Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe: A Huntington Gem for Baked Goods and More

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe Introduce

For those of us living on Long Island, particularly in the vibrant community of Huntington, discovering a local establishment that consistently delivers quality, variety, and a welcoming atmosphere is always a delight. Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe is precisely one such gem, a beloved institution that has become a go-to destination for anyone with a sweet tooth or a craving for a delicious meal. This isn't just your average bakery; it's a comprehensive culinary experience, blending the artistry of traditional baking with the convenience and comfort of a modern cafe.

Stepping into Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe, you're immediately greeted by an abundance of choices. From meticulously crafted pastries and artisanal breads to custom cakes that are truly edible works of art, the selection is vast and designed to tantalize every palate. What sets Buttercooky apart is not just the sheer volume of offerings, but the consistent quality and freshness that shines through in every bite. Customers frequently rave about the incredible flavors and top-notch quality, a testament to the bakery's dedication to its craft. Beyond the sweet treats, the surprising availability of savory dishes and fresh coffee transforms this bakery into a versatile cafe, making it an ideal spot for lunch, a quick bite, or a leisurely break.

The clean and inviting environment further enhances the experience, making Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe a pleasant place to spend time, whether you're grabbing something on the go or settling in for a meal. It's a place where tradition meets contemporary convenience, providing Huntington locals and visitors alike with a reliable source for high-quality baked goods and a satisfying cafe experience. For anyone in New York looking for a comprehensive bakery and cafe experience that never disappoints, Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe is an absolute must-visit destination.

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe boasts a prime location in Huntington, New York, making it exceptionally convenient and accessible for locals and those visiting the area. You can find this beloved establishment at 495 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743, USA. New York Avenue is a major thoroughfare that runs directly through the heart of Huntington, a bustling and historic town on Long Island. Its central placement ensures easy access whether you're driving from neighboring communities like Greenlawn, Centerport, or Commack, or simply walking from other parts of downtown Huntington.

The area surrounding 495 New York Ave is well-equipped with parking options, which is a significant advantage in a popular area like Huntington. Street parking is often available, and there may be nearby municipal lots that provide additional convenience, especially during peak hours. For those utilizing public transportation, local bus routes serving Huntington are likely to have stops within a comfortable walking distance of the bakery, integrating it seamlessly into the town's public transit network. The visibility and easy navigation to this address contribute to its popularity, allowing customers to effortlessly pop in for a coffee, a pastry, or to pick up a larger order for a special occasion. Its integration within the vibrant Huntington village atmosphere adds to its appeal, making it a natural stop during a day out exploring the town.

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe offers an extensive array of services, going beyond traditional baked goods to provide a comprehensive culinary experience. Their diverse offerings cater to various tastes and occasions, ensuring there's always something fresh and delicious to enjoy.

Extensive Baked Goods Selection: A vast assortment of freshly baked pastries, including croissants, Danishes, muffins, scones, and cookies. They are known for their freshness and variety, perfect for breakfast or an afternoon treat.
Custom Cakes: Specializing in bespoke cakes for all occasions, including birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, graduations, and other milestones. Customers can work with their skilled decorators to create personalized cakes in terms of design, flavor, and size.
Artisanal Breads: A selection of freshly baked breads, often including traditional loaves, rolls, and specialty breads, ideal for everyday meals or special gatherings.
Savory Lunch Options: Uniquely, they offer savory dishes, allowing customers to enjoy a full lunch experience. This includes sandwiches, salads, and other savory items, making it a great spot for a meal beyond just dessert.
Gourmet Coffee and Beverages: A full-service coffee bar featuring various coffee preparations (including "coffee on tap"), teas, and other beverages to complement their baked goods and savory offerings.
Holiday and Seasonal Specialties: Crafting themed baked goods and treats for major holidays and seasons, adding a festive touch to celebrations throughout the year.
Dessert Platters and Catering: Providing larger orders and platters of assorted desserts, cookies, and pastries, suitable for parties, corporate events, and family gatherings.
Specialty European Pastries: Often featuring a selection of classic European-style pastries and desserts, showcasing a broader range of international baking techniques.

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe stands out as a premier establishment in Huntington, NY, thanks to several key features and highlights that enhance the customer experience and distinguish it from other bakeries.

Vast Selection and Variety: One of their most prominent features is the sheer breadth of their offerings. From delicate pastries and hearty breads to elaborate custom cakes and even savory lunch items, the extensive menu ensures that every customer finds something to their liking, catering to diverse tastes and needs.
Exceptional Freshness and Quality: Consistently praised in customer reviews, the freshness and high quality of all their baked goods are a significant highlight. This commitment to using premium ingredients and baking fresh daily results in superior flavors and textures across their entire product line.
Unexpected Savory Options: The inclusion of savory dishes for lunch is a unique and highly appreciated feature for a bakery. This transforms Buttercooky into a versatile cafe, providing a complete meal solution rather than just sweet treats, which is a convenient option for locals.
Clean and Inviting Environment: Customers frequently commend the bakery's clean and pleasant atmosphere. A well-maintained and welcoming space enhances the overall experience, making it a comfortable place to dine in or quickly pick up an order.
"Coffee on Tap": This modern and convenient offering for coffee lovers is a distinct highlight, providing fresh, ready-to-serve coffee that appeals to those looking for a quick and quality caffeine fix.
Artistic Custom Cakes: Their ability to create beautiful and delicious custom cakes for various celebrations is a major draw. The attention to detail and creative flair in their cake designs make them a top choice for special occasions on Long Island.
Community Staple: Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe has been a long-standing presence in Huntington, fostering a sense of familiarity and trust within the local community. This established reputation speaks to their consistent quality and customer satisfaction over time.

For inquiries, placing orders, or simply to learn more about the delightful offerings at Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe, you can reach them through the following contact information:

Address: 495 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743, USA

Phone: (631) 424-4034

Mobile Phone: +1 631-424-4034

It is always a good practice to check their official website or social media pages for the most current operating hours, holiday schedules, and any specific instructions regarding custom cake orders or large catering requests. With both a landline and mobile number provided, customers have convenient options for direct communication with the bakery team, ensuring that all their needs can be addressed efficiently and effectively.

In conclusion, Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe is an indispensable asset to the Huntington, NY, community and an excellent choice for any local in the New York region seeking a superior bakery and cafe experience. Its suitability for locals is rooted in its multifaceted appeal, combining convenience, quality, and variety in a way that truly caters to the daily lives and special occasions of Long Islanders.

The location on New York Avenue in Huntington provides unparalleled accessibility, making it an effortless stop whether you're running errands, commuting, or simply enjoying a stroll through the town. This ease of access is a significant factor for busy New Yorkers who appreciate convenience without compromising on quality. The expansive selection of baked goods, from everyday pastries to intricate custom cakes, ensures that Buttercooky can meet virtually any sweet craving or celebratory need. This versatility means locals don't have to look elsewhere, making it a one-stop shop for all things delicious.

Moreover, the unexpected but welcome addition of savory lunch options transforms Buttercooky from just a bakery into a full-fledged cafe. This means locals can enjoy not only their renowned baked goods but also a satisfying meal, all in one clean and pleasant environment. The availability of fresh coffee, including "coffee on tap," further solidifies its role as a convenient daily stop. The consistent praise for freshness, incredible flavors, and top-notch quality, as highlighted by customer reviews, reinforces Buttercooky's commitment to excellence, building trust and loyalty within the community.

Ultimately, Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe embodies what locals truly value in a neighborhood establishment: reliable quality, diverse offerings, a welcoming atmosphere, and genuine community integration. It’s more than just a place to buy bread or cake; it’s a cherished part of the Huntington experience, consistently delivering delicious moments and serving as a go-to for both everyday indulgences and life's most special celebrations. For anyone seeking a truly satisfying and comprehensive bakery and cafe experience on Long Island, Buttercooky is undoubtedly the place to be.

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe Menu

Assorted Danish
Pecan Danish US$6.00
Almond Danish US$6.00
Cherry Danish US$6.00
Pineapple Danish US$6.00
1 Dozen Assorted Danish US$58.00
Cinnamon Danish US$6.00
Cheese Danish US$6.00
Prune Danish US$6.00
Blueberry Danish US$6.00
Apricot Danish US$6.00
Raspberry Danish US$6.00
Mochaccino Danish US$6.00
Chocolate Babka & Espresso based danish/bun

Specials
New York Hero US$16.99
Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, Prosciutto, Red Wine Vinaigrette on a hot hero
Huntington Hero US$16.99
Chicken Cutlet, Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing on hot Hero
Eggs Benedict US$16.95
2 Poached Eggs, English Muffin, Canadian Bacon, Hollandaise Sauce, Potatoes
Sourdough Burrata Toast US$19.95
Toasted Sourdough, Cherry Tomatoes, Burrata, Fresh Basil, Balsamic Glaze, EVOO

Small Pies 4"
Small Pecan Pie US$9.95
Small Blueberry Pie US$9.95
Small Cherry Pie US$9.95
Small Apple Pie US$9.95
Brownie Tart US$9.95
Brownie with Ganache icing in Tart Shell

Cookie Trays
1 Pound Cookie Tray US$32.50
Sugar Free Cookie Tray US$29.95
Cookie Tray 1.5LB US$41.95
one and a half pounds of butter cookies
Cookie Tray 2lb US$49.95
2 pounds of butter cookies

Pastries
Coconut Chocolate Pastry US$6.95
Creamy Coconut Mousse enclosed in a soft peak of coconut Bavarian cream, resting on moist chocolate cake infused with coconut cream in chocolate ganache topped with chocolate shavings and chocolate shards
S'MORES Cream Puff US$8.45
A Cream puff filled with light and airy milk chocolate mousse dipped in rich milk chocolate rolled in graham cracker crumble and finished with a peak of toasted marshmallow fluff
NY Cheesecake Pastry US$6.95
Flan US$6.95
a dessert of sweetened egg custard with a caramel topping
Silk & Satin Pastry US$6.95
Rich and creamy chocolate mousse infused with our famous NY style cheesecake set atop a thin layer of chocolate cake, covered in chocolate ganache
Passion Fruit Mango French Pastry US$8.95
Tropically sweet yet tangy passion fruit mousse, mango cremeux and vanilla cake set atop a buttery vanilla sable cookie topped with whipped vanilla ganache and passion fruit jelly, enclosed in white chocolate and studded with gold leaf
Raspberry Cheesecake French Pastry US$8.45
New York Style Cheesecake set atop of graham cracker crust with a raspberry preserve on top and garnished with fresh raspberries
Biscoff French Pastry US$8.45
Creamy biscoff cookie butter set atop layers of moist vanilla cake topped with caramel glaze, finished with a Lotus Biscoff cookie, biscoff cookie crumble & a fresh strawberry
Oreo Mousse Pastry US$6.95
Rich and creamy vanilla mousse blended with chunks of oreo cookie set atop a chocolate sable, topped with chocolate and white chocolate wafers
Banana Milk Chocolate Bar US$6.95
Banana bread and banana mousse infused with salted caramel, encased in milk chocolate wafer crunch, topped with whipped ganache
Cheesecake Brownie French Pastry US$8.45
A rich fudgy chocolate brownie topped with a layer of new york style cheesecake, finished with a smooth silky white chocolate ganache
Black Forest Pastry US$6.95
Silky Chocolate mousse infused with sour cherry set atop a thin layer of sponge soaked in black cherry syrup encased in dark chocolate topped with whip cream
Matcha Tiramisu Pastry US$6.95
Layers of matcha sponge cake filled with tiramisu cream dipped in a pistachio brittle
Pistachio Sunflower French Pastry US$8.45
Pistachio mousse dipped in crunchy pistachio wafer chocolate set beneath a raspberry crémeux sphere, resting on soft vanilla cake & a buttery vanilla sablé cookie finished with a handcrafted white chocolate sunflower and a dollop of raspberry jam
NY Cheesecake With Strawberry Pastry US$6.95
Key Lime Pie (Mini) US$6.95
Chocolate Mousse Pastry US$6.95
Rich and creamy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of moist chocolate cake topped with chocolate curls
Cheesecake Brownie US$6.95
Rich fudge brownie topped with silky smooth NY style cheesecake
Crème Brulee US$6.95
Hazelnut Mousse Finger Pastry US$6.95
Hazelnut mousse infused with chocolate mousse dipped in hazelnut wafer chocolate crunch set atop a buttery chocolate sablé cookie, finished with hazelnut whipped ganache and chopped hazelnuts
Opera Pastry US$6.95
Layers of vanilla sponge soaked in coffee, mocha buttercream, and chocolate ganache
Strawberry Mousse French Pastry US$8.45
Light and airy strawberry crémeux and strawberry jam set atop layers of lemon vanilla cake dipped in strawberry white chocolate & finished with strawberry and vanilla whipped ganache
Three Tiramisu Cream Puffs US$6.95
Three profiterols lightly soaked in coffee and filled with light and airy mascarpone dusted with cocoa powder
Red Velvet Pastry US$6.95
Oreo Cheesecake Pastry US$6.95

Mousse Cakes
Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse Cake US$37.95
Hazelnut mousse and chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, hazelnut whipped ganache, chocolate triangles and toasted hazelnuts
Dubai Chocolate Cake US$39.95
Our Dubai Chocolate (pistachio and knafeh) set atop of a thin layer of our moist chocolate sponge and covered in chocolate ganache finished with a Dubai bark and vanilla sponge
Tiramisu Cake US$37.95
Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream dusted with cocoa powder and enclosed with lady fingers
French Strawberry Shortcake US$37.95
Fresh Strawberries & Cream, Vanilla Cake. Thin layer of Marzipan on top
Silk And Satin Cake (Chocolate Mousse & NY Cheesecake) US$37.95
Silky chocolate mousse infused with our famous new york style cheesecake set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, gold dusted lines, and lathered in roasted almond slices
Vanilla Chocolate Mousse Cake US$37.95
Rich and creamy chocolate mousse set atop thin layer of moist vanilla cake, finished with chocolate ganache, vanilla velvet puffs, and cake crumbs
Passion Fruit Mousse Cake US$37.95
Delicious, smooth passionfruit mousse set atop thin layer of moist vanilla cake, finished with white chocolate ganache icing, fresh fruit, and vanilla flakes
Red Velvet Mousse US$37.95
Pillowy-soft cream cheese set atop thin layers of moist velvet cake coated in smooth cream cheese icing, finished with ruby red chocolate ganache drip, vanilla buttercream, and red velvet cake crumbs
Chocolate Mousse Cake US$37.95
Light and airy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, a dark chocolate pencil and chocolate cake crumbs

New Years 2025
Honey Balls 1lb (Stroofli) US$24.95
New Years Cookie US$6.50
Drip Cake New Years US$39.95
1lb Lemon Drop Cookies US$29.95
Champagne Toast US$39.95
New Years Decoration
Fruit Cake Loaf US$21.95
1lb Cookie Tray US$24.95
New Years Cupcake US$4.95
Fig Cookies 1lb US$25.95
Gingerbread Christmas Tree US$51.95
gingerbread tree

Bread
Egg Rolls US$0.95
Plain Sesame Poppy
Rye Bread US$6.50
Seeds
Rustic Sourdough US$6.50
Salt Stick US$2.00
Pumpernickel Round US$6.50
French Baguette US$3.50
Semolina US$5.50
Bagel US$2.00
Plain Sesame Poppy
Challah Bread US$6.50
Kaiser Roll US$0.95
Plain Sesame Poppy
Rye Bread Seedless US$6.50
White Bread US$5.50
Italian Bread US$2.95
Whole Wheat Bread US$5.50

Easter Treats
Chocolate Cannoli US$6.20
Crispy fried shell dipped in chocolate filled with sweet ricotta cheese and chocolate chip, topped with a dusting of powdered sugar
1.5 Pound Assorted Butter Cookie Tray US$52.40
Assorted butter cookies in various shapes and flavors, baked with butter for a rich, tender texture.
Easter Cake Pop US$3.95
Happy Easter Cake US$38.00
Funfetti Cake Custard and Whipped Cream Filling Vanilla Buttercream Icing
Traditional Cannoli US$5.65
Crispy fried shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese and chocolate chip, topped with a dusting of powdered sugar
Lamb Boxed Pound Cake US$36.20
1 Pound Rainbow Cookies US$34.95
Large Chocolate Bunny US$39.95
Easter Basket Cake US$41.00
Chocolate Cake Chocolate Fudge Filing Icing
Easter Bread US$5.95
1 Pound Pignoli Cookie US$38.00
8" Coconut Custard Pie US$27.95
Small Marzipan Lamb US$36.20
Grain Pie US$33.95
2 Pound Cookie Tray US$62.95
Easter Cucpake Themed US$4.95
Rabbit Boxed Pound Cake US$36.20
Easter Sugar Cookie Themed US$6.95

Hamantaschen
Raspberry Hamantaschen US$5.25
Apricot Hamantaschen US$5.25
Prune Hamantaschen US$5.25

Gluten Free Items
Gluten Free Cookie US$5.00
Chocolate Chip or Sugar
Creme Brulee US$6.95
Gluten Free Muffin US$5.25
Gluten Free Brownie US$5.00
7" Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free) US$33.45
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
Individual Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free) US$8.10
Smooth and silky cream cheese finished with fluffy whipped cream and a fresh strawberry (gluten-free).
7" NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free) US$28.15
Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
Individual NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free) US$6.25
Smooth and silky cream cheese (gluten-free).
1 Pound Pignoli Cookie US$38.00

Crepe Station
Oreo Crunch US$17.95
Oreo cookies & chocolate sauce.
Nutella Monkey US$17.95
Nutella & bananas.
The Classic Crepe US$15.95
Chocolate sauce & fresh strawberries or raspberries.

Specialty Drink
The Classic Frappe US$10.25
Vanilla, Caramel, or Chocolate Sauce
Nutella Hot Chocolate US$6.50
Chocolate Chunk US$10.25
Chocolate chips, whipped cream & chocolate sauce.
Nutella Meltdown US$10.25
Nutella & cocoa powder.
Hot Chocolate US$6.00

Turnovers
Blueberry Turnover US$5.25
Cherry Turnover US$5.25
Apple Turnover US$5.25

Mother's Day 2025 Menu
Cannoli's US$4.50
Mother's Day Cupcakes US$5.95
Heart Shaped Red Velvet French Pastry US$7.25
1 Pound Rainbow Cookies US$34.95
Mother's Day Drip Cake US$42.00
Vanilla Cake Strawberry and Custard Filling Vanilla buttercream Mother's Day decoration
1.5 Cookie Tray US$41.95
8" Heart Shaped Strawberry Short Cake US$35.00
8" Heart Shaped Red Velvet Cake US$41.95
Flower Pot Cake US$42.00
Chocolate Cake Chocolate Filling Decorated like a flower pot with flowers
1 Pound Pignoli Cookie US$38.00
Mother's Day Cake Pop US$3.95
8" Heart Shaped Chocolate Mousse Cake US$41.95
Cookie Tray 2lb US$49.95
Mother's Day Custom Cookie US$6.95
Chocolate Mousse Heart French Pastry US$7.25
1lb Cookie Tray US$29.95
6 Packaged Macaroon US$14.95

The Breakfast Bar
Breakfast Platter US$16.95
2 Egg Platter Bacon Home Fries Toast
The Breakfast Wrap US$16.95
Two eggs any style with oven roasted potatoes, choice of cheese
The Breakfast Crepe US$16.95
Two eggs any style with bacon and choice of cheese.
Chicken Quesadilla US$18.95
Chicken, Mozzarella, Cheddar, Tomato
Potato & Egg Panini US$16.95
Scrambled eggs, roasted potatoes, mozzarella,
Buttermilk Pancakes US$18.95
3 Pancakes, Topped with berries and Maple Syrup
Avocado Toast With Single Egg US$22.95
Ham & Cheese Croissant US$12.95
Hungry Man Hero US$16.95
Ham, Bacon, 2 Egg, Lettuce, Tomato, Ketchup & Mayo
California Quesadilla US$19.95
two eggs scrambled, bacon, sharp cheddar, mozzarella, red onions, roasted potatoes, grilled tortilla wrap
French Toast US$18.95
Challah Bread French Toast topped with Maple Syrup
The Breakfast Sandwich US$8.75
Two eggs any style served on a roll. Comes with American Cheese and Bacon
Avocado Toast US$19.95

FAMOUS TRES LECHE CAKE
Tres Leche Cake US$41.95
Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted three milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries and blueberries.
Chocolate Tres Leche Cake US$41.95
Silky smooth Chocolate custard cream & dulce de leche set atop Chocolate sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted three milk mixture blend, iced with Chocolate Whipped Cream & topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries & blueberries.
Personal Tres Leche Cake US$12.95
Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted three milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries and blueberries.

Thanksgiving Pies
10" Cherry Pie Traditional US$32.95
10" Apple Pie Traditional US$32.95
8" Blueberry Crumb US$27.95
8" Banana Cream Pie US$28.95
10" Blueberry Crumb US$32.95
10" Pecan Pie US$34.95
8" Chocolate Cream Pie US$28.95
8" Apple Pie Traditional US$27.95
10" Sweet Potato Pie US$32.95
Plain Stollen US$31.95
10" Strawberry Rhubarb US$34.95
8" Sweet Potato Pie US$27.95
8" Pecan Pie US$29.95
10" Cherry Crumb US$32.95
Cornucopia Stuffed With 1lb Cookies US$49.95
8" Apple Crumb Pie US$27.95
8" Cherry Pie Traditional US$27.95
8" Coconut Custard Pie US$27.95
10" Apple Crumb Pie US$32.95
8" Sugar Free Pie US$28.95
8" Mincemeat Pie US$27.95
1.5 Cookie Tray US$35.00
10" Blueberry Pie Traditional US$32.95
1lb Pignoli Cookie US$41.95
8" Strawberry Rhubarb US$27.95
10" Pumpkin Pie US$32.95
8" Blueberry Pie Traditional US$27.95
8" Boston Cream Pie US$28.95
Large Fruit Tart US$36.95
10" Coconut Custard Pie US$32.95
1lb Cookie Tray US$24.95
8" Cherry Crumb US$27.95
8" Lemon Meringue Pie US$29.95
8" Pumpkin Pie US$27.95
Key Lime Pie US$9.95
Creamy key lime pie filling set atop the most wonderful crunchy, sweet and buttery bed of graham cracker crust, finished with whipped cream and decorative lime sugar pieces.

Cookie Trays
Cookie Tray 2lb US$49.95
1 Pound Cookie Tray US$32.50
Sugar Free Cookie Tray US$29.95
Cookie Tray 1.5LB US$41.95
one and a half pounds of butter cookies

Large Pies
Apple Crumb Pie US$26.95
Large Fruit Tart US$36.95
8" Lemon Meringue Pie US$29.95
Blueberry Pie US$26.95
Cherry Pie US$26.95
Key Lime Pie US$28.95
Apple Pie US$26.95

Donuts
Jelly Donut US$4.95
Glazed Donut US$4.95
Chocolate French Cruller Donut US$4.95
Vanilla Frosted Donut US$4.95
Vanilla French Cruller Donut US$4.95
One Dozen Assorted Donuts US$55.00
Vanilla Boston Cream Donut US$4.95
Chocolate Frosted Donut US$4.95
Vanilla Donut With Sprinkles US$4.95
Powdered Cruller Donut US$4.95
Chocolate Boston Cream Donut US$4.95

Thanksgiving Dessert
Marzipan Stollen US$33.95
Apple Cider Donut US$4.00
Large Pumpkin Draft Latte US$6.50
Pumpkin Loaf Slice With Icing US$5.25
5lb Cookie Tray US$120.00
Pumpkin Muffin US$3.95
1lb Rainbow Cookies US$31.95
Pregnant Cannnoli US$55.00
Large Pregnant Cannoli with 30 mini cannoli's inside
Cannoli US$6.00
Pfeffonusse 1lb US$22.95
Honey Balls 1lb (Stroofli) US$24.95
Pumpkin Croissant US$6.50
1lb Pignoli Cookie US$41.95
Thanksgiving Cookie US$6.50
Plain Stollen US$31.95
6" 3D Pumpkin Cake US$35.95
Chocolate Turkey US$29.95
3lb Cookie Tray US$69.95
Fig Cookies 1lb US$25.95
6" Scarecrow Cake US$35.95
Cookie Tray 1.5LB US$41.95
one and a half pounds of butter cookies
Carrot Croissant With Sweet Cream Cheese US$6.50
Small Pumpkin Draft Latte US$5.75
Gingerbread House Small US$65.00
Cornucopia Stuffed With 1lb Cookies US$49.95
Spice Cookie Packed 15 US$16.95
Fruit Cake Loaf US$21.95
Cookie Tray 2lb US$49.95
2 pounds of butter cookies
Thanksgiving Cupcakes US$4.95
6" Turkey Cake US$35.95
Thanksgiving Cake Pop US$4.25
Pumpkin Cheesecake US$8.95
Creamy baked pumpkin cheesecake set atop the most wonderful crunchy, sweet and buttery bed of graham cracker crust, finished with whipped cinnamon cream cheese and toasted pumpkin seeds
Cannoli Chip Platter With 1LB Cannoli Dip US$41.95
Cookie Tray 1lb US$30.95
Flan US$6.95

Eclairs
Custard Éclair US$6.95
Tres Leche Éclair US$6.95
Éclair filled with 3-milk signature blend, custard, and dulce de leche, topped with fresh fruit

Custom Order ( Pre-ordered with our staff)
Custom Order US$5.00
Please call the store first to place your order. Enter the invoice number in special instructions. (631) 424 -4034

Whipped Cream Cakes
Fresh Fruit Salad US$29.95
Silky smooth custard and pillowy-soft whipped cream set atop our specially Italian crafted airy cake sponge loaded with freshly chopped strawberries, bananas, peaches, and pineapples, finished with whip cream, a citrusy glaze, and fresh fruit
Strawberry Shortcake US$29.95
Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped strawberries set atop thin layers of vanilla cake lightly soaked in strawberry syrup, finished with whipped cream icing and topped with fresh strawberries
Black Forest Cake US$29.95
A combination of whipped cream and chocolate whipped cream infused with sour black cherry set between two pieces of chocolate cake and one piece vanilla cake soaked in sour black cherry syrup, finished with dark chocolate shavings, dollops of whipped cream, cherries and lathered in chocolate cake crumbs

Apple Cider Donut Pumpkin Draft Latte Special
Apple Cider Pumpkin Draft Latte Large US$12.95
Apple Cider Pumpkin Draft Latte Small US$9.95

Breakfast Rings
Blueberry Pudding Ring US$16.95
Pecan Ring US$16.95
Cheese Danish Ring US$16.95
Apple Horn Ring US$16.95
Almond Paste Ring US$16.95
Fruit Ring US$16.95
Large Crumb Cake US$18.95
Chocolate Horn Ring US$16.95

Buttercream Cakes
Vanilla Shadow Cake US$28.95
Ever-so-light buttercream between thin layers of moist vanilla and chocolate cake, finished with vanilla buttercream, a decadent dark chocolate ganache drip, and a marachino cherry
Mini Birthday Cake Vanilla US$14.95
Vanilla buttercream between layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with smooth vanilla buttercream, carefully handcrafted buttercream flowers, and vanilla cake crumbs
Funfetti Cake US$28.95
Smooth and silky buttercream between thin layers of vanilla funfetti cake, finished with bright ombre vanilla buttercream, a sweet white chocolate ganache drip, and colorful confetti sprinkles
Oreo Buttercream Cake US$28.95
Creamy vanilla buttercream loaded with chunks of oreo between layers of moist chocolate cake, finished with oreo buttercream, a dark chocolate ganache drip, topped with buttercream swirls and oreo cookies
Seven Layer Cake US$25.95
Rich chocolate buttercream sandwiched between seven layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with creamy chocolate fudge, vanilla cake crumbs, and a marachino cherry
Biscoff Cake US$28.95
Vanilla Cake Biscoff Cookie Cream Biscoff Buttercream Caramel Drip Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"
Mini Birthday Cake Chocolate US$14.95
Rich chocolate buttercream between. thin layers of soft chocolate cake, finished with chocolate buttercream, carefully handcrafted buttercream flowers, and chocolate cake crumbs
Chocolate Devil's Food Cake US$28.95
Decadent moist devil's food chocolate cake with creamy melt-in-your-mouth chocolate fudge, topped with chocolate swirls and chocolate shards. ALL chocolate
Carnival Cake US$31.95
Pink and Blue swirled cake tiers alternate with two layers of purple icing, layers of birthday cake sugar cookie dough made with colorful rainbow sprinkles and buttercream icing
Carrot Cake US$31.95
Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between deeply moist layers of carrot cake baked with golden raisins, finished with super soft and lush sweet cream cheese, a marzipan carrot and lathered in toasted coconut flakes
Chocolate Shadow Cake US$28.95
Rich chocolate buttercream between thin layers of soft chocolate and vanilla cake, finished with smooth chocolate buttercream, a decadent dark chocolate ganache swirl, and a marachino cherry
Cannoli Cake US$33.95
Layers of moist vanilla cake and our delicious cannoli cream with chocolate chips finished with a chocolate drip and pieces of cannolis

St. Joseph's Day/ Irish Soda Bread
Zeppole St. Joseph's Pastry US$6.75
Zeppole filled with Custard Filling
Hot Cross Buns US$4.95
St. Patrick Day Cupcake US$4.95
Lent Donut US$3.95
Plain Donut with powdered sugar
St. Patrick Day Cookie US$6.25
Sfinge St Joseph Pastry US$6.75
Zeppole filled with Cannoli Cream
St. Patrick Day Cake US$36.95
Vanilla Cake Chocolate Fudge Filling St. Patrick Day Themed
Irish Soda Bread US$10.95
St. Patrick Day Cake Pop US$3.95

Large Cookies
Chocolate Sprinkle Cookie US$6.00
Black & White US$6.00
Reese's Peanut Butter Cookie US$6.00
M & M Cookie US$6.00
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie US$6.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$6.00
Chinese Cookie US$6.00
Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie US$6.00
Sugar Cookie US$6.00

Valentine's Day <3
Cake Pop US$3.95
White Chocolate Heel With 4 Truffles US$51.95
The Chocolate Red Bottom heel comes packaged with pink ribbon for the perfect sweet treat for your loved ones <3
9" Heart Shaped Strawberry Shortcake US$39.95
The Dubai Chocolate Croissant US$11.20
Pistachio and Kunafa Filling
Valentine Cupcake US$5.25
Chocolate Covered Strawberry US$6.95
9" Heart Shaped Chocolate Mousse US$52.45
Rose Flower French Pastry US$8.75
Our moist vanilla sponge layered with our strawberry mousse filling finished with a red chocolate velvet texture on the outside
Vanilla Bean Heart Mousse Cake US$49.95
Chocolate Sponge
9" Heart Shaped Red Velvet Mousse US$52.45
5" Heart Shaped Chocolate Mousse Cake US$37.45
Chocolate Mousse Heart French Pastry US$8.75
Light and airy chocolate mousse set atop a thin soft chocolate cake finished with rich chocolate ganache
Teddy Bear Love Cake US$41.20
Chocolate Chocolate Mousse Vanilla Buttercream
Red Velvet Heart French Pastry US$8.95
LOVE French Pastry US$8.75
Chocolate mousse infused with vanilla bean set atop a shortbread cookie and garnished with red velvet coca
Chocolate Mousse Heart Cake US$49.95
5" Red Velvet Mousse Cake US$37.45

Cookies by the pound
1lb Pignoli Cookie US$41.95
1lb Rainbow Cookies US$31.95

Crumb Cake Slice
Crumb Cake Slice US$4.95
Crumb Bun Slice US$4.95
Lemon Pound Cake Slice With Vanilla Hard Icing On Top US$6.95

Valentine Themed Hot Chocolate
Valentine's Day Small Hot Chocolate US$6.50
Valentine's Day Large Hot Chocolate US$7.25

Passover
1lb Assorted Rugelach US$18.95
Jelly Rolls US$19.95
Please write in description the type you'd like: raspberry chocolate lemon apricto
Sponge Cake US$16.95
Seven Layer Cake US$25.95
Nut Cake US$16.95
Rainbow Cookies Per LB US$28.95
Honey Cake US$16.95
Seven Layer Slice US$6.95
Rich chocolate buttercream sandwiched between seven layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with dark chocolate ganache.
Chocolate Flourless Cake US$32.95
Railroad Bar US$4.95
Coconut Macaron US$1.75
Mandel Brodt US$19.95

Scones
1 Dozen Assorted Scones US$55.00
Cranberry Walnut Scone US$5.25
Raisin And Pecan Scone US$5.25
Chocolate Chip Scone US$5.25
Blueberry Scone US$5.25

Hannukkah
Menorah Cake US$38.95
Menorah Design
Hanukkah Cupcakes US$4.95
Hannukkah Themed Cookies US$6.95
1 Lb Assorted Rugelach US$30.25
Apricot, chocolate and raspberry.

Christmas
Plain Stollen US$31.95
Fruit Bread With Dried Fruit
Christmas Cheesecake Colors US$29.95
Cookie Tray 1lb US$30.95
One pound of butter cookies
5lb Cookie Tray US$120.00
Good For 35-50 People
Pregnant Cannnoli US$55.00
Large Pregnant Cannoli with 30 mini cannoli's inside
1lb Rainbow Cookies US$31.95
Christmas Cake Pops US$3.95
Christmas Croissant US$6.95
Lobster Tail Pastry US$6.95
Crispy flaky shell baked gorgeously golden filled with light and delicious bavarian cream
Cannoli Chip Platter With 1LB Cannoli Dip US$41.95
1lb Lemon Drop Cookies US$29.95
Sfoigetelle US$4.95
Marzipan Stollen US$33.95
Fruit Bread with Dried Fruit and Marzipan
3lb Cookie Tray US$69.95
Good For 25-30 People
Fruit Cake Loaf US$21.95
GIngerBread Snaps With Chocolate 1lb US$21.95
1lb Pignoli Cookie US$41.95
Honey Balls 1lb (Stroofli) US$24.95
Chocolate Yule Log US$33.95
Vanilla Cake Chocolate Buttercream Filling Chocolate Buttercream Icing
Strawberry Shortcake US$31.95
Christmas Cupcakes US$5.25
Gingerbread House Large US$90.00
Cookie Tray 2lb US$49.95
2 pounds of butter cookies
Vanilla Yule Log / Buche De Noel US$33.95
Vanilla Cake Chocolate Buttercream Vanilla Buttercream Icing
Cookie Tray 1.5LB US$41.95
one and a half pounds of butter cookies
Gingerbread Christmas Tree US$51.95
gingerbread tree

Omelets
Make It Your Own US$14.00
Traditional three egg omelette served with toast & home fries.
Meat Lover's Omelet US$18.95
Three eggs folded. sausage, bacon, ham, cheddar, roasted potatoes, bread

Belgian Waffles
Belgian Waffle US$14.95
Light and crispy, made to order with a dusting of confectioner’s sugar.

By The Slice / Cannoli's
Lobster Tail Pastry US$6.95
Crispy flaky shell baked gorgeously golden filled with light and delicious bavarian cream
Tiramisu Slice US$6.95
Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream & dusted with cocoa powder
Napolean Slice US$6.95
Gorgeously golden crispy layers of puff pastry filled with rich custard pastry cream, finished with a glossy royal icing
Seven Layer Slice US$6.95
Rich chocolate buttercream sandwiched between seven layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with dark chocolate ganache
Philly Fluff (Cream Cheese Pound Cake) US$16.95
Moist and fluffy pound cake made with cream cheese and cinnamon . Marble or plain.
Carrot Cake Slice US$6.95
Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between deeply moist carrot cake baked with golden raisins, finished with super soft and lush cream cheese icing & a marzipan carrot
Cannoli US$6.00
Our signature cannoli filling in a crispy fried shell
Chocolate Cannoli US$6.00
Our signature cannoli filling in a chocolate covered crispy fried shell

Other Dishes
Grilled Chicken US$7.00
Roasted Potatoes US$5.00
Sweet Potato Fries US$4.00
Bacon US$4.00
Chicken Fingers & Fries US$12.95
Served with French fries.
Yogurt & Granola Bowl US$15.75
Greek yogurt, homemade granola, berry jam, seasonal fruits, honey
Home Fries US$4.00
French Fries US$5.00
Mixed Fruit Bowl US$9.95
Grilled Cheese & Fries US$15.00
Served on Texas toast with French fries.
Soup Du Jour US$10.95
Chicken Noodle, Clam Chowder, Broccoli Cheddar

Superbowl Dessert
1lb Cookie Tray US$24.95
Cookie Tray 2lb US$49.95
2 pounds of butter cookies
Cookie Tray 1.5LB US$41.95
one and a half pounds of butter cookies
Pregnant Cannnoli US$55.00
Large Pregnant Cannoli with 30 mini cannoli's inside
1lb Rainbow Cookies US$31.95
Football Cupcake US$5.25
Football Cake US$36.95
Vanilla Cake Chocolate Mousse Football Themed
Football Cookie US$6.50
Cannoli Chip Platter With 1LB Cannoli Dip US$41.95
Superbowl Cake US$36.95
Chocolate Cake Chocolate Mousse Filling

Passover
Chocolate Flourless Cake US$32.95
Mandel Brodt US$19.95
Honey Cake US$16.95
Rainbow Cookies Per LB US$28.95
Railroad Bar US$4.95
Coconut Macaron US$1.75
Seven Layer Cake US$25.95
Nut Cake US$16.95
Sponge Cake US$16.95
Seven Layer Slice US$6.95
1lb Assorted Rugelach US$18.95
Jelly Rolls US$19.95
Please write in description the type you'd like: raspberry chocolate lemon apricto

Breakfast Pastries
Apple Strudel US$16.95
Chocolate Dipped Almond Horn US$6.00
Sugar Free Pastry US$6.00
Apple, Cherry, Blueberry
Powdered Almond Horn US$6.00
Palmier (Elephant Ear Cookie) US$6.00
Peach Boat Puff Pastry US$6.00
Chocolate Cigar US$6.00
(Puff Pastry Dough)
1lb Assorted Rugelach US$18.95
Apricot, Chocolate and Raspberry

Christmas Pies
8" Banana Cream Pie US$28.95
10" Cherry Crumb US$32.95
8" Strawberry Rhubarb US$27.95
8" Apple Pie Traditional US$27.95
8" Chocolate Cream Pie US$28.95
8" Pumpkin Pie US$27.95
8" Sugar Free Pie US$28.95
8" Apple Crumb Pie US$27.95
10" Coconut Custard Pie US$32.95
10" Blueberry Crumb US$32.95
8" Pecan Pie US$36.10
Rich, buttery filling topped with toasted pecans in a flaky, golden crust.
10" Cherry Pie Traditional US$32.95
8" Cherry Pie Traditional US$27.95
8" Pecan Pie US$29.95
8" Coconut Custard Pie US$27.95
8" Cherry Crumb US$27.95
8" Mincemeat Pie US$27.95
8" Blueberry Pie Traditional US$27.95

Napoleon Cake (Milhojas)
Napoleon Cake (Milhojas) US$33.95

Mini Pastries
Mini Cannoli US$1.95
Mini Chocolate Cannoli US$1.95
Mini Pastries Assorted Per Dozen US$26.95

Crumb Cake Slice
Crumb Cake Slice US$4.95
Crumb Bun Slice US$4.95
Blueberry Pound Cake Slice With Vanilla Hard Icing On Top US$6.95

Tarts
Fresh Fruit Tartlet US$7.95
Silky rich custard cream in a dark chocolate dipped buttery vanilla sablé tart topped with strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, blackberries, mandarin oranges and kiwi
Vanilla Bean Tart US$7.95
Almond sponge cake lightly marinated in almond flavored syrup in a buttery vanilla sablé tart shell infused with rich and creamy vanilla bean mousse topped with whipped white chocolate ganache and white chocolate sticks
Lemon Meringue Tart US$7.95
Citrusy lemon filling in a buttery vanilla sablé tart shell, topped with fluffy vanilla meringue
Salted Caramel Chocolate Mousse Tart US$7.95
Rich chocolate ganache and a liquid salted caramel center in a buttery chocolate sablé tart shell, topped with chocolate mousse lightly coated in caramel ganache & chocolate crunchies and finished with a chocolate disk and cocoa powder
Apple Crumb Tart US$7.95
Fresh diced apples doused in soft cinnamon and sugar in a vanilla sablé tart shell topped & baked with golden buttery crumble and powdered sugar

Cupcakes
Carrot Cupcake US$4.50
Red Velvet Cupcake US$3.95
Oreo Cupcake US$3.95
Hostess Cupcake US$3.95
Classic Cupcake US$3.95
Vanilla or Chocolate Cupcake With Sprinkles and Cherry on Top

Father's Day 2024
Cookie Tray 2lb US$49.95
Chocolate Cannoli US$6.00
Father's Day Cookie US$6.45
Father's Day Hat US$37.95
Cookie Tray 1.5LB US$41.95
Beer Cake US$37.95
Father's Day Cake Pop US$3.00
Father's Day Cupcake US$5.50

Gingerbread Hot Chocolate Special
Gingerbread Hot Chocolate Large US$12.95
Gingerbread Hot Chocolate Small US$10.95

Muffins
Bluberry Muffin US$5.25
Chocolate Chip Muffin US$5.25
Carrot Muffin US$5.25
Lemon Poppy Muffin US$5.25
Corn Muffin US$5.25
Apple Muffin US$5.25
Gluten Free Muffin US$5.25
All Chocolate Muffin US$5.25
1 Dozen Assorted Muffins US$55.00
Bran Muffin US$5.25

Brownies
Fudge Brownie US$6.00
Oreo Brownie US$6.00

Smoothies
Acai Smoothie US$13.50
Acai, strawberry, banana, acai juice.
Banana Blues US$13.50
Bananas, blueberries, low fat yogurt
Strawberry Banana Bash US$13.50
Strawberries, Bananas, Low fat yogurt
Green Dream US$13.50
Kale, Spinach, Banana, Apple, Milk
Berry Balance US$13.50
Blackberries, blueberries, strawberries & raspberries.
Rise & Shine Smoothie US$13.50
Oats, bananas, peanut butter, almond milk, honey.

Salads
Quinoa Salad US$18.95
Spinach, avocado, tri color peppers, cranberries & lemon vinaigrette.
Warm Grain Bowl US$21.95
Mixed greens, 6-minute egg, red quinoa, avocado, grilled tomatoes, roasted red peppers, radish, sunflower seeds, feta, cilantro, lemon vinaigrette
Grilled Chicken Avocado Salad US$21.95
Asian Caesar Salad US$18.95
Romaine Lettuce, Napa cabbage, wontons, parmesan, ginger aioli dressing
House Salad US$17.50
Arugula, cranberries, caramelized walnuts, goat cheese, cherry tomatoes & raspberry vinaigrette.
Strawberry Goat Cheese US$18.95
Mixed Greens, sliced strawberries, goat cheese, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, raspberry vinaigrette

Cheesecakes
Marble Cheesecake US$24.95
Oreo Cheesecake US$26.95
Strawberry Cheesecake US$26.95
New York Cheesecake US$24.95

Father's Day 2025
Father's Day Cookie US$6.45
Cannoli US$6.50
Beer Cake US$39.95
Chocolate Cake Chocolate Filling Beer Mug Decoration
Chocolate Cannoli US$6.00
1 Pound Rainbow Cookies US$34.95
Father's Day Cupcake US$5.50
Cookie Tray 1.5LB US$41.95
Father's Day Cake Pop US$4.95
Tuxedo Cake US$39.95
Vanilla Cake Strawberry & Fresh Cream Tuxedo Decoration
Cookie Tray 2lb US$49.95

Croissants
Cinammon Sugar Round Croissant US$6.95
Filled with Vanilla Pastry Cream
Pistachio Croissant US$6.95
Plain Croissant US$6.50
Cannoli Cruffin US$6.95
cruffin is a hybrid of a croissant and a muffin.
Ham & Swiss Croissant US$8.95
Freshly Baked Everyday
Apple Croissant US$6.95
Cronut (Jelly Filled Fried Croissant) US$6.95
Bear Claw Croissant US$6.95
Chocolate & Toasted Coconut Croissant
Chocolate Croissant US$6.95
The Crookie (Croissant-Cookie) US$6.95
Crunchy croissant exterior and a chewy chocolate chip cookie interior (warm it up)
Almond Croissant US$6.95
Nutella Croissant US$6.95
The Dubai Chocolate Croissant US$10.95
Pistachio & Kunafa Filling
Cream Cheese Cruffin US$6.95
cruffin (sometimes spelled croffin) is a hybrid of a croissant and a muffin.
Raspberry Cheese Croissant US$6.95
Strawberry Almond Twice Baked Croissant US$6.95

Cake Pop
Vanilla Cake Pop US$3.95
Chocolate Cake Pop US$3.95

Coffee Station proudly serving La Colombe Roasters
Large Coffee US$4.00
Small Latte US$5.50
Large Cappuccino US$6.00
Large Iced Tea US$5.00
Cortado US$5.00
Small Chai Latte US$6.00
Small Machiato US$4.75
Large Iced Latte US$6.50
Large Hot Chocolate US$6.50
Small Iced Coffee US$5.00
Espresso US$4.00
Large Americano US$5.50
Large Chai Latte US$6.95
Large Iced Cappucino US$6.50
Small Iced Latte US$6.00
Small Iced Mocha US$6.95
Small Iced Cappuccino US$5.75
Small Coffee US$3.50
Large Mocha US$6.95
Large Latte US$6.00
Double Espresso US$4.50
Large Cold Brew US$5.95
Large Draft Latte US$6.75
Small Americano US$4.50
Small Hot Chocolate US$6.00
Small Mocha US$6.25
Flat White US$5.00
Large Iced Coffee US$5.95
Small Draft Latte US$6.00
Small Cappuccino US$5.25
Small Cold Brew US$5.75

Christmas Pies
10" Cherry Pie Traditional US$32.95
8" Pecan Pie US$36.10
Rich, buttery filling topped with toasted pecans in a flaky, golden crust.
10" Cherry Crumb US$32.95
8" Apple Pie Traditional US$27.95
8" Cherry Crumb US$27.95
8" Apple Crumb Pie US$27.95
8" Mincemeat Pie US$27.95
10" Coconut Custard Pie US$32.95
8" Pumpkin Pie US$27.95
8" Cherry Pie Traditional US$27.95
8" Strawberry Rhubarb US$27.95
10" Blueberry Crumb US$32.95
8" Banana Cream Pie US$28.95
8" Coconut Custard Pie US$27.95
8" Pecan Pie US$29.95
Rich, buttery filling topped with toasted pecans in a flaky, golden crust.
8" Chocolate Cream Pie US$28.95
8" Blueberry Pie Traditional US$27.95
8" Sugar Free Pie US$28.95

Shakes
M&M Shake US$12.95
Chocolate ice cream and milk, topped with whipped cream, M&M candies & chocolate sauce.
The Buttercooky US$12.95
Vanilla or chocolate ice cream with milk, topped with whipped cream, cake crumbs & rainbow sprinkles.
Oreo Mountain US$12.95
Vanilla ice cream, milk and Oreo cookies topped with whipped cream, Oreo crumbs, white & dark chocolate sauces.

Paninis & Wraps
Chicken Quesadilla US$16.95
Chicken Quesadilla
Turkey BLAT US$16.95
oven roasted turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, avocado, tomatoes, honey mustard on wrap
Chicken Garlic US$16.95
Grilled Herb Chicken, lettuce, tomato, mozzarella, charred garlic mayonnaise
Chicken Pesto Panini US$16.95
Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella & basil pesto.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap US$16.95
Chicken Cutlet Fresh Mozzarella Buffalo Sauce
Chicken Gorgonzola Panini US$16.95
Caramelized onion, gorgonzola, mayo & arugula.
Tuna Salad Sandwhich US$16.95
Tuna Salad, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, whole wheat bread
Vegetarian Panini US$16.95
Roasted red peppers, portobello mushroom, grilled eggplant, spinach & basil pesto.
Chicken Caesar US$16.95
Served on Texas toast.
Caprese Panini US$16.95
Tomato, fresh mozzarella, spinach & basil pesto.
Turkey Apple US$16.95
Mayo, granny smith apple, red onion & goat cheese.
Chicken Cutlet Panini US$16.95
Breaded chicken, lettuce, tomato, mozzarella
Americana Panini US$16.95
Grilled chicken, swiss cheese, avocado & honey mustard.

Oatmeal Bar
Chai Oatmeal US$14.95
Raisins, walnuts, steamed chai.
Huntington Rise N’ Shine Oatmeal US$12.95
Fresh fruit, maple syrup, steamed milk.

Quiche
Traditional Quiche Served With Salad US$15.95
Broccoli and Cheese
Florentine Quiche Served With Salad US$15.95
Sun Dried Tomato, Spinach & Sharp Cheese
Whole Quiche US$34.95
Traditional, Lorraine, Florentine
Lorraine Quiche Served With Salad US$15.95
Bacon, Cheese

Cold Beverages
Sparkling Ice Black Raspberry US$3.50
Diet Coke US$3.00
Pellegrino US$3.00
Coco-Cola US$3.00
Cranberry Juice US$3.00
Apple Juice US$3.00
Sprite US$3.00
Poland Spring US$2.00
Nesquik Chocolate Milk US$3.00
Orange Juice US$3.00
Figi Water US$3.00
Pure Leaf Unsweetened Tea US$3.00
Pure Leaf Tea US$3.00
Grape Juice US$3.00

4th of July
4th Of July Cake Pops US$2.95
4th Of July Buttercream Cake US$34.95
Strawberry Shortcake US$31.95
4th Of July Cupcakes US$3.50

Other Dishes
Yogurt & Granola Bowl US$15.75
Greek yogurt, homemade granola, berry jam, seasonal fruits, honey
French Fries US$5.00
Bacon US$4.00
Chicken Fingers & Fries US$12.95
Served with French fries.
Soup Du Jour US$10.95
Chicken Noodle, Clam Chowder, Broccoli Cheddar
Mixed Fruit Bowl US$9.95
Home Fries US$4.00
Sweet Potato Fries US$4.00
Roasted Potatoes US$5.00
Grilled Cheese & Fries US$15.00
Served on Texas toast with French fries.
Grilled Chicken US$7.00

Coffee Station proudly serving La Colombe Roasters
Large Iced Latte US$6.50
Small Iced Cappuccino US$5.75
Flat White US$5.00
Large Americano US$5.50
Small Latte US$5.50
Large Coffee US$4.00
Large Iced Tea US$5.00
Small Coffee US$3.50
Small Machiato US$4.75
Cortado US$5.00
Large Latte US$6.00
Small Americano US$4.50
Large Hot Chocolate US$6.50
Small Iced Mocha US$6.95
Large Iced Coffee US$5.95
Small Iced Latte US$6.00
Small Hot Chocolate US$6.00
Small Mocha US$6.25
Small Chai Latte US$6.00
Small Draft Latte US$6.00
Large Chai Latte US$6.95
Large Cold Brew US$5.95
Double Espresso US$4.50
Small Cappuccino US$5.25
Small Cold Brew US$5.75
Espresso US$4.00
Large Cappuccino US$6.00
Large Draft Latte US$6.75
Large Mocha US$6.95
Small Iced Coffee US$5.00
Large Iced Cappucino US$6.50

Acai Bowl
Acai Bowl US$15.95
Acai, strawberry, banana with granola, blueberry, coconut, honey and strawberry topping.

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe Photos

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe Location

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe

New York Suffolk County Huntington New York Avenue

495 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743, USA

Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 837 user reviews.

tres lechesfrostingdonutsbuttercreamfruitrainbow cookiescannoliwhipped creamjellyrye bread

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This place is such a nice and clean environment !! So much to choose from. I had lunch here too. I didn’t even know they offered savory dishes. Glad I stopped by. Coffee on tap …… yes please !!
June 06 · Cindy B.
I recently tried a large assortment of baked goods from Buttercookie Bakery and Café in Huntington, and everything was fresh and delicious. The flavors were incredible, and the quality was top notch. Highly recommend for anyone with a sweet tooth!
February 09 · James Wood
The food for lunch was decently priced the desserts are worth all their prices and lunch’s very good the service is super fast and the music and atmosphere is amazing 5/5 stars my farm loves to order from them their cakes are expensive but very worth the price every thing they make is amazing the cake I had has chocolate ganache,mousse and cheese cake inside also if your trying to be healthy they have salads and açaí bowls
May 23 · wolfred
Buttercooky made our son’s 4th birthday so special! He’s a monster truck loving boy and seeing this cake made his whole day. The cake was fresh and delicious too. Thank you so much to the team at Buttercooky!
April 06 · Vinny Zukowski
The staff are so friendly and helpful! Our first visit we were a little overwhelmed by the huge selection, the employee was extremely patient and kind. We had breakfast- California quesadilla and pancakes, both excellent. The pastries were delicious! We got a pistachio croissant and the Dubai croissant. Will be our new bakery for sure (even coming from West Islip, it’s worth the drive)
January 19 · Angela R