Strathmore Bagels

For many New Yorkers, the bagel isn't just a food item; it's a cultural icon, a breakfast ritual, and often, the perfect canvas for a satisfying meal. On Long Island, amidst the vibrant communities of Suffolk County, Strathmore Bagels in Selden has carved out its own niche, aiming to provide that quintessential New York bagel experience. This local establishment is known for its extensive menu, offering everything from classic bagels with a schmear to hearty breakfast and lunch options, catering to the diverse tastes of the community.

Strathmore Bagels has been a consistent presence in the Selden area since opening in March of 2003, owned and operated by Chris and Diane Williams. Upon entering, customers are often greeted by the inviting aroma of freshly baked goods and 100% Colombian coffee, creating a warm and friendly atmosphere. While opinions on specific items, such as home fries, can vary, the overall consensus from many patrons points to a place that strives to serve "delicious bagels to fit your lifestyle." It’s a spot that many Long Islanders turn to for their daily fix, whether it's a quick grab-and-go or a more substantial meal to start the day.

Strathmore Bagels is conveniently located at 351 Independence Plaza, Selden, NY 11784, USA. This placement within a shopping plaza is highly advantageous for local customers on Long Island, offering ample parking and easy access by car. Independence Plaza is a well-known commercial hub in Selden, making the bagel shop a readily discoverable destination for residents and those passing through the area. Being in a suburban setting like Selden, accessibility is typically straightforward, without the dense traffic or parking challenges often found in more urban parts of New York. Its presence within a larger plaza often means it's a convenient stop during a shopping trip or daily errands, integrating seamlessly into the lives of busy New Yorkers.

• Freshly Baked Bagels: Strathmore Bagels offers a wide assortment of bagels, including classic options like plain, sesame, poppy, everything, garlic, onion, salt, cinnamon raisin, egg, pumpernickel, and whole wheat. Customers often describe them as fresh and soft.

• Extensive Cream Cheese Selection: To accompany their bagels, they provide a variety of cream cheese flavors, including plain, scallion, vegetable, strawberry, lox spread, cinnamon raisin walnut, green olive, and vanilla raisin walnut cream cheese. Low-fat cream cheese options are also available.

• Breakfast Sandwiches: A popular offering includes a wide range of egg sandwiches, available on bagels, rolls, or even as larger "Hungry Man" heroes. These can be customized with various meats (bacon, sausage, ham) and cheeses. All egg sandwiches typically come with home fries.

• Gourmet Sandwiches and Wraps: For lunch, Strathmore Bagels offers a broad menu of Boar's Head cold cut sandwiches, homemade salads (tuna, egg, chicken salad, whitefish, baked salmon salad), paninis, and wraps. Options include unique gourmet creations like the "Italian Stallion," "Cordon Blue," and "Greek Tycoon." Gourmet sandwiches often come with small coleslaw and a pickle.

• Coffee and Beverages: They serve 100% Colombian coffee, alongside a variety of hot and cold beverages, including iced tea, juices, and bottled sodas.

• Other Baked Goods: Beyond bagels, the bakery also provides a selection of muffins, cookies (including black and white, and rainbow cookies), and other pastries.

• Catering Services: Strathmore Bagels offers catering for parties and office functions, with platters of mini bagel sandwiches, deli sandwiches, wraps, salads, and more, suitable for various events. This includes options for full breakfast setups with eggs, home fries, and choice of meats.

• Online Ordering and Delivery: For customer convenience, Strathmore Bagels often partners with third-party delivery services like DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub, allowing for easy online ordering and delivery.

• Wide Menu Variety: Strathmore Bagels stands out for its extensive menu, offering a comprehensive selection of bagels, spreads, breakfast sandwiches, deli items, and other baked goods, catering to a wide range of preferences and meal times.

• Fresh Bagels: Many customers praise the bagels for being fresh, soft, and warm, providing an authentic Long Island bagel experience.

• Community Presence: As a long-standing establishment (opened in 2003), Strathmore Bagels has become a fixture in the Selden community, serving multiple generations of customers and often supporting local families.

• Convenient Location: Its prime spot in Independence Plaza in Selden provides easy access and ample parking, making it a practical choice for daily visits.

• Dedicated Staff: While specific individuals are not named in provided reviews, the business website emphasizes their "dedicated and friendly staff" who are "always ready to meet your needs." Some customer experiences point to positive interactions and quick service.

• Catering for Events: The availability of comprehensive catering services makes it a valuable resource for local parties, family gatherings, and office events.

• Gluten-Free Options: Although not explicitly detailed in the provided snippet, other Strathmore Bagels locations and their general brand presence suggest a commitment to accommodating dietary needs, often including gluten-free bagels and low-fat cream cheese.

• Value for Money (Mixed): While some isolated reviews mention high prices, others find the overall cost reasonable, especially when considering the included items like home fries with egg sandwiches, indicating perceived good value for many.

Address: 351 Independence Plaza, Selden, NY 11784, USA

Phone: (631) 736-7255

Mobile Phone: +1 631-736-7255

For New Yorkers, particularly those residing in Selden and the surrounding Long Island communities, Strathmore Bagels serves as a suitable and reliable local institution. Its long-standing presence since 2003, coupled with its commitment to a broad menu, makes it a convenient and versatile choice for daily breakfast, lunch, and catering needs. Locals appreciate the accessibility of its location within Independence Plaza, making it easy to pop in for a quick bite or a larger order.

While individual experiences with specific items like home fries may vary, the overall positive sentiment regarding the freshness of the bagels and the convenience of their extensive menu, including a wide array of cream cheeses, egg sandwiches, and deli options, solidifies its appeal. Strathmore Bagels positions itself as a "community-based store" that services "almost four generations of people," indicating a deep integration into the local fabric. For a consistent supply of classic New York-style bagels and a comprehensive menu to suit various cravings, Strathmore Bagels remains a go-to spot for many Long Islanders. It offers the speed and variety needed for busy schedules, alongside the familiarity of a neighborhood favorite.

Strathmore Bagels

351 Independence Plaza, Selden, NY 11784, USA