Gem's Fairy Cakes Introduce
### Introduction / Overview
Located in the heart of Downtown Findlay, **Gem's Fairy Cakes** has quickly established itself as a premier destination for custom-designed baked goods in the **Ohio** region. This charming local establishment operates as a specialized **Bakery**, **Cake shop**, and **Cupcake shop**, dedicated to transforming ordinary moments into magical celebrations. The name itself, "Fairy Cakes," is simply the delightful British term for what we know as cupcakes, signifying a focus on enchanting, high-quality, and personalized sweet treats.
The core appeal of this Findlay bakery is its commitment to both exceptional flavor and personalized service, something often lost in larger operations. Patrons consistently rave about the quality, noting that the baked goods are made from scratch and are remarkably moist and fresh. Reviews highlight specialty items like their **Carrot Cake**, frequently described as "the best... we have ever had," and their classic **Vanilla Cake with Vanilla Buttercream**. Beyond the traditional, they also offer exciting options like **Strawberry Cream** and **Lemon with Raspberry Filling** cupcakes.
Crucially, Gem's Fairy Cakes excels in creating custom orders for every occasion imaginable, from first birthdays and weddings to highly creative and unique requests—such as a spooky "RIP 20's" themed cake. The owner is noted for providing excellent recommendations on size and flavor, and even assists with sourcing specific decorations and cake toppers, simplifying the party planning process for busy **Ohio** families. This dedication to going above and beyond the expected makes Gem's a treasured local find.
---
### Location and Accessibility
**Gem's Fairy Cakes** is perfectly positioned at **118 E Sandusky St, Findlay, OH 45840, USA**, placing it right in the accessible downtown area. Its central location makes it a convenient stop for clients across Findlay and the surrounding Hancock County area of **Ohio**. The ease of access is a key factor for customers picking up large, fragile custom cakes.
While operating from a quaint downtown location, the bakery prioritizes customer access. Essential facilities are in place to ensure a smooth visit, including a designated **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**. This feature is particularly valuable when coordinating the safe transport of a large, multi-tiered cake or numerous boxes of **Cupcakes**.
For convenience, the business structure supports both pre-planned and impromptu visits. Though an **Appointment is required** for detailed custom orders and consultations, customers can also utilize the **Quick visit** option for immediate purchases of daily baked goods or smaller treats. To further enhance efficiency, payments are hassle-free, with acceptance of all major **Credit cards** and **Debit cards**, alongside modern **NFC mobile payments**, catering to the digital payment preferences of the **Ohio** consumer.
---
### Services Offered
The specialized focus of Gem's Fairy Cakes in Findlay allows them to offer highly focused and flexible services to the **Ohio** community:
- **Custom Cake Creation:** Designing and baking bespoke cakes for all major life events, including first birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, graduations, and unique themed parties (e.g., "spooky RIP" themes).
- **Specialty Flavor Consultation:** The owner provides personalized recommendations on cake size, flavor pairings, and fillings, leveraging expert knowledge to ensure the best outcome for the client's event.
- **Dessert Delivery Service:** Offering reliable **Delivery** for large orders, making it simple for customers to receive their custom cakes or bulk **Cupcake** orders without the need for transport.
- **In-store Pickup:** A dependable option for collecting pre-ordered custom cakes and **Fairy Cakes** (cupcakes) at a confirmed time.
- **Takeout:** Availability of smaller, ready-to-eat baked goods for immediate purchase and easy transport, perfect for a spontaneous sweet craving.
- **Cake Topper/Decoration Assistance:** Going above and beyond by assisting customers with ordering or sourcing specific cake toppers and decorative elements, simplifying the final party details.
---
### Features / Highlights
Gem's Fairy Cakes’ unique combination of quality and customer care makes it a standout choice for celebratory sweets in **Ohio**:
- **Exceptional Flavor Quality:** Known for baking from scratch, resulting in superior taste and texture, with particular praise for the moist and flavorful **Carrot Cake** and classic **Vanilla Cake with Vanilla Buttercream**.
- **True Customization Focus:** Specializes in handling highly personalized and sometimes non-traditional requests, ensuring the final product perfectly matches the customer's "inspiration photo" or unique theme.
- **Owner-Led Expert Service:** Provides an intimate and highly professional customer experience where the owner directly offers guidance on planning, sizing, and design, adding a layer of trust and personalized care.
- **Specialty Cupcakes:** Offers a creative rotating menu of "Fairy Cakes" (Cupcakes) including standout options like **Lemon with Raspberry Filling** and **Dark Chocolate**, catering to diverse taste preferences for weddings and parties.
- **Lending Amenities:** Demonstrates a commitment to customer success, exemplified by the owner lending a **Cake holder** to enhance the presentation of a client's special occasion cake.
- **Convenience and Planning Options:** Balances the need for focused consultation (**Appointment required**) with the demand for efficiency (**Quick visit**) and logistics (**Delivery**), serving a wide range of customer needs in Findlay.
---
### Contact Information
To place an order for a custom cake, inquire about **Cupcake** availability, or schedule a consultation for your next event in **Ohio**, please use the following contact details:
- **Address:** 118 E Sandusky St, Findlay, OH 45840, USA
- **Phone:** (419) 306-5628
---
### What is Worth Choosing
Choosing **Gem's Fairy Cakes** in Findlay, **Ohio**, is choosing highly personalized service and demonstrably superior quality, particularly for any special occasion. While large chain bakeries offer standard convenience, Gem's delivers an intimate, custom experience where the owner acts as a true partner in the celebration planning. The highly positive customer reviews highlight not only the deliciousness—from the "best Carrot Cakes" to perfect **Vanilla Cake**—but also the commitment to flawless execution and going the extra mile, such as ordering decorations or lending out a **Cake holder**.
This specialized **Cake shop** is the ideal choice when a celebration demands more than a generic, off-the-shelf product. Whether it's a themed first birthday cake that "turned out so cute" or a unique "spooky RIP 20's" creation, the team at Gem's Fairy Cakes has proven its capacity for creativity and attention to detail. The ability to consult with an expert, receive flavor recommendations, and trust that the cake will be ready exactly on time provides invaluable peace of mind for the busy **Ohio** event planner.
With convenient options like **Delivery**, **In-store pickup**, acceptance of modern **NFC mobile payments**, and essential accessibility features like **Wheelchair accessible parking**, Gem's Fairy Cakes successfully merges the charm and quality of a local specialty bakery with the operational needs of the modern consumer. For a memorable centerpiece that truly tastes as good as it looks, and is backed by exceptional service, Gem's on E Sandusky Street is the reliable, enchanting choice in Northwest **Ohio**.
Gem's Fairy Cakes Details
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Planning
- Appointment required
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Gem's Fairy Cakes Photos










Gem's Fairy Cakes Location
Gem's Fairy Cakes
118 E Sandusky St, Findlay, OH 45840, USA
Gem's Fairy Cakes Reviews
birthdaycupcakescookiesgerman chocolate cakecarrot cake
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I went in to order a cake for a 1st birthday. The owner answered all my questions and offered recommendation on size and flavor. We went with the vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream and I sent over my inspiration photo. The cake was ready right on time and turned out so cute! It was so delicious and I appreciated that the owner was able to order the cake toppers for us so I didn’t have to worry about finding something. I would absolutely order again!
July 25 · Marina BeelmanI am so pleased on how this turned out. I stopped in for a very interesting request and she went above and beyond on this Carrot Cake with a spooky RIP 20's Birthday Cake. The taste was one of the best Carrot Cakes we have ever had. Nancy even let me barrow her Cake holder that just added to the vide on this cake!Thank you so much Nancy for everything!
October 29 · Andy WallesThe best bakery in town by far! The fruit tarts are my absolute favorite, I could eat fifty of them I swear. The cakes and cookies are divine. I got my lemon raspberry birthday cake from here and it was delicious and so cute! The owner is the sweetest person and makes the experience special and enjoyable! I highly recommend going here for any baking needs!
June 26 · AnonymousEveryone at the birthday party agreed that her carrot cake is the best they’ve eaten. Fresh ingredients, moist, and obviously made with love. SO GOOD. Gem’s is our new go-to for cakes.
May 27 · Jeniene HohlDelicious German chocolate cake was a hit for my birthday! Everyone loved it! Cookies are delicious too! Such a cute shop. Can’t wait to sample more items.
June 19 · Matthew Arnold
More Bakery Near Me
The Baking Company & Bread Kneads4.0 (190 reviews)510 S Blanchard St, Findlay, OH 45840, USA
Cakes For Heaven's Sake4.0 (25 reviews)1201 N Main St, Findlay, OH 45840, USA
Great American Cookies4.0 (17 reviews)1800 Tiffin Ave, Findlay, OH 45840, USA
Kroger Bakery5.0 (2 reviews)1996 Tiffin Ave, Findlay, OH 45840, USA
Meijer Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)2200 Tiffin Ave, Findlay, OH 45840, USA
Kroger Bakery3.0 (1 reviews)126 W High St, Fostoria, OH 44830, USA
Buggy Whip Bakery4.0 (15 reviews)104 E Main St, Wayne, OH 43466, USA
Einstein Bros. Bagels3.0 (207 reviews)705 Ridge St, Bowling Green, OH 43403, USA
Sweet Soul0.0 (0 reviews)147 Beechwood Dr, Tiffin, OH 44883, USA
Kroger Bakery4.0 (19 reviews)1094 N Main St, Bowling Green, OH 43402, USA
Ideal Bakery4.0 (205 reviews)101 W Madison St, Gibsonburg, OH 43431, USA
Polly's Pastries5.0 (5 reviews)1015 OH-590, Fremont, OH 43420, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Minicakes by Tasha4.0 (6 reviews)
Einstein Bros. Bagels3.0 (69 reviews)
Liv 4 Chocolate5.0 (3 reviews)
Bread Of Life - Padaria Pão da Vida - Oliver Street4.0 (1102 reviews)
Duck donut4.0 (50 reviews)
Sparkle City Cake5.0 (27 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
