Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette | East Side

Introduction / Overview

For Wisconsin residents craving an authentic, high-quality bagel experience that rivals the best of the coasts, **Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette** on Milwaukee's East Side has firmly established itself as the premier destination. This isn't your average quick-stop shop; it's a full-service luncheonette dedicated to the craft of hand-rolled, boiled, and baked bagels, served alongside classic Jewish-American deli favorites and inventive, house-made specialties.

Located in a spacious venue that is reportedly double the size of their original location, Allie Boy’s offers a welcoming atmosphere for dine-in guests, perfect for a relaxed breakfast or lunch. Their reputation is built on the incredible freshness of their product—customers frequently rave about having the "Freshest bagels we’ve had!!" and note that this is the place that will "spoil us from going anywhere else." The core menu features single bagels, a half dozen, or the full baker's dozen, ready to be paired with an extensive array of house-made schmears, from the simple **Plain Cream Cheese** and luxurious **Whipped Honey Butter** to the gourmet **Roasted Shallot Cream Cheese** and decadent **Smoked Salmon & Sesame** blend.

The luncheonette side of the menu takes the experience far beyond a simple cream cheese spread. Patrons can indulge in signature bagel sandwiches, savory 'Noshes' like the famous **The Big Latke Waffle**, and comforting classics like **Bubbe's Matzoh Ball Soup**. This commitment to both high-quality baking and classic deli fare—rooted in Jewish culture and New York-style dining—makes Allie Boy’s a unique and essential stop for food lovers across Wisconsin. However, a word to the wise from dedicated patrons: be sure to arrive early, as the high-demand bagels are known to **sell out!**

Location and Accessibility

The East Side location of Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette is conveniently situated at **2100 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202, USA**. This address places the shop in one of Milwaukee's most vibrant and walkable neighborhoods, making it a perfect spot to start a weekend or refuel during the work week.

Accessibility is a priority at this location, ensuring a comfortable experience for all Wisconsin visitors. The premises feature a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, **Wheelchair accessible seating**, and a **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, allowing for a pleasant **Dine-in** experience. For those arriving by vehicle, the location offers the dual convenience of a **Free parking lot** and readily available **Free street parking**, which is a significant advantage in this bustling part of the city. Whether you're planning a full sit-down meal or a **Quick visit** for **Takeout** or **In-store pickup**, the location and parking options make a stop at Allie Boy's seamless. The business also accommodates modern payment preferences, accepting both **Credit cards** and **Debit cards**.

Services Offered

• Artisan Bagel Sales: Selling fresh, hand-rolled, boiled, and baked bagels individually, by the **Half Dozen**, or as a **Baker's Dozen** ($2.50 per **Single Bagel**).
• Gourmet Schmear Selection: Providing an extensive menu of both classic and inventive, house-made cream cheese and butter options, including **Vegan Cream Cheese**, **Pesto Cream Cheese**, **Labneh & Herb Cream Cheese**, and **Whipped Honey Butter**.
• Signature Bagel Sandwiches: Crafting a full menu of hearty bagel sandwiches for **Breakfast** and lunch, such as the classic **Egg & Cheese** options, the acclaimed **The Classic** (with Nova Lox), and the unique **Pastrami Chop Cheese**.
• Deli & Luncheonette Items: Offering traditional Jewish-style deli favorites and inventive dishes, including 'Noshes' like **Bubbe's Matzoh Ball Soup**, **The Big Latke Waffle**, and the **Tamago Egg Salad Tartine**.
• House-Made Deli Sides: Selling quality deli items and spreads by the container, such as **Ma Cohen's Nova Lox**, **Whitefish Salad**, **Garlic & Herb Schmaltz**, and even bottles of their **House Made Hot Sauce** and **Allie Boy's Everything Spice**.
• Full Beverage Menu: Featuring a range of drinks, including **Hot Drip Coffee**, **Iced Coffee**, **Espresso** drinks, various teas, **Chocolate Egg Cream**, and local **Sassy Cow Chocolate Milk**.
• Baked Goods & Sweets: Offering fresh-baked pastries and desserts like **Rugelach**, **S'mores Babka Muffin**, **Coconut Macaroon**, and the indulgent **Fried Lavender Sugar Bagel**.
• Pet-Friendly Option: Thoughtfully providing a **Doggie Bagel Treat** for customers visiting with their four-legged friends.

Features / Highlights

• Authentic Hand-Rolled Bagels: Allie Boy's is celebrated for creating what many consider the 'Milwaukee-style bagel,' offering a softer yet still perfectly chewy and flavorful alternative to the hard, crunchy New York extremes, baked fresh daily with Wisconsin-milled flour.
• The 'Luncheonette' Experience: Goes far beyond a typical bagel shop by offering a full deli menu rooted in Jewish-American cuisine, highlighted by items like **Bubbe's Matzoh Ball Soup**, **The Big Latke Waffle**, and the beloved **The Classic** lox sandwich.
• Gourmet and Creative Menu: The menu features genuinely inventive and high-quality items, from the array of creative schmears (**Roasted Shallot Cream Cheese**, **Bacon Jam**) to specialty sandwiches like the **Pastrami Chop Cheese** and the **Smoked Whitefish Salad Sando**.
• Impressive Vegan and Dairy Alternatives: Caters well to dietary needs with readily available **Vegan Cream Cheese** and a wide selection of milk substitutes for their extensive **Coffee** and espresso offerings.
• High Volume and Popularity: The East Side location is notably larger and incredibly popular, a clear sign of customer satisfaction, but requires early visits due to the high demand and potential for items to **sell out**.
• Excellent Customer Favorites: Specific menu items like **The Classic** lox bagel and the **Pastrami Chop Cheese** are highly recommended by local food critics and repeat customers for their quality and generous portions.
• Comfortable and Accessible Dining: Features a large **Dine-in** area with **Wheelchair accessible seating** and restrooms, making it a great destination for a relaxed meal, complemented by the ease of **Free parking**.

Contact Information

Address: 2100 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202, USA

Phone: (414) 988-0388

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette is choosing to invest in Milwaukee's thriving, independent food scene and to experience what many locals now consider to be the gold standard for bagels in the region. What is truly worth choosing here is the combination of impeccable baking quality and the creative, high-end deli concept.

First and foremost, the bagel itself is the star. It's the reason satisfied patrons claim they won't go anywhere else. This is not the chewy-to-a-fault bagel of other regions; Allie Boy's version is celebrated for being supremely fresh, with a pleasant "crunch yet soft insides" that is perfect for a sandwich. For a first-timer, diving into a specialty sandwich is a must. Options like **The Classic**—with house-cured Nova Lox, capers, dill, and the tangy **Labneh & Herb Cream Cheese**—are frequently cited as 'incredible' and a taste of authentic New York-style deli fare right here in Wisconsin. The **Pastrami Chop Cheese** is another fan-favorite for its satisfying, savory punch.

Furthermore, the shop's commitment to house-made quality extends to every detail, from the massive variety of innovative schmears to the scratch-made sides and sweets. Where else in Milwaukee can you grab a bagel with **Almond Praline Butter** and a perfectly seasoned **Bubbe's Matzoh Ball Soup** for lunch? The spacious, accessible, and fast-service environment, complete with guaranteed **Free parking**, seals the deal. Allie Boy’s offers a complete, delightful, and authentic experience that solidifies its status as a top-tier breakfast and lunch destination on the East Side of MKE.

Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette | East Side

2100 N Farwell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202, USA