Sammy’s New York Bagels

In New Rochelle, New York, the reputation of a bagel shop is a serious matter. Sammy’s New York Bagels, located on Centre Avenue, has long been a part of this conversation, serving as a landmark for many in the community. For New Yorkers, a bagel is more than just a baked good; it’s a daily ritual and a benchmark for quality. Sammy’s has built a legacy on offering a variety of breakfast and lunch options that cater to the demanding tastes of Westchester County residents. It's a place that, for years, has been a reliable spot for that authentic New York bagel experience.

The shop operates as a full-service deli, and its menu extends well beyond simple bagels. While the foundation of the business is, of course, the classic bagel, they also offer a wide selection of sandwiches, pastries, and beverages. Their approach to food is centered on providing a hearty, satisfying meal, from a simple bagel with cream cheese to a more elaborate breakfast platter. This broad menu ensures that whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a full meal, you can find what you're looking for.

Over time, the local sentiment around Sammy's has become a mix of strong loyalty and more recent disappointment. Long-time customers express a sense of nostalgia for a time when the bagels were "loaded up" with cream cheese and the value felt consistently high. These patrons are grappling with what they perceive as recent changes, noting that the portions have seemingly shrunk while prices have increased. One review from a customer who has been coming for years laments, "We barely got a smear" of cream cheese and questions if there might be a new owner. This reflects the deep connection locals have with their neighborhood spots and the impact of even small changes on their routine.

For new customers, the experience can also be a mixed bag. One new resident shared a frustrating experience regarding pricing transparency, particularly with a bagel and butter order. They felt "shocked" to be charged a total of $4.00 for what they expected to be a much lower price. The review pointed out a discrepancy between the posted bagel price and the unlisted, high cost of butter, leading to a sense of being "ripped off." This customer's frustration highlights the importance of clear pricing, especially for a staple item like a bagel. On the other hand, the reviews also consistently acknowledge that the quality of the bagels themselves remains very good, which is a crucial factor in the shop's enduring appeal. Even those who feel "ripped off" admit that the bagels are still delicious, a testament to the core product's strength.

Despite these critiques, Sammy's continues to be a central part of the New Rochelle community. The fact that customers are so passionate about the changes—both good and bad—shows how much the place matters to them. It's a place where tradition and loyalty are highly valued, and where the perfect bagel is a non-negotiable. For many, it remains the go-to spot, and the conversations about it are a clear sign that it's a fixture in the neighborhood's dining scene.

Sammy’s New York Bagels is located at 110 Centre Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10805, USA. This location places it in a convenient and easily accessible part of New Rochelle. Its presence on Centre Avenue makes it a simple stop for many who live or work in the area, or those passing through Westchester County.

For customers traveling by car, there is street parking available, though it may be busy during peak hours. The shop's location makes it a practical choice for a quick breakfast pickup on the way to work. As a part of the vibrant New Rochelle community, it is a well-known spot that is easily integrated into the daily routines of many local residents.

• Freshly Baked Bagels: A large variety of classic and specialty bagels, baked fresh daily.
• Breakfast Sandwiches: An extensive menu of egg sandwiches and other breakfast platters made to order.
• Gourmet Cream Cheeses: A selection of delicious cream cheese spreads, including plain, vegetable, and lox spread.
• Deli & Lunch Items: The shop also functions as a full deli, offering lunch sandwiches, wraps, and salads.
• Coffee and Beverages: A full range of hot and iced coffee, as well as other drinks, to pair with your meal.
• Takeaway and Delivery: The shop provides options for in-store pickup and also partners with third-party delivery services for customer convenience.

• Authentic New York Bagels: The core product is a true New York-style bagel, known for its specific texture and taste.
• Community Landmark: Sammy's is a well-established and well-known part of the New Rochelle community, with a long history of serving local residents.
• Broad Menu: The menu offers a wide variety of choices, from simple bagels to full breakfast platters and deli sandwiches, catering to all types of hunger.
• Convenient Location: Its location in a central part of New Rochelle makes it an easy stop for a quick meal.

Address: 110 Centre Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10805, USA

Phone: (914) 235-7800

For residents of New Rochelle, Sammy’s New York Bagels is a deeply ingrained part of the community. Its reputation, built over many years, continues to make it a go-to spot for those seeking a true taste of a New York bagel. While recent customer feedback points to some frustrations with pricing and portions, the underlying quality of the bagel itself is consistently praised, which is the most important factor for any New Yorker. This blend of tradition and deliciousness keeps the community coming back, even as they voice their concerns.

Ultimately, Sammy's is a place where you can find an authentic New York bagel without having to leave the neighborhood. It's a spot that has served countless breakfasts and lunches, and its place in the community is secure. For locals, it represents both the comfort of the familiar and the high standards they hold for their food, making it an essential destination for a satisfying meal in New Rochelle.

Sammy’s New York Bagels

110 Centre Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10805, USA