Baker Sisters Introduce
Located right on the bustling 95th Street in Chicago, Illinois, Baker Sisters is more than just a place to buy sweets—it is a cherished, family-owned establishment where you can truly taste the "passion and love" poured into every treat. As a dedicated, specialized Bakery, Baker Sisters has built a strong reputation for offering handcrafted desserts made with high-quality ingredients like butter and heavy cream.
For the local Chicago community, Baker Sisters is particularly famous for a few signature, standout items. They have been critically recognized for serving "1 of 2 Best Caramel Cakes in Chicago," a testament to their light, fluffy recipe that satisfies without being overly dense. However, the passion project that truly captures the local heart is their legendary Banana Pudding, described by customers as having "so much flavor" in the rich, creamy custard, perfectly layered with vanilla wafers and fresh bananas. Additionally, classic treats such as their buttery Butter Cookies and homemade Peach Cobbler showcase their commitment to comfort and quality.
Emphasizing convenience for the busy Illinois customer, Baker Sisters provides flexible ways to enjoy their treats, including local Delivery and easy Takeout options, making a visit to this treasured establishment a simple and rewarding experience.
Baker Sisters is centrally located in the heart of Chicago on the West side of the city's 95th Street corridor, making it an easy destination for residents of the 60643 zip code and surrounding areas.
The physical address is: 1801 W 95th St, Chicago, IL 60643, USA.
As a specialized, focused bakery, Baker Sisters is designed for efficient service, catering to customers who are looking for a 'Quick visit.' While the general accessibility features of the immediate location are not fully listed in public data, the business is structured for easy transaction and quick service, allowing customers to promptly pick up pre-ordered items or grab a quick dessert.
For modern customer convenience, the bakery ensures payments are seamless, accepting:
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
This streamlined approach to payment ensures that the experience, whether you are picking up a pre-ordered cake or a last-minute craving of Banana Pudding, is as fast and efficient as possible for the local shopper.
Baker Sisters focuses on a curated selection of high-quality, signature baked goods and desserts, delivered with friendly, personalized service.
- Signature Caramel Cakes: Offering their recognized, light, and fluffy Caramel Cakes, available in full sizes and as individual cupcakes.
- Legendary Banana Pudding: Freshly made, rich, and flavorful Banana Pudding, often cited by customers as a key reason for their visit.
- Classic Southern Desserts: Specializing in comforting, homemade-style treats, including Butter Cookies by the dozen and seasonal items like Peach Cobbler.
- Custom Treats and Cupcakes: While they do not specialize in traditional Birthday Cakes, the bakery may be able to accommodate custom cupcake orders for special events. Customers are encouraged to contact them for catering for large gatherings like family reunions.
- Direct Ordering for Pickup: Customers are advised to place their orders ahead of time, especially for popular items, and schedule a convenient pickup time for efficient service.
- Local Delivery Service: Offering Delivery options, which is a key convenience for Chicago residents who may not be able to visit the 95th Street location in person.
- Takeout Service: Providing fast and friendly Takeout for all in-store or pre-ordered products.
The standout features of Baker Sisters revolve around their high-quality recipes, the personal touch of a family business, and their acclaimed signature items.
- Acclaimed Caramel Cake: The bakery has earned significant recognition, including being dubbed "1 of 2 of the best caramel cakes in Chicago" by WGN Radio, a major highlight for a locally focused business.
- Unmatched Banana Pudding: Their Banana Pudding is frequently highlighted in customer reviews as a must-try item, praised for its rich custard flavor, distinguishing it from standard recipes.
- Family-Owned and Operated: The business is run by a family, and customers often note that they can "taste the passion and love" in the treats, translating into warm customer service and consistent product quality.
- Focus on Signature Quality: By concentrating on a smaller, highly perfected menu of classics (Caramel Cake, Banana Pudding, Cookies), the Baker Sisters ensures an exceptional culinary experience with their core offerings.
- Streamlined Ordering for Speed: The service model prioritizes efficiency, with a focus on pre-ordered, scheduled pickup and 'Quick visit' transactions, respecting the valuable time of Chicago customers.
For Chicago residents looking to place an order, inquire about custom treats, or arrange a pickup, the Baker Sisters can be contacted using the following information:
Address: 1801 W 95th St, Chicago, IL 60643, USA
Phone: (773) 614-8224
Mobile Phone: +1 773-614-8224
Customers are encouraged to call ahead to place or confirm orders, especially for larger quantities, to ensure their favorite treats are available for pickup or delivery.
For Illinois residents in Chicago seeking authenticity, flavor, and a truly handcrafted dessert experience, Baker Sisters is the clear choice. You are choosing a business where baking is a passion passed down through a family, resulting in products that have earned critical acclaim. If you have been searching for the "best banana pudding" in Chicago, or an impressively "light and fluffy" Caramel Cake that avoids being overly heavy, this is the destination.
The focused menu guarantees exceptional quality in its signature items, and the personal, family-driven customer service creates a welcoming experience. While they offer modern conveniences like Delivery and easy mobile payments, the true value lies in the homemade taste and dedication to classic, comforting desserts. When you choose Baker Sisters on 95th Street, you are supporting a local Chicago business and ensuring your next craving for an authentic, passion-filled sweet treat is more than satisfied.
Baker Sisters Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Takeout
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Baker Sisters Photos





Baker Sisters Location
Baker Sisters
1801 W 95th St, Chicago, IL 60643, USA
Baker Sisters Reviews
caramel cakesundayvanillasweetcookies
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I have been craving banana pudding and I happened to catch some of their last batch. OMG I had to stop eating so fast 🤣 this has to be the best banana pudding I have had in a VERY long time. The actual pudding itself has so much flavor, the vanilla wafers and fresh bananas are just added bonuses. Craving Satisfied!Customer Service: They are family owned and operated and you can taste the passion and love in all the treats.You have to place your order and schedule pickup. They pleasantly greeted me with my order 🤗
July 20 · L StampleyToday 9/2/24 I bought the caramel cake from Pete’s Produce on 87th and Loomis it had a Best Buy date of 9/12/24. The cake looked absolutely amazing but the taste didn’t match the appearance. It was extremely dry on the inside, I mean no type of bounce back on the cake , no moisture at all. You can taste granulated sugar in the caramel, it’s extremely sweet but the caramel wasn’t nasty . Now I will say I haven’t tried the cake directly from the bakery so it may be worth trying to see if it’s moist vs Pete’s because I don’t know how Pete’s store the cakes. I only tried the cake because of the reviews. I’ll update the reviews after I try directly from the bakery.
September 02 · Sherri RainesI give kudos to this business for operating in uncertain financial times. However as a 20-year baker, I am disappointed with a caramel cake I purchased at Fairplay Foods in Chicago. The cake is headachy sweet and flavorless except for a taste of lots of sugar and imitation vanilla.Bad aftertaste. The caramel is an unappetizing crystalized graininess instead of a smoothness.
July 21 · R HeardThe caramel cake is phenomenal! Do not skip the "incredible candle"! Lots of oohs and ahhs from the group. For an extra touch, the butter cookies are awesome.
November 24 · Heather RandallThe absolute best cakes!! The caramel cake is by far my favorite! The ribs are delicious as well! Don’t walk, run to the Beverly Farmers Market to purchase your treats! Great selection of local vendors! Every Sunday 8am-1pm :-)
June 04 · Marissa Warren
More Bakery Near Me
Poppin Dough4.0 (311 reviews)1235 W 95th St, Chicago, IL 60643, USA
Meijer Bakery4.0 (11 reviews)9200 S Western Ave, Evergreen Park, IL 60805, USA
Wolf's Bakery4.0 (894 reviews)3241 95th St, Evergreen Park, IL 60805, USA
Kesha Kake Boutique5.0 (7 reviews)3345 W 95th St, Evergreen Park, IL 60805, USA
D&D's Place4.0 (509 reviews)8324 S Kedzie Ave, Chicago, IL 60652, USA
Pan Baguette4.0 (110 reviews)8325 S Pulaski Rd, Chicago, IL 60652, USA
Pies by Shine5.0 (8 reviews)W 71st St, Chicago, IL 60636, USA
Mondelu0113z International Chicago Bakery3.0 (334 reviews)7300 S Kedzie Ave, Chicago, IL 60629, USA
Dat Donut4.0 (1863 reviews)8251 S Cottage Grove Ave, Chicago, IL 60619, USA
Brown Sugar Bakery4.0 (2009 reviews)328 E 75th St, Chicago, IL 60619, USA
Pie Guys Bakery Presents Turkey Chop Gourmet Grill4.0 (88 reviews)7907 S Champlain Ave, Chicago, IL 60619, USA
8101u2606CHICAGO Cake Company0.0 (0 reviews)8101 S Kenneth Ave, Chicago, IL 60652, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
IFT Bakery3.0 (29 reviews)
Cupcakes Actually4.0 (49 reviews)
BJ's Wholesale Club4.0 (26 reviews)
Le Paris Bakery #24.0 (91 reviews)
Mercy's Daylight Donuts4.0 (202 reviews)
Suissa Bakery & Coffee Shop4.0 (183 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
