More Than A Bagel

For New Yorkers, especially those residing in the Long Island area, finding a truly authentic and satisfying bagel spot is a cherished quest. More Than A Bagel, located in Hewlett, aims to be that very place, offering what many consider to be classic New York bagels alongside a comprehensive menu of breakfast and lunch items. This establishment has built a loyal following over the years, with many customers returning consistently, drawn by the promise of fresh, delicious bagels and a welcoming atmosphere.

The name "More Than A Bagel" is a fitting descriptor, as while their bagels are a cornerstone, the menu extends far beyond, encompassing a full deli experience. From hearty breakfast sandwiches to fresh salads and classic deli sides, they strive to be a convenient and reliable option for any meal of the day. Reviews frequently highlight the exceptional friendliness and attentiveness of the staff, who often remember regular customers' orders by heart, fostering a genuine sense of community. While individual preferences on certain menu items like tuna salad may vary, the overall consensus points to quick service, a clean environment, and a dedication to customer satisfaction that makes More Than A Bagel a fixture in the Hewlett community.

More Than A Bagel is conveniently located at 1303 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA. Hewlett is a charming hamlet in Nassau County, Long Island, situated within easy reach of surrounding communities such as Woodmere, Lynbrook, and Valley Stream. Broadway is a central thoroughfare in Hewlett, making the bakery easily identifiable and accessible for both local residents and those passing through.

For New Yorkers in Long Island, driving is typically the most common mode of transport, and More Than A Bagel's location on Broadway likely offers reasonable parking options in the vicinity, though it's always advisable to check during peak hours. The area is served by local bus routes, which can connect to Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) stations in nearby towns, providing broader accessibility for commuters from other parts of Long Island or even New York City boroughs. Its presence in a local commercial strip ensures it's a convenient stop for daily commutes, weekend errands, or a dedicated trip for authentic New York bagels.

• Freshly Baked Bagels and Flagels: More Than A Bagel offers a wide variety of fresh bagels, including classic options like Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Everything, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Pumpernickel, Cinnamon Raisin, Blueberry, and Egg bagels. They also offer "flagels," which are flatter versions of bagels. Bagels can be purchased individually or by the dozen.

• Extensive Cream Cheese Selection: To complement their bagels, they provide a vast array of cream cheese flavors, including Plain, Lite, Scallion, Vegetable, Walnut Raisin, Sundried Tomato, Strawberry, Olive, Garlic & Herb, Funfetti, Jalapeño, and various Lox spreads. Tofu cream cheese options are also available.

• Breakfast Sandwiches and Platters: A full breakfast menu includes egg sandwiches on bagels or rolls (with optional cheese, bacon, sausage, or ham), breakfast wraps (such as Egg White with Spinach and Mushrooms, or Farmer's Wrap), omelets (create-your-own or L.E.O.), and platters like "The Bagel Boss Plate" which typically includes eggs, home fries, a bagel/bialy, orange juice, and coffee.

• Hot Off the Grill Items: Beyond sandwiches, they offer classic breakfast staples like Buttermilk Pancakes and French Toast (available with coffee or juice), Home Fries, and Hash Browns.

• Deli Sandwiches and Salads: The "More Than A Bagel" name truly shines here, with a comprehensive deli menu. This includes a wide selection of lunch sandwiches with various meats and cheeses, hot sandwiches like grilled roast beef or chicken cutlets, and specialty panini. They also offer a range of fresh deli salads sold by the half-pound or pound, such as tuna salad, egg salad, white fish salad, chicken salad, potato salad (noted as "phenomenal"), and various health salads.

• Homemade Baked Goods: In addition to bagels, they feature assorted freshly baked muffins (Blueberry Crumb, Corn, Chocolate Chip, etc.), crumb cake, cookies (Oatmeal Raisin, Black & White, Chocolate Chip), croissants, apple turnovers, cheese Danish, and specialty items like Famous Chocolate Babka and Rugelach.

• Coffee and Beverages: A full coffee bar offers Colombian coffee (regular and decaf), specialty coffees like Latte, Cappuccino, Mochaccino, Americano, and Espresso. They also serve iced coffee, iced tea, and hot chocolate.

• Catering Options: While not explicitly stated in reviews, the extensive menu and bulk options (dozens of bagels, salads by the pound) suggest they cater to larger orders, suitable for local events or office breakfasts.

• Authentic New York Bagels: Praised by loyal customers for their delicious bagels, which are considered to be truly representative of the classic New York style.

• Exceptional Staff and Service: Reviews consistently highlight the staff as "super friendly," "very kind people," and "attentive." Many mention that the team remembers their orders, contributing to a welcoming and personalized experience.

• Quick Service: Despite juggling multiple customers, the service is described as "very quick," making it an efficient stop for busy New Yorkers.

• "Phenomenal" Potato Salad: One specific highlight is their potato salad, which a customer explicitly called "phenomenal," indicating a standout side dish.

• Competitive Local Pricing: Customers note that prices are "cheap for this area," offering good value within the Long Island region.

• Clean Establishment: The bakery is described as a "clean place," an important factor for customer comfort and trust in a food establishment.

• Cash Only Policy: It's important to note for new customers that the establishment operates on a "Cash only" policy, which is a significant piece of information for planning a visit.

Address: 1303 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA

Phone: (516) 569-9350

For New Yorkers in Hewlett and the surrounding Long Island communities, More Than A Bagel stands out as a genuine local institution. Its suitability for locals is multifaceted, beginning with its core offering: authentic, delicious New York bagels that consistently garner praise. This is not just a place for a quick bite; it’s a spot where the staff often knows your order by heart, creating a warm, community-focused atmosphere that is truly appreciated in a bustling metropolitan area.

Beyond the bagels themselves, the comprehensive menu ensures that More Than A Bagel is a versatile choice for any meal. Whether you're grabbing a hearty breakfast sandwich on your way to work, picking up a substantial deli lunch, or treating yourself to a fresh muffin and coffee, they have a wide array of options to satisfy diverse tastes. The noted "phenomenal" potato salad is an example of the quality that extends beyond their namesake. Furthermore, the combination of quick and friendly service with competitive pricing for the area makes it an efficient and economical option for everyday needs. While it's important for new customers to remember their "Cash only" policy, the overall experience of quality food, attentive service, and a welcoming environment firmly establishes More Than A Bagel as a beloved and highly suitable destination for New Yorkers seeking an authentic and reliable local eatery in Hewlett.

More Than A Bagel

1303 Broadway, Hewlett, NY 11557, USA