Great American Cookies Introduce
When an Ohio family is celebrating a milestone—or simply needs an irresistible treat—nothing quite compares to a warm, fresh-baked cookie. For residents across Northwest Ohio, the name synonymous with these delightful desserts is Great American Cookies. Located conveniently in Toledo, this spot has perfected the classic chocolate chip and gone far beyond, specializing in their iconic Cookie Cakes that have become the centerpiece of celebrations throughout the region.
More than a typical bakery, Great American Cookies is a dedicated Cookie shop focused on delivering joy through high-quality, generously sized, and expertly decorated treats. They understand that a dessert is often the highlight of an event, and their focus on customization, convenience, and a welcoming environment makes them a trusted choice for local users looking for that perfect sweet indulgence.
---
## Introduction / Overview
The Great American Cookies location in Toledo, Ohio, serves as a premier destination for cookie lovers. Its reputation is built on delivering a consistent, comforting, and deeply satisfying product, moving beyond simple cookies to create memorable dessert experiences. This is the place Toledo locals turn to for party-ready confections, quick afternoon pick-me-ups, and thoughtful gifts.
The core of their offering revolves around classic, freshly baked Regular Cookies and their signature Cookie Cakes. These cakes are available for Create Your Own customization and in a variety of holiday, seasonal, and special occasion themes. From fun Birthday designs like the "Tractor" and "Unicorn" themes to dedicated decorations for School & Grad ceremonies, Father's Day, and Mother's Day, they ensure every event has a sweet, personalized touch.
Their menu also features favorites like the Double Doozies®, two cookies sandwiched around rich, creamy frosting, and the massive Colossal Cookie. For Ohioans needing a convenient, dessert-focused solution that promises great taste and visual appeal, Great American Cookies is a highly valued local resource.
---
## Location and Accessibility
This Great American Cookies location is strategically situated to offer maximum convenience to Toledo residents and visitors, placing it right in a major local retail hub.
Address: 5001 Monroe St Ste FC13, Toledo, OH 43623, USA
Being located within a prominent shopping area means the bakery is easy to find and access. Its placement ensures that it meets modern standards for customer convenience and inclusivity:
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
This focus on accessibility makes it a practical stop for all members of the community, whether you're quickly running in to grab a pre-ordered item or settling in for a treat after a day of shopping. The central location on Monroe Street makes it a familiar and favored spot for anyone in the greater Toledo area.
---
## Services Offered
Great American Cookies provides a focused suite of services centered around quick, customized, and enjoyable dessert procurement for Ohio customers.
- In-Store Shopping: Patrons can browse the full selection of cookies, brownies, and slices of cookie cake right in the shop.
- In-Store Pickup: Ideal for pre-ordering large items like custom Cookie Cakes, allowing for a seamless and quick collection.
- Takeout: All menu items, including Regular Cookies and Cookie Dozens, are readily packaged for fast and easy takeout.
- Dine-in: Guests have the option to enjoy their dessert and a refreshing Fountain Drink or Bottled Water right on location.
- Custom Cookie Cake Creation: Extensive options for decorating Cookie Cakes for virtually any occasion, including Birthday, School & Grad, Baby announcements, and various Sports and Special Occasion & Thank You themes.
---
## Features / Highlights
The unique features of this Toledo cookie shop are what make it a memorable and frequently revisited spot for dessert in Northwest Ohio.
- The Cookie Cake Specialist: The bakery’s primary highlight is the customizable, delicious Cookie Cake, offered in options like the double-layered Double Doozies® style, highly praised by customers for being "AMAZING! Worth every penny!!"
- Signature Treats: Beyond the cake, standouts include the original Regular Cookies ($2.49) and the indulgent Cookies & Cream Stuffed Cookie made with Oreo® Cookie, often featured as a Limited Time Only special.
- Party Platters and Bulk Options: Perfect for Ohio businesses, schools, or family gatherings, they offer 1.5 Dozen Assorted Cookie Platter ($39.99) and 2 Dozen Assorted Cookie Platter options, making catering easy.
- Inclusive and Welcoming Atmosphere: The shop is designated as LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace, creating a comfortable and affirming environment for everyone in the community.
- Convenient Amenities and Payment: Customers can enjoy free Wi-Fi during their visit, and checkout is easy with accepted methods like Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
- Variety of Occasions: Their decoration selection covers every need, from professional themes like Happy Boss's Day to personal milestones like Welcome Baby and Prom?
---
## Contact Information
For local customers in the Toledo area who need to place an order, confirm an existing order, or inquire about their custom cookie cakes, here is the necessary contact information.
Address: 5001 Monroe St Ste FC13, Toledo, OH 43623, USA
Phone: (419) 474-9417
Mobile Phone (Direct Line/Inquiry): +1 419-474-9417
It is recommended that customers placing high-value or highly personalized orders, such as large custom Cookie Cakes, use the phone number provided to speak directly with a team member. While the occasional lapse in service, such as the reported issue with a raw cookie cake, suggests that direct communication is best, many customers report positive experiences with the quality of the final product.
---
## What Is Worth Choosing: The Guaranteed Crowd-Pleaser
Great American Cookies is worth choosing for Toledo, Ohio residents because it offers a guaranteed crowd-pleaser for any event. When you need a dessert that is universally loved, their signature Cookie Cakes are the answer. They provide a high-impact, personalized centerpiece with the approachable, comforting flavor of a classic cookie. This specialization sets them apart from general bakeries.
The primary value here is Specialization and Customization. They don't try to master every type of pastry; they master the cookie. This focused expertise is evident in the quality of their main products, such as the rich Double Doozies® and the vast array of designs available for their custom cakes. The ability to quickly pop in for a Cookie Cake by the Slice ($4.79) or a dozen fresh cookies makes it perfect for a Quick visit.
While one customer noted a negative experience with a raw cake—a reminder to always check complex baked goods upon pickup—another enthusiastically shared that their $58 Double Doozie Cookie Cake was "AMAZING! Worth every penny!!" This confirms the incredible potential quality of their signature items when executed correctly. By focusing on a safe, welcoming environment, speed, and a product that is consistently a party hit, Great American Cookies solidifies its place as the sweet spot for celebrations and everyday cravings across the Northwest Ohio region.
Great American Cookies Vibe
Limited Time Only
- Cookies & Cream Stuffed Cookie made with Oreo® Cookie $3.99
Our Cookies & Cream Cookie stuffed with an Oreo(R) Cookie.
Create Your Own Cookie Cake
- Create Your Own Cookie Cake
Cookies & Brownies
- Regular Cookies $2.49
- Cookie Dozen $29.99
- COOKIE CAKE BY THE SLICE $4.79
- Double Doozies® $4.99
The Double Doozie® is made with our delectable icing sandwiched between your favorite cookies.
- Colossal Cookie $4.59
- 1.5 Dozen Assorted Cookie Platter $39.99
1 1/2 dozen assorted cookies arranged on a cookie platter.
- 2 Dozen Assorted Cookie Platter $61.99
2 dozen assorted cookies arranged on a cookie platter.
Cookie Card
- Cookie Card $18.99
Birthday
- Balloons B1030
- Dude, You're OLD B1041
- Birthday Fish B1042
- Birthday Horse B1043
- Island Birthday B1045
- Tractor B1046
- Rocket Ship B1047
- Unicorn B1048
- Birthday Bouquet B1049
- Groovy Birthday B1050
- Taco Birthday B1051
- Mermaid Tail B1052
- Level Up B1053
- Forever 29 B1038
- Happy Birthday Jenny B1037
- Birthday Basketball B1039
- Princess Crown B1028
- Caterpillar & Butterfly B1014
- Princess Cake B1019
- Boot B1027
- Guitar B1026
- 1st Birthday B1025
- Motorcycle Happy Birthday B1023
- B1022 Jeep Happy Birthday
- Pirate Ship Happy Birthday B1021
- Dinosaur B1005
- Painter Birthday B1032
- Roller Skate Birthday B1031P
- Happy Birthday Dump Truck B1036
Father's Day
- Coolest Pop - HS2427
- #1 Dad Coffee Mug - HS2428
- Grill HS2407
- Hammock HS2409
- Golf
- Father's Day Recliner HS2413
- Happy Father's Day Camp HS2418
- You're Flippin Awesome HS2419
- Happy Father's Day F-Ball HS2420
- Dad You're Reely Great HS2423
School & Grad
- Class of 2025 Diploma - S3026
- Class of 2025 Block - S3027
- Back to School S3404
- We Love Elementary S3405
- Congratulations Graduate S3001
- Tassel Hassle S3002
- Congratulations Grad! S3005
- Hats off to the Grad! S3009
- Graduate and Diploma S3025
- Class of Diploma S3020
- Class of S3021
- Congrats Grad Balloons S3022
- Back To The Books S3402
Special Occasion & Thank You
- Pink Ribbon O4052
- Get Well Flowers O4005
- Poker Night O4008
- Pig Out O4009
- Yellow Ribbon O4010
- Best Friends Forever O4016
- Brighten Your Day! Rainbow O4017
- Good Luck Moving O4018
- Sad To See You Go! O4019
- Girls' Night Out Martini O4020
- Prom? O4024
- Family Reunion Watermelon O4030
- Thanks A Latte O4040
Sports
- Great Season S3502
- Football Fever! S3503
- Football Field S3504
- Goal! S3505
- Go Team Helmet S3506
- Good Luck Team Baseball S3508
- Score Basketball S3509
Baby
- Welcome Baby O4004
- He or She O4036
- It’s a Girl Elephant O4038
- Ahoy It’s a Boy O4037
Work Occasions
- Boss Latte - O4050
- Happy Boss's Day Pennant - O4051
- You're The Best! O4011
- Happy Nurse's Day O4022
- Happy Boss’s Day O4027
- Happy Boss’s Day Ribbon O4046
- Best Boss Ever O4047
Summer & Patriotic
- 4th Of July Flag - HS2507
- US Flag HS2502
- Fourth of July HS2503
- Have A Great Summer! O4012
- Pool Time O4041
- Summer Vibes Only Pineapple O4042
- Let Summer Begin
Mother's Day
- Best Mom Ever – HS2326
- Mom, Mommy, Mama – HS2327
- Mother's Day Daisies HS2305
- Mother's Day Flowers Bird HS2316
- Butterfly Flowers HS2318
- Mother’s Day HS2321
- Mom, Love you Lots HS2322
- You're Stuck With Us Mom HS2323
Beverages
- Fountain Drink Small $2.29
- Fountain Drink Reg $2.69
- Fountain Drink Large $2.89
- Bottled Water $2.09
Add-Ons
- Cookies & Cream Stuffed Cookie made with Oreo® Cookie $3.99
Our Cookies & Cream Cookie stuffed with an Oreo(R) Cookie.
- Cookie Cake by the Slice $4.79
- 1 Dozen Assorted Regular Cookies $29.99
- 2 Dozen Assorted Regular Cookies $59.99
Great American Cookies Details
Service options
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Takeout
- Dine-in
- Delivery
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Dining options
- Dessert
Amenities
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safespace
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Great American Cookies Photos










Great American Cookies Location
Great American Cookies
5001 Monroe St Ste FC13, Toledo, OH 43623, USA
Great American Cookies Reviews
cookie cakepricesmalltraditionalbirthdayfrostingcallmoviesname
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Purchased a cookie cake for my son’s birthday today at the one in the food court. Served for after dinner to 5 adults and it was raw in some parts/middle. Tried calling and no one will answer the phone. So not happy especially after paying just shy of $40. 😩🤮
August 01 · Jody GardnerI ordered a cookie cake, for $20 extra I made it a double doozie. Although I thought $58 for a cookie cake was pricey, I went for it. It was AMAZING! Worth every penny!! It was definitely a hit!!!
September 14 · Tiffney AlvaradoThe individual cookies are amazing. Always soft and chewy, though last time we went they didn’t have many flavors out to choose from. I’ve never tried to order one of their cookie cakes though, which it seems many people have bad experiences with.
November 12 · Kaylie PaceI used the online ordering to order a 16” x 16” cookie and was given a round cookie - the store didn’t give a price adjustment like they said they would. I had someone else pick up the cookie, they reviewed it for wording but didn’t know it was the wrong size. I called the store, they offered to bake another one or give a price adjustment if I brought it back to the store. Except, they couldn’t bake a a square in time and I didn’t have the time to drive all the way back to the store and back to work in time for our office lunch. We decided I’d keep what I had but they’d provide a price adjustment to my credit card. They never did refund the price difference, even after an online complaint.These cookies used to be quite the treat and something special - they are not worth the price anymore! Another victim to shrink-flation. Cookies are super thin and this store in particular holds back on the frosting so that you’ll buy “full frosting.” With all the wording I had, I thought it’d fill the cake, they made sure it didn’t.There are too many other bakery options out there - I will never order from them again.
August 21 · CorrineIf i could give zero stars i would. She took a picture of what i wanted and everything. The name i gave her was spelt wrong and you can’t even read what it says. Paid 37.99 and apparently they made the baseball smaller because she didn’t charge me for “full frosting” i would’ve paid extra for what i wanted if they would’ve called and let me know. She told me i could bring it back and they’d make a new one but i laughed and said “i can’t because the party’s in a half hour” you LOST MY BUSINESS.
April 21 · Jessica
More Bakery Near Me
Cafe Donuts4.0 (442 reviews)5330 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43623, USA
Walmart Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)5821 Central Ave, Toledo, OH 43615, USA
Kroger Bakery5.0 (2 reviews)2257 N Holland Sylvania Rd, Toledo, OH 43615, USA
Organic Bliss4.0 (212 reviews)3723 King Rd # 200, Toledo, OH 43617, USA
Kroger Bakery3.0 (3 reviews)7545 W Sylvania Ave, Sylvania, OH 43560, USA
Nothing Bundt Cakes4.0 (99 reviews)7427 Central Ave, Toledo, OH 43617, USA
Kroger Bakery5.0 (1 reviews)2555 Glendale Ave, Toledo, OH 43614, USA
Walmart Bakery3.0 (7 reviews)2925 Glendale Ave, Toledo, OH 43614, USA
All Crumbs Bakery @ Toledo Farmers' Market4.0 (21 reviews)525 Market St, Toledo, OH 43604, USA
Sam's Club Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)1300 E Mall Dr, Holland, OH 43528, USA
La Paloma Pastries4.0 (319 reviews)1244 Broadway St #9, Toledo, OH 43609, USA
Barry Bagels Imagination Station Toledo4.0 (77 reviews)1 Discovery Way, Toledo, OH 43604, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Cassie's Donuts5.0 (12 reviews)
SusieCakes - Costa Mesa4.0 (117 reviews)
Dream Bakery4.0 (37 reviews)
Joey Bats Cafe4.0 (100 reviews)
Bagel Broker - Downtown4.0 (122 reviews)
Cerrato's Pastry Shop4.0 (310 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
