Amish Bakery

Hello, dedicated Wisconsin food adventurers! While the state is rich with fantastic bakeries, few offer the unique experience and authentic quality found at the **Amish Bakery** in Readstown. Located in the beautiful, winding roads of the Vernon County area, this establishment is more than just a place to buy baked goods—it’s a true local "secret," known primarily by those who live in the community or who have received directions from a friendly neighbor. The journey to this hidden gem adds to the appeal, promising a reward of handcrafted perfection that is truly worth the effort.

The moment you find this unassuming location on Parsonage Rd, you are stepping into a world where quality, tradition, and simple, honest ingredients reign supreme. This **Bakery** specializes in the comforting classics that define home baking at its best. According to satisfied patrons, bakers Elizabeth and Berta are responsible for crafting "the best pies and cakes & more," a testament to their skill and dedication. But the offerings go beyond the traditional sweet treats. In a surprising and valuable twist, this local operation also sells **homemade pasta and sauces**, making it a fantastic stop for preparing an entire, high-quality, handcrafted meal.

The experience is defined by the limited hours and the sense of discovery. This is a very special destination, open only on **Fridays and Saturdays** during the primary season, and switching to **special orders only in the winter**. This limited availability underscores the dedication to freshness and small-batch production, ensuring that every pie, cake, or dozen cookies is made with the utmost care. As one reviewer noted, the search is part of the fun: "had a bit of an adventure finding it" but the reward, especially the **WONDERFUL fry pies (or hand pies, depending)**, makes it a "must stop if you’re in the area!!" For locals and those exploring the scenic Driftless Area, this bakery represents a direct connection to authentic, traditional Wisconsin baking and craftsmanship. The homemade pasta and handcrafts also provide valuable, unique products that you won't find at a standard grocery store.

Location and Accessibility for Wisconsin Users

The Amish Bakery is located at **S8376 Parsonage Rd, Readstown, WI 54652, USA**. This address places it within the peaceful, rolling hills of Vernon County, a region famous for its Amish settlements and picturesque scenery. For most Wisconsin residents, a visit here will require a dedicated, scenic drive, but the promise of authentic, scratch-made goods makes the excursion a rewarding experience in itself.

Finding the Hidden Gem: Patrons often describe getting directions locally, reinforcing its status as a "secret" only known to locals. While GPS may guide you, embracing the small-town, local-knowledge aspect of the journey enhances the unique appeal. This is part of the charm of visiting businesses in the heart of Wisconsin's countryside—it feels like an adventure that leads to a genuine reward.

Simple Access: While specific accessibility details beyond the expected simplicity of a countryside operation are not provided, the location is designed for a direct "drop-in" nature. Parking is typically straightforward at such locations, allowing visitors to quickly and easily pick up their freshly baked treasures. The lack of elaborate retail infrastructure means the focus remains entirely on the quality of the product.

Specialized Services Offered to the Local Community

The services at the Amish Bakery are tailored to its unique operational schedule and commitment to traditional, handcrafted goods.

• Limited Retail Hours: Open only on **Fridays and Saturdays** for general sales, making it a weekend tradition for many local families.
• Custom/Special Orders: Operates on a **special orders only** basis during the winter, indicating a flexible and direct-to-customer service model for cakes, pies, and other baked goods for major events.
• Takeout Sales: The exclusive service option, focused entirely on providing fresh products to take home immediately.
• Homemade Savory Goods: Also offers **homemade pasta and sauces**, providing valuable meal components alongside the baked goods.
• Handcraft Sales: Sells **handcrafts**, providing visitors with unique, locally made items in addition to the food.

Features and Highlights - The Authentic Amish Quality

The key draw of the Amish Bakery is the uncompromising quality and traditional methods employed by the bakers.

• "Best Pies and Cakes": Praised highly by customers, specifically naming Elizabeth and Berta as the talented bakers behind the superior pies and cakes.
• The Fry Pie Experience: The **WONDERFUL fry pies (or hand pies)** are noted as a signature, must-try item, representing a classic, portable Amish treat.
• Unique Product Mix: Offers a valuable combination of baked goods, **homemade pasta and sauces**, and **handcrafts**, making it a multi-purpose stop for quality, locally-made items.
• Commitment to Freshness: The limited, weekend-only schedule ensures that all products sold are freshly baked, maximizing flavor and quality.
• Authentic Local Experience: Provides a genuine "secret" atmosphere known mostly to locals, giving visitors a rewarding sense of discovery and connection to the local culture.
• Traditional Value: The expectation with Amish baking is high-quality ingredients and generous portions at a value that reflects a simple, honest pricing structure.

Contact Information for the Amish Bakery

Due to the nature of an Amish business, contact methods may be traditional. Here is the essential information for planning your visit or special order:

Address: S8376 Parsonage Rd, Readstown, WI 54652, USA

Phone: (608) 935-3812 (Note: This number is often a shared or centralized line for Amish businesses in the area, but is the most reliable contact provided.)

We encourage Wisconsin residents planning a visit, especially during the off-season, to call ahead to discuss their **special orders** for cakes or pies.

What Is Worth Choosing at the Amish Bakery

For Wisconsin residents, choosing the Amish Bakery is a vote for authenticity, tradition, and uncompromising quality over mass production. What is truly worth choosing here is the **taste of genuine, handcrafted excellence**—the kind of baking passed down through generations.

You are choosing the "best pies and cakes," and an opportunity to sample the famous **fry pies** that are described as "WONDERFUL." You're also getting the added benefit of stocking up on other authentic goods, like their **homemade pasta and sauces**, providing a taste of the region's rich culinary traditions that you can take home. The limited hours and seasonal nature of the operation are not inconveniences; they are a guarantee that the product you receive is fresh, seasonal, and made with personal care by bakers Elizabeth and Berta.

Finally, you are choosing a unique local experience—an "adventure" that results in finding a "secret" community gem. For those exploring the beauty of Vernon County, making the stop on a Friday or Saturday is a rewarding cultural and culinary experience. It is a definite "must stop" that connects you directly to the simple, high-quality life found in the heart of rural Wisconsin.

Amish Bakery

S8376 Parsonage Rd, Readstown, WI 54652, USA