R and M Bakery

Introduction / Overview

Nestled in the heart of Newark, Ohio, R and M Bakery stands as a genuine cornerstone of the community and potentially the oldest bakery in Licking County. This cherished, family-run establishment is more than just a place to pick up a morning donut; it’s a destination where tradition meets creativity, and every baked good tells a story of local passion. The bakery, currently led by owners Sam and Kristi White, carries forward a decades-long legacy, having once been known as Hartshorn's, and even housed in a building over a century old that served as a fire station.

R and M Bakery prides itself on offering a vast array of freshly baked goods that cater to both everyday cravings and special occasions. Their diverse selection includes everything from classic cookies and donuts to more unique creations like their signature Pepperoni Rolls. What truly sets them apart, however, is their reputation for custom celebration cakes. Customers consistently praise the quality, beautiful decorations, and surprising affordability of their products—a rarity in today’s specialty market.

The warmth of R and M comes from the people behind the counter. Sam White, the Owner and Master Dough Artisan, and Kristi White, the Owner and Chief Cake Artisan, work tirelessly to maintain the bakery's historical standing while infusing it with their own deep love for the craft and community interaction. Kristi’s talent for cake design is a major draw, creating stunning and personalized centerpiece cakes for all life events. Beyond their retail service, the owners are committed to community engagement, even hosting educational events like 4H cake decorating meetings, fostering a sense of connection and skill-sharing that enhances the local Newark atmosphere.

For any Ohioan looking for authentic, homemade quality, fantastic value, and a friendly, familiar atmosphere, R and M Bakery is a local must-visit. Whether you need a batch of cookies for the family, a stunning birthday cake, or just a quick, delicious treat, this Newark staple delivers on its promise of joy in every bite.

Location and Accessibility

R and M Bakery is centrally located, making it a convenient stop for residents of Newark and visitors to Licking County. The bakery’s address is 369 Mt Vernon Rd, Newark, OH 43055, USA.

The owners have ensured the location is accessible to everyone in the community. Patrons will find wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible parking lot, making visits comfortable and stress-free for all.

Parking options are plentiful and free, which is a major convenience for a quick stop. Customers can utilize the free parking lot adjacent to the bakery or find available free street parking. This ease of access, combined with the bakery's planning for a Quick visit, ensures that you can grab your favorite treats without significant delay, whether you're on your morning commute or running errands in downtown Newark. The bakery also simplifies transactions by accepting all major forms of payment, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Services Offered

R and M Bakery provides a full range of services designed to meet the sweet and savory needs of the Central Ohio community.

• Full-Service Takeout and In-Store Pickup: Customers can walk in for a spontaneous purchase or place advance orders for in-store pickup.
• Custom Cake Design: Led by Chief Cake Artisan Kristi, the bakery specializes in creating stunning custom party cakes for birthdays, anniversaries, and other celebrations, with options ranging from six-inch cakes to multi-tiered wedding cakes.
• Signature Baked Goods: Offering an array of popular items including cookies, donuts, pastries, and their unique, famous Pepperoni Rolls.
• Specialty Dessert Items: The menu includes unique treats such as Buckeyes, Cake Balls, Oreo Balls, Ho Ho Cakes, and Strawberry Donut Sandwiches.
• Community Engagement and Education: The bakery supports local groups by hosting events, such as 4H meetings, to teach valuable skills like cake decorating.
• Pre-Ordering for Events: Customers can easily order treats in bulk, including cupcakes, truffles, and various sweet treats for any size party or gathering.

Features / Highlights

R and M Bakery distinguishes itself through its rich history, dedication to affordability, and the exceptional skill of its owners.

• Local Historical Landmark: Housed in a building that is over a century old and once served as a fire station, carrying forward the tradition of what may be the oldest bakery in Newark and Licking County.
• Exceptional Value: Customers repeatedly highlight the affordable pricing for high-quality, beautifully decorated goods, such as a custom cake and a half-dozen cookies for around $21.
• Custom Cake Artistry: Co-owner Kristi is a Chief Cake Artisan known for impressive decoration skills and attention to detail, consistently leaving customers "really impressed with the colors and decorations" on their cakes.
• Signature Pepperoni Rolls: A unique and highly praised savory item that has become a staple for many regulars.
• Family-Run & Community Focused: The business is run by Sam and Kristi White, who are dedicated to preserving the bakery's legacy and fostering a deep bond with the local Newark community.
• Comprehensive Accessibility: Full commitment to customer convenience with wheelchair accessible entrance and parking, along with free parking options.

Contact Information

To place an order for a custom cake, inquire about the daily menu, or learn more about hosting an event, please use the following contact details.

Address: 369 Mt Vernon Rd, Newark, OH 43055, USA

Phone: (740) 345-3615

Mobile Phone: +1 740-345-3615

What is Worth Choosing

For residents of Newark and the surrounding Licking County area, choosing R and M Bakery means investing in a piece of local history and supporting a dedicated, family-run business. This bakery’s commitment to providing high-quality, delicious baked goods at an exceptional value is its most compelling feature. In a time when custom-made cakes and specialty desserts can often come with a high price tag, R and M consistently delivers beautiful, custom creations—from simple cakes to elaborate tiered designs—that meet or exceed expectations without breaking the bank.

The variety of offerings ensures that every member of the family finds a favorite. While their cakes are legendary, their other items, such as their famous cookies, the highly-praised Oreo Balls, and their unique Pepperoni Rolls, keep customers returning weekly. This diversity of menu, catering to both sweet and savory tastes, sets them apart from single-focus bakeries.

Furthermore, R and M is a true community partner. The owners’ willingness to host educational events, like cake decorating classes for youth, shows a dedication that goes beyond simple commerce. It’s an inviting, friendly atmosphere where staff often know customers by name, turning a simple transaction into a pleasant local tradition.

For any Ohioan planning a party, celebrating a milestone, or just needing a quick, affordable, and delicious pick-me-up, R and M Bakery offers the perfect blend of small-town charm, professional artistry, and unbeatable value. It's a place where they're truly "baking memories," and that is something worth choosing every time.

R and M Bakery

369 Mt Vernon Rd, Newark, OH 43055, USA