Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe: A Staten Island Bakery Legacy for New York Locals

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe Introduce

For New York residents, a great bakery is more than just a place to buy sweets—it’s a community cornerstone, a repository of tradition, and the essential stop for every major life celebration. In Staten Island, one name has been synonymous with exceptional Italian craftsmanship and quality baked goods for over half a century: Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe. Since its founding in 1970, this establishment has woven itself into the fabric of the borough, carrying forward the rich culinary heritage of its founder, Alfonso Campitiello.

Alfonso’s journey began in Italy, where he honed his skills working alongside regional chefs. This dedication to perfection continued when he arrived in America, leading him to prestigious roles such as baking at the renowned Plaza Hotel and serving as the pastry chef for The Hampshire House. This high-level experience laid the foundation for the bakery's unwavering commitment to quality. The original shop opened on Manor Road in 1970, later moving to Victory Boulevard in 1978, and has since expanded to a second location on Amboy Road, ensuring that this cherished legacy is accessible to more Staten Islanders and visitors alike.

Today, Alfonso's is proudly run by the next generation, preserving the old-world techniques and traditions while embracing the latest cake trends. Stepping into Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe on Amboy Road is to immerse yourself in a world of sweet, authentic Italian flavors. Whether you're picking up a loaf of fresh bread for Sunday dinner, grabbing a quick, decadent treat, or commissioning a show-stopping custom cake, the shoppe offers a delightful experience built on tradition, warmth, and exceptional taste.

The bakery is famous throughout New York for its vast selection, covering everything from classic Italian biscuits to sophisticated layer cakes. Locals repeatedly turn to Alfonso's for their cannolis—often cited as some of the best in the area—their flaky sfogliatelle, and their vibrant rainbow cookies. The continuous stream of loyal customers is a testament to the quality and consistency that this family-owned business strives to maintain, making it a reliable choice for families celebrating milestones like graduations, confirmations, engagements, and birthdays.

This particular location, nestled on Amboy Road, serves the South Shore community of Staten Island with the same dedication to quality that has defined the brand since its inception. While the original Victory Boulevard location holds decades of history, the Amboy Road shop carries the torch forward, ensuring that more New Yorkers have access to their incredible array of fresh, daily-baked goods.

The immense selection is perhaps the most impressive aspect of Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe. The sheer variety ensures that every customer finds their perfect indulgence. From simple, yet perfect, Italian loaves to elaborate, multi-tiered cakes, the offerings reflect a mastery of both Italian and contemporary baking. The commitment to providing fresh products is a core value, driving the team to constantly bake and restock their shelves. While some long-time patrons have noted inconsistencies in product freshness during off-peak hours, the overall consensus remains that for specialty items and celebratory cakes, Alfonso’s delivers a quality product that New Yorkers expect.

It is important for local patrons to remember that a business with such a long history often evolves. Current owner, Anthony Campitiello, continues to honor his father Alfonso’s dream, ensuring that the essence of the Italian bakery tradition lives on. The shop is a place where you can find products specifically catering to various dietary needs, such as gluten-free and sugar-free options, illustrating their commitment to serving the entire community.

When planning your next family gathering, holiday meal, or simple Sunday treat, keep Alfonso’s Pastry Shoppe in mind. Their classic Italian specialties are a taste of history, and their modern cake designs ensure they stay current with today’s demands. It’s a true New York staple, celebrating the sweetest moments of life, one fresh pastry at a time.

Location and Accessibility

The Amboy Road location of Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe makes it a convenient stop for residents in the southern part of Staten Island. Located in a commercial area, accessibility is a key focus for the establishment, making sure the experience is smooth for all customers.

Address: 4366 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA

Accessibility Features:

The location offers a Wheelchair accessible entrance.

Parking:

Customers can utilize the Free parking lot, which makes quick pick-ups or longer browsing a stress-free experience.

Services Offered

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe caters to a wide variety of customer needs, focusing on convenience and a comprehensive selection of baked goods.

Takeout and In-store shopping service options are available.
The bakery offers a wide array of fresh bread, baked daily, including Italian, Peasant, Semolina, and specialty loaves like Meat Bread.
A diverse selection of individual cookies and packaged Italian biscuits, including Pignoli, Rainbow, and Gluten-Free varieties.
Large and Mini Pastries, featuring Italian classics such as Cannolis, Napoleon, Sfoghiatelli (clam shells), and Lobster Tails.
Full-size cakes, including Layer Cakes (Red Velvet, Blackout, 7 Layer), Cheesecakes (Italian, Cream Cheese, Sugar Free, Strawberry), and Specialty Cakes (Tiramisu, Fruit Tarts).
Custom Birthday Cakes, available in both buttercream and whipped cream finishes, with Cannoli Birthday Cakes also offered.
Pies and Rings, such as Apple, Blueberry Crumb, Lemon Meringue, and specialty items like Grain Pie.
A selection of Cupcakes, including Standard Vanilla, Chocolate, Oreo, and Red Velvet.
Special deals are often available, such as the Tuesday-Saturday special on large pastries (buy 12 or more for a reduced price per piece).

Features / Highlights

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe is distinguished by a number of key features that have made it a Staten Island institution.

Decades of Tradition: The bakery has been a family-owned Staten Island staple since 1970, founded by Alfonso Campitiello, who brought high-level culinary experience from his time in Italy and at establishments like the Plaza Hotel.
Signature Italian Pastries: Widely known for their famous Cannolis and Cannoli Cream, as well as other Italian favorites like Sfoghiatelli, Pasticiotti, and Lobster Tails.
Extensive Cookie Selection: Features an expansive showcase of classic Italian butter cookies sold by the pound, including the highly popular Rainbow Cookies, Pignoli Cookies (gluten-free), and a selection of Italian biscuits.
Accommodating Menu: The menu includes specialized items like Dietetic (sugar-free) Butter Cookies and Gluten-Free Cookies, demonstrating a commitment to serving a diverse customer base.
Custom Cake Artistry: Known for creating specialty and custom cakes for all occasions, from simple birthday cakes to elaborate wedding cakes.
High Variety of Fresh Bread: Daily-baked bread options range from basic Italian and French loaves to unique offerings such as Meat Bread and Roasted Artichoke and Asiago Cheese bread.
Multiple Locations: The Amboy Road shop is one of two locations on Staten Island (the other being on Victory Boulevard), providing more access points for loyal New York customers.

What is Worth Choosing

For anyone in the New York area looking for an authentic and reliable bakery, Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe represents a fusion of old-world Italian baking passion and modern convenience. The primary reason for choosing Alfonso's is its deeply rooted history and the consistency of its core, traditional products. The Cannoli is a must-try item—it’s an iconic Italian pastry that the bakery is built upon, known for its rich, house-made cream, often containing chocolate chips and citron. Beyond the creamy classics, their cookie trays are an essential purchase for any New York gathering or holiday. The ability to order a tray of mixed Italian butter cookies, including the celebrated Rainbow Cookies and luxurious Pignoli Cookies, takes the stress out of planning for guests. Furthermore, for major life events, the expertise in custom-designed cakes, whether a classic Tiramisu or a customized multi-layer birthday cake, ensures a beautiful and delicious centerpiece for any celebration. The availability of fresh Italian bread, like the Round Semolina or the unique Meat Bread, also makes it a perfect stop for those looking to complement their savory meals. Alfonso's is more than just a bakery; it's a piece of Staten Island’s heart, ready to add sweetness to your day.

Contact Information

Address: 4366 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA

Phone: (718) 984-8011

Mobile Phone: +1 718-984-8011

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe Menu

Breads
We offer fresh bread made daily in a variety of shapes and sizes perfect for everyone's needs
Round Semolina $4.95
Round Peasant $4.95
light and airy on the inside hard and crispy on the outside also known as Old Fashioned
Marble Rye $4.75
Only on holidays
Rye $4.75
seeded or plain
Pumpernickel $4.25
Olive $5.75
Old fashioned bread generously filled with black olives
Meat $6.25
A customer favorite- this bread is packed with prosciutto, salami, ham, and provolone
Roasted Artichoke and Asiago Cheese $5.75
The name says it all! Slow roasted artichokes and asiago cheese make the perfect combination in this specialty bread
Large Twist $4.95
Our most popular bread, customers can't resist this one. Perfect for sandwiches or dipping in sauce!
French $2.75
Classic baguette
Peasant Loaf $2.95
Semolina Loaf $2.80
Multigrain $4.75
Whole Wheat $4.25
Large Italian $4.50
Italian $2.60
We can't make this fast enough- it flies of the shelves. Tuesday through Saturday its on special 2 loaves for $3!
White Bread $3.50

Rolls
Variety of rolls perfect for sandwiches, barbecues, or Sunday Sauce!
Peasant $1.00
Weekends and holidays only
Club $1.00
Not carried in the store, but can be made to order
Kaiser $0.80
Made fresh daily, come in plain or poppy seeded
Dinner $0.50
weekends and holidays only

Specialty Breads
We also make certain specialty breads if they are ordered a few days in advance. Please call for pricing and availability
Panelli
St. Anthony
3/4 Ft Heroes

Cookies
Black and White Cookies $2.25
Linzer Tarts $2.00
Classic linzer tart filled with raspberry jam
Sugar Cookies $1.75
A variety of large cookies made with chocolate chips, multi-colored sprinkles, M&Ms, and double chocolate

Butter Cookies
Our butter cookie showcase is filled with everyone's favorite class Italian cookies plus a nice variety of current favorites
Rainbow Cookies $17.00
A constant fan favorite, filled with apricot jam
Pignoli Cookies $26.00
This almond paste based cookie is topped with Italy's finest pignoli nuts. Containing no flour ingredients, this cookie is naturally gluten free
Amaretti Cookies $17.00
This almond paste cookie is dusted with granulated sugar. Light and satisfying, it contains no flour making it a perfect treat for those gluten sensitive
Mini Linzer Tarts $17.00
Chocolate Dot $17.00
Not carried in showcase, but can be provided for by request
1/2 Dipped Jelly Sandwich $17.00
This cookie sandwich is filled with raspberry jam and dipped halfway in smooth chocolate
Chocolate Buttercream Sandwich $17.00
This cookie sandwich is filled with chocolate buttercream and a light drizzle of chocolate on top
Apricot Sandwich $17.00
This cookie sandwich is filled with apricot jam and is covered with chopped peanuts or almonds. Please ask your salesgirl if there is an allergy
Jelly Dot with Chocolate Drizzle $17.00
This cookie is not carried in the showcase at all times, but can be requested
Dutch Boys $17.00
Every child's favorite, these dutch boys come in chocolate or vanilla and are sandwiched together
1/2 Dipped Sprinkle Cookies $17.00
These cookies are an Alfonso's staple and come in three varieties. The sprinkles vary depending on holiday and season
Quarazemali $17.00
A small vanilla biscotti filled chunks of almonds, perfect for dipping coffee
Calcagnoli $17.00
Lace Cookie $17.00
Chocolate Covered Pretzels $17.00
Perfect combination of salty and sweet, our pretzels come in Oreo, M&M, Snow Cap, and Rainbow Non-pareils

Dietetic Butter Cookies
All cookies are $14 per pound. They are a perfect sugar-free treat
Raspberry Spritz
Oatmeal
Marble
Chocolate Chip
Orange Fan
Pistachio Leaf

Italian Biscuits
We carry all classic Italian biscuits for $9.60 per pound. Located on our back wall, we offer two full racks of over a dozen varieties
1/2 Dipped $9.60
Chocolate Sprinkle $9.60
Cherry Dot $9.60
1/2 Dipped Jelly Stick $9.60
Powdered Jelly Stick $9.60
Cucidatti $9.60
fig cookie
Multi Sprinkle $9.60
Lemon Drop $9.60
Seeded S $9.60
Plain S $9.60
Regina $9.60
Anisette $9.60
Vanilla Glazed $9.60

Gluten Free Cookies
We offer a small, but delicious variety of gluten free cookies. All cookies are prepared with separate baking utensils, but do share oven space with baked goods that contain flour. We take extra care in keeping all work space clean and flour free while preparing gluten free products. They are immediately packaged and appropriately labeled to avoid contamination
Gluten Free Butter Cookies $9.75
Made in three flavors: half-dipped chocolate, jelly sticks, and multi-colored sprinkle and prepared with gluten free flour, they closely resemble our classic butter cookies
Gluten Free Rainbow Cookies $9.75
This cookie emulates the Italian classic so well you would never know the difference!

Large Pastries
A wide variety of beautifully handcrafted pastries made fresh daily. Regularly $3.50 per piece, we run a special Tuesday- Saturday: Buy 12 or more for $2.50 per piece
Cannolis
The world's best! This Italian classic is what put us on the map and continues to bring customers in from everywhere
Sfoghiatelli
Lovingly known as the "clam shell" this Italian classic is handmade and filled by our talented bakers
Pasticiotti
These little pies come with a rich crust and three types of filling: vanilla, chocolate, or cheese. Don't be put off by the cheese! It's comparable to an Easter grain pie
Lobster Tails $5.00
Refrigerated with our large pastries these lobster tails are in a class of their own. Generously filled with cannoli cream or custard, they weigh in at a half pound each!
Whipped Cream Puffs
Large puffs stuffed with whipped cream and topped with a cherry and drizzled chocolate
Cream Puffs
Custard cream filled puffs
Cappuccino Mousse
A coffee lovers dream! Chocolate cake layered with cappuccino mousse filling this packs a nice coffee flavored punch
Peach Melba
A beautifully topped peach and raspberry delight
Baba Rums
Swimming in rum, this Italian classic comes plain or filled with cannoli cream or custard
Rainbow Cannoli
The name says it all! This a perfect pairing of everyone's favorites
Eclair
Traditional pastry covered in chocolate and filled with custard
Napoleon
Another fan favorite, this flaky and delicate pastry dough is layered with French cream and topped with a marble fondant icing
Red Velvet
This cake recently became a popular seller in the store and can now be found in slices. Filled with homemade cream cheese icing this beautiful pastry is the perfect size for just a taste of the popular cake
Cheesecakes
Our individual cheesecakes come in cupcake form and are refrigerated with our large pastries. Topped with a variety of fruit flavors, this creamy delight is also gluten free
Chocolate Mousse
A mini version of the chocolate lover's cake this pastry is a slice of chocolaty heaven

Mini Pastries
Our mini pastries are offered with a bit more of a selection than our large. Offering a few more choices, they are $2 per piece. This deal offers them at $1.75 per piece Tuesday- Saturday when purchasing a dozen or more. For descriptions please see the Large Pastries section
Cannoli
Napoleon
Cream Puff
Whipped Cream Puff
Eclair
Sfoghiatelli
Peach Melba
Red Velvet
Chocolate Mousse
Cappuccino Mousse
Rainbow Cannoli
Carrot Cake
This pastry is only found in mini. It is the perfect carrot cake filled with walnuts and raisins and iced with out homemade cream cheese frosting
Swiss Layer
This chocolate almond cake is only found in the minis and is layered with pistachio and strawberry cream
Chocolate Almond Ball
This beautiful combination of chocolate and almond paste is covered in chocolate curls

Pies
Apple $12.75
Our apple pie is filled with our homemade filling and light, buttery crust
Apple Crumb $12.75
Generously filled with our homemade apple filling and topped with our cinnamon crumbs
Blueberry Crumb $12.75
Blueberry and house made crumbs unite to create this flavor filled pie loaded with blueberries and topped with our famous crumbs
Lemon Meringue $13.75
This light lemony delight is topped with house made meringue to create the perfect pie
Pumpkin
Take a bite into fall with our always popular pumpkin pie. Customers anxiously await the return of our pumpkin pie every fall! Please call during season for pricing
Coconut Custard
Coconut lovers unite for this fall treat! Made solely during the fall and winter months this pie is a best seller at Thanksgiving. Filled with a coconut custard and a sugary coconut topping this is the perfect holiday pie. Please call during season for pricing
Grain
The famous Easter pie is made two weeks before Palm Sunday until two weeks after Easter Sunday. Sold in slices and varying pie sizes this crowd favorite sells out fast during the Lenten season. Please call the store during season for pricing
Banana Cream Pie $17.95
Our banana cream pie is an overload of fresh bananas and fresh cream. Made year round, this pie has a generous whipped cream topping
Chocolate Cream Pie $17.95
Our chocolate cream pie is loaded with chocolate custard and whipped cream. Perfect for any occassion this pie is made year round

Cakes
Chocolate Chip Sour Cream $14.75
This best seller is made year round and doesn't have to be refrigerated. The sour cream may throw some off, but it is used simply to create a light and moist cake. Created over 5 years ago this cake sells out on every holiday!
Apple Ring $14.75
Originally created for the fall only, this cakes growing popularity caused us to keep it on the menu year round. A light, moist vanilla cake is the base of this apple filled ring. Topped with cinnamon crumbs and a glazed icing, this cake is loved by all
Chocolate Chocolate Chip Ring $14.75
This chocolate lovers dream is made in the winter months only. The chocolate based cake is filled with chocolate chips, then topped with chocolate crumbs and a chocolate drizzle
Plantation Ring $12.75
This simple crumb cake is perfect for with a cup of coffee or a quick dessert. Pleasing both chocolate and vanilla fans this cake is made seasonally
Apple Cheese Crumb Cake $14.75
This cake has been a staple for over 20 years. Filled with a baker's cheese and apple pie filling it is perfect for those who enjoy more filing and less crust. Topped with cinnamon crumbs and powdered sugar this will delight many

Layer Cakes
Chocolate or Vanilla Cake $18.75
Customers have a choice of either chocolate or vanilla cake. Both come with a chocolate butter cream filling and chocolate ganache topping. During the holidays we turn these into our popular holiday layer cakes
Red Velvet $18.75
Our red velvet cake is layered between our house made cream cheese filling in a perfect balance of cake and filling
7 Layer $18.75
Made in the winter months only this cake is artfully created to have 7 thin layers of sponge cake soaked in rum, 7 thin layers of buttercream, and a chocolate ganache topping
Blackout $18.75
This chocolatey delight is filled with a chocolate pudding to create the perfect, but light chocolate layer cake
Chocolate Fudge $18.75
The name says it all! Not for the faint of heart, this fudge filled chocolaty delight is perfect for serious chocolate lovers

Cheesecakes
Cream Cheese $15.50
Our famous cream cheese is a best seller regardless of the holiday or time of year. Selling out at every holiday, this cheese cake is flourless and crustless also making it gluten free
Sugar Free $18.50
This is perfect for those watching their sugar. Not too big, but just enough to share
Italian $16.50
With a creamy ricotta filling and small pieces of citron this Italian classic will please everyone
Marble $16.00
Swirls of chocolate cheesecake mixed in make this cheesecake a fan favorite
Raspberry Chocolate Mousse $18.50
The perfect combination of cheesecake, chocolate cake, and raspberry swirl this cheesecake has been a fan favorite for almost five years
Pumpkin $18.50
A mouthwatering combination of our cheesecake and pumpkin pie this cheesecake is a fan favorite during Thanksgiving. Also gluten free, this cheesecake is carried from Halloween to Thanksgiving
Strawberry $25.75
Made year round this beautiful creation is generously topped with glazed strawberries and fresh whipped cream. Always a crowd pleaser it is perfect for any occasion
Oreo $18.50
Our original cheesecake filled with crushed Oreos giving it an extra crunch

Specialty Cakes
Fruit Tarts $24.50
Masterfully designed with a fresh fruit topping, this tart shell is filled with vanilla custard. Covered in peaches, blueberries, strawberries, kiwis, and bananas this beautifully made tart is perfect for any occasion
Tiramisu $27.50
This classic dessert is artfully created with house made lady finger and our outstanding filling. The perfect combination of mascarpone cheese, cream cheese, and whipped cream is filled into coffee and masala wine soaked sponge cake
Cappuccino Mousse $29.50
This chocolate cake is filled with cappuccino mousse and sweet and satisfying layer of caramel on top. Decorated artfully with white chocolate curls this is the perfect cake for the coffee lover in your life
Chocolate Mousse $29.50
Chocolate cake layered with chocolate mousse create yet satisfying cake for all
Napoleon Strip $20.75
Flaky pastry dough layered with our delicious French cream makes this strip cake the larger version of its pastry counterpart. Topped with crumbs and pastry sugar it is perfect for the napoleon lover
Strawberry Shortcake $22.75
A fresh and light dessert the shortcake is made of fresh sponge cake, fresh strawberries, and fresh whipped cream

Birthday Cakes
Buttercream Birthday Cakes $23.50
Our buttercream birthday cakes are perfect for 7-10 people. Offering a nice selection, customers can choose from: Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream and a strawberry filling Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream and chocolate filling Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream Vanilla cake with chocolate buttercream
6" Whipped Cream Birthday Cakes $23.50
This is the perfect small birthday cake serving up to six people. Customer's choice of: Sponge cake with cannoli cream and chocolate cream Sponge cake with strawberries and chocolate cream
7" Whipped Cream Birthday Cakes $26.00
These cakes will feed 7-9 people and come in the same varieties as the 6" birthday cake
6" Cannoli Birthday Cake $26.50
This cannoli filled birthday cake has sponge cake soaked in rum and is covered in whipped cream

Cupcakes
Standard Vanilla and Chocolate Cupcakes $2.50
Covered in chocolate or vanilla buttercream frosting these cupcakes are decorated for children and adults!
Oreo Cupcake $2.50
Chocolate cupcake frosted with vanilla buttercream and topped with an oreo
Red Velvet Cupcake $2.50
Made just like the cake and the pastry!

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe Details

Service options
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance

Amenities
Restroom

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe Photos

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe Location

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe

New York Richmond County Eltingville Amboy Road

4366 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA

Alfonso's Pastry Shoppe Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 294 user reviews.

cannolipricescheesecakeislanditalianpiedonutsrainbowsemolinalobster

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Fantastic bakery! One of the BEST. My family stops here for pastries, bread, and other delicious desserts whenever we’re in Staten Island.
September 08 · Anthony M
The place is a neighborhood staple and I refrained from writing this review for a couple days because the kids that work in there are sweethearts, but I’ve been burned more then once now…for starters it seems like whoever is running the place whether it’s a manager or the owner I couldn’t tell you but regardless he’s a miserable person thankfully, he isn’t in there too often so you don’t have to see that depressed mug or hear him talk to the girls like crap too often & the bulldog walking around like she’s in the iron workers union, like she’s back there building a high rise, calm down you’re baking cookies… sometimes I go in & there’s either one of them walking around And talking like They are doing you a favor serving you there semi stale products at three times the amount they should be charging…. Listen, I have no problem spending good money on goods & services as long as you get what you’re paying for… But these guys definitely push the limits of “fresh” on some of their items & When you’re having guests it’s embarrassing if stuff is beyond a day or two old and lost it’s zest so to speak… anyway, I’ve been biting my tongue for month's. My wife keeps sending me there even though I tell her I hate spending money there but after this past weekend, I’m done, enough is enough. I’ll take the ride to a further bakery At least I know I’m getting fresh stuff from people that appreciate your business and not act like they just did you a solid slinging you some sour cheese cake and gravel topped crumb cake. Respectfully, Get your acts together and stop being complacent…
September 14 · Rece Rock
Has been a part of the neighborhood for years. The products they produce are well made and we never had an issue.The fresh breads are great. We particularly love the Meat Bread.Prices are extremely high (40 dollars for a 2 pound of cookie tray). A 5 pound tray had a price of 98 bucks!!!! INSANE Personally I think bakery prices are way too high recently,The staff are very friendly and helpful.Owner or manager seems very hands on and looking for improvements.
May 27 · Joseph Iacono
Bought an apple crumb cake here today (4-5-25). Brought it home, cut into it, MOLD.
April 05 · Michael Murphy
Delicious Gluten Free cookie and rainbow cake. Please make more!!!
May 03 · Jason Krebs