Stuff by SJ Introduce
For New Jersey residents seeking a truly unique and memorable centerpiece for their celebrations, Stuff by SJ in Montclair stands as a beacon of culinary artistry and personalized service. This isn't your average bakery; it's a dedicated studio specializing in custom-designed cakes, cupcakes, and treats that are as visually stunning as they are incredibly delicious. What began as a virtual bakeshop, creating personalized goods and chocolate delights, has blossomed into a beloved brick-and-mortar location, a testament to the overwhelming support and high demand from the community.
Stuff by SJ, a proud woman-owned small business, operates with a clear mission: to provide homemade, artisan baked goods specifically designed for each client. Their philosophy revolves around crafting unique creations from scratch, using only the highest quality ingredients. This commitment ensures that every cake, cupcake, or treat not only looks spectacular but also delivers a fresh, balanced flavor that is never overly sweet. Whether it’s a whimsical birthday cake that perfectly captures a child’s favorite movie or an elegant design for a significant milestone, Stuff by SJ aims to exceed expectations.
The team at Stuff by SJ, including the highly praised Drew and Sarah (SJ herself), is known for their detail-oriented approach and exceptional customer service. They work closely with clients through creative consultations, ensuring that every specific detail, from design to dietary accommodations, is meticulously handled. For those in Montclair and the surrounding Northern New Jersey area, Stuff by SJ offers more than just baked goods; they offer a delightful and stress-free experience in bringing your sweetest visions to life.
Location and Accessibility
Stuff by SJ is conveniently located at 342 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA. Bloomfield Avenue is a prominent and bustling street in Montclair, making the bakery easily identifiable and accessible for residents throughout this vibrant New Jersey town and its surrounding communities.
Situated in the heart of Montclair, the bakery benefits from a central location that is well-connected. While Montclair is known for its walkable areas, Bloomfield Avenue is a main artery, making it straightforward to reach by car. For those driving, Montclair offers various parking options, including street parking and municipal lots, though availability can fluctuate depending on the time of day. The accessibility of Stuff by SJ ensures that picking up your custom cake or stopping by for a treat is a convenient and straightforward process for local patrons.
Services Offered
Custom Cakes for All Events: Stuff by SJ specializes in creating bespoke cakes for a wide array of occasions, including birthdays, weddings, corporate events, and unique celebrations. They are known for mimicking inspiration pictures perfectly and crafting themed cakes that capture the spirit of any event.
Wedding Cakes: They offer dedicated services for wedding cakes, including consultations and tastings, ensuring that the centerpiece of your special day is as perfect as imagined. They are equipped to create vintage-style wedding cakes and accommodate various needs.
Custom Cupcakes & Treats: Beyond cakes, they provide customized cupcakes, chocolate treats, cake cups, French macarons, crumb cakes, and other delicious baked goods. These can be personalized to match event themes or dietary preferences.
Dietary Accommodations: Stuff by SJ is highly regarded for offering various dietary options, including gluten-free and dairy-free cakes and desserts, ensuring that guests with specific dietary needs can enjoy their treats without concern. They also offer nut-free, sugar-free, vegan, and vegetarian options.
Creative Consultations: They provide a high-level experience that includes creative consultations to discuss design, flavors, and all specific details for custom orders, ensuring the client's vision is brought to life.
Dessert Installations & Setup: For larger events, Stuff by SJ offers services like dessert installations and setup, ensuring their beautiful creations are perfectly presented at your venue.
Baking Events & Classes: The bakery hosts unique cake decorating events, such as "Cake & Sip" and "Kids Night," and summer camps, allowing customers to participate in the baking and decorating process.
Free Local Delivery: Stuff by SJ offers free delivery for orders, providing added convenience for customers in Essex County and Northern NJ.
Features / Highlights
Incredible Customization & Design Accuracy: Customers consistently praise Stuff by SJ's ability to perfectly mimic inspiration pictures and capture specific themes. Whether it's a complex character design like Madagascar 3 or a specific tequila bottle shape, their artistic execution is top-notch.
Delicious & Perfectly Balanced Flavors: A common highlight is that their cakes and treats are "fresh and delicious and not overly sweet." This balance of flavor ensures that the desserts are enjoyable and satisfying without being cloying.
Exceptional Customer Service & Communication: The team, particularly Drew and Sarah (SJ), receives high praise for being "quick, detail-oriented," providing "helpful recommendations," and being "TERRIFIC" in confirming details and working with clients. This personalized and attentive service is a major differentiator.
Accommodating Dietary Needs: Their extensive range of dietary accommodations, including renowned gluten-free and dairy-free options that still taste great, makes them a crucial resource for many New Jersey families and event planners. They also offer nut-free, sugar-free, vegan, and vegetarian options.
Fast Turnaround for Custom Orders (when feasible): While general recommendation is two weeks advance notice for custom orders, one review highlights an impressive fast turnaround time (Saturday order for Wednesday AM pickup), demonstrating flexibility when possible.
Homemade & From-Scratch Quality: All cakes, icings, and fillings are made from scratch using high-quality ingredients, contributing to the superior taste and texture of their products.
Woman-Owned Small Business: This highlights their local roots and commitment to the community, appealing to customers who wish to support local entrepreneurs.
Contact Information
To inquire about custom orders, discuss your next celebration cake, or learn more about their offerings, you can contact Stuff by SJ directly:
Address: 342 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Phone: (973) 771-6907
Mobile Phone: +1 973-771-6907
Email: info@stuffbysj.com (for custom order inquiries)
Conclusion: Why This Place Is Suitable for Locals
Stuff by SJ is exceptionally suitable for New Jersey locals, particularly those in the Montclair area, due to its specialized services, unparalleled quality, and deep commitment to customer satisfaction and community needs. It stands out as a top-tier option for anyone seeking bespoke baked goods that elevate special occasions.
Firstly, for New Jersey residents, the ability to obtain a truly custom-designed cake or treat that perfectly matches an inspiration picture or a unique theme is a huge advantage. Whether it's a beloved cartoon character for a child's birthday or an intricate design for a corporate event, Stuff by SJ consistently delivers edible art that becomes the highlight of any party. This level of personalized service is invaluable when celebrating significant milestones.
Secondly, the bakery's dedication to accommodating various dietary needs is a major benefit for the diverse population of New Jersey. Offering delicious gluten-free, dairy-free, nut-free, sugar-free, vegan, and vegetarian options ensures that no one is left out of the celebration. This inclusivity provides peace of mind for hosts and ensures all guests can enjoy the delectable offerings safely and happily.
Moreover, the exceptional customer service provided by the team, including detailed consultations and reliable communication, fosters trust and a positive experience. Locals appreciate businesses that are responsive, attentive, and genuinely invested in making their event special. The fact that all products are made from scratch using high-quality ingredients ensures a fresh, balanced, and superior taste that resonates with those who appreciate authentic baking.
Finally, as a woman-owned small business deeply rooted in Montclair, Stuff by SJ contributes to the local economy and community fabric. Their engagement through baking classes and events further connects them with residents, making them more than just a vendor, but a true community partner. For New Jerseyans who value unique, high-quality, and reliable custom baked goods from a friendly local establishment, Stuff by SJ is an undisputed gem.
Stuff by SJ Food & drink
Frozen Drinks & Beverages
- Milkshake US$8.25
Classic ice cream drink made to order
- Soda US$2.25
12 oz can
- Poland Spring Water US$2.25
16.9 oz bottle
Handmade Chocolates
- Chocolate Dipped Pretzel Rods US$4.00
Pack of 2 pretzel rods dipped by hand in premium white or milk chocolate with a drizzle & premium sprinkles. (colors, designs and decorations may vary)
- Chocolate Dipped Oreos US$4.00
Oreo cookie dipped by hand in premium white or milk chocolate with a drizzle & premium sprinkles. (colors, designs and decorations may vary)
Bake Shop
- SJ's Monthly Cake Slice (Vanilla Pride Cake) US$8.95
Each month SJ bakes up a special, unique creation available for a limited time only. For the month of June, we celebrate love & inclusivity for Pride Month with a homemade, from-scratch vanilla cake filled with homemade rainbow Swiss buttercream and covered with rainbow sprinkles.
- Raspberry Crumb Cake US$7.50
Cake with sweet crumb topping, raspberry filling & sweet icing glaze.
- Strawberry Cake Cup US$10.50
Vanilla cake crumb with homemade strawberry compote and sweet, whipped cream.
- Carrot Cake Cup US$10.50
Homemade carrot cake crumb with cream cheese icing & sweet, whipped cream
- Chocolate Cake Slice US$5.75
Chocolate cake with homemade chocolate buttercream.
- SJ's Monthly Cake Slice (Chocolate Pride) US$8.95
Each month SJ bakes up a special, unique creation available for a limited time only. For the month of June, we celebrate love & inclusivity for Pride Month with a homemade, from-scratch chocolate cake filled with homemade rainbow Swiss buttercream and covered with rainbow sprinkles.
- Cheesecake Slice US$8.75
New York style cheesecake.
- French Macarons US$16.25
A sweet meringue-based confection in assorted flavors. Pack of 6.
- Key Lime Pie Slice US$6.75
Graham cracker crust with key lime filling.
- Vanilla, Chocolate Or Red Velvet Cake Cups US$9.00
Your choice of cake crumb with homemade sweet, whipped cream.
- SJ's Original Cookies & Cream Cake Slice US$7.95
Chocolate and vanilla cake layers with SJ's cookies and cream filling.
- Celebration Cakes US$42.00
Whole six inch round, two layer cakes, iced and finished with premium sprinkles. Homemade, from scratch. Available in multiple flavors. (Colors & designs may vary)
- SJ's Homemade Triple Chocolate Brownie US$5.25
Classic square cut chocolate fudge brownie with chocolate drizzle & sprinkles. (seasonal decorations & design may vary)
- Lemon Strawberry Cake Slice US$8.95
Homemade from-scratch lemon cake filled and finished with strawberry Swiss buttercream.
- Tiramisu US$8.75
Italian multi-layer dessert with mascarpone, coffee and lady fingers.
- SJ's Monthly Cake Slice (Vanilla Choc Chip Cake) US$8.95
Each month SJ bakes up a special, unique creation available for a limited time only. For the month of April, it's a homemade, from-scratch vanilla chocolate chip cake filled and finished with chocolate Swiss buttercream & garnished with semi-sweet chocolate chips and mini chocolate chip cookies.
- Red Velvet Cake Slice US$5.75
Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting.
- Sj's Cookies & Cream Cup US$10.50
Chocolate and vanilla cake crumb with sj's cookies and cream filling.
- Crumb Cake US$7.50
Cake with sweet crumb topping
Cupcakes
- Classic Cupcake US$5.00
Vanilla or chocolate cupcake with swiss merengue buttercream and premium sprinkles. Colors & designs vary daily.
- Tres Leches Cupcake US$5.00
Light, airy cupcake filled with 3 decadent and creamy milks, topped with fluffy homemade whipped cream and a fresh strawberry.
- Oreo Cupcake US$5.00
Chocolate or Vanilla cupcake with homemade cookies & cream icing, topped with Oreo crumble & cookie.
- PB & J US$5.00
Vanilla cupcake with homemade peanut buttercream frosting filled and topped with all natural grape jelly.
- Chocolate Peanut Buttery Cupcake US$5.00
Chocolate cupcake filled with homemade peanut butter frosting and topped with crumbled peanut butter cups.
- Sj's Campfire S'mores Cupcake US$5.00
Vanilla or Chocolate cupcake with chocolate frosting, toasted marshmallow, chocolate drizzle & graham cracker.
- Mixed Berry Cupcake US$5.00
Vanilla cupcake filled with mixed berry compote and topped with swiss merengue buttercream and a fresh berry.
- Apple Pie Cupcake US$4.25
Spice cupcake filled with homemade apple pie filling, topped with cream cheese icing & a caramel drizzle.
- Dulce De Leche Cupcake US$5.00
Chocolate or Vanilla cupcake filled with dulce de leche & topped with chocolate buttercream & a dulce de leche drizzle.
- 6 Pack Cupcakes (Mix & Match How You Like) US$30.00
6 Premium Cupcakes - any combination of cupcakes from the cupcake menu. (design & decoration may vary)
- Cinnamon Spice Cupcake US$4.25
Spice cupcake with cream cheese frosting dusted with cinnamon.
- Very Fun(Fetti) Cupcake US$5.00
Funfetti cupcake with rainbow swiss merengue buttercream & rainbow sprinkles.
Coffee Shop
- Iced Americano US$4.50
Two shots of espresso and cold water with ice.
- Cappuccino US$6.00
Double shot espresso with steamed milk and foam.
- Iced Latte US$4.25
Double shot espresso with steamed milk and small amount of foam over ice.
- Hot Coffee US$3.50
Freshly brewed.
- Macchiato US$6.00
Double shot espresso with small amount of steamed milk and foam.
- Latte US$5.00
Double shot espresso with steamed milk and small amount of foam.
- Iced Coffee US$4.50
Freshly brewed.
- Iced Cappuccino US$4.25
Double shot espresso with steamed milk and foam over ice.
- Iced Red Eye US$5.00
Two shots of espresso and cold coffee with ice.
- Americano US$3.75
Two shots of espresso and hot water.
- Espresso US$2.75
Finely ground coffee brewed under pressure.
- Iced Macchiato US$4.25
Double shot espresso with small amount of steamed milk and foam over ice.
- Red Eye US$4.75
Two shots of espresso and hot coffee.
Stuff by SJ Details
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- In-store shopping
- On-site services
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
Amenities
- Gender-neutral toilets
- Toilet
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safe space
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Stuff by SJ Photos










Stuff by SJ Location
Stuff by SJ
342 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Stuff by SJ Reviews
cupcakespartydesignsweetsonfillingdeliveryideasicingvanilla
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I had a great experience with "Stuff by SJ" ordering a custom cake for my client's moving away party. I spoke with Drew on a Saturday for a following Wednesday AM pickup - so the turnaround time was very fast. Drew was quick, detail oriented, and walked me through some helpful recommendations. The cake itself was incredible. Everything was fresh and delicious and not overly sweet. It was also perfectly designed to mimic the inspo pic I shared. Definitely recommend SJ & Drew for your custom cake needs!
May 08 · Meg EremitaOur son absolutely loves Madagascar 3, and it was such a challenge to find a cake that truly captured the spirit of the movie. This cake exceeded all expectations—it looked incredible and tasted even better! Everyone at the party raved about it. I couldn’t have asked for a more perfect representation of the movie. It was a huge hit!
April 19 · Andrea De SilvaStuff by SJ hosted a “Nailed It!” style competition for a birthday, and it was an absolute BLAST. SJ, Drew, and their staff were such excellent hosts, guiding our group through the process while providing enough leeway for everyone to be creative. I totally recommend this place if you’re looking for a unique event idea. Their Nailed It party package came in at such a good price for all that you get, and everyone left raving about how much fun the party was.
January 28 · Hamza QThe flavor of the cakes is amazing. It is perfectly sweet but not too sweet. The cake ordered was a yellow cake with chocolate mousse filling. It was so delicious. Even my family members that do not like cake tried it and said it was delicious. This is a family owned bakery and they are very kind! I can’t wait to try their Valentine’s Day menu. They are also one of the few places that make Blue velvet cake! I will be doing business with them again🎂🍰 🧁!!
January 26 · Vanessa HI ordered a custom cake a week in advance for my sister’s 21st. I asked for a specific design that included these critters from a movie she really likes. Every other detail about the flavor and decoration was met successfully, and I am extremely happy about the results. I planned to feed four people total, we ended up with an extra person and still we had only eaten into 1/4th of the cake, a 6 inch was plenty. This was my first time trying Stuff by SJ, and they will definitely see me in the future for more birthdays and events :) Definitely worth checking out!
October 17 · Samantha M
More Bakery Near Me
Tous Les Jours Montclair4.0 (62 reviews)520 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
PreciseLee Baked5.0 (4 reviews)3 Hollywood Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA
Gencarelli's Bakery4.0 (1458 reviews)446 Broad St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Bloomfield Best Bagels4.0 (625 reviews)404 Broad St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Cambridge Bagel Factory Inc3.0 (134 reviews)648 Bloomfield Ave, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
The Pie Store4.0 (386 reviews)100 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043, USA
Sweet Bliss By Liss0.0 (0 reviews)5 Sunset Ave, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Rombiolo Bakery Cafe4.0 (560 reviews)119 Broughton Ave, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Hot Bagels - N - More4.0 (103 reviews)287 Pompton Ave, Verona, NJ 07044, USA
HerSweetVision0.0 (0 reviews)11 Maolis Ave, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Team Dadzie Patisserie4.0 (96 reviews)162 Glenwood Ave, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Jed's Bread Craft Bakery4.0 (19 reviews)72 Morse Ave, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Auntie Anne's2.0 (30 reviews)
Krispy Kreme4.0 (2238 reviews)
Red Ribbon Bakeshop4.0 (127 reviews)
Padokka Bakehouse4.0 (369 reviews)
Colossus Cookies3.0 (10 reviews)
Panadería y Pastelería Mi Ranchito4.0 (12 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create Homemade Chocolate Croissants: A Step-by-Step Guide
5 Delicious Ways to Use Leftover Bread for Baking at Home
How to Create the Perfect Cinnamon Rolls at Home
How to Make Perfect Strawberry Jam for Baking – A Step-by-Step Guide
How to Make the Best Chocolate Dipped Biscotti
How to Make Bakery-Style Croissants with Puff Pastry: A Step-by-Step Guide
