Sweet Tiers Fort Pierce: Florida’s Premier Custom Cakes and Dessert Buffet Experts on Orange Ave

XSweet Tiers Fort Pierce Introduce

Introduction / Overview: Sweet Tiers Fort Pierce—Crafting Florida’s Most Exquisite Custom Cakes

Situated in the heart of Fort Pierce, Sweet Tiers is renowned throughout the Treasure Coast and South Florida as an elite, award-winning Cake shop and Bakery. This is not just a place to grab a quick pastry; it is a specialty custom cake shoppe where culinary artistry meets confectionary excellence. Sweet Tiers has built a decades-long reputation for specializing in custom luxury and novelty cakes, becoming the go-to vendor for Florida weddings, major corporate events, and all milestone celebrations.

The bakery’s commitment to quality is evident in every detail, from the freshness of their ingredients to their signature, light, and not overly sweet buttercream frosting. Their expertise has been recognized nationally, with staff members having been featured on major Food Network challenge shows like The Big Bake and Cake Hunters. This high level of skill is applied to their core offerings, which include bespoke tiered cakes, an impressive variety of gourmet cupcakes, and comprehensive dessert buffets designed to delight guests at any scale event.

Locals often praise Sweet Tiers for its extensive and imaginative flavor menu, which boasts over 80 combinations—far surpassing the standard options found at typical bakeries. From the sophisticated White Chocolate Keylime (a nod to Florida) to the fun Elvis and the seasonal Southern Comfort Egg Nog, Sweet Tiers ensures every cake is a memorable culinary experience tailored to the client's exact desires.

Location and Accessibility in Historic Downtown Fort Pierce

Sweet Tiers is conveniently located at 205 Orange Ave, Fort Pierce, FL 34950, USA. Its position on Orange Avenue places it centrally in the vibrant downtown area of Fort Pierce, making it highly accessible for residents of St. Lucie County and the surrounding Florida communities. The central location is ideal for clients coming in for consultations, cake tastings, or for simply stopping by for a sweet snack.

Accessibility is a priority for the shop, which features a Wheelchair accessible entrance and a dedicated Wheelchair accessible parking lot. This ensures a comfortable and hassle-free experience for all visitors. The shop facilitates modern convenience through various payment methods, including Checks, Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments. For those looking to work or simply relax while enjoying a treat, the bakery also provides Wi-Fi. The operation is structured to accommodate everything from comprehensive custom cake planning appointments to a Quick visit for in-store purchases of daily available desserts.

Comprehensive Services Offered

As both a Cake shop and a Bakery, Sweet Tiers offers a wide spectrum of sweet services for the Florida market:

Custom Tiered and Novelty Cakes: Specializing in bespoke cakes for weddings, birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, and unique themed parties, all baked fresh for the special event.
Gourmet Daily Treats: Offering an impressive selection of Standard Cupcakes and larger desserts available for In-store shopping and Takeout.
Extensive Flavor Menu: Providing over 80 unique flavor combinations, including award-winning recipes like the Marble Cake with White Chocolate Liqueur and a fudge filling and Florida-inspired flavors such as Key Lime and Orange Creamsicle.
Full Dessert Buffet Design: Creating stunning, custom dessert tables for large events, featuring a diverse price list of over 20 items like Mini Cannolis, French Macarons, Cake Pops, Pie Shooters, and special treats like Jack Daniels Cake Shooters.
Delivery and Pickup Options: Facilitating ease of planning for busy Florida clients with services for Delivery (especially important for custom cakes and weddings) and In-store pickup.
Specialty Desserts: Crafting a variety of high-end desserts, including Key Lime Cheesecake ($11.00), Chocolate Stout Cake ($10.00), and seasonal items like Rhubarb and Berry Crisp ($9.00).
Dietary Accommodations: Working with clients to accommodate specific dietary needs, including options for gluten-free and other specialized requests, as confirmed through customer reviews.

Features / Quality and Taste Highlights

The competitive advantages of Sweet Tiers stem from its high standards of quality and proven expertise:

Award-Winning Flavor Recipes: The bakery is celebrated for its delectable flavors, with an emphasis on unique combinations and its signature buttercream that is light, creamy, and not excessively sugary.
Masterful Cake Design: The staff includes cake artists and pastry chefs with nationally recognized skills, capable of creating elegant, simple wedding cakes as well as intricate, realistic novelty cakes.
Impressive Variety (The 80+ Flavor List): The sheer volume of flavor options ensures a truly personalized cake experience. Highlights include unique choices like Butterbeer, Pina Colada, Lavender & Lemon, and the adult-focused Jack Daniels Whiskey Cupcake.
High-Quality Dessert Buffet Items: The option to create a Dessert Buffet using an extensive list of miniature desserts provides a high-end, customized solution for catering events across the Florida region.
Positive Customer Experience: Customers consistently praise the friendly, helpful, and professional staff, noting the stress-free process for ordering complex, custom creations—a critical factor for wedding and event planning.

Contact Information

To book a custom cake consultation, inquire about their dessert buffet options, or simply check on the daily cupcake selection, please contact Sweet Tiers using the information below:

Address: 205 Orange Ave, Fort Pierce, FL 34950, USA
Phone: (772) 242-8128 or +1 772-242-8128

What is Worth Choosing at Sweet Tiers Fort Pierce

For any individual or business in the Florida region looking for a top-tier bakery, Sweet Tiers in Fort Pierce offers a compelling choice that merges high-volume production capability with small-batch artistry.

It is worth choosing for Unmatched Customization: The opportunity to select from over 80 distinct flavors—from White Chocolate Strawberry to the unexpected Dark Chocolate with Mango & Apricot—ensures that your cake is truly unique. This level of customization is unparalleled in the local market and is essential for making a wedding or special occasion truly reflective of personal taste. The ability to sample multiple flavors and work collaboratively with nationally recognized cake artists guarantees a stunning and delicious final product.

It is worth choosing for Event Expertise and Reliability: Sweet Tiers has a proven track record of handling high-stakes events, having been recognized on national TV and by local voters as a leading bakery. Florida event planners and couples can trust the bakery’s experience in design, flawless execution, and reliable Delivery and setup. When ordering a large, multi-tiered cake or an extensive Dessert Buffet, reliability is as important as taste, and Sweet Tiers consistently delivers on both.

It is worth choosing for the Gourmet Experience, Even for a Quick Visit: While their forte is grand cakes, the everyday visitor can experience the same gourmet quality. Stopping in for a specialty cupcake, such as the highly-rated flavors or one of their unique desserts like the Banana Bread Foster ($11.00), provides an accessible taste of their award-winning expertise. The bakery atmosphere and staff friendliness, as consistently noted in reviews, make even a Quick visit a pleasant and rewarding part of the Fort Pierce local experience.

XSweet Tiers Fort Pierce Vibe

All Flavors
White Chocolate Strawberry
A delicious white chocolate cake with sweet strawberry filling, vanilla buttercream and a strawberry drizzle
White Chocolate Keylime
A delicious white chocolate cake with delicious key lime curd filling, vanilla buttercream and a keylime/kiwi drizzle
White Chocolate Raspberry
A delicious white chocolate cake with sweet raspberry filling, vanilla buttercream and a raspberry drizzle
Beach Bum
This is a strawberry cupcake with chocolate chips in the batter, banana mousse filling and vanilla buttercream
Chocolate Merlot
This is a chocolate cupcake with a merlot buttercream filling and merlot buttercream icing. Yum!!
Dark Chocolate Pumpkin
Dark chocolate cupcake with pumpkin spice chips in the batter and pumpkin spice filling and vanilla buttercream
Pumpkin Dark Chocolate
This is a pumpkin cupcake with chocolate chips in the batter, dark chocolate mousse and vanilla buttercream
Chocolate Coconut
This is a chocolate cupcake with toasted coconut and chocolate chips in the batter, chocolate mousse filling and vanilla buttercream topped with moist delicious toasted coconut flakes
Black Jack
This is a chocolate cupcake with drunken walnuts and Jack Daniels whiskey baked in and a double shot of Jack Daniels icing on top
Butterfinger
This decadent cupcake is chocolate with pieces of Butterfinger candy baked inside, chocolate butterfinger mousse and vanilla icing topped with a delicious chocolate drizzle and crushed butterfinger pieces
Strawberry lemon marble
Strawberry and lemon cake swirled together for this sweet and zesty cupcake, filled with strawberry fruit and topped with vanilla buttercream and a dollop of lemon curd on top
Red velvet/vanilla marble
This is a red velvet and vanilla cake swirled together with a cream cheese filling and topped with vanilla buttercream
Butterbeer
Harry Potter would be proud! This delicious cream/butterscotch/caramel cake is magical. It is filled with butterbeer mousse and topped with vanilla buttercream
Neopolitan
This chocolate, vanilla and strawberry cake is swirled together for an old fashioned ice-cream flavor. It is filled with vanilla mousse and topped with a chocolate and strawberry drizzle
Elvis
This was Elvis Presley's favorite dessert flavor. It is a banana cupcake with peanut butter chips in the batter, peanut butter mousse and vanilla buttercream topping
Birthday Cake
What kind of cake shop would we be if we didn't offer this American favorite. This is a cream cake with sprinkles baked inside, filled with vanilla mousse and topped with vanilla buttercream and multi-colored sprinkles for that added bit of birthday cheer
Key Lime
Key lime cupcake with key lime curd filling, key lime drizzle and vanilla buttercream, a local favorite
Almond & Raspberry
Almond cupcake with raspberry fruit filling and vanilla buttercream
Lemon Bomb
Lemon cupcake with lemon curd filling and vanilla buttercream
Orange and Cranberry
Orange cupcake with cranberry bits and cranberry mousse filling with vanilla bean buttercream
Banana Strawberry
Moist and delicious banana cupcake with strawberry fruit filling, strawberry buttercream with dried strawberry and banana chip on top
Lavender & Lemon
Lavender cupcake with lemon curd filling and crème bouquet buttercream. Our very own one of a kind, signature flavor
Cookies n Cream
Oreo cupcake, Oreo mousse filling and vanilla buttercream. Delicious!
Pistachio
Pistachio cupcake with pistachio mousse and vanilla buttercream frosting
S'mores
Chocolate cupcake with graham cracker bottom, marshmallow filling, vanilla buttercream, graham cracker, chocolate bar, toasted marshmallows and a chocolate drizzle. Everyone's favorite
Banana Split
Waffle cup bottom to a banana cupcake topped with pineapple, chocolate and strawberries, vanilla buttercream and a maraschino cherry
Lemon Poppy
Lemon cupcake with poppy seeds, lemon curd filling and vanilla buttercream
Banana & Chocolate
Banana cupcake with chocolate mousse filling and chocolate frosting
Kings Cake
Cream cupcake with nutmeg and cinnamon, filled with creamy praline filling and topped with maple buttercream. A Mardi gras favorite
Strawberries & Cream
Strawberry cupcake with vanilla mousse filling, strawberry drizzle and vanilla buttercream
Orange Creamsicle
This is a tangy orange cupcake with vanilla mousse filling, orange drizzle and vanilla buttercream
Mango madness
Cream cupcake with mango mousse filling, mango drizzle and apricot buttercream
PB&J
Peanut butter cupcake with grape jelly filling and peanut butter buttercream. A tall glass of milk is a must with this one
Red Velvet
This is a traditional red velvet cupcake with white chocolate mousse filling and vanilla buttercream, topped with a delicious chocolate covered Bing cherry
Peaches n Cream
Cream cupcake with peach fruit filling and vanilla buttercream
Pina Colada
Pineapple cupcake with coconut mousse filling, pineapple drizzle and lime buttercream. Paper umbrella, edible fondant flip flops and a maraschino cherry top this delicious sweet treat
Spice
Old fashioned spice cupcake with vanilla mousse filling and vanilla buttercream on top. A fall and winter favorite
Ginger & Pear
Ginger cupcake with pear mousse filling and vanilla buttercream topping
Chocolate Snickers
Chocolate cupcake with Snickers baked right in the batter, with a chocolate and caramel drizzle and topped with chocolate buttercream
Black Forest in a Jar
Chocolate cupcake with loads of cherry fruit filling, vanilla buttercream served in a mini mason jar
Pumpkin
Pumpkin cupcake with cream cheese filling and, vanilla buttercream topping
Banana Cream Dream
Nilla wafer bottomed banana cupcake with banana mousse filling and vanilla buttercream
Strawberry Banana Smoothie
Strawberry cupcake with banana mousse filling, vanilla buttercream with a strawberry drizzle
Dulce De Leche
Caramel cupcake with delicious, thick dulce de leche filling and caramel buttercream. Fantastic
Razzleberry
Strawberry cupcake with blueberry fruit filling and raspberry buttercream. A flavorful choice
Bailey's Irish Cream
Irish Cream cupcake with Irish Cream mousse filling and vanilla buttercream
Snickerdoodle
Cinnamon sugar cupcake with caramel mousse filling and cinnamon buttercream on top
Hot Chocolate
Chocolate cake with mini marshmallows and marshmallow filling, topped with vanilla buttercream
Sea Turtle
Chocolate cake with caramel and pecans, caramel mousse and chocolate buttercream, with Himalayan sea salt sprinkled on top
Mango Strawberry
Mango cupcake with flavorful strawberry fruit filing and vanilla buttercream with a tropical mango drizzle
The Frog
Orange cupcake with Fig, Raspberry and Ginger mousse, with vanilla buttercream with sugared ginger crystal topping
Dark chocolate with Mango & Apricot
Dark chocolate cupcake with mango and apricot mousse filling vanilla buttercream and mango drizzle
Chocolate Covered Cherry
Chocolate cupcake with imported cherry chips, Maraschino cherry mousse filling and maraschino cherry buttercream
Almond & Cherry
Almond cupcake with cherry fruit filling and vanilla buttercream
White Chocolate and Macadamia Nut
Cream cupcake with white chocolate chips and macadamia nuts, filled with white chocolate mousse and topped with vanilla buttercream
Orange & Chocolate
Orange cupcake with chocolate ganache filling and chocolate buttercream frosting
Jack Daniels Whiskey Cupcake
Cream cupcake with walnuts and Jack Daniels baked in, with a double shot of Jack Daniels icing
Inside Out German Chocolate
Chocolate cupcake with caramel, pecans and coconut in the batter, chocolate drizzle and topped with creamy chocolate buttercream
Strawberry Lemonade
Strawberry cupcake with lemon curd filling, strawberry drizzle and vanilla buttercream
Caramel Apple
Apple cupcake with apple fruit filling and a thick, caramel drizzle topped with caramel buttercream
Chocolate Overload
Chocolate cupcake with chocolate chips, chocolate mousse, chocolate drizzle, chocolate buttercream, and chocolate chips on top
Pineapple Lovers
Pineapple cupcake with pineapple fruit filling and vanilla buttercream, topped with a sweet pineapple slice candy
Mocha Java
Chocolate & coffee cupcake with coffee drizzle and coffee buttercream with chocolate covered Espresso beans on top
Salted Caramel
Chocolate cupcake with Caramel filling, caramel buttercream, caramel drizzle and sea salt sprinkled on top
Pink Lemonade
This is a pink lemonade flavored cupcake filled with lemon curd and topped with vanilla buttercream
Reeses Peanut Butter
Chocolate cupcake with Reeses baked right in, with chocolate peanut butter filling and buttercream with mini Reeses on top
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Dark chocolate cupcake filled with sweet strawberry fruit filling, strawberry and chocolate drizzles and vanilla buttercream
Coconut and Dark Chocolate
Coconut cupcake with dark chocolate mousse and chocolate mousse butter cream
Butterscotch
Cream cupcake with butterscotch chips, butterscotch mousse, vanilla buttercream, and butterscotch drizzle
Chocolate Rolo
Milk chocolate cupcake with Rolo caramel candies baked right in, topped with caramel buttercream and chocolate drizzle
Chocolate Raspberry
Dark chocolate cupcake with raspberry fruit filling and raspberry buttercream and chocolate drizzle
Tickle Me Pink
Pink champagne cupcake with white chocolate mousse filling and vanilla buttercream on top
Mint Chocolate Chip
This is a chocolate chip cupcake with mint chips right in the batter and mint flavored buttercream
Traditional Carrot Cake
This old time favorite is a traditional carrot cake cupcake with cream cheese filling and vanilla buttercream, topped handmade edible fondant carrots
Cinnamon Apple
Apple cupcake with apple filling and vanilla buttercream and cinnamon drizzle
Toasted Coconut
Coconut Cupcake with coconut cream mousse, vanilla buttercream and toasted coconut on top
Fig & Vanilla Bean
Fig cupcake with vanilla buttercream frosting and topped with white chocolate curls
M&M
Chocolate cupcake with M&Ms in the batter, vanilla mousse filling chocked full of M&M pieces, vanilla buttercream frosting, chocolate drizzle and mini M&M topping
White Chocolate Cherry
White chocolate cupcake with white chocolate and cherry chips, cherry filling and vanilla buttercream
Coconut & Raspberry
Moist delicious coconut cupcake with raspberry fruit filling and vanilla buttercream
Southern Comfort Egg Nog (Seasonal)
Southern comfort egg nog cupcake with Southern Comfort Egg Nog filling and vanilla buttercream. Yumm!!!
Lemon & Raspberry
Delicious lemon cupcake with raspberry fruit filling and vanilla buttercream with a double drizzle of lemon and raspberry
Guava and Cream
Cream cupcake with guava fruit filling and vanilla buttercream
Turtle
Chocolate cake with caramel and pecans, caramel mousse and chocolate buttercream
Strawberry Kiwi
Strawberry kiwi cupcake with strawberry kiwi mousse and vanilla buttercream with a strawberry drizzle and dried kiwi on top
Apple Pie
Cream cupcake with graham cracker bottom, cinnamon apple fruit filling and maple buttercream. A summertime picnic favorite

Desserts
Rhubarb and Berry Crisp $9.00
Vanilla bean ice cream
Chocolate Stout Cake $10.00
Vanilla bean ice cream
Almond Joy Tres Leches Cake $9.00
Chocolate ganache, toasted coconut, almonds, blackberries
Banana Bread Foster $11.00
Vanilla bean cheesecake ice cream
Key Lime Cheesecake $11.00
Seasonal Sorbet $6.00

Dessert Buffet Price List
Mini Cannolis
Mini Chocolate Covered Cannolis
Blue Ribbon Praline Bark
Pie Shooters
several flavors
Jack Daniels Cake Shooters
Standard Cupcakes
several flavors
Mini Pies
several flavors
Chocolate Covered Strawberries
Mini Cheesecakes
several flavors toppings
Cake Pops
standard
French Macarons
several flavors
Brownies / Blondies
Cookies
Chocolate Covered Oreos
Oreos Pops
Chocolate Covered Pretzels
Marshmellow Kabobs
Pastry Puffs / Turnovers Several Flavors
Chocolate Lollipops
several flavors
Coconut Macarrons
Cake Pops (Designer)
Smore Kabobs
Personality Pops
Fruit Filled Chocolates
Rice Krispie Pops
dipped in chocolate
Barks
pretzel, rocky road, tropical, salted caramel peppermint

XSweet Tiers Fort Pierce Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Checks
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

XSweet Tiers Fort Pierce Photos

XSweet Tiers Fort Pierce Location

XSweet Tiers Fort Pierce

Florida St. Lucie County Fort Pierce Orange Avenue

205 Orange Ave, Fort Pierce, FL 34950, USA

XSweet Tiers Fort Pierce Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 125 user reviews.

cupcakeswedding cakeflavorspricepartytastingbeautifuldesignmoneycrisco

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I don’t even like cupcakes my wife was craving a sweet snack and we stopped in here just to test them out got 2 cupcakes and i immediately had to return for more cupcakes!!! Best cupcakes I’ve ever had in my life no joke. You won’t be disappointed the staff is super friendly and helpful 10/10 experience. 100% chance we will be back again and again.
September 07 · Joe Tenore
We absolutely LOVED our cake from The Cake Lady. We went in and tried multiple flavors and decided to keep it simple with vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet. We ended up getting a 3 tiered cake that was very simple and elegant, as well as two half sheets of cake. None of it went to waste it was that good! The whole process was easy and stress free. Thank you so much for being apart of our special day! We look forward to eating the top of the cake in 7 months to celebrate, and will definitely be stopping in the store for some sweets!
June 30 · Kaitlyn Baker
I ordered a cake with Staci for my wedding over this last weekend. She had us come in for a complimentary cake tasting, showed us other customs that she had done that were similar to what we were looking for. She designed and created a cake that was perfect for us. The flavors were phenomenal and the cake was loved at our wedding!I highly recommend her and her high quality products and her sincerely kind service!
October 23 · Natalie Ann
The team was fantastic! We had a last minute drop out for a custom cake request and called Cake Lady Custom Cakes with less than a weeks notice for a birthday party cake. They took on the challenge and delivered! They brought this beautiful cake to the place we’re staying at. The team helped us pull off an amazing party!
February 15 · Matt Johnson
We had such a wonderful experience with The Cake Lady Custom Cakes! Stacie was amazing to work with, she took her time with us during the tasting/design process and was always available for a phone call or email leading up to the day for any last minute changes. She and her team created the perfect cake for our wedding! I highly recommend working with her to make your cake dreams come true. I know we will be coming back for cakes to help us celebrate other special occasions in the future. Thank you Stacie!
June 12 · Ryann Foster