Beeman's Baked Goods

For those in Pennsylvania who cherish the rich culinary heritage of homemade, traditional baked goods, Beeman's Baked Goods in Carlisle offers an authentic and delightful experience. This is more than just a bakery; it's a testament to generations of family recipes and a commitment to crafting delicious treats from scratch. Specializing in Pennsylvania Dutch style baked goods, Beeman's brings a comforting taste of tradition right to our local community. In a world increasingly dominated by mass production, Beeman's stands out by offering products made with genuine care and time-honored methods.

This article is designed to introduce our fellow Pennsylvanians to the charm and deliciousness of Beeman's Baked Goods. We'll explore their dedication to using fresh, often local ingredients, the wide array of comforting favorites they offer, and the unique experience of visiting their Carlisle location. From their famous pies to their seasonal delights, Beeman's promises a culinary journey that evokes nostalgia and satisfies the palate. Join us as we uncover why this family-owned and operated bakery has become a cherished part of the Carlisle community, serving up sweetness and tradition since 1984.

Beeman's Baked Goods is conveniently located at 51 S Orange St, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA. This address places it in the heart of Carlisle, making it easily accessible for residents of the town and those traveling from surrounding areas in Pennsylvania. South Orange Street is a well-known thoroughfare, contributing to the bakery's visibility and straightforward navigation for customers.

Accessibility to Beeman's is generally good. Being a standalone retail shop in a well-established area of Carlisle, customers can typically expect readily available parking options, whether on the street or in nearby lots. The location allows for a comfortable visit, providing ample space to browse their well-presented goods without feeling cluttered, as noted by a customer. This setup encourages a leisurely shopping experience, where visitors can take their time to appreciate the array of fresh baked items. Furthermore, the ability to "watch them baking the items, while I shop the items" adds a unique and engaging element to the visit, offering a glimpse into the artisanal process. This transparency and inviting atmosphere contribute significantly to why many Pennsylvanians consider Beeman's Baked Goods a go-to spot for quality homemade treats.

Beeman's Baked Goods prides itself on a comprehensive selection of made-from-scratch Pennsylvania Dutch style baked goods, with many recipes developed by current and past generations of the family. Their offerings are extensive and cater to various tastes.

• Pies: A wide variety of pies, including fruit pies (Apple, Peach, Cherry, Blueberry, Strawberry Rhubarb, Black Raspberry, Raisin), cream pies (Chocolate Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream, Coconut Cream, Lemon Meringue, Peanut Butter Cream, Pumpkin Cream Cheese, Pumpkin Custard), and specialty pies (Shoofly, Montgomery, Key Lime, Pumpkin, Pecan). Many fruit pies use locally grown apples, peaches, black raspberries, zucchini, and rhubarb.
• Whoopie Pies: Available in packs of 3 or single-serve, with flavors such as Chocolate with Vanilla Filling, Chocolate with Peanut Butter Filling, Pumpkin with Vanilla Filling, and seasonal Red Velvet.
• Cookies: A diverse range including Soft Sugar, Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Molasses, Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter, Irish Shortbread, Sandtarts, and Iced Sugar Cookies. Seasonal and Christmas cookies like Pecan Sandies, Peanut Butter Blossoms, and Cheesecake Cookies are also offered.
• Quick Breads: Available by the loaf or single-serve, featuring Zucchini (plain, nut & raisin), Pumpkin (plain, nut & raisin), and Banana Nut.
• Breads: Includes White, Wheat, Sourdough, Potato, and by-order options like Sourdough Raisin Bread, Raisin Bread with Icing, Rye Sourdough, Dark German Rye, Dinner Rolls, and Sandwich Rolls.
• Pastries & Breakfast Items: Made fresh daily, including Sticky Buns (plain or with English walnuts), Iced Cinnamon Rolls, Cinnamon Twists, Cheese & Cherry Cheese Danish. They are also known for their Fastnachts, a traditional potato donut eaten plain or dipped in molasses, especially popular on Fat Tuesday.
• Cakes: Available in 8-inch square or single-serve, including Chocolate (with Peanut Butter, Buttercream, or Chocolate Frosting), Vanilla (with Chocolate or Buttercream Frosting), Carrot with Walnuts (Cream Cheese Frosting), and Coconut (Buttercream Frosting). Seasonal options like Red Velvet and Spice cakes are also offered. Decorated cakes are available pre-made or by special order (72-hour notice required for custom designs).
• Cupcakes & Coffee Cakes: Cupcakes by the half-dozen in-store, with special orders for full or mini dozens. Coffee cakes come in large or small loaves with flavors like Banana Nut with Chocolate Chips, Pumpkin with Chocolate Chips, Apple with Pecans & Cinnamon Glaze, and Blueberry Lemon.
• Pickled Goods and Other Items: Beyond baked goods, they offer a "variety of pickled goods and other not mass produced items," indicating a broader selection of homemade provisions.

Beeman's Baked Goods distinguishes itself through several compelling features and highlights that resonate deeply with the local Pennsylvania community.

• Authentic Pennsylvania Dutch Style Baking: This is a cornerstone of their identity. All products are "made-from-scratch" using recipes passed down through "current and past generations of the family," ensuring a genuine taste of regional tradition that is hard to find elsewhere.
• Family-Owned and Operated Since 1984: With over 30 years of experience, first at farmers markets and then at their retail shop since 2014, their long-standing presence and family dedication contribute to a trusted and cherished local business.
• Transparency with On-Site Baking: Customers can "watch them baking the items, while I shop," creating an engaging and reassuring experience that highlights the freshness and homemade nature of their products. This visual element adds to the bakery's appeal.
• Use of Local Ingredients: Beeman's actively "sources fresh fruits and vegetables for their fresh, tasty homemade treats, when possible." They partner with local farms, like the Elicker family from Dillsburg, PA, for apples, peaches, black raspberries, zucchini, and rhubarb, reinforcing their commitment to community and quality.
• Unique and Not Mass-Produced Items: Beyond their main baked goods, the availability of "pickled goods and other not mass produced items" indicates a curated selection of unique, handcrafted products that offer something different from large retailers.
• Nostalgic Appeal: As highlighted in reviews, their baked goods, particularly molasses cookies and sticky buns, "evoke nostalgic memories of homemade treats," providing a comforting and familiar taste experience for many locals.
• Diverse and Comprehensive Menu: Their extensive menu, ranging from various pies, breads, cookies, cakes, and specialty items like Fastnachts, ensures there's always something to satisfy diverse tastes and occasions.

To experience the delicious homemade goodness of Beeman's Baked Goods, here is their contact information:

Address: 51 S Orange St, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA
Phone: (717) 218-5258
Mobile Phone: +1 717-218-5258

Customers are encouraged to call ahead for any specific inquiries, to place special orders (e.g., custom cakes which require 72-hour notice), or to confirm daily specials and availability. Their operating hours are typically Tuesday – Friday, and Saturday, making it convenient for weekday and weekend visits.

For residents across Pennsylvania, and particularly those in the Carlisle area, Beeman's Baked Goods is an exceptional local establishment that perfectly embodies the spirit of traditional, homemade baking. It is highly suitable for locals because it offers not just delicious food, but an experience rooted in family heritage and community values. The commitment to "made-from-scratch" recipes, often utilizing locally sourced fruits and vegetables, ensures a level of freshness and quality that stands apart.

Whether you're looking for a comforting loaf of bread, a classic Pennsylvania Dutch pie for a family gathering, or unique seasonal treats like Fastnachts, Beeman's delivers with authenticity and flavor. The inviting atmosphere, where you can even watch the baking process, fosters a strong connection to the product. Supporting Beeman's Baked Goods means investing in a long-standing local family business that consistently provides high-quality, nostalgic, and genuinely delightful baked goods to the Carlisle community. It's truly a sweet part of Pennsylvania's culinary landscape.

Beeman's Baked Goods

51 S Orange St, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA