Itzy's Jello and Desserts

In the heart of Middletown, New York, a local gem known as Itzy's Jello and Desserts has been making a name for itself by creating beautiful, custom-designed cakes that consistently exceed customer expectations. For many in the New York region, finding a baker who can perfectly capture a vision for a special occasion cake can be a challenge. Itzy’s Jello and Desserts, run by a talented baker named Beatriz, seems to have mastered this art. This article will provide an in-depth look at what makes this bakery a standout choice for residents, from the high quality of their custom work to their exceptional customer service. The information is based on real customer feedback, offering an authentic look at what makes this place so special.

The cornerstone of Itzy's Jello and Desserts is its ability to create stunning, custom cakes that are true to the customer's vision. One reviewer shared a powerful testament to this, posting a picture of what they wanted and the final result, stating that the baker, Beatriz, "out did herself on my boyfriends custom cake." The customer was so impressed that they "absolutely loved it" and vowed to be a returning client. This kind of direct comparison and praise highlights the bakery's skill in taking an idea and executing it with precision and artistry. It's a skill that builds trust and loyalty, making the bakery a reliable partner for any celebration.

Another key feature that sets Itzy's Jello and Desserts apart is its accommodating and "excellent service." A grateful customer shared an experience of needing a "last min cake for my daughter’s birthday." The customer was thrilled that Beatriz was able to accommodate the request and deliver a beautiful cake. This flexibility and willingness to help with a last-minute need is a huge advantage for busy locals who might find themselves in a pinch. The review also praised the "Great price for the cakes" and noted that the cake came out "exactly how I wanna it," reinforcing the bakery's commitment to both quality and affordability. This customer also highly recommended the bakery and stated they would "for sure be going back."

While the name "Itzy's Jello and Desserts" suggests a specialization in more than just cakes, the provided reviews heavily focus on the custom cake aspect. It is a reasonable assumption that the bakery offers other sweet treats as well, perhaps including Jello-based desserts, which could provide a unique twist to a typical dessert menu. The ability to provide a variety of options would make it a one-stop-shop for a celebration's dessert needs, from a centerpiece cake to smaller, individual treats. This versatility would further cement its place as a valuable local resource for parties, events, and personal indulgences.

The personal connection to the baker, Beatriz, is a recurring theme in the feedback. When a business owner is directly involved in the creation of the products and the service, it often results in a higher level of care and attention. Customers appreciate this personal touch, as it makes them feel valued and heard. The ability to communicate directly with the person who is baking the cake helps ensure that every detail is perfect, from the flavor to the design. This level of personalized service is a significant advantage of supporting a small, independent bakery over a large chain.

In conclusion, Itzy's Jello and Desserts has quickly become a respected and beloved business in the Middletown, NY area. The combination of exceptional custom cake design, accommodating service, and fair pricing has earned it a strong reputation among locals. For New Yorkers looking for a reliable and talented baker for their next celebration, this bakery offers a compelling solution. The positive feedback from customers, particularly regarding the ability to handle last-minute orders and deliver on their creative vision, makes it a highly recommended spot. It is a true testament to the value of a dedicated, local business that puts its customers first.

Location and Accessibility

Itzy's Jello and Desserts is located at 13 Sunnyside Ave, Middletown, NY 10940, USA. This address places it within a community-centric area of Middletown, making it easily accessible for local residents. Its location on Sunnyside Avenue suggests it is a part of the neighborhood fabric, making it a convenient stop for local customers. While the reviews do not provide specifics on parking or public transportation, its residential-commercial setting typically means there is easy access for pickups. The proximity to customers makes it an ideal spot for custom orders, which often require communication and coordination for delivery or pickup.

Services Offered

• Custom-designed cakes for various occasions like birthdays.
• Ability to handle last-minute cake orders, providing excellent flexibility.
• Creation of cakes that are highly faithful to customer-provided pictures and designs.
• A variety of desserts, as suggested by the name "Jello and Desserts."
• Personalized service from the owner and baker, Beatriz.

Features / Highlights

• The bakery excels at replicating a customer’s desired design, as shown in a customer review with a before-and-after picture.
• Known for "excellent service" and a willingness to accommodate last-minute requests.
• Cakes are offered at a "great price" for the quality and customization provided.
• Positive customer feedback highlights the owner, Beatriz, and her exceptional skills.
• A local, independent business that offers a personal touch that is highly valued.

Contact Information

Address: 13 Sunnyside Ave, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

Phone: (845) 800-8170

Conclusion: Why This Place is Suitable for Locals

Itzy's Jello and Desserts is a perfect fit for the Middletown, NY community and the wider New York region because it provides a reliable, high-quality, and personalized service that is crucial for celebrations. For locals, the convenience of having a talented baker who can create beautiful custom cakes right in their neighborhood is a huge asset. The bakery’s ability to handle last-minute requests and its commitment to customer satisfaction make it a stress-free choice for planning a party or event. By supporting Itzy's, locals are not just buying a cake; they are getting a piece of art that is made with care and dedication, all while supporting a valuable member of their community.

Itzy's Jello and Desserts

13 Sunnyside Ave, Middletown, NY 10940, USA