Bake Share Introduce
Nestled in the heart of Grayslake, IL, **Bake Share** stands out not just as a local bakery, but as a beloved community hub renowned for delivering some of the most exceptional pies and baked goods in the entire Illinois region. Described by enthusiastic local customers as the home of the **"World's Greatest Key Lime Pie,"** this small business, led by the talented owner Michael, has successfully cultivated a loyal following that consistently praises the quality of the products and the genuine warmth of the service.
Bake Share’s specialty lies in mastering the art of the perfect pie, offering an incredible variety that includes not only signature sweet treats like the famous Key Lime and Pecan Pie, but also comforting savory options such as the classic **Beef & Ale** and **Chicken Pot Pie**. This dedication to quality is evident across their entire offering, which extends to large, freshly baked muffins, rich cinnamon buns, and a delightful assortment of cookies. Beyond retail, Bake Share also operates as a **Wholesale bakery**, serving local establishments and extending its reach across Lake County. This dual function underscores its commitment to high-volume, scratch-made quality.
Crucially, Bake Share is more than a place to pick up a treat; it is a truly **inclusive and welcoming space**. It proudly identifies as **LGBTQ+ friendly** and a **Transgender safespace**, offering a **gender-neutral restroom** and a friendly atmosphere where everyone is respected. Furthermore, the ability for customers to bring their **Dogs inside** makes it a unique and truly pet-friendly stop for a quick, casual visit. This combination of culinary excellence and community-focused values solidifies Bake Share as an essential local gem in Grayslake, IL.
Conveniently located in the charming downtown area of Grayslake, Bake Share offers a straightforward and stress-free visit for residents across Lake County. Its central address makes it an easy stop for a spontaneous treat or a pre-arranged pick-up.
The exact address is:
**827 Center St, Grayslake, IL 60030, USA**
The bakery is designed with customer ease in mind, ensuring accessibility and parking are never an issue for the busy Illinois customer.
Key accessibility and parking features include:
- **Wheelchair accessible entrance:** The storefront is easily accessible, providing a welcoming entry point for all patrons.
- **Wheelchair accessible parking lot:** Dedicated parking spaces are available, offering convenience and safety right near the entrance.
- **Free parking lot & On-site parking:** Ample parking is provided for a no-hassle visit, whether you are running in for a quick slice or picking up a large wholesale order.
- **Gender-neutral restroom:** This amenity enhances the comfortable and inclusive atmosphere of the establishment.
- **Planning:** The store is optimized for a **"Quick visit,"** ensuring that customers can efficiently grab their order and be on their way.
Bake Share provides a flexible range of services designed to meet both retail and business needs, from a simple cup of coffee to full-scale catering and wholesale supply.
The core services available at this Grayslake bakery include:
- **Wholesale Operations:** As a recognized **Wholesale bakery**, Bake Share supplies other local businesses with their high-quality, scratch-made goods, extending Michael’s famous recipes across the Lake County area.
- **Flexible Purchasing Options:** The shop supports convenient retail transactions through:
- **In-store shopping** (allowing customers to browse the daily-changing selection of fresh-baked goods).
- **Takeout** (for fast, easy on-the-go orders).
- **Order Fulfillment Services:** For pre-arranged and catering orders, customers can choose from:
- **In-store pickup** (ideal for large pie orders for events).
- **Delivery** (offering maximum convenience for corporate or remote customers).
- **Onsite services** (for customized large-volume needs, often associated with wholesale or major events).
- **Beverage Service:** The bakery offers **Coffee** alongside its sweet treats, making it a perfect spot for an afternoon break or morning refreshment.
- **Pet Accommodation:** Uniquely, **Dogs are allowed inside**, inviting pet owners to enjoy their treats without leaving their furry friends outside.
- **Modern Payment Methods:** To ensure fast and easy transactions, all major payment types are accepted: **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments**.
Bake Share’s highlights are a powerful combination of its signature, high-quality baking and its genuinely community-minded operation, making it a destination in the Illinois North Shore area.
The most compelling features and product highlights include:
- **The "World's Greatest" Pies:** The bakery is renowned for its **Gourmet Pie** selection. Customer reviews specifically call out the **Key Lime Pie** for its perfection and intense flavor. Other beloved pies include **French Silk, Pecan, Lemon Ice Box, Pumpkin, Cold Brew Coffee, and Savory Pies** like the **Beef & Ale**, showcasing an incredible range of flavor expertise.
- **Outstanding Gluten-Free Options:** Offering **Gluten-free options** (such as GF muffins) is a major feature, catering to customers with dietary sensitivities. This commitment to inclusion in their product line further demonstrates their dedication to serving the entire community.
- **Unwavering Commitment to Inclusivity:** The dedication to being a welcoming and safe environment is paramount. As an **LGBTQ+ friendly** and **Transgender safespace** with a **gender-neutral restroom**, Bake Share ensures a positive and respectful experience for all Illinois patrons.
- **Personal Touch and Friendly Service:** Owner Michael (Mike) is frequently highlighted in reviews as a **"seriously great dude"** who provides **"awesome customer service."** This personalized, friendly approach elevates the customer experience far above that of a standard chain store.
- **Perfect Portability and Size Options:** Customers can purchase pies in various convenient formats: a single **Slice of Pie ($7.95)** for immediate consumption, **"Pielets"** (5-inch mini pies) for individual gifts, or the classic 9-inch whole pies for events.
For inquiries regarding wholesale opportunities, special requests, or current pie flavor availability, please use the following contact details for this Grayslake, IL small business.
Address: 827 Center St, Grayslake, IL 60030, USA
Phone: (847) 356-1854
For residents of Illinois seeking a bakery that excels in both product quality and community spirit, **Bake Share** in Grayslake is the clear choice. It is worth choosing for the undisputed excellence of its baked goods—specifically, the legendary **Key Lime Pie** and other scratch-made gourmet pies that truly set a new local standard. The owner, Michael, and the entire friendly staff ensure that every visit is met with genuinely warm and helpful customer service, creating a welcoming neighborhood feel that large chains simply cannot replicate.
Beyond the taste, choosing Bake Share means supporting a small business that champions inclusivity, proudly operating as an **LGBTQ+ friendly** and **Transgender safespace** with a pet-friendly policy that allows **Dogs inside**. This ethical and community-focused approach adds significant value to every purchase. Whether you require **Gluten-free options**, need **Wholesale** quantities, or are simply looking for a slice of the best pie you've ever had, Bake Share provides a unique, high-quality, and deeply ethical destination that truly represents the best of local Illinois entrepreneurship and culinary talent.
Bake Share Details
From the business
- Small business
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Coffee
Amenities
- Gender-neutral restroom
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safespace
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free parking lot
- On-site parking
Pets
- Dogs allowed inside
Bake Share Photos










Bake Share Location
Bake Share Reviews
farmers marketpecan piecookieskey lime piechicken pot piecrustgluten freeapple pieoatmeal creme piesilk
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Looking for the world’s greatest key lime pie? Well, you found it!!!! Truly, Mike has managed to create the perfect key lime pie. It is so insanely good…The only downside is that you will never enjoy a key lime pie from somewhere else ever again 😆 We have also tried & loved the French silk, pumpkin, lemon ice box, apple pie, beef & ale….you really can’t go wrong. Gluten free options are a cherry on top. Very friendly staff and the owner Mike is a seriously great dude! Bake Share rules!!
August 17 · Katie AndrewsPecan pie is the best pie I have ever had.It is delicious. Michael gave us awesome customer service. You must try this pie. You too will be hooked!
August 21 · Diana AikenThis Bakery is special! They also offer Gluten free decadent delicious options. The creative flavors come from the super passionate mind of Micheal! This is local favorite. Especially if you do not want to bake but want real ingredients and homemade deliciously fresh desserts this is the place!!
July 01 · Tonya TalentedFirst time going today ive heard so much about this amazing pie shop! Michael is an amazingly sweet person! I'm so greatful to work so close! The pies are amazing! So far my top fav is the pear pie! It's so sweet and savory! Because of the wonderful amount he has i couldn't decide so I got alot of sample pies 🥰🥰🥰! Can't wait to show my family and friends how wonderful these pies are!! If you are in the area you NEED to check this place out! The price and the atmosphere 👌 ill be back very soon! Keep up the amazing job!!
February 23 · Lil Mits :3I picked up two pies this week, a cold brew coffee pie and an apple one. Well, this cold brew coffee pie is now my favorite. Omg it’s delicious. My kids who don’t like coffee even liked it. Can’t wait to try the apple pie. The owner is friendly and always welcomes my kids who have a thousand questions 😀
December 05 · V Koesema
More Bakery Near Me
393 Center Street4.0 (6 reviews)393 Center St, Grayslake, IL 60030, USA
Lee Donuts4.0 (345 reviews)124 Peterson Rd, Libertyville, IL 60048, USA
Mrs Fields4.0 (75 reviews)6170 W Grand Ave, Gurnee, IL 60031, USA
La Luz Bakery4.0 (428 reviews)500 N Lake St, Mundelein, IL 60060, USA
El Mana Bakery4.0 (7 reviews)500 N Lake St, Mundelein, IL 60060, USA
Tony Cannoli4.0 (248 reviews)460 N Lake St, Mundelein, IL 60060, USA
Duck Donuts4.0 (301 reviews)111 School St, Libertyville, IL 60048, USA
Nana's Rum Cakes4.0 (42 reviews)668 E Hawley St, Mundelein, IL 60060, USA
Karina's Bakery4.0 (546 reviews)401 N Seymour Ave, Mundelein, IL 60060, USA
Days Treats Brazilian Bakery4.0 (41 reviews)300 N Lake St, Mundelein, IL 60060, USA
Hewn Bakery - Libertyville Outpost4.0 (110 reviews)348 N Milwaukee Ave, Libertyville, IL 60048, USA
Gurnee Donuts4.0 (721 reviews)4949 Grand Ave #9A, Gurnee, IL 60031, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Rolled Out Bakery @ The Kitchen's Market4.0 (56 reviews)
Nothing Bundt Cakes4.0 (100 reviews)
Suspiros Cakes Thomas3.0 (19 reviews)
Walmart Bakery3.0 (2 reviews)
Krispy Kreme3.0 (1940 reviews)
Georgia French Bakery & Cafe4.0 (774 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
