Sally's Sweet Shoppe Introduce
Introduction / Overview
For those of us who appreciate the true taste of home-baked goodness, finding a local bakery that delivers on flavor, tradition, and friendly service is like hitting the jackpot. Sally's Sweet Shoppe, located in the charming Genesee Depot area of Wisconsin, is precisely this kind of establishment. It stands out as a genuine, community-focused bakery where the emphasis is firmly placed on quality ingredients and time-honored recipes, not mass production. While many bakeries strive for trendy, modern designs, Sally's Sweet Shoppe is celebrated by local customers for providing what is often described as the "yummy good old fashioned stuff."
This beloved Genesee Depot spot has carved out a loyal following, particularly noted for its ability to deliver on classic confectionary cravings. Imagine craving an old-fashioned style turtle—not the meticulously "pretty shaped and painted designs," but the rich, deeply satisfying treat featuring ample caramel and chocolate atop a bed of pecans or cashews. Customers consistently report that Sally's Sweet Shoppe provides exactly this authentic experience. Beyond these decadent treats, the shoppe offers a vast array of bakery items, ensuring there’s something perfect for every occasion, from a simple afternoon pick-me-up to a major celebration.
The core of Sally's appeal lies in the quality of her creations. Custom orders, like cakes and cupcakes, are frequently praised for being **moist and full of flavor**, making the bakery a trusted source for important events. The process is designed to be easy, allowing customers to simply fill out a form and trust Sally to execute their vision flawlessly. This combination of exceptional product quality, reliable ordering, and the **friendly, sweet people** who run the shop, creates a deeply satisfying and welcoming experience that keeps folks from Genesee Depot and the surrounding Waukesha County area coming back for more. It is truly a Wisconsin local treasure focused on delivering sweetness with a smile.
Location and Accessibility
Sally's Sweet Shoppe is perfectly positioned to serve the greater Waukesha County community, nestled at S42 W31238, WI-83, Genesee Depot, WI 53127, USA. Its location along WI-83 makes it easily accessible for customers driving from nearby towns or even those passing through this beautiful area of Wisconsin. Genesee Depot offers a pleasant, small-town backdrop, enhancing the charm of visiting a local establishment focused on traditional, quality baking.
For the convenience of all local patrons, the bakery has taken steps to ensure ease of access. The shoppe is committed to accessibility, featuring a **wheelchair accessible entrance** and a **wheelchair accessible parking lot**. This ensures that everyone in the Wisconsin community can comfortably stop in and enjoy the wide array of delicious offerings. The straightforward location and attention to accessibility reinforce its status as a welcoming local business. Whether you are coming from work, running errands, or making a dedicated trip for a special order, the Genesee Depot location is set up for a smooth and simple visit.
Services Offered
Sally's Sweet Shoppe provides services centered on convenience and a delightful customer experience, tailored for the local Wisconsin patron:
- In-store Shopping: Patrons can browse the extensive selection of freshly baked goods and make their choices in person.
- Takeout: All items, from a single cookie to large custom cakes, are available for convenient takeout.
- Coffee Service: Fresh coffee is offered to perfectly complement the sweet treats and baked goods.
- Quick Visit Planning: The shoppe is structured to accommodate customers who need to quickly grab a treat or coffee and be on their way.
- Easy Custom Ordering: The process for ordering custom cakes and cupcakes is streamlined, often involving just a simple form submission.
- Flexible Payment Options: Accepts both credit cards and debit cards for hassle-free transactions.
Features / Highlights
The defining qualities of Sally's Sweet Shoppe are what draw customers from all over the region, offering a distinct advantage over commercial alternatives:
- Old-Fashioned Style Confections: A key highlight is the focus on **traditional, homemade quality** like the "old fashioned style turtles," which feature generous caramel, chocolate, and nuts without overly modern, decorative flourishes.
- Exceptional Cake Quality: The custom cakes and cupcakes are consistently reviewed as being **moist and full of flavor**, making them a reliable choice for celebrations.
- Wide Variety of Baked Goods: The offerings extend far beyond custom orders to include delicious brownies, cookies, cinnamon rolls, and cakes of all kinds, ensuring a selection for any craving.
- Friendly and Sweet Staff: The people running the shoppe are noted for being **friendly and sweet**, enhancing the overall welcoming and pleasant customer experience.
- Reliable Custom Order Process: Ordering custom items is described as **overall easy**, building trust and reducing stress for event planning.
- Coffee Availability: Offering coffee alongside the sweets makes it a perfect destination for a complete morning or afternoon break.
Contact Information
For residents of Genesee Depot and the surrounding Wisconsin communities looking to place an order or inquire about their offerings, please use the following contact details:
Address: S42 W31238, WI-83, Genesee Depot, WI 53127, USA
Phone: (262) 968-1803
Mobile Phone: +1 262-968-1803
What is worth choosing
For the Wisconsin resident, choosing Sally's Sweet Shoppe is a choice for quality, tradition, and supporting a truly local business. It's an establishment that understands the value of **flavor over fuss**. What makes it truly worth selecting over other options is its commitment to that deeply satisfying, old-fashioned taste. If you've been craving a treat that tastes exactly like it should—rich, indulgent, and made with care—this is your destination. The highly praised turtles, the **yummy good old fashioned stuff**, are a perfect example of this dedication to classic confectionary excellence that many modern shops overlook.
Beyond the daily treats, the shoppe is an invaluable resource for celebratory occasions. The fact that customers consistently praise the **moistness and flavor** of the cakes and cupcakes, even for major events, speaks volumes about the consistency and quality of Sally's baking. The easy ordering process removes the headache from planning, allowing Wisconsin hosts to simply trust in the expertise provided and focus on enjoying their event. This reliable, simple approach to custom orders is a significant factor in its local reputation.
Finally, the overall customer experience is a major draw. Visitors frequently highlight the warmth and friendliness of the staff—the **sweet people** who make every visit a pleasure. This welcoming, community-oriented atmosphere, combined with the convenience of in-store shopping, quick visit options, and accessible facilities, elevates Sally's Sweet Shoppe from a simple bakery to a treasured local resource. When you choose Sally's, you are choosing authentic, homemade quality delivered with genuinely friendly, small-town Wisconsin service.
Sally's Sweet Shoppe Details
Service options
- In-store shopping
- Takeout
- Delivery
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Coffee
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Sally's Sweet Shoppe Photos










Sally's Sweet Shoppe Location
Sally's Sweet Shoppe
S42 W31238, WI-83, Genesee Depot, WI 53127, USA
Sally's Sweet Shoppe Reviews
cupcakesdessertshamcarrot cakerollssticky bunsmuffinlemon barspeanut butterstrawberry rhubarb
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Sally was great and our cake and cupcakes were perfect. The cake was moist and full of flavor. Overall easy ordering, just filled out a form and she went from there. Thanks again.
September 15 · Kristilynn SmukowskiI have been craving old fashioned style turtles with caramel and chocolate on the bed of pecans or cashews and they had exactly what I was looking for old fashioned style, not those pretty shaped and painted designs but the yummy good old fashioned stuff. They also sell brownies and cookies and cinnamon rolls and cakes of all kinds cupcakes. It's a lot more. Everything is so yummy and they're such friendly, sweet people.
August 15 · Cindy HuberWe had purchased a customized Disney Frozen cake. Was a beautiful cake. My daughters smile that was provided was amazing. The cake flavor itself was pretty bad. Lacked flavor and the cake was dry. No one in my family would eat it. We brought it to other families houses to try it to make sure it wasn't us and they agreed it wasn't good. We ended up throwing the cake away. Appearance was amazing but for the price of the cake and it being well cake, I wouldve expected my kids and other kids to want another piece. Instead they didn't finish one slice.
October 14 · Christopher HuebnerSally’s did our wedding cake, custom father of the bride cake, and cupcakes for our wedding. Sally and her team did an incredible job bringing my ideas and photo inspiration to life. The cakes and cupcakes were accurate, delicious, and exactly what we wanted. She did it all with enthusiasm and a willingness to help. I absolutely recommend using Sally’s Sweet Shoppe for your wedding, even if you have a custom or unique request. You can trust Sally and her team to handle it!! (Photo credit to Meg Boersma, Brilliant Bee Photography)
January 21 · Leah ToroSally’s Sweet Shop did a fantastic job on my Mother in Law’s 90th birthday cake and mini cupcakes. Her favorite cake is carrot cake, it was so beautiful and delicious, there were no leftovers! Sally’s Sweet Shop was easy to work with and definitely high quality cake!
September 17 · Sherrie Bindrim
More Bakery Near Me
The Coffee Talk Bakery4.0 (191 reviews)S52W28809 Saylesville Rd, Waukesha, WI 53189, USA
Little Self-Serve Bakery4.0 (28 reviews)S42W25248 Dale Dr, Waukesha, WI 53189, USA
La Estrella Bakery4.0 (66 reviews)123 W Sunset Dr, Waukesha, WI 53189, USA
Mama Ducky's Desserts5.0 (30 reviews)151 E Sunset Dr, Waukesha, WI 53189, USA
Einstein Bros. Bagels3.0 (301 reviews)180 E Sunset Dr Suite A, Waukesha, WI 53189, USA
Meijer Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)801 E Sunset Dr, Waukesha, WI 53189, USA
Created With Joy, LLC5.0 (2 reviews)S107W29895 Pickering Dr, Mukwonago, WI 53149, USA
Jetaime Pastry5.0 (1 reviews)3115 S Hanke Dr, New Berlin, WI 53146, USA
Coutagge Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)W229S8890 Clark St, Big Bend, WI 53103, USA
Paws & Purrs Pet Bakery4.0 (10 reviews)s75w17317 Janesville Rd, Muskego, WI 53150, USA
Love At First Bite5.0 (14 reviews)S75W16715 Jacob Ct UNIT 29, Muskego, WI 53150, USA
Einstein Bros. Bagels4.0 (412 reviews)17000 W Bluemound Rd Suite A, Brookfield, WI 53005, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Ramona Susan's Bake Shop4.0 (152 reviews)
Zell's Cottage Bakery4.0 (24 reviews)
Pretty Tasty Bakery5.0 (23 reviews)
Krispy Kreme4.0 (3008 reviews)
Burney's Sweets & More4.0 (305 reviews)
knead+nest sourdough microbakery5.0 (6 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
