Brother's Bakery Cafe: Your Go-To Spot for Fresh Baked Goods in New York

Brother’s Bakery Cafe Introduce

For New Yorkers seeking a delightful escape into the world of freshly baked aromas and comforting flavors, look no further than Brother's Bakery Cafe. Nestled in the vibrant East Harlem neighborhood, this establishment has garnered a reputation as a reliable and cherished local spot, providing a diverse menu that caters to various tastes and cravings. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with the inviting scent of warm pastries and brewing coffee, setting the stage for a truly satisfying experience. Brother's Bakery Cafe isn't just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a community hub where quality ingredients and friendly service come together to create a memorable culinary journey for every visitor.

This beloved bakery and cafe has firmly established itself within the local fabric, earning a loyal following thanks to its consistent quality and commitment to customer satisfaction. Whether you're an early riser looking for a hearty breakfast, a midday visitor in search of a savory lunch, or simply in need of a sweet treat to brighten your day, Brother's Bakery Cafe offers something for everyone. Their dedication to crafting delicious food, combined with a welcoming atmosphere, makes it a true gem in the bustling landscape of New York City.

Brother's Bakery Cafe is conveniently located at 2155 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA. This prime East Harlem address makes it easily accessible for residents and visitors alike. The neighborhood is well-served by public transportation, with several bus routes and subway lines within walking distance, ensuring a hassle-free journey to and from the bakery. For those traveling by car, street parking options may be available in the vicinity, though it's always advisable to account for New York City's dynamic parking situation.

Its location in East Harlem places it right in the heart of a diverse and lively community, making it a perfect spot to drop in for a quick bite before work, enjoy a leisurely weekend brunch, or pick up treats for a gathering. The ease of access contributes significantly to its appeal as a neighborhood staple, allowing locals to seamlessly integrate a visit to Brother's Bakery Cafe into their daily routines.

Brother's Bakery Cafe offers a comprehensive range of services and menu items designed to satisfy various appetites throughout the day. Their offerings extend far beyond just baked goods, encompassing a full cafe experience.

Freshly Baked Pastries and Desserts: A wide selection of pastries, including danishes, muffins, croissants, and their highly praised creme brûlée cups, often caramelized to perfection.
Custom Cakes for Special Occasions: Known for their delicious custom cakes, including fan favorites like the Red Velvet cake, perfect for birthdays and other celebrations. They also offer various sized holiday-themed cookies and pies, such as pumpkin, pecan, apple, peach, and cherry.
Breakfast and Brunch Options: A diverse breakfast menu featuring bagels with various spreads, egg sandwiches (including bacon, egg, and cheese), omelettes, pancakes, French toast, and Belgian waffles. Healthy options like granola and fruit parfaits, and egg white wraps are also available.
Lunch Items: A selection of sandwiches, paninis, burgers, wraps, quesadillas, and salads. Menu highlights include the Farm Wrap, Cobb Salad, and various daily specials.
Coffee and Beverages: A full range of hot coffee drinks, cold beverages, and fresh fruit juices to complement any meal or snack.
Catering and Takeout: Convenient options for both pickup and delivery, making it easy to enjoy Brother's Bakery Cafe's offerings from the comfort of your home or office.

Brother's Bakery Cafe distinguishes itself through several key features and highlights that contribute to its popularity among New Yorkers:

Signature Red Velvet Cake: A consistent highlight for many customers, often chosen for special occasions due to its consistent quality and flavor.
Caramelized Creme Brûlée Cups: A unique and highly recommended treat that showcases the bakery's attention to detail and dessert craftsmanship.
Diverse Menu Beyond Just Baked Goods: While celebrated for its bakery items, the cafe also offers a robust menu of savory breakfast and lunch options, appealing to a broader clientele. This versatility makes it a suitable spot for any meal of the day.
Reliable and Friendly Service: Many reviews commend the staff for their friendly demeanor and efficient service, contributing to a positive customer experience. The bakery's staff are often noted for remembering regular orders and providing helpful assistance.
Commitment to Freshness: The bakery prioritizes fresh ingredients and made-to-order items, ensuring high quality in their offerings, from pastries to breakfast sandwiches.
Community Staple: Described by many as an "East Harlem staple," it's a place where locals feel at home and can rely on for consistent, good food.
Variety of Holiday Offerings: Beyond daily delights, Brother's Bakery Cafe provides seasonal treats, from special holiday cookies to a selection of pies for festive gatherings.

To experience the delights of Brother's Bakery Cafe, you can find them at:

Address: 2155 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA

Phone: (212) 641-0646

Mobile Phone: +1 212-641-0646

Operating Hours: Monday through Sunday, 6:00 AM - 8:00 PM. Please note that some third-party delivery services might list slightly different hours (e.g., 6:30 AM - 6:00 PM on weekdays and 7:00 AM - 5:00 PM on weekends). It is always recommended to verify directly with the bakery for the most current information, especially if planning a visit near closing hours.

Brother's Bakery Cafe is an ideal spot for New Yorkers because it encapsulates the essence of a reliable, high-quality neighborhood establishment. For locals, it’s more than just a place to grab coffee and a pastry; it’s a consistent source of comfort food and celebratory treats. Whether you’re a long-time resident of East Harlem or just passing through, the bakery offers the kind of authentic experience that defines local New York.

Its broad menu, from substantial breakfast platters to gourmet sandwiches and custom cakes, means that it can cater to almost any need, at any time of day. This versatility, combined with the convenience of its location and the option for delivery, makes it an invaluable resource for busy New Yorkers. The consistent positive feedback on their baked goods, particularly the Red Velvet cake and creme brûlée, highlights their mastery of classic bakery items, while their savory offerings provide satisfying meal options.

Ultimately, Brother's Bakery Cafe stands out as a genuine local favorite, celebrated for its delicious food, welcoming atmosphere, and dedicated service. It's a place where quality is paramount and community is valued, making it a perfect fit for the diverse and discerning palates of New York City.

Brother’s Bakery Cafe Food & drink

Hot Coffee Drinks
Coffee
Decaf Coffee
Cafe Au Lait
Hot Chocolate
Coconut Hot Chocolate
Espresso
Red Eye
Traditional Macchiato
Espresso with a splash of milk and a lot of foam.
Chai Latte
Cappuccino
Latte
Pumpkin Spice Latte
With whipped cream and cinnamon on top.
Hot Matcha Green Tea Latte
Americano
Mocha
Tiramisu Mocha
Milky Way Latte
Peppermint Mocha
Hot Tea
Honey Lavender Latte -Hot-

Cold Drinks and Fruit
Regular Iced Coffee
Iced Latte
Iced Pumpkin Spice Latte
With whipped cream and cinnamon on top.
Iced Chai
Iced Americano
Iced Red Eye
Iced Matcha Green Tea Latte
Organic Iced Tea
Black, green tea or peach black.
Italian Soda
Sparkling Water and Gourmet flavored syrup
Granola Fruit Parfait US$4.95
Fresh Fruit Salad US$5.95
Melon, cantaloupe, strawberries, and blueberries.
Frappuccino US$9.95
20 oz
Smoothies US$9.75
20 oz.
Mocha
Tiramisu Mocha
Milky Way Latte
Peppermint Mocha
Green Tropical Smoothie US$7.95
20 oz. Comes with kale, spinach, bananas, mango and pineapple juice.

Beverages
Poland Spring Water
Juice 15 Oz. Tropicana Bottle
Tropicana Orange Carton US$3.25
Gatorade US$3.50
Snapple US$3.50
Vitamin Water US$3.50
San Pellegrino Sparkling Water
San Pellegrino Can Soda US$3.25
Smart Water
Tropicana Bottle 10 Oz.
V8 Splash US$2.75
Canned Sodas US$2.25
Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice US$5.75
Freshly Squeezed Lemonade US$3.50
Freshly Squeezed Pink Lemonade US$3.50
Fresh Half & Half Lemonade Iced Tea US$3.50
Izze Soda Can US$2.95
Cup Of Ice US$1.50
Bai Antioxidant Infusion Drink US$3.50
Zero Snapple US$2.95
Essentia Water
Perrier Sparkling Water US$2.95
Jarritos US$3.25
12.5 oz glass bottle.
Foco Coconut Juice US$3.25
46 OZ. Tropican Bottle US$7.95

Omelettes
Western Omelette US$14.50
Green peppers, onions, red peppers, ham and cheddar cheese. Includes toast and home fries.
Greek Omelette US$14.50
Spinach, red onion, tomatoes, black olives and feta cheese. Includes toast and home fries.
Veggie Omelette US$14.50
Mushroom, spinach, onions, peppers and choice of cheese. Includes toast and home fries.
Make Your Own Omelette US$14.50
Includes toast and home fries.
Spinach And Feta Omelette US$13.95
Includes toast and home fries.
Salmon And Scallion Omelette US$15.95
Three egg whites, salmon, and scallion. Includes toast and home fries.
California Omelette US$15.95
Tomato, mushroom, bacon, cheddar and avocado. Includes toast and home fries.
Three Cheese Omelette US$12.95
Swiss, mozzarella and provolone omelette. Includes homefries and toast.
Healthy Omelette US$14.50
Egg whites, broccoli, spinach and avocado. Includes toast and homefries.
Mexican Omelette US$13.95
Jalapeno, tomato, onion and American cheese. Includes toast and homefries.

Healthy Egg Wraps and Fruit Salads
Farm Wrap US$10.95
Egg whites, chicken breast, mozzarella on choice of wrap.
Sunny Day Wrap US$10.95
Egg whites, tomato, choice of turkey bacon or fresh roasted turkey and cheddar on choice of wrap.
Oasis Wrap US$10.95
Egg whites, broccoli, spinach, onions and pepper jack cheese on choice of wrap.
Fresh Fruit Salad US$6.75
Melon, Countelope, Strawberries, Blueberries.

Bagel
Bagel US$1.95
Bagel With Butter US$2.95
Bagel W/Butter And Jelly US$3.50
Bagel With Peanut Butter And Jelly US$5.25
Bagel With Cream Cheese US$4.75
Bagel W/Cream Cheese And Jelly US$5.25
Bagel With Vegetable Cream Cheese US$5.25
Cream cheese with carrots and bell peppers.
Bagel With Jalapeño Cream Cheese US$4.95
Bagel With Scallion Cream Cheese US$5.25
Bagel With Lox Spread US$5.95
Bagel With Cream Cheese And Lox US$16.95
Includes Onion, tomatoes and capers.

Eggs and Breakfast Sides
Egg, Bacon And Cheese Sandwich US$8.95
Egg And Cheese Sandwich US$6.25
Egg With Bacon Sandwich US$7.25
Breakfast Burrito Wrap US$9.95
Eggs, bacon, cheese, and home fries inside the tortilla
2 Eggs Any Style US$12.95
With home fries, toast and choice of meat.
Breakfast Combo US$19.95
2 small pancakes, Slice of french toast, 2 eggs, choice of meat, and home fries or french fries
Side Of Eggs US$3.95
Pancakes US$12.95
French Toast US$12.95
Belgium Waffles US$12.95
3 large fluffy Belgium Waffles.
Granola And Fruit Parfait US$5.25
Plain, vanilla or strawberry flavored yogurt. With housemade granola and fresh fruit.
Side Of Bacon US$4.25
Side Of Homefries US$6.50
Bananas Each US$1.25
Oatmeal US$4.50
Only available in large (16 oz)
Hard Boil Eggs (Two) US$3.95
Two hard boil eggs.

Lunch Sides
Side Of French Fries US$6.50
Side Fresh Garden Salad US$5.95
Lettuce, tomato, cucumber and onion. Choice of dressing.
Buffalo Wings US$8.95
6 pieces
Chicken Tenders US$9.95
5 pieces
Chicken Nuggets US$8.95
8 pieces
Side Of Sweet Pototo Fries US$6.50

Deli and Weighted Sides
Sliced Turkey
Sliced Ham
Sliced Roast Beef
Sliced Salmon
Sliced Pastrami
Sliced American Cheese
Sliced Cheddar Cheese
Sliced Swiss Cheese
Plain Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Lox Cream Cheese Spread
Tuna Salad
Chicken Salad

Salads
Caesar Salad US$9.50
Romaine lettuce, croutons and Parmesan cheese.
Caesar Salad With Grilled Chicken US$12.75
Romaine lettuce, croutons and Parmesan cheese.
Keto Salad With Protein US$13.75
Includes spinach, avocado, olives, feta cheese, broccoli, almonds and choice of protein. Comes with olive oil and vinegar dressing.
Cobb Salad US$13.75
Mixed greens, chicken, avocado, tomatoes, chopped eggs, bacon and blue cheese with balsamic vinaigrette.
Tuna Salad US$13.75
Roasted peppers, tomatoes, onions and cucumber over romaine.
Fresh Garden Salad US$9.95
Tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, onions and artichoke hearts.
Grilled Chicken Salad US$13.75
Roasted peppers, corn, avocado, fresh mozzarella over mixed greens.
Chef Salad US$13.95
Roast Beef, Turkey, Ham, Egg, Swiss Cheese, Tomato, Onion on Romaine Lettuce with Choice of Dressing.
Mexican Chicken Caesar Salad US$13.95
Romaine Lettuce, chicken, avocado, tortilla chips, Jalapeno, Parmesan cheese, Pico de Gallo. Comes with Caesar dressing

Make Your Own Salad
Make Your Own Salad US$12.75

Hamburgers
Hamburger US$10.95
8 oz beef burger served with lettuce, tomato and pickles.
Hamburger Deluxe US$15.50
8 oz beef burger (lettuce, tomato and pickles) served with fries.

Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken Sandwich US$12.50
Lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.
Triple Decker Sandwich US$13.50
Three slices of bread consisting of two layers of turkey,bacon,lettuce,tomato and mayonnaise served with a side of home made potato chips
Philly Cheesesteak Combo US$17.95
Philly cheesesteak accompanied by a side of garden salad and french fries. (no substitutions)
Chicken Philly Cheesesteak Combo US$17.95
Chicken Philly cheesesteak accompanied by a side garden salad and French fries. (no substitutions)
Grilled Veggies Sandwich US$11.75
Carrots, mushroom, onions, peppers, spinach, celery and baby squash with feta cheese.
Pastrami Reuben US$12.50
Pastrami, Sauerkraut, Swiss cheese with thousand Island dressing on Rye bread.
Monte Cristo Sandwich US$12.50
Ham, turkey and Swiss cheese.
Turkey Cuban Sandwich US$12.50
Turkey, ham, pickles, Swiss cheese and Russian dressing.
Chicken Salad Sandwich US$11.50
Mayo, lettuce and tomatoes.
Tuna Salad Sandwich US$11.75
Tuna, lettuce and tomatoes.
Egg Salad Sandwich US$8.95
Lettuce and tomatoes.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich US$6.75
Ham And Cheese Sandwich US$9.50
Pastrami Sandwich US$12.50
Warmed pastrami, sauteed onions, Swiss cheese and mustard.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich With Bacon US$8.95
Roast Beef Sandwich US$12.50
Roast beef, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and Chipotle mayo.
Maple Glaze Honey Turkey And Avocado Sandwich US$12.50
With lettuce, tomatoes and honey mustard.
Turkey Club Sandwich US$12.50
With bacon, lettuce and tomatoes.
Chicken Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich US$12.50
With melted American cheese, sauteed green and red peppers, onions on a hero.
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich US$12.50
With melted american cheese, sauteed green and red peppers, onions on a hero.
Ham And Swiss Croissant US$8.25
No additions or changes. On a croissant.
BLT Sandwich US$8.95
Bacon, lettuce, tomato.
ABLT Sandwich US$10.25
Avocado, bacon, lettuce and tomato.
Italian Sandwich US$12.50
Genoa Salami, Ham, Provolone cheese, lettuce tomato, and Italian dressing

Wraps
California Wrap US$11.95
Grilled chicken, bacon, tomatoes, avocado and ranch dressing.
Vegetarian Keto Wrap US$11.95
Includes mixed greens, bell pepper, tomato, olives, feta and avocado with choice of wrap. Balsamic dressing included. ——SERVED COLD——
Tuna Wrap US$11.95
Tuna, lettuce, tomatoes and cheddar.
Roast Beef Wrap US$12.50
Roast beef, lettuce, tomato, cheddar and mayo.
Italian Wrap US$11.95
Genoa salami, ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and Italian dressing.
Chicken Caesar Wrap US$11.95
Grilled chicken, croutons, lettuce, Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing.
Pastrami Wrap US$11.95
Warmed pastrami, sauteed onions, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and mustard.

Burritos & Guacamole
Grilled Beef Burrito US$12.50
Served with choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. Made with rice, beans, pico de gallo and sour cream.
Grilled Chicken Burrito US$12.50
Served with choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. Made with rice, beans, pico de gallo and sour cream.
Grilled Vegetables Burrito US$12.50
Served with choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. Made with rice, beans, pico de gallo and sour cream.
Salsa & Chips US$8.25
Guacamole & Chips US$12.50
Pico Di Gallo
6 oz
Salsa
Bag Of Tortilla Chips US$4.50

Quesadillas
Cheese Quesadilla US$10.95
Made with peppers and onions. Choice of tortilla. Pico de Gallo, salsa and sour cream on the side.
Grilled Chicken Quesadilla US$12.95
Made with cheese, peppers and onions. Choice of tortilla. Pico de Gallo, salsa and sour cream on the side.
Grilled Vegetable Quesadilla US$12.95
Made with cheese, peppers, onions and assorted vegetables. Choice of tortilla. Pico de Gallo, salsa and sour cream on the side.

Paninis
Italiano Panini US$12.95
Chicken, roasted pepper, pesto sauce and mozzarella. Served with side home made potato chips or small side salad.
Chicken Fajita Panini US$12.95
Salsa chicken, mayo, grill peppers, red onion and cheddar. Served with side home made potato chips or small side salad.
Turkey Avocado Club Panini US$13.95
Turkey, provolone, bacon, tomato, red onions, avocado and mayonnaise. Served with homemade potato chips or Caesar salad.
Tuna Panini US$12.95
Tuna, mayo, celery, onion and cheddar. Served with side home made potato chips or small side salad.
Cuban Panini US$12.95
Turkey, ham, Swiss, pickles and Russian dressing. Served with side home made potato chips or small side salad.
Veggie Delight Panini US$12.95
Mushroom, carrots, onions, peppers, spinach, celery and baby squash. Served with side home made potato chips or small side salad.

Homemade Chips
Potato Chips US$3.75

Pastries
Cupcake
Tres Leches Cup US$4.95
Cup Of Chocolate Mousse US$4.75
Sliced Cake US$4.25
Cannoli
Eclairs US$3.75
French Macaroon US$2.95
Large macaroon pieces.
Fruit Tart US$8.50
4" Pecan Tart US$7.95
6 Piece Assorted Mini Cupcakes US$9.75
Key Lime Tart US$7.95
Mini Pecan Tart US$3.95
Mini Key Lime Tart US$3.95
Flan US$6.50
Creme Brulee US$5.25
Creamy custard with vanilla bean
Carrot Bar US$3.95
Pecan Bar US$3.95
Six Piece Assorted French Macaroon US$13.95
Tres Leches Square Cake US$0.00
Tiramisu Square Cake US$6.50
Oreo Bar US$3.95
Blueberry Cheesecake Bar US$3.95
Rainbow Bar US$3.95
Bread Pudding US$6.50
4 in. Squares, raisins included.
Cake Pops US$3.95
Chocolate covered cake lollipops
Oreo Cheesecake Bar US$3.95

Cakes
4" Cake US$15.95
6" Cakes US$39.95
Various flavors of delicious cakes made in house.
9'' Cake US$59.95

Baked Goods
Muffins US$3.75
Square Bar US$3.95
Croissants US$3.75
Apple Turnover US$3.75
Danish US$3.75
Loaf Cake US$5.95
Rice Crispies US$4.25
Rugelach US$2.50
Coconut Macaroon US$2.50
Black And White Cookie US$3.95
Large Cookie
Raspberry Pecan Cookie US$2.75
Sesame Street Character Cookies US$5.95
Large shortbread cookie.
Almond Biscotti US$2.75
Italian almond biscuit.
Bites Box US$5.95
4 oz.
Yogurt Loaf Slice US$3.95
Cookies Box US$5.75
4 oz
Large Cookies US$2.50
Madeleines Cookies US$1.50
Palmaer (Elephant Ear) Cookie US$1.50
1 cookie per order
Yogurt Loaf Cake US$6.50
Yogurt Based
Linzert Heart Cookie US$2.75
Short bread cookie with filling
Concha (Sea Shell) US$3.75
Traditional Mexican sweet bread roll with a flavored crunchy topping. Best eaten with hot chocolate or coffee.
Large Heart Shape Cookie US$5.95
Large decorative shortbread cookie

Brother’s Bakery Cafe Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Wi-Fi

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Brother’s Bakery Cafe Photos

Brother’s Bakery Cafe Location

Brother’s Bakery Cafe

New York New York County New York 2nd Avenue

2155 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA

Brother’s Bakery Cafe Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 438 user reviews.

breakfastdeliverycashiersbagelmoneyorderfrench toastbaconloxpeaceful

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Big fan of brother’s bakery! Every year for my birthday I always get the Red velvet cake and it never fails. One of my favorite treats is the creme brûlée cups and they even caramelized the tops with sugar. Definitely a must try! If you’re looking for a sweet treat or a cake for a special occasion you have got to try their cakes.
June 17 · Melissa Rivera
The toast was burnt and they did not have a beverage I ordered online available in store when I went to pick up so I had to choose something else as a result. I usually buy coffee from here which is great. But I have to say my bacon egg and cheese was unpleasant.
June 14 · Marytere Guillon
Solid breakfast.Build your own or pig from their many options.The home fries were well seasoned.The toast came out pre-buttered.Also tried some of their baked goods which were tasty.Had a nice cozy vibe inside. At times there is a line to order so you can tell this place is popular.
December 20 · Cem Unsal
Placed an order for a birthday cake in advance and when I went to go pick up the cake I was mortified by the writing on the cake. It looked like a 2 year old wrote the words.The lady helping me rudely just offered a refund, instead of asking to fix it. I said it was fine; because I needed the cake and she continued to reiterate returning mymoney was not an issue as she packed it. Looking back she did not even apologize.The cake was delicious and I could’ve looked past the ugly writting but will not be returning due to their awful customer service.
May 05 · Cruzmary D
Bin going there for years. Picked up two cakes yesterday for graduation party; red velvet and butter cake with raspberry. Delicious 😋 Everyone loved it. Great service. Short notice. Can’t go wrong with brothers.
June 25 · Kusalee Vachananda