The Eccentric Bagel

For New Yorkers, especially those residing in or frequently visiting the beautiful East End, the quest for the perfect bagel is a serious one. Look no further than **The Eccentric Bagel** on Shelter Island. This beloved local establishment has quickly cemented its reputation, not just as a good bagel shop, but as a contender for the "best bagel in NY state" and "the best bagels on the entire East End." It's a place where tradition meets innovation, resulting in a truly exceptional breakfast or lunch experience.

The Eccentric Bagel is more than just a quick stop; it's a vibrant community hub where quality ingredients, diverse flavors, and genuine hospitality converge. Whether you're a long-time resident of Shelter Island, a weekend visitor, or just passing through, stepping into The Eccentric Bagel promises a delightful start to your day or a satisfying meal break. Their commitment to crafting delicious bagels, complemented by outstanding coffee and a variety of other tempting treats, makes it a highly recommended destination for anyone seeking an authentic and high-quality bagel experience in the New York region.

---

The Eccentric Bagel is conveniently located at **25 W Neck Rd #1, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA**. This address places it centrally on Shelter Island, making it highly accessible for both residents and visitors exploring the island. West Neck Road is a key thoroughfare, ensuring that finding the shop is straightforward, whether you're arriving by ferry or driving from another part of the island.

Shelter Island itself is a unique destination, reachable primarily by short ferry rides from Greenport on the North Fork or Sag Harbor on the South Fork of Long Island. Once on the island, getting to The Eccentric Bagel is relatively easy, with ample space for parking typically available. Its accessible location ensures that whether you're a local starting your day or a tourist enjoying the island's charm, a delicious bagel is never far away. The inviting facade and clear signage make it an easy and welcoming stop for anyone seeking a true New York bagel experience.

---

The Eccentric Bagel offers a comprehensive range of services and products designed to cater to every bagel lover's desire, along with other delicious accompaniments.

• **Freshly Baked Bagels:** Their core offering includes an extensive variety of bagels, praised for their deliciousness and perfect texture. They provide a "nice mixture of flavors" ensuring there's something for every palate.
• **Wide Array of Spreads and Toppings:** To complement their bagels, they offer numerous options for cream cheeses, butter, and other toppings to create your perfect bagel sandwich.
• **Breakfast and Lunch Sandwiches:** Beyond just bagels and cream cheese, they craft delicious breakfast and lunch sandwiches using their fresh bagels, customized to order.
• **Delicious Coffee:** They serve high-quality coffee, noted by customers as being "delicious" and the ideal pairing for their bagels and pastries.
• **Muffins and Cookies:** For those looking for something different or an extra treat, The Eccentric Bagel also offers a selection of tempting muffins and cookies that are highly recommended.
• **Gluten-Free Options:** A significant service highlight is their provision of gluten-free bagels, ensuring that individuals with dietary restrictions can also enjoy their offerings. This commitment to inclusivity is a major plus for many customers.
• **Friendly Service:** Customers consistently praise the friendly and welcoming service, making the overall experience pleasant and inviting.

---

The Eccentric Bagel is distinguished by several key features and highlights that consistently earn it high praise and a loyal customer base, making it a true standout on Shelter Island and beyond.

• **"Best Bagel in NY State" & "Best Bagels on the Entire East End":** These are significant accolades, frequently echoed in customer reviews, underscoring the exceptional quality and taste of their bagels.
• **Delicious and Varied Bagel Selection:** Customers rave about the bagels themselves, highlighting their deliciousness and the "nice mixture of flavors" available, indicating both classic and unique options.
• **Friendly and Welcoming Staff:** Owner Darren and the entire staff are noted for their "friendly service" and positive "vibes," contributing to a great overall atmosphere that makes customers feel welcome.
• **High-Quality Coffee:** The coffee is consistently described as "delicious," ensuring that the beverage offering matches the excellence of their food.
• **Excellent Complementary Treats:** The muffins and cookies are also highly recommended and considered "really worthy," showcasing the overall quality of their baked goods beyond just bagels.
• **Inclusion of Gluten-Free Options:** The availability of "gluten-free" bagels is a major highlight, making their delicious products accessible to a wider audience with dietary needs. This thoughtful inclusion is greatly appreciated by customers.
• **Great Local Spot with Good Vibe:** Customers consistently describe it as an "outstanding spot" with a "great local spot" feel and "great vibes," indicating a comfortable and enjoyable environment.
• **Consistent Quality and Flavor:** The reviews suggest a high level of consistency, with customers enjoying "everything" they tried and finding "all" the bagels delicious.

---

For those eager to experience the acclaimed bagels and welcoming atmosphere of The Eccentric Bagel, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 25 W Neck Rd #1, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA

Phone: (631) 749-5363

It is always a good idea to call ahead for current hours, especially if you're planning a visit during off-peak seasons on Shelter Island, or for any specific requests regarding large orders.

---

For New Yorkers, especially those residing in or frequently visiting Shelter Island and the surrounding East End, The Eccentric Bagel is more than just a place to grab breakfast; it's an essential local establishment that perfectly caters to the community's needs and tastes. Its reputation for having the "best bagel in NY state" and the "best bagels on the entire East End" is not just hyperbole; it's a testament to the consistent quality and deliciousness that locals have come to expect and rely upon.

The convenient location on West Neck Road makes it easily accessible for island residents, whether they're heading to work, enjoying a leisurely morning, or gathering provisions for a day out. The friendly service and inviting "vibe" create a welcoming atmosphere that fosters a sense of community, encouraging repeat visits and making it a comfortable spot to start the day. Moreover, the diverse menu, which includes not only a "nice mixture of flavors" for traditional bagels but also delicious coffee, muffins, cookies, and notably, "gluten free" options, ensures that there truly is "something for everyone." This inclusivity is particularly valuable in a close-knit community like Shelter Island, where diverse dietary needs are increasingly common.

The Eccentric Bagel embodies what a perfect local spot should be: high-quality products, exceptional service, and a welcoming environment. It has become a cherished part of the Shelter Island experience, providing a consistent source of delicious food that fuels the community and enhances daily life. It's a place where every visit feels "really worthy," solidifying its status as a top choice for locals seeking a genuine, top-tier bagel experience right in their own backyard.

The Eccentric Bagel

25 W Neck Rd #1, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA