Sugarplum Cake Shoppe

Introduction / Overview

Nestled in the heart of Colorado Springs, The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe has established itself as the premier local destination for high-quality, handcrafted cakes and desserts for over a decade. Founded in 2010 by Amanda Adams, the bakery operates on the simple yet profound belief that exceptional baked goods are essential to celebrating life’s most significant moments. Specializing primarily in custom cakes for weddings and special occasions, the team of expert bakers and master decorators focuses on transforming a client’s vision—whether it's for an elaborate multi-tiered wedding cake or a themed birthday centerpiece—into a delicious, edible work of art.

This dedicated Colorado Springs cake shop is renowned not just for the stunning visual appeal of its creations, but for the quality and complexity of its flavors. Customer testimonials consistently praise the cakes for being moist, rich, and "out of this world," making the taste experience as memorable as the visual design. Beyond large custom orders, The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe maintains a robust bakery case featuring a wide variety of scratch-made sweets for a quick indulgence or small gathering, including cupcakes, pies, bars, and seasonal offerings. Their reputation for beautiful designs, incredible flavor variety (offering over 40 different choices), and exceptional customer service—with a focus on collaboration and ease—makes them a top choice for Colorado residents planning any celebration.

Location and Accessibility

The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe is conveniently located at 412 S 8th St, Colorado Springs, CO 80905, placing it easily within reach for patrons across the El Paso County region. Situated in the 80905 zip code, the bakery is highly accessible for quick pickups and comprehensive consultations alike.

The bakery understands the importance of convenience and comfort for all of its Colorado clients, particularly when handling delicate custom orders. To ensure a stress-free visit, the location is equipped with key accessibility features. These include a wheelchair accessible entrance, facilitating smooth and easy entry for all customers, and a dedicated wheelchair accessible parking lot. Furthermore, the bakery offers a highly valued free parking lot, eliminating the hassle and expense of finding street parking in a busy area of Colorado Springs. For customers needing a swift transaction, service options like curbside pickup and takeout are readily available, while in-store pickup remains an option for those wishing to briefly explore the bakery case or meet with a staff member for a quick chat about an order.

Services Offered

The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe provides a comprehensive suite of services tailored to both major events and everyday sweet cravings for the Colorado Springs community.

• Custom Wedding Cakes: Specializing in bespoke wedding cakes, offering tiered creations with intricate designs in both buttercream and elaborate fondant finishes, often including professional delivery and setup services at the venue.
• Special Occasion Cakes: Designing custom cakes for all milestones, including birthdays, graduations, baby showers, and other events, with options for 2D, 3D, and themed novelty designs (e.g., superhero, video game, castle).
• Celebration Cakes and Sizes: Providing custom round cakes (starting at 7" to 8") and sheet cakes (starting at 1/4 and 1/3 sizes) with customizable flavors and fillings to serve any size gathering.
• Private Cake Tastings and Consultations: Complimentary private tasting sessions for couples planning weddings (for orders of 30 servings or more), offering samples of four cake flavors and six filling options while meeting with a designer for custom quotes.
• Dessert Bar Catering: Offering a full dessert bar menu that includes a wide array of treats such as cookies, brownies, mini cupcakes, cannolis, cheesecake fingers, French macarons, cake truffles, and dessert shooters for events.
• Everyday Bakery Items: A diverse selection of fresh-baked goods available daily, including full-size pies, muffins, scones, lemon and key lime bars, eclairs, cream puffs, and various cheesecakes.
• Dietary Accommodations: Providing options to accommodate specific dietary needs, including gluten-free and lactose-free cake selections.
• Order and Pickup Flexibility: Offering multiple convenient service options, including delivery, curbside pickup, in-store pickup, and takeout for quick grab-and-go purchases.

Features and Highlights

This Colorado Springs bakery stands out in the local market for its quality ingredients, unparalleled flavor variety, and professional dedication to the craft of custom cake making.

• Over 40 Distinct Cake Flavor Options: An extensive menu of specialty flavors, including signature creations like Sugar Plum Fairy (almond, lemon, and vanilla blend), Butter Almond, Carrot Cake, Bailey's Triple Chocolate, and Fresh Lemon Cake, ensuring a unique taste for every customer.
• Expert Master Decorators: The team possesses the skill to replicate complex designs from photos or create entirely original, unique concepts, transforming a client's specific vision into reality.
• Collaborative Design Process: The staff, including owner Amanda Adams, is consistently noted in reviews for being "easy and enjoyable to work with," providing consultations that ensure every detail is captured accurately, which reduces customer stress during the planning process.
• Full Dessert Bar Range: A notable feature is the comprehensive selection of small-format desserts, perfect for weddings or large parties seeking variety over a single cake, including items like cake pops, tarts, and dessert shooters.
• Use of Local Colorado Flavors: The bakery incorporates fresh, local ingredients when in season, such as Palisade peaches and Canyon City apples, to give their fillings an authentic, fresh Colorado quality.
• Wedding-Focused Services: Offering crucial support for wedding couples, including private consultations, delivery, professional setup, and the option for cake stand rentals.

Contact Information

To place a custom order, schedule a cake tasting, or inquire about the daily bakery selection, Colorado Springs customers can reach The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe using the details below.

Address: 412 S 8th St, Colorado Springs, CO 80905, USA

Phone: (719) 930-3343

Mobile Phone: +1 719-930-3343

What is Worth Choosing The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe

For residents across Colorado Springs and the surrounding region, choosing The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe is a commitment to quality, creativity, and a stress-free experience, particularly for significant life events. The overwhelming consensus from local customers, especially those planning weddings, highlights two key distinguishing factors: the incredible flavor and the collaborative, professional service. Clients consistently describe their wedding cakes as not just "gorgeous to look at," but also "delicious" and "out of this world," noting that the cake remained moist and flavorful through every layer—a testament to the high-quality, scratch-made ingredients used.

The personalized approach to cake design, led by the experienced team, ensures that whether a customer brings a Pinterest board inspiration or a simple idea, the final product is exactly what they envisioned. This bespoke, high-touch process removes the common anxieties associated with ordering custom baked goods. Furthermore, the sheer variety of flavor combinations—from the classic Carrot Cake with cream cheese filling to unique blends like Almond cake with raspberry filling—means every client can find a perfect, personalized profile. When you choose The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe, you are investing in an edible masterpiece backed by a local business dedicated to making your Colorado Springs celebration truly unforgettable, from the first consultation and tasting right through to the final, delicious slice.

Sugarplum Cake Shoppe

412 S 8th St, Colorado Springs, CO 80905, USA