Prairie Pie

Introduction / Overview

For residents of the Missouri region, particularly those around Springfield, the name Prairie Pie is synonymous with artisanal, handmade perfection. This local bakery, situated in the charming Rountree neighborhood, has elevated the humble pie to a gourmet delicacy, offering an extensive selection of both delectable sweet pies and hearty savory pot pies. Prairie Pie is far more than just a dessert shop; it’s a full-service culinary destination that focuses on original recipes, visually appealing presentations, and fantastic taste, using seasonal and local ingredients whenever possible.

Founded by baker Eleanor Taylor, the business has grown from a well-loved pop-up to a beloved storefront, now operating inside the established Tea Bar & Bites location. This unique setup allows patrons to enjoy the best of two worlds: Prairie Pie’s fresh-baked creations and a warm, inviting atmosphere complete with quality Coffee offerings. While the pies—such as the famous Honey Sea Salt and the highly-praised Chicken Pot Pie—are the stars, the menu has expanded to include wood-fired selections and freshly prepared sides, creating a complete dining experience. The establishment prides itself on being an inclusive space, welcoming all members of the community and identifying as LGBTQ+ friendly. Whether you are in the mood for a satisfying lunch, a convenient dinner solution, or the perfect slice of Missouri's best dessert, Prairie Pie promises an unmatched, flaky, buttery crust and a filling that tastes like home—but better.

Location and Accessibility

Prairie Pie is conveniently located in the vibrant Rountree neighborhood of Springfield, Missouri, making it an easy stop for locals across the region. The bakery operates from:

621 S Pickwick Ave, Springfield, MO 65802, USA

This prime location within Tea Bar & Bites provides a welcoming environment that is readily accessible to all customers. The bakery offers multiple parking solutions to ensure a hassle-free visit, including on-site parking and readily available free street parking in the surrounding neighborhood. Furthermore, Prairie Pie is committed to ensuring a comfortable visit for every patron, providing necessary accessibility features. The premises feature a wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible parking lot. Inside, customers will find amenities such as a restroom and a gender-neutral restroom, emphasizing the bakery's dedication to inclusivity and comfort. With Wi-Fi available, it is an ideal spot for a quick visit or a relaxing break.

Services Offered

Prairie Pie offers flexible and customer-centric service options, ensuring that their gourmet pies and bakery items can be enjoyed by everyone in the Missouri area, whether on-site or at home.

UL

• In-Store Shopping / Dine-in: Enjoy a slice of pie, a savory pot pie, or a wood-fired dish in the comfortable and inviting atmosphere of the bakery.

• Takeout / In-store Pickup: Easily collect your individual pie slices, cookies, pot pies, or full pie pre-orders for a delightful treat at home or at the office.

• Delivery: Customers can have the entire menu—from their savory pot pies to their decadent sweet pies—delivered directly to their door, perfect for a hassle-free meal or dessert.

• Sweet Pie Pre-Order: Full-size 10-inch pies and mini pies are available for pre-order, ideal for holidays, parties, and special occasions, with options often including Apple, Pumpkin, Cinnamon Buttermilk, and Chocolate Pecan.

• Take & Bake Pot Pies: For the ultimate convenience, Prairie Pie offers frozen, un-baked pot pies—including the Chicken Pot Pie and Curry Vegetable Pot Pie—in both individual and family sizes, ready to bake at home with provided instructions.

• Coffee and Drinks: High-quality Coffee is available to pair perfectly with any sweet or savory selection.

Features / Highlights

Prairie Pie has garnered local acclaim and a loyal following due to its commitment to quality, creativity, and community. Its unique offerings are what make it a must-visit destination in Southwest Missouri.

UL

• The Honey Sea Salt Pie: A beloved signature item frequently mentioned in local reviews. This pie features a buttermilk base with a distinct honey addition and a flakey crust, creating a uniquely satisfying blend of sweet and salty flavors that is often described as "unmatched."

• Gourmet Savory Pot Pies: Beyond dessert, Prairie Pie is famous for its savory options, particularly the award-winning Chicken Pot Pie and the highly-rated Curry Vegetable Pot Pie. Reviewers praise the creamy fillings, the right balance of spice, and the exceptional all-butter, flaky crusts.

• Handmade, All-Butter Crusts: A cornerstone of the bakery's quality. The crust is consistently described as "buttery, flakey," and a key factor in the superior taste of both the sweet and savory pies.

• Seasonal and Unique Sweet Flavors: The menu features an impressive rotation of flavors that move beyond the classics, including options like Key Lime Pie, Amaretto Chocolate, Earl Grey Cream Pie, Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (in season), and a rich Chocolate Chess Pie, offering customers something new with every visit.

• Diversified Savory Menu: The bakery expands its offerings to include daily-prepared savory meals such as Wood-Fired Starters (like Baked Fontina), a rotating selection of gourmet Pizzas (such as Mushroom Pizza Sauce and Carbonara), Salads, and Subs, providing a full meal solution.

• Commitment to Inclusivity: The establishment is a community leader, proudly creating a safe and welcoming space by being openly LGBTQ+ friendly and providing a Gender-neutral restroom.

Contact Information

To reach Prairie Pie for pre-orders, to inquire about their weekly rotating menu, or for general questions, please use the contact information provided below.

UL

• Address: 621 S Pickwick Ave, Springfield, MO 65802, USA

• Phone: (417) 883-2462 (Note: This is the number for the Tea Bar & Bites location where Prairie Pie is housed)

What is Worth Choosing

For a Missouri local making their first or hundredth visit to Prairie Pie, there are a few must-try items that represent the very best of what this Springfield bakery has to offer.

Begin your journey with the legendary Honey Sea Salt pie. Customers rave about this specific creation for its perfect balance of salty and sweet within a rich, buttermilk custard—it's truly a signature dessert that you won't find anywhere else. For those looking for a classic with a twist, the Apple Pie is prepared with granny smith apples and a generous scoop of made-from-scratch caramel sauce, offering a decadent upgrade to a traditional favorite. For chocolate enthusiasts, the rich, baked Chocolate Chess Pie or the ever-popular, seasonally available Amaretto Chocolate pie is highly recommended.

However, a visit is incomplete without trying one of their savory masterpieces. The Chicken Pot Pie is consistently the most-liked savory item, featuring a creamy velouté sauce, shredded chicken, and fresh vegetables all encased in that famous all-butter, flaky crust. For a delicious vegetarian option, the Curry Vegetable Pot Pie is praised for its "impeccable flavor" and just the "right degree of spice," with a satisfying filling of squash, carrots, and peas in a creamy curry sauce. Whether you enjoy it hot and ready for Dine-in, or grab a Take & Bake family size for a convenient dinner at home, Prairie Pie offers a unique and satisfying culinary experience that makes it a true gem in the heart of the Ozarks.

Prairie Pie

621 S Pickwick Ave, Springfield, MO 65802, USA