Cakes Creatively by Crystal

Introduction / Overview

For residents across the greater Columbus area and throughout Ohio, Cakes Creatively by Crystal in Pickerington stands as a beacon of artistry and flavor in the world of custom confectionery. Officially operating as a specialized Wedding Bakery, this cherished local dessert shop, run by the talented Crystal Alward, has built a reputation far beyond its specific location. What began as a passionate hobby in 2004 quickly blossomed into a dedicated full-time venture, initially focusing on crafting dream wedding cakes for hundreds of couples annually. The business expanded, opening its physical storefront at the Porter’s Coffee House and Bakery location, which serves as a welcoming spot for daily treats while still being the heart of the custom cake operation.

The name itself speaks to the core mission: creating cakes that are not just desserts, but personalized, creative masterpieces. The expertise here is not limited to simple tiered cakes; it extends to complex, unique designs that capture the spirit of any celebration, whether it’s a big wedding day or an intimate gathering. Ohio customers consistently praise the shop for its professionalism, dependability, and, most importantly, the incredible taste of the products. Reviews highlight the moistness, dense texture, and remarkable flavors like the specialty French Toast cake, proving that the shop successfully balances aesthetic brilliance with gastronomic delight. Whether you are seeking an affordable, beautifully simple sheet cake or a custom-designed, leather-look motorcycle wedding cake, Cakes Creatively by Crystal delivers with unparalleled attention to detail and a genuine caring nature for every single order.

Beyond the grand wedding cake designs, the shop is a fantastic local resource for everyday and smaller celebrations, offering individual cupcakes and various sizes of ready-to-order celebration cakes. This Pickerington shop is the go-to specialist for those in Ohio who value custom artistry and exceptional flavor from a dedicated, local professional.

Location and Accessibility

Cakes Creatively by Crystal is ideally situated to serve the Pickerington community and the wider central Ohio region.

Address: 194 W Church St, Pickerington, OH 43147, USA

The bakery is located on West Church Street in Pickerington, placing it within a historical and easily accessible part of the city. This location provides convenient access for local patrons and those traveling from Columbus and surrounding suburbs to consult on custom orders or pick up pre-arranged desserts. Accessibility is a key feature of this location, which is particularly important when dealing with delicate items like wedding or celebration cakes. The property features a Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot, ensuring ease of access for all guests, which is a thoughtful consideration for anyone planning a large event where accessibility matters to their guests. The storefront is set up for straightforward Takeout service, allowing for quick retrieval of orders, and its central location in Pickerington makes it a dependable hub for delivery services across the region.

Services Offered

The spectrum of services provided by Cakes Creatively by Crystal caters to both the large-scale event planner and the individual with a daily sweet craving.

• Specialized Wedding Cakes: Expert consultation and creation of bespoke, highly customized wedding cakes, from elegant, simple tiers to complex, themed designs.
• Celebration Cakes: Ready-to-order, standard-sized cakes perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, and other milestones, available in classic flavors like:
  • 6" Vanilla Cake with Vanilla Buttercream ($45.00)
  • 6" Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream ($45.00)
• Custom Sheet Cakes: Providing beautifully presented, high-quality sheet cakes—an excellent and often more practical alternative for serving large guest counts at weddings and parties.
• Individual Cupcakes: Offering daily options for an accessible treat or for building a mixed dessert table:
  • Build Your Own Individual Cupcake ($4.00)
  • Two Cupcakes ($7.00)
  • Four Cupcakes ($14.00)
  • Six Cupcakes ($21.00)
  • A Dozen Cupcakes ($42.00)
• Custom Flavor Profiles: Offering a variety of delicious and unique cake, filling, and icing flavors, including highly praised specialties like the French Toast flavor.
• Delivery Service: Providing reliable delivery for custom and large orders, minimizing stress for clients on their event day, a service specifically highlighted and appreciated by wedding clients.
• Payment Convenience: Accepting a variety of secure payment options, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.

Features / Highlights

Cakes Creatively by Crystal sets itself apart in the competitive Central Ohio dessert landscape with several distinguishing qualities that keep customers returning.

• Artistry and Unique Designs: The shop is widely recognized for its ability to execute complex, unique, and personalized designs—from custom grooms’ cakes kept as a surprise to detailed leather-look textures, showcasing high-level artistry and attention to detail.
• Exceptional Flavor Profile: While presentation is key, customers consistently rave about the taste. Cakes are described as dense, moist, and delicious, a testament to the quality ingredients and baking expertise. The signature French Toast flavor is a massive, memorable hit.
• Professionalism and Dependability: Multiple testimonials stress Crystal's professionalism, her caring nature for every order, and, crucially, her dependability, ensuring cakes are delivered on time and exactly as requested, which is a non-negotiable factor for high-stakes events like weddings.
• Versatile Offerings: The business successfully manages to offer both high-end, custom-designed tiered wedding cakes and simple, affordable options like single cupcakes and basic celebration cakes, appealing to a broad range of customer needs and budgets.
• Local Owner Dedication: The business is rooted in a passion that started in 2004, reflecting a deep commitment to the craft and the community, offering a personalized experience often lacking in larger, more commercial operations.
• Pricing Transparency: Clearly listed prices for standard items like 6" celebration cakes and cupcakes allow customers to plan easily, while custom quotes are available for more intricate wedding orders.

Contact Information

For residents and event planners in the Ohio area looking to collaborate on a custom cake design or to simply place an order for cupcakes, Cakes Creatively by Crystal welcomes inquiries.

Address: 194 W Church St, Pickerington, OH 43147, USA

Phone: (614) 783-4830

Mobile Phone: +1 614-783-4830

Reaching out via phone is the best way to start the process for a custom consultation or to confirm availability for a specific date, ensuring your vision is perfectly aligned with the bakery’s schedule and capabilities.

What is worth choosing

For Ohio users, Cakes Creatively by Crystal is the ultimate choice for any event where the dessert needs to be more than just an afterthought—it needs to be a focal point. What makes this establishment particularly worth choosing is the unparalleled blend of artistry and flavor. You can find beautiful cakes elsewhere, and you can find delicious cakes elsewhere, but finding a baker who excels at both, while demonstrating genuine care and dependability, is rare.

If you are planning an event, especially a wedding in the Columbus or Pickerington area, Crystal’s ability to take a "unique design" concept, such as the motorcycle and leather theme, and execute it flawlessly—both visually and in taste—is a huge value proposition. The customer service, which includes going above and beyond to deliver cakes to ease the couple's stress, is a testament to the business's commitment to the client experience.

Even for simpler needs, choosing this bakery means you are guaranteed a superior product. It is highly recommended to try one of the signature, non-traditional flavors. Customers repeatedly single out the specialty French Toast flavor as an absolute "HUGE hit," making it a must-try for both custom cakes and a simple cupcake indulgence. When you choose Cakes Creatively by Crystal, you are investing in an edible work of art created with professionalism and passion, ensuring your Ohio celebration is not just sweet, but unforgettable.

Cakes Creatively by Crystal

194 W Church St, Pickerington, OH 43147, USA