Sugar and Whisk

Introduction / Overview

For anyone in Wisconsin seeking an indulgent, handcrafted sweet treat, Sugar and Whisk represents a premium local option right in Columbus, WI. This dedicated bakery specializes in transforming classic desserts into gourmet, high-quality creations, ensuring every bite is a delightful experience. They are committed to crafting delicious cookies, cakes, cupcakes, and other sweet items made with evident care and using top-tier ingredients.

Sugar and Whisk is known for bringing a perfect balance of homemade warmth and professional bakery-style indulgence to the local market. They have established a reputation for creativity, offering signature items that go beyond the everyday pastry case. Customers can look forward to unique flavor combinations and decadent recipes that cater to sophisticated palates and special occasions. This focus on artisanal, handcrafted quality distinguishes them as a premier choice for celebration desserts and everyday indulgence in the Central Wisconsin area.

While operating from a base that emphasizes personalized service and custom orders, the bakery ensures a wide variety of treats are available, often focusing on larger, chunky, and richly flavored cookies, along with unique specialties like their popular Banana Pudding. They are structured to accommodate both personal cravings and large orders for events, making them a versatile and reliable partner for any Wisconsin celebration, from a small gathering to an elaborate wedding. The quality is consistent, the flavors are bold, and the dedication to satisfying your sweet cravings is clear in every handcrafted item they produce.

***

Location and Accessibility

Sugar and Whisk is conveniently located at 550 S Birdsey St in Columbus, WI 53925, USA. This location makes it a central point for residents in Columbus and the surrounding communities in Columbia County to easily access their exceptional baked goods. As a local business deeply rooted in the area, its positioning is ideal for customers planning to pick up custom orders or check on the availability of daily treats.

Though information suggests the business operates largely on a pre-order or scheduled basis, the commitment to accessibility is evident:

• Wheelchair accessible parking lot: The provision of accessible parking ensures that all customers, regardless of mobility needs, can easily and conveniently access the business premises for pickup.

Customers are encouraged to contact the bakery via phone or online to confirm service options and arrange convenient pick-up times, ensuring a smooth and personalized transaction process at their Columbus location.

***

Services Offered

Sugar and Whisk specializes in a tailored approach to sweet treats, focusing heavily on custom orders and high-quality individual products.

• Custom Cake and Wedding Cake Creation: Expertly crafting elegant and custom-designed cakes for all major life events, including weddings, with premium flavors like Lavender & Raspberry, Pink Champagne & Strawberries, and White Chocolate & Blackberry.
• Gourmet Cookie Production: Offering large, handcrafted, chunky cookies in unique and popular flavors, such as the Ferrero Dream Cookie and the Brookie Chunky Cookie (a blend of brownie and cookie).
• Specialty Dessert Boxes: Providing pre-packaged assortments like the Banana Pudding Quartet Box and boxes of mixed cupcakes, perfect for gifting or small gatherings.
• Individual Sweet Treats: Baking a variety of smaller items for personal indulgence, including Redvelvet Cookies, Cupcakes, and Mini Velvet Noir Cakes.
• Unique Dessert Focus: Featuring specialty items that are highly popular, such as their Medium Banana Pudding, made with the same dedication as their custom creations.
• Takeout/Scheduled Pickup: Operates primarily by taking orders for pickup, ensuring maximum freshness and personalized service for every item made.
• Pre-Ordering: Encouraging customers to place orders in advance, particularly for specific flavors or large quantities, to allow ample time for preparation and scheduling.

***

Features / Highlights

Sugar and Whisk’s distinct features highlight their dedication to quality ingredients, creative flavors, and personalized customer care within the Columbus, WI community.

• Artisan, Handcrafted Quality: Every cookie, cake, and dessert is lovingly made by hand with high-quality ingredients, resulting in soft, flavorful, and indulgent products.
• Gourmet & Unique Flavor Profiles: Excelling in premium and sophisticated flavors for cakes, such as Chocolate & Bourbon, Lemon & Blueberry, and Almond Pecan Praline, offering an elevated dessert experience for the Wisconsin market.
• Signature Cookies: Their chunky, decadent cookies, weighing approximately 5.5 ounces, are a standout feature, blending rich flavors and textures for a truly satisfying bite.
• Celebration Focus: The bakery is well-equipped to serve as the exclusive provider for weddings and large celebrations, with specialized menus and tasting options for couples planning their big day.
• Personalized Service: The nature of their operation ensures that each order receives individual attention and care, from preparation to scheduling pick-up.
• Commitment to Quality Control: Notes on their custom orders emphasize their commitment to allowing ample time for baking fresh, handcrafted goods, prioritizing quality over speed.

***

Contact Information

To place an order for your next celebration, inquire about custom cakes, or arrange a pick-up for a gourmet treat, you may contact Sugar and Whisk directly:

Address: 550 S Birdsey St, Columbus, WI 53925, USA

Phone: (920) 382-9138

***

What is Worth Choosing

For residents and event planners across Wisconsin, choosing Sugar and Whisk is choosing a premium, artisan experience that elevates the standard of local baked goods. The value of this Columbus bakery lies not just in its products but in its uncompromising commitment to taste, creativity, and customer focus.

The core reason to choose Sugar and Whisk is the exceptional quality and gourmet nature of their offerings. You are not buying a mass-produced item; you are investing in a meticulously crafted dessert. Their cake menu reads like a list of culinary artistry, blending high-end ingredients with complex flavors like lavender, champagne, bourbon, and house-made curds. This makes them the definitive choice for weddings, anniversaries, and any milestone event where the dessert must be as memorable as the occasion itself.

Furthermore, for those days when you simply need a superior sweet fix, their unique cookies and specialty items—like the much-loved Banana Pudding—provide that perfect, indulgent moment. These are chunky, satisfying portions made to impress. The ability to easily pre-order and communicate directly with the baker via phone ensures that whether you need a single, decadent cookie or a multi-tiered cake, your needs are met professionally and personally.

Ultimately, Sugar and Whisk offers a convenient local source for world-class sweetness right here in Columbus, WI. By prioritizing handcrafted excellence and personalized service, they have established themselves as the go-to bakery for customers in Wisconsin who want their sweet treats and celebrations to be nothing short of the sweetest part of their day.

Sugar and Whisk

550 S Birdsey St, Columbus, WI 53925, USA