Cakes Extraordinaire Introduce
For us folks here in Maine, especially those of us celebrating life's big moments, finding a local business that can truly bring our visions to life is incredibly valuable. Today, we're putting a spotlight on a gem right here in Yarmouth: Cakes Extraordinaire. As its name suggests, this isn't just any bakery; it's a place where ordinary cakes are transformed into edible works of art, designed to make your special occasions truly unforgettable. Specializing in custom creations, Cakes Extraordinaire has built a reputation for its meticulous attention to detail, incredible artistry, and, of course, delicious flavors. Whether you're planning a grand celebration, a milestone birthday, or simply want to add a touch of sweetness to an event, this Yarmouth-based bakery is dedicated to exceeding expectations. This article will explore what makes Cakes Extraordinaire a truly exceptional choice for anyone in the Maine region looking for that perfect centerpiece cake, highlighting their commitment to craftsmanship and customer satisfaction.
The location and accessibility of a local business are key factors in how easily and frequently we, as Mainers, can utilize its services. Cakes Extraordinaire is conveniently situated at 305 U.S. Rte 1, Yarmouth, ME 04096, USA. This address places it directly on a major thoroughfare, making it incredibly easy to find and access for residents not only in Yarmouth but also from surrounding towns like Freeport, Falmouth, and even Portland. U.S. Route 1 is a primary artery through coastal Maine, ensuring high visibility and straightforward navigation for anyone traveling by car. The presence on a main route typically means ample parking is available, allowing for stress-free pick-ups of your custom cake creations. For those relying on public transportation, while options might be more limited compared to larger urban centers, U.S. Route 1 is generally well-served, and local taxi or ride-share services are always an option. Its strategic location makes Cakes Extraordinaire a practical choice for anyone needing to pick up a celebration cake, whether they are making a dedicated trip or simply passing through the area. This ease of access contributes significantly to its appeal as a local specialist, ensuring that getting your extraordinary cake is as convenient as the cake itself is remarkable.
Cakes Extraordinaire, as its name proudly proclaims, specializes in delivering cakes that go above and beyond the ordinary. Their core service revolves around creating highly customized cakes that are not only visually stunning but also incredibly delicious. While specific menu items beyond custom cakes are not detailed in the provided information, the reviews clearly indicate a strong focus on bespoke creations for celebrations. Here’s a breakdown of the services and product types implied by customer experiences:
- Custom Celebration Cakes: This is the primary offering. They excel at crafting unique cakes for significant events. Examples include:
- Graduation Cakes: Demonstrated by the instance of creating a cake featuring a researched medical school logo, leading to a highly emotional and successful celebration.
- Birthday Cakes: Shown through the specific request for a "lemon cake with lemon filling and vanilla frosting, with yellow icing, and a yellow axolotl." This highlights their capability to handle very specific and unusual design requests.
- Event Cakes: Implied by their ability to make any "event special" with their detailed and talented work.
- Artistic Cake Decoration: A major part of their service. They are noted for their ability to research specific designs (like logos or obscure animals) and execute them flawlessly, resulting in "beautiful" and "perfect" visual outcomes.
- Variety of Cake Flavors: While the full range isn't listed, successful creations of "carrot cake" and "lemon cake with lemon filling" demonstrate their capability to offer popular and well-loved flavors.
- Personalized Consultations: The interactions described with "Steve" (presumably the owner or a key baker) suggest a process of detailed consultation to understand and fulfill customer requests, even those that are highly specific or require research.
What truly sets Cakes Extraordinaire apart and makes it a stand-out business in the Maine landscape are its remarkable features and highlights, all of which are echoed in the enthusiastic reviews from real customers. These aspects contribute to its reputation as the go-to specialist for memorable celebratory cakes:
- Exceptional Customization and Detail: The bakery excels at fulfilling "extremely specific" requests, even going as far as to research obscure elements like a "med school logo" or an "axolotl." The result is always "way better than we could have imagined" and "perfect," demonstrating an incredible level of artistic skill and attention to detail.
- High Emotional Impact: The cakes are so well-executed that they evoke strong emotional responses, such as a daughter "cried when she saw it." This highlights the bakery's ability to create more than just a dessert; they create a moment.
- Delicious Flavors: Beyond the stunning visuals, the cakes are celebrated for their taste. The "carrot cake" was "loved" by guests and described as "really well done," indicating that flavor is never sacrificed for design. The "lemon cake" also met specific taste expectations perfectly.
- Owner's Dedication and Talent: "Steve" (presumably the owner) is repeatedly praised for being "extremely detailed, talented, thoughtful and great to work with." This personal touch and commitment from the leadership contribute significantly to the positive customer experience and the quality of the final product.
- Problem-Solving Approach: Even when faced with unfamiliar requests (like the axolotl), the owner's willingness to "research it" and "make it happen" demonstrates a proactive and customer-focused approach, ensuring that unique visions are realized.
- Reliability for Special Events: The consistent success in making events "special" and creating "best celebration of the season" cakes indicates high reliability and professionalism, crucial for important occasions.
For those ready to discuss their next extraordinary cake, here is the contact information for Cakes Extraordinaire:
Address: 305 U.S. Rte 1, Yarmouth, ME 04096, USA
Phone: (207) 874-2253
Mobile Phone: +1 207-874-2253
In conclusion, for us Mainers, especially when it comes to celebrating life's significant milestones, Cakes Extraordinaire in Yarmouth stands out as an unparalleled local resource. This isn't your everyday stop for a quick pastry; it's the destination for that truly special, custom-designed cake that will become the centerpiece of your event and create lasting memories. What makes them particularly suitable for locals is their proven ability to handle unique and highly specific requests with incredible artistry and a commitment to flavor. The direct praise for "Steve's" detailed, talented, and thoughtful approach resonates with the value we place on personal service and craftsmanship in our local businesses. Knowing that a bakery is willing to research a medical school logo or an obscure animal like an axolotl, and then execute it perfectly, gives us immense confidence for any important celebration. The combination of stunning visuals and delicious taste, as exemplified by their carrot and lemon cakes, ensures that your guests will be as impressed with the flavor as they are with the design. For birthdays, graduations, anniversaries, or any occasion demanding a truly unique and memorable cake, Cakes Extraordinaire in Yarmouth is undoubtedly the premier choice, making it an invaluable asset to our Maine community.
Cakes Extraordinaire Vibe
Cupcake
Choose your cake options, icing flavors and jimmies options.
- Cupcake US$3.00
Choose a cupcake flavor: Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Lemon, Red Velvet. Choose a icing: Vanilla, Chocolate, Cream Cheese, No Icing. Would you like to add jimmie's?: Add Multicolored Jimmie, Add Red Jimmie, Add Pink Jimmie, Add Purple Jimmie, Add Chocolate Jimmie.
- 2 Piece Cupcakes US$6.00
Choose up to 2 cupcake flavor: Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Lemon, Red Velvet. Choose a icing: Vanilla, Chocolate, Cream Cheese, No Icing. Would you like to add jimmie's?: Add Multicolored Jimmie, Add Red Jimmie, Add Pink Jimmie, Add Purple Jimmie, Add Chocolate Jimmie.
- 4 Piece Cupcakes US$12.00
Choose up to 4 cupcake flavor: Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Lemon, Red Velvet. Choose a icing: Vanilla, Chocolate, Cream Cheese, No Icing. Would you like to add jimmie's?: Add Multicolored Jimmie, Add Red Jimmie, Add Pink Jimmie, Add Purple Jimmie, Add Chocolate Jimmie.
- 6 Piece Cupcakes US$18.00
Choose up to 6 falvor: Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Lemon, Red Velvet. Choose a icing: Vanilla, Chocolate, Cream Cheese, No Icing. Would you like to add jimmie's?: Add Multicolored Jimmie, Add Red Jimmie, Add Pink Jimmie, Add Purple Jimmie, Add Chocolate Jimmie.
- 12 Piece Cupcakes US$36.00
If you would like multiples of a certain flavor and/or combination, please indicate the quantity of each in the Special Instructions. Choose cupcake flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Lemon, Red Velvet. Choose a icing: Vanilla, Chocolate, Cream Cheese, No Icing. Would you like to add jimmie's?: Add Multicolored Jimmie, Add Red Jimmie, Add Pink Jimmie, Add Purple Jimmie, Add Chocolate Jimmie.
Cakes Extraordinaire Details
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Payments
- Cheques
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Cakes Extraordinaire Photos










Cakes Extraordinaire Location
Cakes Extraordinaire
305 U.S. Rte 1, Yarmouth, ME 04096, USA
Cakes Extraordinaire Reviews
cupcakesfrostingpartycarrot cakeresearchvanillawedding cake
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1What a fantastic experience and cake!!! We requested a cake to celebrate our daughter’s graduation from med school. Steve researched the med school logo and said he could make it happen. And he sure did!!!! My daughter cried when she saw it. The restaurant said it was so well done and beautiful!! Best celebration of the season!!!! Our guests loved the carrot cake. Really well done!! Steve is extremely detailed, talented, thoughtful and great to work with!!! Thank you so much for making the event special!!!
May 20 · Susan BeamanOur daughter had an extremely specific request for her birthday cake. She wanted a lemon cake with lemon filling and vanilla frosting, with yellow icing, and a yellow axolotl. Even though the owner had not heard of an axolotl before, and had not put one on a cake, he was kind enough to research it, and the end result was way better than we could have imagined! It’s perfect!! She is going to go crazy when she sees it.
April 05 · Julia BailinSteve made us a beautiful wedding cake and cupcakes for our daughters wedding and it was delicious. So many of our guest let us know it was the best cake they have ever tasted. Our order was delivered at the agreed time and set up so nicely, everything was lovely.
September 27 · Gretchen QuatticciThis is a baker who strives for, and reaches, excellence. His creations are a joy to the taste buds as well as to the eyes. Highly recommended.
April 18 · Ralph CabanaSteve ROCKS, his cakes and attention to details we want is great. We have been getting cakes for years. We absolutely love the cakes, the white frosting and peanut butter frosting. This year we purchased gingerbread house for the first time. My 11 year old granddaughter had a blast decorating it. Thank you from the Reynolds. Have a great holiday.I wanted to post pictures but couldn’t figure out how.
December 24 · Virginia Reynolds
More Bakery Near Me
Rocky Coast Cheesecake LLC5.0 (14 reviews)3 Marina Rd, Yarmouth, ME 04096, USA
European Bakery and Tea Room4.0 (317 reviews)395 U.S. Rte 1, Falmouth, ME 04105, USA
Bam Bam Bakery4.0 (234 reviews)125 Bucknam Rd, Falmouth, ME 04105, USA
Wicked Whoopies4.0 (272 reviews)100 Main St, Freeport, ME 04032, USA
Bessie's Farm Goods4.0 (13 reviews)1 Grace Ln, Freeport, ME 04032, USA
Botto's Bakery4.0 (90 reviews)550 Washington Ave, Portland, ME 04103, USA
u201cTheu201d Sweet Spot4.0 (93 reviews)59 Portland Rd, Gray, ME 04039, USA
Belleville4.0 (277 reviews)1 North St, Portland, ME 04101, USA
Prairie Baking Co.5.0 (14 reviews)44 Romasco Ln, Portland, ME 04101, USA
Katie Made Bakery4.0 (185 reviews)181 Congress St, Portland, ME 04101, USA
Bakery Outlet5.0 (3 reviews)256 Warren Ave, Portland, ME 04103, USA
Country Kitchen-Le Page Bakery4.0 (81 reviews)276 Warren Ave, Portland, ME 04103, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Walmart Bakery4.0 (6 reviews)
Mestas Sourdough Delights5.0 (22 reviews)
Central Caribbean Bakery & Central Seafood Restaurant4.0 (270 reviews)
Philly Pretzel Factory4.0 (90 reviews)
Corsicana Donut & Bakery4.0 (146 reviews)
Classy Chocolate4.0 (117 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
