Peschel's Cheesecakes: Tampa's Legacy Brand for Artisanal, Gourmet Cheesecake Specialties

Peschel's Cheesecakes Introduce

Introduction / Overview

In the vibrant and ever-evolving culinary landscape of Florida, certain brands leave an indelible mark, celebrated not just for their products, but for their passion and unique history.

Peschel's Cheesecakes

is precisely one such establishment. While the bakery’s operations may have transitioned beyond a simple storefront, the brand’s identity is intrinsically linked to its origins in Tampa, and its specialty items remain highly sought after by Floridian patrons. Peschel's is, first and foremost, a specialized

Bakery

, concentrating its entire focus on the refined art of crafting the perfect cheesecake.

This is not a general-purpose dessert shop; it is a destination for cheesecake connoisseurs. The foundation of Peschel's success rests on a remarkable piece of history: a treasured

100-year-old family recipe

. This time-honored tradition ensures that every slice is more than just a sweet treat—it is a piece of culinary heritage, crafted for a modern, gourmet palate. The result is a cheesecake noted for its

softer, creamier

consistency, offering a sophisticated upgrade to traditional New York-style density.

The entire experience is defined by an absolute commitment to quality and care. Customers consistently rave about the

warmth and kindness

of the service and the owner's personal investment in every detail, from the carefully selected,

clean, organic ingredients

to the

beautifully crafted packaging

. For any Florida resident visiting or living in the Tampa Bay area, Peschel's Cheesecakes represents the pinnacle of specialized, artisanal baking, offering a memorable experience that makes the stomach happy.

The brand's enduring popularity is a testament to its singular focus on excellence. While local residents are encouraged to inquire about the current ordering schedule, the desire for this superb dessert—whether the flagship flavor or a seasonal specialty—remains high across the state.

Location and Accessibility

Peschel's Cheesecakes built its reputation on the local support it received while operating out of the Tampa area. The address provided,

5226 S Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33611, USA

, served as the essential

local pickup

point, often operating from a shared commercial space like The Bakery Box. It is important for Florida customers to note that while this address is part of the brand's local legacy, the primary production and dispatch operations have recently relocated out of state. However, the business maintains a strong relationship with its Florida customer base, primarily serving them now through shipping and special ordering schedules.

For context regarding the ease of service during its tenure in Tampa, the former pickup location was easily accessible on South Dale Mabry Highway, a major thoroughfare in South Tampa. This setup ensured that customers could quickly collect their orders. The location featured a crucial element of convenience:

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

. This demonstrated the business's commitment to ensuring that all customers had the ability to easily access their highly sought-after baked goods, supporting the Tampa community with practical accessibility features.

New and existing Florida customers should be aware that the primary mode of receiving a Peschel's Cheesecake is now via shipping, delivered directly to their Florida home. Therefore, the accessibility focus shifts from the physical site to the ease of the digital ordering process, ensuring that the unique flavors are still available to the devoted Florida fan base, regardless of the physical move.

Services Offered

Given the business model's shift to specialized ordering and shipping, the available services are focused on ensuring maximum quality and convenience for customers securing a premium product:

Specialized Ordering: All products are created based on a specific
Production & Ordering Schedule
, ensuring that every cheesecake is baked fresh for its specific dispatch date.
Shipping: The primary service is now shipping, with customers advised to select
overnight or 2-day shipping
to maintain the quality and frozen state of the delicate product, ensuring it arrives perfectly to homes across Florida and beyond.
Takeout (Legacy/Inquiry): While daily
Takeout
at the Tampa address is no longer an option, customers can use the phone number to inquire about any possible local pop-ups or special Florida events the brand may attend.
Electronic Payments: The brand is modern and convenient, accepting major
Credit cards
and
Debit cards
for secure online transactions.

This highly specialized service model reflects the brand's commitment to delivering a premium, fresh product, prioritizing quality control over mass production. The emphasis on scheduled ordering ensures the dedication to the

100-year-old family recipe

is never compromised.

Features / Highlights

Peschel's Cheesecakes is distinguished by its history, its meticulous use of ingredients, and its array of unique flavor profiles:

The 100-Year Recipe: The core identity is the use of a
100-year-old family recipe
that creates a distinctively
softer, creamier
texture, setting it apart from denser, traditional cheesecakes.
Gourmet, Organic Ingredients: A commitment to using
clean, organic ingredients
appeals directly to Florida customers prioritizing quality and fresh sourcing in their gourmet purchases.
Unique Flavor Portfolio: The menu features a highly creative and artisanal rotation of flavors, including the widely praised
Keylime cheesecake
, rich
Peanut Butter Chocolate Cheesecake
, seasonal offerings like
Pumpkin Bourbon Pecan Cheesecake
,
Peppermint Bark Cheesecake
,
honey lavender
, and
strawberry rhubarb
.
Exceptional Customer Service: Reviewers emphasize the owner’s personal touch, describing the experience as marked by
warmth and kindness
and a dedication to care that turns each cheesecake purchase into a
memorable experience
.
Beautiful Presentation: The product arrives in
beautifully crafted packaging
, highlighting the attention to detail that accompanies the high quality of the dessert itself.

Contact Information

Despite its physical relocation, Peschel's Cheesecakes remains connected to its loyal Florida customer base via the original contact channels. The phone number and former local address are the reference points for inquiries regarding custom orders or the current shipping schedule.

Former Local Pickup Address (Tampa Legacy Location): 5226 S Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33611, USA

Phone for Inquiries: (941) 257-3144

Operational Hours: Due to the business's transition to a shipping-focused model, there are no regular daily operating hours. All ordering is done through the official online schedule, with specific cut-off dates for production.

What is Worth Choosing

For the Florida resident who simply

loves cheesecake

, choosing Peschel's Cheesecakes is choosing a level of quality and heritage that is unmatched. The most compelling reason is the product itself: a delicious dessert made with a

100-year-old family recipe

that results in a unique, perfectly consistent texture. This is a dessert that satisfies the highest standards of gourmet indulgence.

Beyond the taste, the brand is worth choosing for its integrity. The commitment to using

clean, organic ingredients

is a major selling point for health-conscious consumers in Florida. More importantly, the personalized service—the

genuine care

and the owner's investment in every detail—transforms a simple purchase into a rewarding and memorable transaction. The review comments, like

your stomach will be happy that you did

, speak volumes about the satisfaction the product delivers.

Even with the relocation, the ability to still access these gourmet flavors—including the sublime

Keylime cheesecake

and the decadent

pecan bourbon

flavor—via a streamlined shipping process ensures that the Peschel's legacy lives on for its Florida fan base. For a special occasion, a thoughtful gift, or a personal indulgence, Peschel's delivers a consistently rich, creamy, and flavorful experience, directly from a brand with deep Tampa roots.

Peschel's Cheesecakes Details

Service options
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards

Peschel's Cheesecakes Photos

Peschel's Cheesecakes Location

Peschel's Cheesecakes

Florida Hillsborough County Tampa Sun Bay South South Dale Mabry Highway

5226 S Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33611, USA

Peschel's Cheesecakes Reviews

An average rating of ★5 from 14 user reviews.

key limepackagingdinnergift

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I cannot rave about this place enough! First and foremost, the service here is absolutely wonderful. The owner responded to my inquiry via Instagram in a very timely manner as I was a last minute customer wanting to order some cheesecake from Orlando as I was visiting from out of town. On top of that, the Keylime cheesecake was absolutely superb! The crust was perfect, and the consistency was very, very nice. I would highly recommend anyone who is visiting Tampa or who simply loves cheesecake to try this place out and your stomach will be happy that you did.
March 12 · Seth Jensen
I recently had the most delicious cheesecakes from Peschel's Cheesecakes, and I can't stop raving about them! The pecan bourbon and peanut butter chocolate flavors were absolutely divine - each bite was rich, creamy, and full of flavor. But beyond the amazing taste, what truly sets Peschel's apart is the warmth and kindness in every part of the experience. The owner puts so much thought and love into every detail, from the beautifully crafted packaging to the genuine care in her service. You can feel the compassion and dedication in everything she does, making eachcheesecake not just a treat, but a memorable experience. Highly recommend!
November 14 · Sasha Kelly
When my brother told me he was gifting me a cheesecake I’ll admit, I was skeptical. I wondered how well something like that could travel across states and would it really be worth the cost. The short answer is, it was DEFINITELY worth the cost and it traveled perfectly thanks to the care that Peschel’s took in its packaging. They really go out of their way to package the cheesecakes with care so they stay cool and whole and they give clear instructions for how to unbox and manage the cake once you get it. They even sent a really nice platter. But then the actual cheesecake? Out of this world delicious. And despite its generous size my family devoured it in only a couple of days. It was irresistibly good. My 6 year old son who never likes cheesecake asked when we would get more. I will definitely keep buying cheesecakes from Peschel’s and have already recommended this company to many friends. They deserve the good reviews they’re getting. Order from Peschel’s and keep this company going so my family can keep eating cheesecake!
May 24 · Kristi Artinian
I ordered a cheesecake for a special dinner I was hosting and absolutely loved it! As did all my guests. It was so delicious that I ordered two cakes for my sisters who also loved them. I had the standard cheesecake and they ordered the key lime and raspberry. Our families and friends all agreed it was the best cheesecake we've ever had!
May 23 · Michelle Taylor
I feel incredibly lucky to have discovered Peschel’s Cheesecakes. From the moment I placed my order, the customer service was top-notch, making the whole experience seamless and enjoyable. I tried two separate variety packs, and every single flavor was absolutely divine.My favorites were the classic, orange creamsicle, and key lime cheesecakes. Each bite was a perfect blend of rich, creamy goodness that left me wanting more. I don’t think I can resist trying all the other flavors in the future!This is now my go-to for any special occasion, and I can’t recommend them enough. I’m eagerly anticipating what they come up with next—maybe cheesecake bites? Whatever it is, I can’t wait to try it!
May 29 · Derek Johnson