Beiler's Bakery

Welcome to the heart of South Jersey's culinary treasures! When local residents talk about the absolute best baked goods in the region, one name consistently rises to the top: Beiler's Bakery in Mullica Hill, NJ. More than just a local spot, this Amish-run establishment has become a destination for people across New Jersey and beyond, all searching for that authentic, homemade taste that only traditional baking methods can deliver.

Beiler's Bakery is particularly famous for its incredible selection of hand-made, often described as larger and heavier than the norm, freshly fried donuts. It’s an experience where you can literally watch the doughy delights being created right in front of you. While the donuts are the main draw, the bakery offers a stunning variety of other PA Dutch specialties, including everything from cakes and pies to rolls and whoopie pies. The commitment to using natural ingredients and time-honored techniques shines through in every bite, transforming a simple trip to the bakery into a genuinely comforting experience.

For any New Jersey resident with a serious sweet tooth, or even those looking for high-quality, freshly baked artisan breads, Beiler's Bakery should be pinned on your must-visit list. The consistent line of customers is a testament to the quality, value, and dedication the owners and their team put into every single creation, making it a true gem in the Mullica Hill community.

Location and Accessibility

Beiler's Bakery is conveniently located in the Mullica Hill Amish Market, making it a perfect stop during a weekend shopping trip or simply a dedicated detour for a sweet treat. The market setting adds a unique, pleasant atmosphere to your visit, allowing you to enjoy a variety of goods from other Amish vendors once you've secured your pastry haul.

The bakery is situated at the following address, easily accessible for those living in or traveling through Southern New Jersey:

108 Swedesboro Rd, Mullica Hill, NJ 08062, USA

For planning your visit, the bakery has made accessibility a priority for all patrons.

Accessibility Features:

• Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring easy access for all visitors.
• Quick visit environment, perfect for grabbing your favorites without a long wait.

Services Offered

As a traditional, full-service Amish bakery, Beiler's offers far more than just its legendary donuts. The product range encompasses a wide variety of baked goods prepared fresh daily.

• Donuts & Fritters: Over 40 different flavors of hand-made donuts and fritters, including highly popular selections like Boston Crème, Apple Fritter, Maple Bacon, Coconut Custard, Oreo Crème, and Banana Crème.
• Cakes and Pies: A comprehensive selection of whole cakes (such as Red Velvet, German Chocolate, and Carrot Cake), cheesecakes, and all-natural fresh fruit pies like Apple, Cherry, Blueberry, and the classic Shoo-fly Pie.
• Whoopie Pies: Famous homemade Whoopie Pies in various flavors like Chocolate with White Cream, Peanut Butter Crème, and seasonal options.
• Breads and Rolls: A selection of fresh-baked breads, including Sourdough, Rye, Wheat, and a large variety of bagels, dinner rolls, and hamburger buns.
• Sticky Buns: Fresh, hot, and delicious Amish Sticky Buns, often available with icing, caramel, or nuts.
• Other Baked Treats: A variety of cookies, brownies, mini-cheesecakes, and quiches.
• Gluten-Free Options: The bakery accommodates dietary needs with gluten-free products, which often include lemon bars, whoopie pies, and various breads and cookies.
• Coffee and Beverages: Freshly brewed coffees, including Colombian Blend and Jamaican Me Crazy, alongside various cappuccinos and non-alcoholic beverages.
• Takeout Service: All items are available for convenient takeout.

Features / Highlights

What makes Beiler's Bakery a standout in the competitive South Jersey market? It’s a blend of tradition, quality, and a commitment to a truly fresh product.

• Amish-Run Authenticity: The bakery operates with genuine Amish heritage, ensuring traditional, from-scratch recipes and a focus on using natural, high-quality ingredients.
• Donuts Made Fresh Hourly: Visitors can witness the "donut theater" — watching the dough being cut, fried, filled, and topped right in front of them, ensuring the freshest possible experience.
• Exceptional Dough Quality: Customer reviews consistently praise the yeast dough as being incredibly fresh, fluffy, light, and airy, providing a superior base for all their creations.
• The Boston Crème Standard: The Boston Crème donut is frequently cited by customers as a "gold standard" and one of the best versions of the classic donut available anywhere.
• Generous Portions: Many customers note that the donuts are noticeably larger and heavier than those found at many chain shops, offering excellent value for the price (which is often cited around $2 per donut).
• Variety and Creativity: With over 40 donut flavors, from traditional Glazed to unique fillings like Key Lime, Peanut Butter Crème, and Maple Bacon, there is always something new to try.
• Payment Flexibility: The bakery accepts various convenient payment methods, including Debit Cards and NFC mobile payments.

Contact Information

If you are planning your visit or need to inquire about special orders, you can reach Beiler's Bakery at their Mullica Hill location:

Address: 108 Swedesboro Rd, Mullica Hill, NJ 08062, USA

Phone: (856) 223-9998

Mobile Phone: +1 856-223-9998

What is Worth Choosing

While the entire selection at Beiler's Bakery is worth exploring, there are a few items and aspects that New Jersey residents should prioritize to fully appreciate the experience.

For the Classic Lover: You absolutely must try the Boston Crème. Its reputation as a national "gold standard" is hard to ignore. The perfect balance of fluffy yeast dough, velvety Bavarian crème filling, and rich chocolate icing is an unparalleled classic. Similarly, the Crème Filled Powdered donut is a messy-but-irresistible delight, packed with a thick, sweet cream.

For the Adventurous Eater: Dive into the Maple Bacon donut, a popular favorite that perfectly blends sweet maple crème with savory, crunchy bacon pieces. Or, sample the Key Lime crème-filled donut for a bright, tangy, and refreshing twist that cuts through the sweetness.

Beyond Donuts: Do not overlook the rest of the bakery’s Amish specialties. Customers consistently rave about the non-donut items, describing the overall selection of cakes, breads, and rolls as "the best baked goods I have had in Southern New Jersey." A fresh slice of one of their Homemade Creampies or a classic Whoopie Pie will complete your authentic Amish market experience.

In short, Beiler's Bakery in Mullica Hill is more than just a place to buy bread or a sweet snack; it’s an immersive experience in quality, tradition, and culinary passion. It’s a necessary stop for anyone in the New Jersey area who values homemade excellence.

Beiler's Bakery

108 Swedesboro Rd, Mullica Hill, NJ 08062, USA