Tara's Cheesecakes Introduce
## Introduction / Overview
Deeply nestled in the picturesque village of Winesburg, Ohio, you'll find a true destination for dessert lovers: **Tara's Cheesecakes**. This cherished **small business** has rapidly earned a reputation for producing what many local Ohio customers call the "ultimate cheesecake experience." Tara and her team pour quality and care into every creation, resulting in a product that is described as having a **silky smooth texture** and a flavor that is "perfectly balanced—not overly sweet, just pure cheesecake perfection."
Operating as a dedicated **Bakery** specializing in this decadent dessert, Tara's Cheesecakes is a spot where creativity meets tradition. While the name highlights their signature product, the business offers an atmosphere that is described as **SO CUTE!**, reflecting the personality and thoughtfulness of the owner. Whether you’re celebrating a major Ohio milestone, surprising a loved one, or simply craving an unmatched sweet treat, Tara’s dedication to quality ensures every whole cheesecake or slice is an indulgence worth the drive.
In addition to their legendary cheesecakes, the shop often delights visitors with other scratch-made goodies, such as fluffy **Cinnamon Rolls**, and even a selection of unique retail items like long-lasting, wonderfully smelling soy candles, making it a charming and memorable stop in the heart of Ohio.
## Location and Accessibility
Tara's Cheesecakes is situated in the charming, accessible small-town setting of Winesburg, offering a delightful backdrop for a pleasant visit. The address places it conveniently for residents throughout Holmes County and visitors exploring the scenic Ohio countryside.
The shop’s exact location is:
2097 Main St, Winesburg, OH 44690, USA
The establishment is set up for high convenience, making it ideal for a **Quick visit**. Accessibility has been considered to ensure a smooth experience for all customers:
- **Wheelchair accessible parking lot** is available, providing designated and easy parking near the shop for hassle-free entry and the secure loading of your order.
Customers often highlight the friendly and engaging atmosphere, noting that Tara and her mom are "so nice and fun to talk to." The location is designed to allow customers to pop in, grab their pre-ordered or selection of treats via **Takeout**, and be back on the road swiftly, though you may want to linger to enjoy the inviting ambiance and unique retail offerings.
## Services Offered
Tara's Cheesecakes delivers a focused and high-quality range of products and services, emphasizing specialty desserts and customer convenience.
Services available to their Ohio patrons include:
- **Gourmet Cheesecake Sales:** Offering their signature cheesecakes in various sizes, including 9-inch and 10-inch options, renowned for their incredible, smooth texture and perfectly balanced flavor.
- **Rotating Monthly Flavors:** A key feature is the introduction of **Special Monthly Flavored Cheesecakes**, ensuring repeat customers can always find something new and seasonal, such as **Apple Crumble**, **Pecan Praline**, or specialty holiday varieties.
- **Specialty Baked Goods:** The menu expands beyond cheesecake to include other highly-rated desserts like **Soft and Fluffy Cinnamon Rolls**, often sold in 4-packs with a choice of rich cream cheese or sweet maple frosting.
- **Convenient Service Options:** Operating on a straightforward **Takeout** model, ideal for customers making a **Quick visit** to pick up their orders.
- **Wholesale Contact:** The business provides a wholesale contact option, indicating an interest in supplying their popular cheesecakes to local Ohio establishments.
- **Flexible Payment:** Accepting both **Credit cards** and **Debit cards** to make transactions fast and easy.
## Features / Highlights
What makes Tara’s Cheesecakes a must-visit destination in Winesburg, Ohio, is the dedication to creating an experience that goes beyond simply buying dessert. These features contribute to the business's high level of hype and positive reviews.
Key highlights and features include:
- **Unmatched Cheesecake Quality:** The core highlight is the consistent delivery of **Incredible Cheesecake** defined by its high-quality ingredients, resulting in a **silky smooth** texture and a flavor that is intentionally **not overly sweet**, pleasing a sophisticated Ohio palate.
- **Charming Atmosphere and Personality:** Customers consistently praise the **"SO CUTE!"** shop aesthetic, the welcoming environment, and the engaging, friendly personalities of Tara and her mother, who make every interaction enjoyable and secure, even for long drives.
- **Unique Retail Add-ons:** Beyond the food, the shop offers quality non-edible items, such as **soy candles**. These products, like the pumpkin-smelling one mentioned in a review, are noted for their longevity and strong scent, offering a creative cross-selling feature.
- **The Small Business Touch:** As a declared **small business**, Tara’s Cheesecakes offers an authentic, personal touch that large chains cannot replicate, guaranteeing "quality and care that goes into every slice." This personalized approach extends to securing orders for travel, demonstrating thoughtful service.
- **Creative Flavor Exploration:** The regular introduction of **Special Monthly Flavored Cheesecakes** keeps the menu fresh and exciting, encouraging repeat visits to try seasonal and novel creations.
## Contact Information
For Ohio dessert enthusiasts looking to treat themselves to Tara's incredible cheesecakes or place a large order for a gathering, here is the essential contact information for the Winesburg location.
Address:2097 Main St, Winesburg, OH 44690, USA
Phone:(330) 231-0496
Mobile Phone:+1 330-231-0496
Customers are encouraged to call ahead or check their online platform to confirm availability, especially for the popular **Special Monthly Flavored Cheesecakes** or the soft and fluffy **Cinnamon Rolls**.
## What is Worth Choosing
**Tara's Cheesecakes** is definitively worth choosing for any Ohio resident seeking the single best cheesecake they can find. If you are a connoisseur of this classic dessert, or if you need a show-stopping item for a special occasion, your search should end here.
This Winesburg gem is worth your visit because it offers **unmatched quality**; the focus is singular—perfection in every slice of cheesecake. Choosing Tara means investing in a dessert where the texture is **silky smooth** and the flavor is expertly balanced, ensuring it’s not cloyingly sweet. The **small business** environment ensures a personal, warm experience, adding to the charm of visiting Winesburg itself.
Furthermore, the **Monthly Flavors** keep the concept fresh, allowing you to sample seasonal creativity while still relying on the exceptional quality of the base recipe. When you want to **Treat yourself!** or provide a dessert that guests will genuinely rave about and remember—for its flavor, texture, and the care that went into it—Tara's Cheesecakes is the ultimate destination in Ohio.
Tara's Cheesecakes Details
From the business
- Small business
Service options
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Tara's Cheesecakes Photos






Tara's Cheesecakes Location
Tara's Cheesecakes Reviews
pumpkinwedding
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I'm surprised I'm the first Google review! This place deserves a lot of hype! I got the pleasure of going to Tara's Cheesecakes for the first time and also the first time seeing Winesburg! Tara and her mom were so nice and fun to talk to. My friend and I had a long drive, and they made sure that the cheesecakes would be secure for the drive. The shop is SO CUTE!There are some wonderful smelling candles too! They are soy candles, I bought a pumpkin smelling one, and it lasts soooo long! I had a Walmart candle burning the same time as it, and there was so much wax in the Walmart one vs. the soy candle!Loved the atmosphere, the personality, and the creativeness of Tara's Cheesecakes. Treat yourself!
September 26 · Jessica DanielsIncredible Cheesecake!Tara’s Cheesecakes are truly unmatched! From the first bite, you can taste the quality and care that goes into every slice. The texture is silky smooth, the flavor is perfectly balanced—not overly sweet, just pure cheesecake perfection. If you're searching for the ultimate cheesecake experience, this is it. Highly recommend!
February 18 · Rachel MillerI’ve never been to her little shop but I’ve had her cheesecakes at restaurants and O M G…best cheesecake you’ll ever have. Better than Cheescake Factory for sure!
March 24 · Aisha KelleyTara’s Cheesecakes are delicious! I’d highly recommend everyone try a slice. There is a flavor for everybody!
March 24 · Katy JohnsonSome of the best cheesecakes I've ever had! Peanut butter cup is always a favorite, and her pumpkin cheesecakes were TO DIE FOR!
March 12 · Rebecca Mattern
More Bakery Near Me
Troyer's Home Pantry4.0 (532 reviews)668 W Main St, Apple Creek, OH 44606, USA
L J Sweets Designs4.0 (10 reviews)875 Walnut Rd SE, Massillon, OH 44646, USA
Cherry Top Cookie Shop LLC5.0 (23 reviews)Viking Ave, Orrville, OH 44667, USA
Cheesecakery Wooster5.0 (14 reviews)715 Callowhill St, Wooster, OH 44691, USA
Troyer's Home Pantry II4.0 (162 reviews)319 E North St, Wooster, OH 44691, USA
Rogue Sweets0.0 (0 reviews)140 S Walnut St, Wooster, OH 44691, USA
Walmart Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)3883 Burbank Rd, Wooster, OH 44691, USA
Auntie Anne's4.0 (209 reviews)3883 Burbank Rd Suite 1, Wooster, OH 44691, USA
Miss Amy's Bakery4.0 (285 reviews)1494 E Smithville Western Rd Suite C, Wooster, OH 44691, USA
Meijer Bakery4.0 (3 reviews)4845 Burbank Rd, Wooster, OH 44691, USA
Bumble Bee's Sweet Shop4.0 (2 reviews)14740 Oak Grove Dr #206, Doylestown, OH 44230, USA
whisked away bakery0.0 (0 reviews)Reedsburg Rd, Wooster, OH 44691, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Sabrina's Home4.0 (133 reviews)
Alpine Bakery5.0 (2 reviews)
Fresh Market Bakery4.0 (1 reviews)
Leavened4.0 (292 reviews)
Walmart Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)
Walmart Bakery5.0 (2 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
