Guilty Cake Jars Introduce
Introduction / Overview
For New Jersey residents in search of truly exceptional custom cakes—especially those who navigate food sensitivities—
Guilty Cake Jars in Princeton Junction is a local gem that rises above the standard cake shop. While the name suggests a playful indulgence, the reality is a serious commitment to artistry, flavor balance, and accommodating dietary needs. This business operates as a dedicated cake shop, focusing on bespoke creations that are beautiful to look at and a delight to eat. Far from generic, every cake is a testament to the skill and dedication of the baker, with a personal touch that ensures each client's vision is not only met but exceeded.
In the competitive Central Jersey culinary scene, Guilty Cake Jars has established a strong reputation, particularly for its ability to expertly handle allergy-friendly requests, a crucial service for many local families. The reviews speak volumes, highlighting not only the delicious taste and stunning appearance of the cakes but also the 'absolute wonderful service' and personalized customization provided. It’s clear that this is a destination for discerning customers who value high-quality ingredients, customized design, and a perfectly balanced sweetness that avoids being 'too sweet.' This blend of artistry and accommodation makes Guilty Cake Jars a standout choice for celebrations across the New Jersey region, from local Princeton Junction birthdays to larger events.
Location and Accessibility
Guilty Cake Jars is conveniently situated in the Princeton Junction area, providing accessible services to residents throughout West Windsor and the greater Mercer County region. Its location is ideal for customers needing to pick up an order quickly or coordinating a delivery for a nearby event. While the core of the business is customization and order fulfillment, the physical location is structured for ease of access.
The specific address for this specialized cake shop is:
19206 Warbler Way, Princeton Junction, NJ 08550, USA
In terms of physical access, the facility is designed to be accommodating to all patrons. For customers arriving in person, there is a dedicated wheelchair accessible parking lot. This attention to accessibility ensures that coordinating a pickup—even for a large, special-occasion cake—is convenient and stress-free. The operation is structured to facilitate a quick visit for order collection, respecting the busy schedules of New Jersey clientele who rely on efficiency without compromising on quality.
Services Offered
Guilty Cake Jars offers a specialized range of services centered around custom-made cakes and desserts, focusing on both traditional requests and specialized dietary needs.
- Bespoke Celebration Cakes: Creating highly customized, unique cakes for all life events, including birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, and other special occasions.
- Customized Flavor Profiles: Specializing in balancing flavors to ensure cakes are 'super smooth and delicious' and 'not too sweet,' with the perfect mix of fruit, flavor, and frosting.
- Allergy-Friendly Baking: Expertise in accommodating specific dietary restrictions, such as egg allergies, ensuring safe, beautiful, and equally delicious alternatives.
- Thematic Cake Design: Working closely with customers to incorporate unique design requests and themes, nailing expectations 'to the point' for a truly personal presentation.
- Dessert Customization: Offering flexibility to customize every element of the dessert, from the flavor combination (like Chocolate Mousse with Berries) to the overall appearance.
- Order Fulfillment Options: Providing multiple convenient options for New Jersey customers, including local Delivery, In-store Pickup, and Takeout services.
- Event Desserts: Although the focus is cakes, the dedication to custom work extends to ensuring high-quality, memorable dessert centerpieces for any gathering.
Features / Highlights
The key features of Guilty Cake Jars revolve around its dedicated commitment to quality, customization, and customer-focused baking, making it a highly reliable and desirable choice for Princeton Junction and the surrounding communities.
- Dietary Accommodation Expertise: A major highlight is the baker's successful and celebrated ability to create cakes for those with allergies, such as egg-free options, without sacrificing taste or beauty. This is a vital service for many local families.
- Unwavering Commitment to Quality: The baker, noted for continuously liking to 'improve and refine her baking skills,' ensures a consistently high standard of product, utilizing excellent technique in every creation.
- Superior Customer Service: Customers frequently praise the 'superb service' and how the baker makes the process 'absolutely wonderful,' customizing everything to their exact desire.
- Flavor Balance Mastery: The cakes are celebrated for being perfectly balanced in sweetness and flavor, avoiding the overly sweet profile found in many commercial bakeries.
- Aesthetic Excellence: Cakes are not only delicious but also described as 'beautiful' and 'super smooth,' demonstrating a high level of decorative and textural finesse.
- Affordable Customization: Despite offering highly customized and specialized products, the pricing is noted as 'Affordable too,' providing great value to the local community.
- Convenient Payment Options: The business accepts modern payment methods, including Credit cards and Debit cards, for a smooth transaction process.
Contact Information
For residents in New Jersey looking to commission a custom cake, inquire about allergy accommodations, or arrange an order pickup in Princeton Junction, Guilty Cake Jars can be contacted using the following information:
Address: 19206 Warbler Way, Princeton Junction, NJ 08550, USA
Phone: (682) 208-8350
Mobile Phone: +1 682-208-8350
It is highly recommended that customers planning a custom order contact the cake shop well in advance to discuss design, flavor, and specific dietary needs to ensure the baker can dedicate the necessary time and attention to their special creation.
What is Worth Choosing
Choosing Guilty Cake Jars is an investment in quality, peace of mind, and bespoke artistry for your most important celebrations. For New Jersey locals, especially those with family members managing food allergies, this cake shop is an essential resource. It's worth choosing Guilty Cake Jars because they don't force you to compromise; you get a cake that is simultaneously safe for special diets (like egg-free) and a stunning centerpiece that tastes absolutely phenomenal.
The consistent customer loyalty—with one reviewer noting it's 'Another year, another birthday, but the same cake place'—is the strongest evidence of their superb delivery. When you choose Guilty Cake Jars, you are trusting a dedicated baker to not just fulfill an order, but to craft a personalized memory. The dedication to perfectly balanced flavors, stunning and unique design, coupled with truly superb and highly communicative service, makes this Princeton Junction cake shop a standout business. For a custom cake that is guaranteed to be the beautiful and delicious highlight of your event, look no further than the unparalleled service and skill offered by Guilty Cake Jars.
Guilty Cake Jars Details
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Guilty Cake Jars Photos










Guilty Cake Jars Location
Guilty Cake Jars
19206 Warbler Way, Princeton Junction, NJ 08550, USA
Guilty Cake Jars Reviews
birthdayfrostingbakingshotssweetnesseggless cakebundt cakeadultsmoussechocolate truffle
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1My daughter has an egg allergy and I’m so happy I found guilty cake! absolute wonderful service and she customized everything to what we wanted not to mention it was beautiful and delicious! Affordable too and superb service will for sure be returning!
July 27 · Kat FisherAnother year, another birthday, but the same cake place. The baker just keeps getting better at baking. Mrs. Nishu Singh just likes to improve and refine her baking skills. The cake I ordered this time was a little custom. I requested a Chocolate Mousse with Berries with little unique design. It turned out to be really good. I am not an expert at giving a description, but Mrs. Singh nailed my expectations to the point. The cake was super smooth and delicious. It was not too sweet, just the right amount. Every slice had the right mix of fruit, flavor and the frosting.
August 12 · Rushal PatelThe cake that we ordered was very tasty. All our guests enjoyed the cake . It was not too sweet and did not have too much cream. Would highly recommend Mrs Nishi. I am glad I found her at right time
August 26 · bhanu raviTalented baker, amazing cakes and 20 shots I ordered. Recently i had a desert from them it was a top notch - cake lasagna - layers of cakes, cream, etc. she takes care of your request carefully and customize it. If you have parties, need eggless cake, shes best
December 11 · Archy The Doodler (archysdesign)The Galentine's cake jars were delicious and disappeared in no time, highly recommend! Thank you for accommodating at the last minute, it made experience even better.
March 01 · Shama Ahsan
More Bakery Near Me
Nothing Bundt Cakes4.0 (51 reviews)3495 U.S. Rte 1, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA
Auntie Anne's3.0 (44 reviews)146 Quakerbridge Mall, Lawrence Township, NJ 08648, USA
Paris Baguette4.0 (602 reviews)157 Nassau Park Blvd, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA
Paul's bakery5.0 (1 reviews)17 Armour Rd, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA
The Gingered Peach4.0 (584 reviews)2 Gordon Ave, Lawrence Township, NJ 08648, USA
Milk & Cookies4.0 (134 reviews)20 Nassau St, Princeton, NJ 08542, USA
Chez Alice4.0 (708 reviews)5 Palmer Square W, Princeton, NJ 08542, USA
Belle Journu00e9e - Princeton3.0 (57 reviews)19 Chambers St, Princeton, NJ 08542, USA
The Little Chef Pastry Shop4.0 (159 reviews)8 S Tulane St, Princeton, NJ 08542, USA
House of Cupcakes4.0 (556 reviews)142 Nassau St, Princeton, NJ 08542, USA
ThinSlim Foods3.0 (2 reviews)174 Nassau St, Princeton, NJ 08542, USA
Bread Boutique4.0 (137 reviews)41 Witherspoon St, Princeton, NJ 08542, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
West Town Bakery4.0 (206 reviews)
Golden Delight Bakery4.0 (359 reviews)
Ms Maureen's Irish Soda Bread0.0 (0 reviews)
Rosita’s Bakery4.0 (33 reviews)
Bittersweet Bake Shoppe4.0 (65 reviews)
B & B Donuts4.0 (927 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
