Mamaroneck Bagel Co.: Your Neighborhood Gem for Authentic NY Bagels and Hearty Sandwiches

Mamaroneck Bagel Co. Introduce

## Discover Your New Favorite Spot: Mamaroneck Bagel Co. in Mamaroneck, NY

For New Yorkers, especially those of us who appreciate the unparalleled quality of a true New York bagel, finding a local spot that consistently delivers is a real win. In the charming town of Mamaroneck, Westchester County, that quest often leads straight to **Mamaroneck Bagel Co.** This isn't just another bagel shop; it's a "neighborhood gem" that has quickly become a "must-visit" destination for anyone seeking delicious, hearty meals and the authentic taste of a New York bagel.

Mamaroneck Bagel Co. stands out not only for its "top quality bagels"—praised by those who have lived in "many neighborhoods in NYC"—but also for its impressive array of "delicious, hearty sandwiches and crispy sides." Whether you're craving a classic nova bagel, a robust breakfast sandwich, or an inventive lunch creation, this establishment is designed to satisfy. Customers rave about the freshness of ingredients, the cleanliness of the space, and the friendly service, all contributing to an experience that feels welcoming and authentic. From "The Chubby Chicken" to "The Mamaroneck Special," their menu promises flavor-packed options that will leave you eager to return. For locals and visitors alike, Mamaroneck Bagel Co. offers a genuine taste of New York’s beloved deli culture, making it an indispensable part of the community’s culinary landscape.

---

## Location and Accessibility: Right on East Boston Post Road

Mamaroneck Bagel Co. is conveniently located at 723 E Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA. This prime address places it directly on a major thoroughfare in Mamaroneck, a vibrant waterfront community in Westchester County. East Boston Post Road (also known as US Route 1) is a significant artery, ensuring high visibility and straightforward access for both local residents and those commuting through the area.

For New Yorkers who rely on driving, the location offers excellent accessibility. Being on a main road means it's easy to spot, and parking is generally available in the vicinity, whether directly at the shop or in nearby lots. This makes it a hassle-free stop for individuals heading to work, families grabbing weekend brunch, or anyone looking for a quick and satisfying meal. Furthermore, Mamaroneck is well-served by local public transportation options, including Westchester County Bee-Line Bus routes that operate along East Boston Post Road, potentially providing access for those without personal vehicles. Its integration into the local commercial landscape of Mamaroneck solidifies Mamaroneck Bagel Co.'s role as a convenient and essential destination for fresh bagels, hearty sandwiches, and delicious coffee, making it a daily convenience for many in the community.

---

## Services Offered: A Full Deli and Bagel Experience

Mamaroneck Bagel Co. goes above and beyond the traditional bagel shop, offering a comprehensive menu that caters to breakfast, lunch, and beyond. Their focus on hearty, flavorful options ensures there's something to satisfy every appetite. Here’s a detailed look at their services and popular offerings:

Top-Quality Bagels: Their core offering, praised by customers as "top quality bagels." They offer a variety of fresh bagels, including plain, sesame, poppy, everything, and specialty options, perfect for classic cream cheese spreads or as the base for sandwiches.
Gourmet Breakfast Sandwiches: A wide array of breakfast sandwich options, featuring fresh ingredients and hearty portions. These are often toasted to perfection.
Signature Lunch Sandwiches: A key highlight of their menu, featuring unique and robust creations:
- The Chubby Chicken: Loaded with chicken cutlet, cheddar cheese, bacon, grilled onions, and barbecue sauce.
- The Mamaroneck Special: Featuring grilled steak, sautéed onions, broccoli rabe, and mozzarella cheese.
- These and other substantial sandwich options are described as "packed with flavor."
Crispy Sides: Perfect accompaniments to their sandwiches, highly praised for their quality:
- Crispy onion rings
- Golden, thin-cut fries
Strong, Flavorful Coffee: A vital component of any New York bagel experience. Customers commend their "strong, flavorful coffee with a little milk that hit all the right notes."
Homemade Cream Cheeses: A variety of fresh cream cheese flavors to complement their bagels, including classic plain and often specialty flavors. Their Nova bagels are specifically highlighted by customers.
Fresh Ingredients: A commitment to using fresh ingredients in all their preparations, ensuring high-quality and delicious results.
Catering Services (Likely): Given the popularity of their bagels and sandwiches, it's highly probable that Mamaroneck Bagel Co. offers catering services for local businesses, events, and family gatherings.

---

## Features and Highlights: Why Mamaroneck Bagel Co. is a Gem

Mamaroneck Bagel Co. has quickly established itself as a beloved "neighborhood gem" in Westchester, thanks to several key features and highlights that consistently impress its clientele:

"Top Quality Bagels": Perhaps the most significant highlight, confirmed by patrons who have experienced bagels across NYC neighborhoods. This speaks to their commitment to authentic New York bagel tradition, ensuring the perfect texture and flavor.
"Delicious, Hearty Sandwiches": Beyond bagels, their creative and generously portioned sandwiches, like "The Chubby Chicken" and "The Mamaroneck Special," are a major draw. These are described as "packed with flavor" and "toasted to perfection."
Crispy and Delicious Sides: The rave reviews for their "crispy onion rings and golden, thin-cut fries" indicate that even their accompaniments are executed with care and quality.
Strong and Flavorful Coffee: A crucial element for many breakfast routines, their coffee is praised for its robust flavor, completing the quintessential bagel shop experience.
Friendly and Clean Environment: Customers highlight that "these guys are friendly, clean," which contributes significantly to a positive and welcoming atmosphere. This attention to service and hygiene enhances the overall experience.
Fresh Ingredients: The consistent quality of their food is attributed to the use of "fresh ingredients," a fundamental aspect of truly delicious food.
Family Favorite: The fact that "My whole family gets nova bagels and we love them!" underscores its appeal as a reliable and cherished spot for local families.
"Must-Visit" Destination: The strong recommendation to be a "must-visit" place indicates high customer satisfaction and a memorable culinary experience.

---

## Contact Information

To experience the delicious offerings at Mamaroneck Bagel Co., or to inquire about their menu, here is their contact information:

Address: 723 E Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA
Phone: (914) 630-0088

---

## Conclusion: Your Essential Culinary Stop in Mamaroneck

For New Yorkers residing in Mamaroneck and the broader Westchester County, Mamaroneck Bagel Co. is undeniably a "neighborhood gem" and a "must-visit" destination. It embodies the very best of a local New York bagel shop, delivering not only "top quality bagels"—praised by those with extensive NYC experience—but also an impressive array of "delicious, hearty sandwiches and crispy sides" that are "packed with flavor." This establishment consistently provides a satisfying and authentic culinary experience, making it a beloved staple for many.

The commitment to fresh ingredients, combined with a clean environment and genuinely friendly service, creates a welcoming atmosphere that encourages repeat visits. Whether you're a family enjoying Nova bagels together, a commuter grabbing a "Chubby Chicken" sandwich and a "strong, flavorful coffee" on the go, or simply craving crispy onion rings, Mamaroneck Bagel Co. exceeds expectations. Its convenient location on East Boston Post Road makes it easily accessible for daily routines or special weekend treats. For anyone seeking a true taste of New York’s iconic bagel culture, coupled with a diverse and delicious deli menu, Mamaroneck Bagel Co. is a highly recommended and essential local resource in Westchester. It's a place that will undoubtedly leave you eager to return for more.

Mamaroneck Bagel Co. Food & drink

Beverages
7. Small Water US$2.00
11. Large Water US$3.75
6. Arnold Palmer US$4.00
15. Gatorade US$4.00
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
2. Tea US$3.00
16. San Pellegrino (Can) US$4.00
4. Iced Coffee US$4.00
14. Yoohoo US$4.00
13. Snapple US$4.00
12. Red Bull US$4.75
18. Soda (Can) US$2.40
3. Hot Chocolate US$3.00
5. Iced Tea US$4.00
1. Coffee US$3.00
19. Seltzer Water (20 Oz) US$3.70
9. Medium Water US$2.25
17. Large Gatorade US$4.75
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
20. Soda (Bottle) US$3.70
8. Tropicana Juice (Bottle) US$4.00
10. Tropicana Juice (Carton) US$4.25

Homemade Salad
4. Low-Fat Chicken Salad (1 Lb) US$20.00
2. Tuna Salad (1 Lb) US$19.00
12. Greek Salad US$16.50
Romaine lettuce, black olives, feta cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers.
1. Chicken Salad (1 Lb) US$19.00
8. Coleslaw (1 1b) US$10.75
10. Caesar Salad US$14.00
Romaine lettuce, croutons, Parmesan cheese & Caesar dressing.
11. Caprese Salad US$16.00
Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomatoes, fresh basil and balsamic dressing.
3. Egg Salad (1 Lb) US$13.00
6. Potato Salad (1 Lb) US$10.75
13. House Salad US$17.55
Chopped iceberg lettuce, cucumber, tomato, chickpeas, roasted peppers, beans and homemade balsamic dressing.
9. Avocado Salad US$17.55
Romaine lettuce, avocado, tomatoes, red onions, homemade balsamic vinegar dressing and beets.
5. Low-Fat Tuna Salad (1 Lb) US$20.00
7. Macaroni Salad (1 Lb) US$10.75

Breakfast Sandwiches
1. Two Eggs US$6.00
3. Two Eggs And Cheese With Any Meat US$9.45
Bacon, sausage, ham, turkey bacon.
2. Two Eggs And Cheese US$6.75

Paninis
2. Panini Di Carne US$18.25
Shell steak, caramelized onions, arugula, white American cheese, tomatoes.
6. Panini De Avocado US$19.00
Grilled chicken, avocado, jack cheese, bacon, lettuce, garlic mayo.
1. Panini Di Prosciutto & Pollo US$17.55
Grilled chicken prosciutto, mozzarella, fontina cheese, tomatoes & arugula.
5. Panini Di BBQ US$17.50
Chicken cutlet, grilled onions, bacon, cheddar cheese and BBQ sauce.
4. Panini Di Cuba US$19.00
Pernil, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles and mustard.
3. Panini Al Pesto US$17.55
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers and home made pesto sauce.

Bakery Department
2. Crumb Cakes US$4.00
3. Donuts US$4.00
5. Croissant US$4.00
6. Homemade Chocolate Chip Cookies US$5.00
1. Muffins US$5.00
Corn, blueberry, chocolate, banana, chocolate chip, raisin bran, pistacho, oat bran.
4. Black And White Cookie US$4.00

Pancakes & More
8. Fresh Fruit Cups US$9.45
Watermelon, pineapple, melon.
10. Parfait US$8.00
7. Oatmeal Plain US$8.00
With banana, blueberry, strawberry topping for an additional charge.
5. French Toast (3) US$11.00
2. Buttermilk Pancakes (3) US$15.00
3. Chocolate Chip Pancakes (3) US$16.00
6. Grilled Cheese US$8.45
1. Waffles US$12.25

Cold Lunch Specials
6. Italian Combo US$17.55
Ham, salami, pepperoni, prosciutto, provolone cheese, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, Italian dressing on a roll.
8. New York Turkey Special US$15.50
Fresh turkey, onion, tomatoes, romaine lettuce, mayo,oil & vinegar on a roll.
3. Nova Classic US$19.00
Smoked salmon, capers, scallion cream cheese, red onions, tomatoes served on your favorite bagel.
9. Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap US$15.00
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese, Caesar wrap.
1. House Special US$15.50
Grilled chicken, green apple, arugula, fontina cheese, raspberry dressing, served on a roll.
2. Ceci's Club US$16.25
Pepper turkey, jack cheese, bacon, cucumber, ranch dressing on a roll.
5. Rare Russian US$17.25
Roasted beef, cole slaw, Swiss cheese, Russian dressing on a roll.
4. Turkey Club US$17.55
Fresh turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, bacon, mayo on toasted white bread.
7. Boston Post Road Special US$16.25
Honey turkey, cranberry sauce, walnuts, fontina cheese, mix greens, honey mustard on a multigrain ciabatta bread.

Breakfast Wraps
4. Italian Breakfast Wrap US$12.25
Two eggs, sausage, peppers, onions, provolone cheese.
3. Vegetable Breakfast Wrap US$11.50
Two eggs, spinach, broccoli, mushrooms & tomatoes.
2. Chilli Breakfast Wrap US$12.25
Two eggs, chorizo, grilled onions, fresh jalapeño, pepper jack cheese.
1. Mamaroneck Breakfast Wrap US$14.25
Two eggs, avocado, pepper jack cheese, bacon, beans.
5. American Breakfast Wrap US$15.00
Two eggs, avocado, home fries, fresh turkey, American cheese.

Bagels
15. Mini Bagel With Flavor Cream Cheese US$5.00
Cream cheese variety - scallion, vegetables, strawberry, bacon scallion, tomato bacon, olive, walnut raisin, jalapeño low fat plain, low fat scallion, low fat vegetable.
6. Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese US$6.00
16. Mini Bagel With Lox Spread US$6.00
7. Bagel With Flavor Cream Cheese US$7.45
Cream cheese variety - scallion, vegetables, strawberry, bacon scallion, tomato bacon, olive, walnut raisin, jalapeño low fat plain, low fat scallion, low fat vegetable.
2. Each Bagel US$2.30
12. Flat Bagel With Lox Spread US$10.25
8. Bagel With Lox Spread US$8.75
1. Baker's Dozen (13) US$28.35
3. Flat Bagel US$3.00
5. Bagel With Butter US$4.40
11. Flat Bagel With Flavor Cream Cheese US$8.75
Cream cheese variety - scallion, vegetables, strawberry, bacon scallion, tomato bacon, olive, walnut raisin, jalapeño low fat plain, low fat scallion, low fat vegetable.
10. Flat Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese US$7.45
9. Flat Bagel With Butter US$5.75
13. Mini Bagel With Butter US$3.40
4. Mini Bagel US$2.00
14. Mini Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese US$4.60

Homemade Soups
1. Chicken Noodle US$9.50
3. Beef Barley Soup US$9.50
2. Lentil US$9.50

From The Grill
6. Chicken Wings (6) US$13.50
With celery, blue cheese.
9. BLT US$12.00
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
11. Side Home Fries US$6.75
7. Chicken Quesadilla US$17.55
With French fries, sweet potato fries or onion rings.
3. Bacon Cheeseburger US$19.00
Comes with lettuce, tomatoes and French fries.
12. Side Sweet Potato Fries US$8.00
10. Side French Fries US$6.75
2. Cheeseburger US$17.50
Comes with lettuce, tomatoes and French fries.
4. Empanadas US$4.00
Each. chicken or beef.
5. Chicken Fingers (4) US$15.00
With French fries.
1. Hamburger US$16.25
Comes with lettuce, tomatoes and French fries.
13. Side Onion Rings US$8.00
8. Steak Quesadilla US$19.00
With French fries, sweet potato fries or onion rings.

Cream Cheese
1 Lb Flavor Cream Cheese US$17.00
1/2 Lb Flavor Cream Cheese US$8.50
1 Lb Plain Cream Cheese US$15.00
1/2 Lb Butter US$7.50
1 Lb Butter US$15.00
1/2 Lb Plain Cream Cheese US$7.50

Cold Cut Sandwich
5. Boars Head Turkey US$12.25
1. Homemade Roasted Beef US$14.50
6. Boars Head Ham US$12.25
4. Brisket US$16.00
2. Homemade Fresh Turkey US$13.50
3. Corned Beef US$16.00

Hot Lunch Specials
2. Spicy Tiger's Team US$16.00
Spicy. Buffalo chicken cutlet, pepper jack cheese, celery, blue cheese dressing on a roll.
8. Gaetano's Grilled US$16.75
Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil mavo. Served on a roll.
3. Manhattan Special US$17.55
Grilled chicken, tomatoes, avocado, cilantro, Swiss, garlic mayo on a ciabatta bread.
7. Ralph's Roast US$15.50
Pernil, sautéed onions, tomatoes, lettuce, havarti cheese, garlic mayo served on a ciabatta bread.
4. Chubby Chicken US$17.55
Chicken cutlet, cheddar cheese, bacon, grilled onions, BBQ sauce on a roll.
9. Pichi's Special US$17.55
Grilled chicken, avocado, spinach, jack cheese, chipotle mayo served on a ciabatta bread.
6. Reuben Special US$18.50
Corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, Russian dressing on rye bread.
1. Mamaroneck Bagel Special US$18.50
Grilled steak, sautéed onions, broccoli rabe, mozzarella cheese. Served on ciabatta bread.
5. Philly Cheesesteak US$16.75
Roasted beef, sautéed onions, peppers, American cheese on a roll.

Omelette Varieties
4. Irish Omelette US$17.55
Three eggs, onions, avocado, cheddar, potatoes, corned beef.
3. Healthy Omelette US$16.00
Three egg whites, cilantro, onions, avocado, fresh mozzarella.
5. House Omelette US$16.35
Three eggs, bacon, sausage, and cheese.
2. Western Omelette US$15.25
Three eggs, ham, peppers and sautéed white onions.
1. Vegetable Omelette US$15.25
Three eggs, broccoli, spinach, mushrooms and peppers.

Mamaroneck Bagel Co. Details

Service options
In-store pick-up
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

Mamaroneck Bagel Co. Photos

Mamaroneck Bagel Co. Location

Mamaroneck Bagel Co.

New York Westchester County Mamaroneck East Boston Post Road

723 E Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA

Mamaroneck Bagel Co. Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 58 user reviews.

pricesandwichonion ringscream cheesepaniniloxsautéed onionsbakedflavorbacon

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This spot is a must-visit for anyone who loves delicious, hearty sandwiches and crispy sides.The Mamaroneck Bagel Company in Mamaroneck, NY! The full review is on YouTube.We tried The Chubby Chicken sandwich, loaded with chicken cutlet, cheddar cheese, bacon, grilled onions, and barbecue sauce, and The Mamaroneck Special, featuring grilled steak, sautéed onions, broccoli rabe, and mozzarella cheese. Both were toasted to perfection and packed with flavor.On the side, we enjoyed crispy onion rings and golden, thin-cut fries-both absolutely delicious! And to top it off, we had a cup of strong, flavorful coffee with a little milk that hit all the right notes.This place is a gem, and we can’t wait to go back!Check out our full review and let us know what you think. Would you try these sandwiches?
January 18 · Franjez
Super happy to have this place in my neighborhood. Top quality bagels… and I’ve lived in many neighborhoods in NYC. These guys are friendly, clean, and make great bagels with fresh ingredients. My whole family gets nova bagels and we love them!
January 05 · Nick Oliva
Was waiting a long time for this place to finally open and it was well worth it. We were fans of Brooklyn bagel in mamaroneck as well but this is a very close rival maybe not as expensive? I would definitely recommend the bagels here and the coffee cake is unbelievable!
June 07 · Sean Comp
Mamaroneck Bagel Co. is always 10/10! Literally, everything I've had there has been amazing. Go now!
January 04 · Nicole Abiamo
Finally, authentic NYC-style bagels in Mamaroneck! The bagels are definitely made the correct way, boiled first and then baked. They are extremely fresh, large, chewy, and delicious. They are a bit pricier but well worth it! Also love that they have parking available.
July 11 · Suzy O.