Scuteri's Cannoli Connection

For New Yorkers seeking a genuine taste of traditional Italian baking and a truly satisfying pizza experience, look no further than Scuteri's Cannoli Connection. Nestled in the charming village of Watkins Glen, this local gem has been delighting customers since 1971, earning a reputation not only for its namesake cannoli but also for its surprisingly exceptional pizza. It's the kind of establishment where you feel the warmth of a family operation in every bite, making it a beloved staple for those in the Finger Lakes region and a worthy destination for anyone craving authentic Italian treats.

Scuteri's Cannoli Connection isn't just another bakery; it's a testament to time-honored recipes and a dedication to quality that has spanned decades. While their cannoli are legendary, often cited as among the best in the area, the word has spread about their pizza, which many consider a hidden culinary treasure. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, a visit to Scuteri's offers a comforting and delicious experience that embodies the spirit of local, family-run businesses.

Beyond the delectable offerings, the inviting atmosphere and the friendly, helpful staff contribute to a memorable visit. Customers consistently rave about the genuine care and "family love" that goes into preparing each item, creating a sense of community and connection that goes beyond just a transaction.

Scuteri's Cannoli Connection is conveniently located at 409 E 4th St, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA. Watkins Glen itself is a picturesque village situated at the southern tip of Seneca Lake in the Finger Lakes region of New York. This makes Scuteri's an ideal stop for those exploring the natural beauty and attractions of the area, including the Watkins Glen State Park and the nearby Seneca Lake Wine Trail.

Accessibility is straightforward for both local residents and visitors driving through the region. The bakery is situated on a main street, making it easy to find with ample parking typically available nearby. For those living in the wider New York region, Watkins Glen is a scenic drive, and many make the journey specifically to enjoy the local charm and, of course, the delights of Scuteri's. While public transportation options within Watkins Glen itself may be limited, the bakery's location makes it a readily accessible spot by car for anyone navigating the upstate area.

• Freshly Filled Cannoli: The cornerstone of their reputation, Scuteri's cannoli are filled fresh with their secret recipe creamy ricotta cheese mixture, often featuring mini chocolate chips. They offer various sizes, including small and the famous "Original" large cannoli, as well as chocolate-dipped options.

• Traditional Italian Pastries: Beyond cannoli, they offer a tempting array of Italian baked goods. This includes tiramisu, rum cakes, Italian cookies (such as assorted fancy butter-style cookies and pignoli nut cookies), pizzelles (thin crisp waffle cookies), sfogliatelle (also known as Angel Wings), and lobster tails (an empty sfogliatelle pastry shell filled fresh with cannoli cream).

• Piping Hot Pizza: While primarily known as a bakery, Scuteri's is highly praised for its traditional, New York-style pizza. Customers consistently highlight the perfect balance of marvelous dough, classic sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. It is important to note that pizza availability can sometimes be limited, with many reviews suggesting calling ahead to confirm "pizza day" to avoid disappointment, as it is often sold by the whole pie on specific days like Fridays and Saturdays.

• Specialty Cakes: They create custom cakes for various occasions, including cannoli cakes (vanilla or chocolate cake with cannoli cream between layers, topped with buttercream and crumbled shells) and Italian rum cakes. Pre-ordering is often recommended for these specialty items to ensure availability and customization.

• Catering for Events: Scuteri's accommodates orders of all sizes, from a few treats to large quantities for weddings, anniversaries, birthdays, or other special events. Their capability to handle larger orders makes them a great choice for event planners or those hosting gatherings.

• Legendary Cannoli: The main draw for many, their cannoli are consistently lauded for their fresh filling, crispy shells, and authentic taste, making them a must-try for any pastry enthusiast.

• Exceptional, Traditional Pizza: Despite being a bakery, their pizza stands out. It's often described as a true, old-school pizza with a perfect crust, flavorful sauce, and excellent cheese, reminiscent of classic New York pizzerias.

• Family-Owned and Operated: Since 1971, Scuteri's has been run by a local family, and this familial touch is evident in the quality of their products and their customer service. Many reviewers highlight the warm and welcoming atmosphere provided by the family members who are always there to help.

• Generous "Family Love" in Every Pie: Customers frequently mention the care and passion infused into the food, particularly the pizza, which contributes to its unique and appealing flavor.

• Hidden Gem for Pizza Lovers: For those in the know, Scuteri's is a go-to spot for pizza, often surprising first-time visitors who come primarily for the cannoli but leave equally impressed by the savory offerings.

• Pre-ordering for Convenience: The bakery encourages customers to call ahead, especially for larger orders or to confirm pizza availability, ensuring a smooth and satisfying experience.

Address: 409 E 4th St, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA

Phone: (607) 535-7568

Mobile Phone: +1 607-535-7568

For New Yorkers, especially those residing in or frequently visiting the Finger Lakes region, Scuteri's Cannoli Connection is more than just a place to grab a bite; it's a community institution that offers a genuine slice of Italian-American culinary tradition. Its suitability for locals stems from several key aspects. Firstly, it provides a consistent, high-quality product, from its renowned cannoli to its highly-praised traditional pizza, which rivals many dedicated pizzerias. This reliability makes it a trusted go-to for family treats, special occasions, or simply a satisfying meal.

Secondly, the family-owned and operated nature of Scuteri's fosters a sense of local pride and community connection. Customers appreciate the personal touch and the evident passion that goes into every item, making them feel like a part of the Scuteri's family. This local charm and dedication to craft are qualities highly valued by residents who seek authentic, independent businesses rather than chain establishments.

Moreover, its dual appeal – excelling in both sweet Italian pastries and savory pizza – means it caters to a wide range of cravings, making it a versatile choice for different occasions. Whether you're looking for a celebratory cake, a quick dessert, or a hearty pizza dinner, Scuteri's delivers. The emphasis on calling ahead for pizza is a small but important detail that locals quickly learn and appreciate, as it ensures they don't miss out on their favorite "pizza day."

In essence, Scuteri's Cannoli Connection is a cornerstone of the Watkins Glen food scene, offering not just delicious food but also a warm, familiar experience. It’s a place where quality, tradition, and community intertwine, making it an indispensable part of the local culinary landscape and a cherished destination for New Yorkers seeking authentic flavors and a friendly welcome.

Scuteri's Cannoli Connection

409 E 4th St, Watkins Glen, NY 14891, USA