Bagelmakers

Introduction / Overview

For the Wyoming resident, particularly those navigating the fast pace of Laramie life, Bagelmakers at 252 N 3rd St is far more than a morning stop; it is a beloved local institution built on the principle of authentic, old-world baking. This establishment stands out in the Laramie food scene by adhering to the traditional method of bagel creation: the dough is first boiled, then baked on a stone hearth. This critical process is what gives their bagels that distinctively crunchy crust and wonderfully chewy interior—a texture and flavor profile that sets them apart from mass-produced alternatives.

Bagelmakers caters to a diverse set of needs, seamlessly blending the best elements of a true bagel shop, a hearty breakfast restaurant, a quick-service fast food spot, and a full-fledged sandwich shop, including catering as a Box lunch supplier. Whether you are craving a simple, freshly baked Cinnamon Raisin bagel with an extra generous slather of cream cheese, or a substantial meal to fuel a day in the high plains, Bagelmakers has perfected the art of the bagel-based meal.

Their menu extends well beyond the classics, offering a variety of house-made cream cheese spreads—with flavors like Jalapeño Red Pepper and Honey Walnut—and a selection of hot breakfast sandwiches, most notably the fan-favorite Farmers Special, built with your choice of savory meat, egg, and cheese. By focusing on fresh preparation and generous portions, as noted by enthusiastic local customers, Bagelmakers has successfully cemented its reputation as a must-visit spot for quality and satisfaction in downtown Laramie, ensuring every Wyomingite gets a truly great bagel experience.

Location and Accessibility

Bagelmakers is centrally and conveniently located in the heart of downtown Laramie at 252 N 3rd St, Laramie, WY 82072, USA. This central positioning makes it easily reachable for residents and visitors alike, whether they are working in the downtown core, running errands, or simply looking for a quality breakfast or lunch while exploring the city.

The establishment is highly accessible, a key factor for any successful downtown business. Accessibility features include a wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring smooth entry for all patrons. Additionally, the location provides both a free parking lot and free street parking options nearby. This combination of parking choices—especially the free parking lot—helps mitigate some of the typical downtown parking difficulties, making a quick visit truly achievable for those arriving by car.

The location’s ease of access, combined with its central spot on 3rd Street, means that whether you are walking, driving, or utilizing an accessibility device, getting in and out for a quality meal is designed to be as seamless and convenient as possible. It is perfectly positioned for those on a tight schedule who need a quality meal without the hassle.

Services Offered

Bagelmakers provides a comprehensive range of service options designed to fit the busy schedules of Laramie residents and visitors, focusing on speed and convenience:

• Dine-in: Customers are welcome to enjoy their freshly baked bagels, sandwiches, and coffee in the friendly, casual atmosphere of the shop.
• Takeout: For those in a hurry, efficient counter service allows for quick and easy ordering and pickup to take your meal on the go.
• In-store Pickup: Orders placed ahead—via phone or online through delivery partners—can be picked up quickly inside the store, minimizing wait times during peak hours.
• Delivery: Partnering with local delivery services allows customers across the Laramie area to enjoy the full menu, from hot breakfast to cold sandwiches, delivered directly to their home or office.
• Box Lunch Supplier: The shop’s ability to function as a sandwich and box lunch supplier makes it an excellent choice for local businesses, university departments, and events needing quality, individually packaged meals for a group.

Features / Highlights

What truly makes Bagelmakers a standout in the Wyoming region are its unique operational methods and popular menu items:

• Authentic Boiling and Baking Process: The core highlight is the traditional method used to prepare the bagels—they are boiled before being baked on a stone hearth, which is responsible for the coveted crunchy exterior and satisfyingly chewy interior.
• The Farmers Special: A highly popular and much-raved-about signature breakfast item, featuring a choice of bacon, ham, or sausage with egg and cheese on a fresh bagel.
• Generous Cream Cheese Portions: As noted by satisfied customers, the shop is known for being generous with its shmears, ensuring you get a fully coated and flavorful bagel experience.
• Specialty Deli Sandwiches: Beyond breakfast, the shop excels as a sandwich provider, offering specialty cold cuts like the "NYC" (Lox and cream cheese) and "Mile High" (a towering club sandwich) on their fresh bagels.
• Convenient Parking and Payments: The availability of both a free parking lot and free street parking, coupled with acceptance of Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, makes the logistics of a quick stop exceptionally smooth.

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about daily specials, or ask about box lunch options for your next event, please use the following contact details:

Address: 252 N 3rd St, Laramie, WY 82072, USA

Phone: (307) 721-7000

Mobile Phone: +1 307-721-7000

What is Worth Choosing

For the discerning Wyomingite, choosing Bagelmakers in Laramie comes down to an appreciation for quality, tradition, and a genuinely friendly local experience. What is most worth choosing is the shop’s unwavering commitment to the authentic, *boiled-and-baked bagel*. This traditional preparation method is a rarity and results in a superior product—a crunchy crust and dense, chewy interior—that simply cannot be matched by other methods. If you value a true bagel, Bagelmakers delivers on that promise every single time.

Beyond the bagel itself, the value of Bagelmakers is found in the combination of menu depth and customer care. The breakfast menu, anchored by the beloved Farmers Special, is substantial, providing a hearty, protein-packed start to the day. For lunch, the transformation into a deli and sandwich shop means you can get specialty creations like the Reuben or the NYC on that same fresh, high-quality bagel base. Customers consistently praise the staff for being "kind and patient," creating a fun and welcoming environment that elevates the entire experience. This focus on both product quality and positive interactions makes it a true local gem.

The logistical ease is also a major benefit worth choosing. The availability of free parking and all modern payment methods (including NFC) ensures that a "Quick visit" is genuinely quick and hassle-free, which is essential for busy Laramie professionals and families. Whether you need a dozen for the office or a satisfying breakfast for yourself, Bagelmakers offers an unparalleled blend of convenience, quality ingredients, and a truly authentic taste of the old-world bagel tradition right here in the heart of Wyoming.

Bagelmakers

252 N 3rd St, Laramie, WY 82072, USA