagel experience.
Eli's Bagel Shop Vibe
Breakfast & Lunch
- French Toast US$8.15
With maple syrup.
- Home Fries
- Potato Knish US$5.45
- Baked Ziti US$16.25
- Eggplant Parmesan US$16.25
- Cheese Blintzes US$10.15
Includes two.
- Vegetable Cutlet US$6.10
- 1/2 Potato Kugel US$5.45
- Hot Parve Cholent US$8.15
- 1/2 Grilled Vegetables US$8.15
- Vegetable Soup US$8.15
Bakery
- Bagel US$2.05
- Dozen Bagel US$20.30
- Rolls US$2.75
All rolls are mezonas.
- Danish US$5.45
- Chocolate Cheese Muffin US$4.10
- Muffins US$4.10
- Jumbo Cookies US$4.10
- Slice Cheese Cake US$9.50
Sandwiches & Wraps
- 2 Eggs Sandwich US$7.85
- Hobo Sandwich US$7.85
Egg with home fries in sandwich.
- Pizza Bagel US$9.50
Includes homemade pizza sauce.
- American Cheese Sandwich US$7.15
- Avocado Sandwich US$9.20
- Tuna Melt US$12.55
- Grilled Cheese US$8.15
- Butter Sandwich US$3.85
- Jelly Sandwich US$4.60
- Cream Cheese Sandwich US$4.75
- Lox Bits Sandwich US$7.30
- Olive Cream Cheese Sandwich US$5.95
- Tuna Salad Sandwich US$8.50
Includes 2 vegetable toppings.
- Egg Salad Sandwich US$8.50
Includes 2 vegetable toppings.
- White Fish Salad Sandwich US$9.60
Includes 2 vegetable toppings.
- Sliced Lox & Cream Cheese Sandwich US$10.60
Includes 2 vegetable toppings.
Salads & Spreads
- Israeli Salad US$16.25
Per Lb.
- Tomato & Onion Salad US$16.25
Per Lb.
- Tomato, Onion & Olive Salad US$16.25
Per Lb.
- Caesar Salad US$16.25
- Plain Cream Cheese
- Vegetable Cream Cheese
- Scallion Cream Cheese
- Tuna Salad
- Egg Salad
- Whitefish Salad
- Sliced Lox
- Potato Salad
- Tri Color Pasta Salad
- Guacamole
- Salad With Tuna Bowl US$20.30
Drinks
- Coffee
- Tea
- Hot Chocolate
- Sweetened Cappuccino
- Flavored Tea
- Orange Juice
- Iced Cappuccino US$6.80
- Cold Coffee
- Snapple US$4.45
- Soda Can US$2.75
- Powerade US$5.15
- Gatorade US$5.15
- Chocolate Milk US$5.15
- Water US$2.40
- Sports Water US$3.80
- Milkshakes US$8.15
With ice chips.
- Vitamin Water US$5.15
- Apple Juice US$2.75
Platters
- Sliced Lox, White Fish Salad, Egg Salad, Tuna Salad, Garnished With Vegetables US$115.05
Serves 10-12 guests.
9x13
- 9x13 Baked Ziti US$81.20
- 9x13 Eggplant US$81.20
- 9x13 Potato Kugel US$33.85
- 9x13 Eggs US$74.45
10 - 12 people.
- 9x13 Salad US$81.20
4 Lb - 5 Lb.
- 9x13 Home Fries US$52.80
10 - 12 people.
Eli's Bagel Shop Details
Service options
- Drive-through
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Amenities
- Toilet
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
Eli's Bagel Shop Photos










Eli's Bagel Shop Location
Eli's Bagel Shop
58 N Myrtle Ave, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
Eli's Bagel Shop Reviews
home frieshash brownsdrive throughpizzatoastedkosherareafeelfood and servicemuffins
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1It was my first time here and I must say it was delicious! Fast and friendly service!
March 31 · Eli RosenthalThe pictures say it all. Burnt bagel. Overly salted home fries, and the grease from home fries spilled in the bag. I've never seen an omelet that looks like that. Awful. Threw everything out.
January 02 · Lisa WhiteCame with a group of 12 students. Staff was very friendly, and patient taking everyone's orders. Definitely recommend!
March 30 · Sir AuirnessWent in Friday morning for a quick breakfast pickup, in and out in 5 minutes with 3 delicious and fresh breakfast specials. Great customer care and most importantly delicious food. My bill for 3 people was $27 including drinks.
November 17 · Joshua FriedmannWow what a delightful experience!Came Friday morning the place was packed with a Yeshiva from Lakewood a million things were going on yet still my order was taken fairly quickly everyone was so pleasant and friendly a real mom and pop type place.The service was really a pleasure!I got the hobo sandwich (hate calling my food that🤔) I’ve been hearing about it for years from my Monsey people and it’s really was good.The hash browns or home fries as they call them really are delicious never had better they were so good we ordered more even though we really were full that good!Next time I’m in town Eli’s is definitely the first stop.
July 16 · Y Z
More Bakery Near Me
Taam Eden Bakery5.0 (4 reviews)80 West St, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
BUNZ Baked Bliss5.0 (3 reviews)39 N Cole Ave, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
La Baguette BAKERY and BISTRO3.0 (246 reviews)214-216 N Main St, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
Sabor Ambateno Bakery4.0 (46 reviews)288 N Main St, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
Joseph's Cake Shop4.0 (16 reviews)288 N Main St, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
Daily Fresh Donuts4.0 (64 reviews)277 N Main St, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
Eben Ezer Bakery4.0 (52 reviews)75 S Central Ave, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
Sanders Bakery5.0 (35 reviews)11 S Pascack Rd, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
Healthy Joy Bakes4.0 (2 reviews)11 S Pascack Rd, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
Shloimy's Heimishe Bakery4.0 (20 reviews)Rockland Kosher Supermarket, 27 Orchard St, Monsey, NY 10952, USA
Sanders Bakery4.0 (229 reviews)110 NY-59, Monsey, NY 10952, USA
Taam Eden Bakery4.0 (83 reviews)31 B Jefferson Ave, Spring Valley, NY 10977, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Del Carmen Bakery4.0 (51 reviews)
sugar homemade bakery5.0 (12 reviews)
EEK Creations0.0 (0 reviews)
Mi Bella Colombia Bakery4.0 (209 reviews)
I Love Bread0.0 (0 reviews)
The Village Bakery & Cafe4.0 (720 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Make the Best Chocolate Covered Marshmallows – Easy Tips and Recipes
How to Create the Perfect Chocolate Drizzle for Cakes Step by Step
Discover the Best Bakeries for Cupcakes and Frosting Lovers Across the U.S.
The Best Baking Mixes You Can Buy for Quick Results
How to Make Bakery-Style Croissants with Puff Pastry
How to Make Delicious Pumpkin Churros with Chocolate Dip
