Catskill Bagel Co.: Your Essential Brooklyn Bagel & Breakfast Destination

Catskill Bagel Co. Introduce

In the vibrant landscape of Brooklyn, where a good bagel is not just food but a way of life, Catskill Bagel Co. has firmly established itself as a must-visit destination for locals and anyone seeking an authentic New York bagel experience. Located on the bustling Cortelyou Road, this establishment goes beyond simply serving bagels; it offers a comprehensive breakfast and lunch experience that consistently exceeds expectations. From the moment you step in, the inviting aroma of freshly baked goods promises a meal that is both satisfying and memorable. Catskill Bagel Co. has quickly become a beloved fixture, celebrated for its commitment to quality, generous portions, and a menu that caters to a wide array of tastes and dietary preferences.

For New Yorkers, who appreciate both quality and value, Catskill Bagel Co. hits all the right notes. Imagine biting into a freshly baked bagel, warm with a soft interior and a delightfully crisp exterior, each bite packed with flavor. Whether you're craving a classic cream cheese bagel, a hearty breakfast sandwich like their lauded BLT with added turkey, or exploring their well-rounded menu, the satisfaction is palpable. Beyond the bagels, the establishment also offers delectable baked goods and fresh juices, making it a versatile stop for any time of day. In a city where quick service often means sacrificing quality, Catskill Bagel Co. manages to maintain excellent food and service, even during the morning rush. It's truly one of those places you'll be glad to have discovered in your local New York neighborhood.

Catskill Bagel Co. is conveniently situated at 1416 Cortelyou Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11226, USA. This prime location places it right in the heart of the bustling Cortelyou Road corridor, nestled between the vibrant neighborhoods of Ditmas Park and Flatbush. This makes it an incredibly accessible spot for a wide range of Brooklyn residents and those passing through the area.

The accessibility of Catskill Bagel Co. for New Yorkers is excellent, largely due to its proximity to public transportation. The bakery is just a short walk from the Cortelyou Road Q train station, providing direct and efficient subway access to Manhattan and various other parts of Brooklyn. This is a significant advantage for commuters and anyone relying on the subway system. Additionally, several MTA bus lines operate along Cortelyou Road and major cross streets, with bus stops conveniently located within easy walking distance of the bagel shop. For those who prefer to travel on foot or by bicycle, the surrounding streets of Ditmas Park and Flatbush are generally pedestrian-friendly, making for a pleasant stroll or ride to the destination. While there isn't designated parking for the establishment, the area typically offers plenty of street parking options, which is a considerable convenience in New York City. This strong local accessibility ensures that Catskill Bagel Co. is a practical and easy stop for a delicious breakfast, lunch, or snack, firmly establishing its role as a neighborhood staple.

Services Offered:

Freshly Baked Bagels: Offering a variety of bagels baked fresh daily, known for their warm, soft interior and crisp exterior.
Breakfast Sandwiches: A wide selection of breakfast sandwiches, including popular items like BLTs with various additions (e.g., turkey, cheese).
Well-Rounded Menu: Beyond bagels and breakfast, the menu includes diverse options for lunch and other meals.
Variety of Drinks: A good selection of beverages, including coffee, tea, and fresh juices.
Delectable Baked Goods: In addition to bagels, they offer other sweet baked goods at the counter.
Indoor and Outdoor Seating: Provides options for dining in, whether you prefer to sit inside or enjoy the fresh air.
Vegetarian Options: Plenty of vegetarian choices available on the menu.
Dietary Accommodations: Staff are accommodating and willing to do their best to meet specific dietary restrictions.
Takeout Service: All menu items are available for convenient takeout.
Kid-Friendly Environment: Welcoming to children, with many kids reportedly enjoying their visits.
Wheelchair Accessibility: The establishment is wheelchair accessible, ensuring ease of access for all customers.

Features / Highlights:

Exceptional Bagel Quality: Known for freshly baked bagels with an ideal texture – warm, soft inside, and crisp outside.
Generous Portions & Value: Provides substantial portion sizes for the price, offering great value for money.
Delicious & Varied Menu: Consistently delivers satisfying food across a well-rounded menu, including praised sandwiches and other items.
Accommodating Staff: Staff are friendly and willing to work with customers on dietary restrictions, enhancing the service experience.
Vegetarian-Friendly: Offers numerous options for vegetarian diners, making it inclusive for a broader clientele.
Convenient Seating: Provides both indoor and outdoor seating, even during peak times for those who visit later in the morning.
Positive Customer Experiences: Consistently receives high praise for both food quality and staff friendliness, leading to strong recommendations.
Local Favorite: Has quickly become a highly recommended and loved spot by locals in the area.
Wheelchair Accessible: Ensures the establishment is welcoming and navigable for individuals with mobility aids.
No-Designated Parking, but Ample Street Parking: While it lacks its own lot, the availability of street parking is a convenient feature in a dense urban environment.

Contact Information:

Address: 1416 Cortelyou Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11226, USA

Phone: (718) 282-5049

Catskill Bagel Co. is an excellent fit for locals in New York, particularly those residing in Brooklyn's Ditmas Park and Flatbush neighborhoods, for a multitude of reasons that perfectly align with the everyday needs and desires of city dwellers. Firstly, the core offering – freshly baked bagels – is a quintessential New York staple, and Catskill Bagel Co. excels at it, delivering the ideal warm, soft interior with a delightful crisp exterior. This commitment to an authentic and high-quality bagel experience immediately resonates with locals who understand and appreciate the art of a perfectly crafted bagel.

Beyond the bagels themselves, the generous portion sizes, especially for items like their hearty BLTs, offer exceptional value for the price, a crucial factor in budget-conscious New York. The well-rounded menu, including various breakfast and lunch options, vegetarian choices, and even delectable baked goods and fresh juices, means that Catskill Bagel Co. can cater to almost any craving at any time of day. Its prime location on Cortelyou Road, combined with easy access to the Q train and local bus routes, makes it incredibly convenient for commuters, families, and anyone running errands in the area. The availability of both indoor and outdoor seating, along with their accommodating staff and kid-friendly atmosphere, transforms it from a mere bagel shop into a comfortable and welcoming neighborhood hub. In a city where finding a reliable, high-quality, and accommodating local spot is highly prized, Catskill Bagel Co. stands out as a genuine gem, perfectly suiting the fast-paced yet community-oriented lifestyle of New Yorkers.

Catskill Bagel Co. Food & drink

On a Bagel
Bagel US$1.50
Cream Cheese By The Pound
Lox Spread By The Pound US$13.99
Vegetable Cream Cheese By The Pound US$12.99
Scallion Cream Cheese By The Pound US$12.99

All Day Breakfast
Bacon, Egg And Cheese On A Roll US$9.00
Egg And Cheese On A Roll US$7.00
2 Eggs, Home Fries And Coffee US$11.00
Eggs any style.
French Toast, 2 Eggs, Home Fries And Coffee US$18.00
Eggs any style.
Pancakes, 2 Eggs, Bacon And Coffee US$18.00
Eggs any style.
Two Eggs US$12.50
Eggs any style.
Diet Delight US$8.00
Three egg whties and turkey on a bagel.
Catskill Mountain Omelette US$14.00
Roasted poblano peppers, corn, chorizo and queso fresco.
Scrambled Morning US$13.50
Two scrambled eggs with green peppers, roasted tomatoes and scallions. Served with homefries.
Fluffy Pancakes US$10.00
White Bread French Toast US$10.00
French Toast With Fruit US$12.00
Your choice of fruit.
Pancakes With Fruit US$12.00
Your choice of fruit.
Blueberry Pancakes US$11.00
Served with fruit.
Cortelyou Lox US$16.00
Homemade lox, cream cheese, capers, minced red onion, tomato and lemon on a bagel.
Lox And Eggs US$14.00
Breakfast Sandwich US$9.00
Organic eggs, American or cheddar cheese, Virginia ham and our ketchup on a roll.
Potato And Egg Sandwich US$8.00
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato Breakfast Sandwich US$7.50
Homemade Granola US$6.00
With organic yogurt, mixed honey and seasonal fruit.
Irish Oatmeal US$7.00
With brown sugar, raisins and banana.

Breakfast Wrap
Cortelyou Road Wrap US$10.95
Three eggs, bacon and cheese.
D Train Wrap US$10.95
Sausage, onions and cheese.
Q Train Wrap US$10.95
Three eggs, mushrooms, Swiss and tomato.
3 J's Wrap US$10.95
Three eggs, spinach and cheese.
Vegetarian Wrap US$8.50
Three egg whites, carrots, onions, tomato and peppers.
Ditmas Park Wrap US$9.00
Three eggs, feta cheese, onions, scallions and tomato.
South Brooklyn Wrap US$7.50
Mushroom, avocado, tomato and brie.
Roast Beast Wrap US$7.00
Eggs, herb cream cheese, roast beef, grilled onions, queso fresco and greens.
Veggie Egg White Wrap US$7.50
Two egg whites, sun-dried tomato cream cheese, tofu cheese, mushrooms, roasted tomato and alfalfa sprouts on spinach wrap.

Homemade Salad Sandwiches
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Egg Salad Sandwich
Salmon Salad Sandwich
Chicken Salad Sandwich
White Fish Sandwich
Fresh Lox Sandwich

Smoothies
Pineapple And Banana Smoothie
Pineapple Smoothie
Apple Smoothie
Strawberry And Pineapple Smoothie
Orange And Banana Smoothie
Mango And Pineapple Smoothie
Lemon And Strawberry Smoothie
Blueberry, Strawberry And Banana Smoothie
Pineapple And Mango Smoothie
Strawberry And Lemon Smoothie

Vegetable and Fruit Juice Bar
Carrot Juice
Carrot And Apple Juice
Carrot And Orange Juice
Carrot, Beet And Apple Juice
Carrot, Cucumber And Beet Juice
Carrot, Beet And Celery Juice
Carrot, Apple And Celery Juice
Carrot, Apple And Spinach Juice
Carrot, Celery And Parsley Juice
Carrot, Beet And Spinach Juice
Orange Juice
Apple Juice
Grapefruit Juice

Coffee Bar and Tea
Coffee
Tea
Served hot.
Hot Chocolate
Nesquick.
Espresso
Served hot.
Cappuccino
Served hot.
Mochaccino
Served hot.
Cafe Latte
Served hot.
Red Eye
Served hot.
Americano
Served hot.

Iced Coffee and Tea
Iced Coffee
Iced.
Iced Tea
Iced.
Iced Flavored Coffee
Iced with your choice of flavoring.
Iced Cappuccino
Iced.
Lemonade

Beverages
Soda US$2.50
Water US$1.00
Lemonade US$4.00
Kombucha US$5.00
Hals Seltzer Water US$2.50
Tropicana Orange Juice US$3.00

Salad by The Pound
Tuna Salad US$12.99
1 lb.
Egg Salad US$8.99
1 lb.
Salmon Salad US$18.99
1 lb.
Potato Salad US$7.99
1 lb.
Fresh Lox US$36.99
1 lb.
Chicken Salad US$13.99
1 lb.
White Fish Salad US$18.50
1 lb.
Mozzarella And Tomato Salad US$12.99
1 lb.
Macaroni US$6.99
1 lb.
Coleslaw US$4.99
1 lb.

Soups and Such
Lentil Soup
Soup Of The Day
Please call restaurant for today's selection.
Soup And 1/2 Sandwich Combo US$12.00
A cup of soup or chili with half sandwich.
Soup And 1/2 Salad Combo US$12.00
A cup of soup or chili with half salad.

Specialty Salads
Garden Salad US$12.00
Cortelyou Road Salad US$14.00
Organic Greens Salad US$12.00
Spinach Salad US$12.00
Cobb Salad US$12.00
Catskill Mountain Special Salad US$12.00
Caesar Salad US$12.00
Chicken Ceasar Salad US$14.00
Greek Salad US$12.00
Tuna Salad Platter US$11.50
Chicken Salad Platter US$12.50
Catskill Mountain Chopped Salad US$12.00
Caprese Salad US$12.00
Spinach And Roasted Peppers Salad US$12.00

Sandwiches
Chicken Salad Special Sandwich US$13.00
Served on a roll or bagel
Mozzarella And Tomato Sandwich US$12.00
Served on a roll or bagel.
Ham Sandwich US$13.00
Served on a roll or bagel.
American Hero Sandwich US$13.00
Served on a roll.
Carroll Street Bridge Sandwich US$8.00
Served on a roll.
Brooklyn Bridge Sandwich US$8.00
Served on a roll.
Verrazano Bridge Sandwich US$8.00
Served on a roll.
Grilled Vegetable Sandwich US$12.00
Served on a roll.
Curry Chicken Salad Sandwich US$12.00
Served on a roll.
Romano Special Sandwich US$12.00
Served on a roll.
Albacore Tuna Salad Sandwich US$12.00
Served on a roll.
The Dagwood Sandwich US$14.99
Served on a roll.
Roasted Turkey Delight Sandwich US$8.00
Served on a roll.
Chicken Teriyaki Sandwich US$8.00
Served on a roll.
Goodfella Sandwich US$13.00
Served on a roll.
BLT Sandwich US$8.00
Served on a roll.
Union Street Bridge Sandwich US$8.00
Served on a roll.
Manhattan Bridge Sandwich US$12.00
Served on a roll.
3rd Street Bridge Sandwich US$8.00
Served on a roll.
Roasted Portabello Mushroom Sandwich US$8.00
Served on a roll.
Catskill Chicken Salad Sandwich US$10.00
Served on a roll.
Italian Combo Sandwich US$13.00
Served on a roll.
Home Roast Beast Sandwich US$12.00
Served on a roll.
Organic Peanut Butter Sandwich US$4.50
Served on a roll.

Triple Decker Clubs
Honey Turkey 1 Triple Decker US$12.95
Three pieces of bread with bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
Roast Beef Triple Decker US$12.95
Three pieces of bread with cheddar cheese, cole slaw and Russian dressing.
Honey Turkey 2 Triple Decker US$12.95
Three pieces of bread with hummus, feta cheese, olives and avocado.
Ham Triple Decker US$13.00
Three pieces of bread with muenster cheese, pickles, lettuce, tomato and mustard.
Tuna Salad Triple Decker US$13.00
Three pieces of bread with mesculin salad, tomato and onions.
Grilled Chicken Triple Decker US$12.95
Three pieces of bread with Swiss cheese, sauteed onions and honey Dijon dressing.
Prosciutto Triple Decker US$12.95
Three pieces of bread with mozzarella cheese, tomato, oil and vinegar.
Three Cheese Triple Decker US$13.00
Three pieces of bread with Swiss, muenster and provolone.
Smoked Pepper Turkey Triple Decker US$13.00
Three pieces of bread with muenster cheese, sprouts and olives.
Ham And Roast Beef Triple Decker US$13.00
Three pieces of bread with Swiss cheese, pickles and Russian dressing.

Specialty Wraps
Catskill Wrap US$15.00
Fresh lox, cream cheese, cucumber, onion, tomato and capers.
Glenwood Road Wrap US$13.00
Roast beef, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomato and Peter Luger sauce.
Downtown Wrap US$13.00
Chicken cutlet, bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.
Dorchester Road Wrap US$11.00
Smoked turkey, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomato and honey dijon dressing.
B.Q.E. Wrap US$8.50
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, American cheese and mayonnaise.
Rugby Road Wrap US$8.50
Grilled chicken, cheese, tomato and honey Dijon mustard.
Barely Wrapped Wrap US$8.50
Tuna salad, onion and tomato.
Veggie Wrap US$8.50
Grilled vegetable, roasted peppers, onion, tomato, mushrooms and balsamic dressing.
Chicken Deluxe Wrap US$8.50
Grilled chicken with mesculin salad and fresh lemon juice.
Greek Chicken Wrap US$12.00
Greek salad with grilled chicken and balsamic vinegar.
Goodfella Wrap US$12.00
Salami with ham, pepperoni, mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomato, oil and vinegar.
Chicken Veggie Wrap US$12.00
Grilled Chicken with grilled vegetables and balsamic vinegar.
Vegetarian Delight Wrap US$8.50
Grilled vegetables with romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, avocado, sprouts and raspberry vinaigrette.
Marlborough Road Wrap US$12.00
Roast beef, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and horseradish dressing.
Newkirk Avenue Wrap US$8.50
Grilled eggplant, smoked mozzarella and tomato with fresh tomato sauce.
Foster Road Wrap US$13.00
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, avocado, roasted pepper and ranch dressing.
Argyle Road Wrap US$13.00
Chicken cutlet, cheddar cheese, avocado, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing.
Ditmas Avenue Wrap US$12.00
Peppermill turkey, gruyere cheese, romaine lettuce, roma tomato and thousand island dressing.
Beverly Road Wrap US$8.50
Portabello mushroom, sun-dried tomatoes, provolone cheese, romaine lettuce and olive oil.

Panini
Prosciutto Panini US$11.95
Served on panini bread with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomato, arugula, oil and vinegar.
Roast Beef Panini US$11.95
Served on panini bread with oven charred peppers, caramelized onions, jack cheese and mayo.
Portabello Mushroom Panini US$11.95
Served on panini bread with fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, grilled onions and tomato.
Roasted Turkey Panini US$11.95
Served on panini bread with goat cheese, alfalfa sprouts, avocado and sour cream spread.
Eggplant Panini US$11.95
Served on panini bread with mozzarella and tomato.
3 Cheese Panini US$11.95
Served on panini bread with fresh mozzarella, provolone and Swiss cheese with romaine lettuce and tomato.
Mozzarella And Tomato Panini US$11.95
Served on panini bread with romaine lettuce, oil, vinegar and roasted red peppers.

Hot Sandwiches
Reuben Sandwich US$11.00
Grilled sandwich on rye with sliced pastrami, topped with sauerkraut, covered with Swiss cheese and melted.
9 Oz. Hamburger US$9.00
On a poppy seed bun with lettuce, tomato, onion and a pickle.
Veggie Italiano Press Sandwich US$11.00
Marinated pepper, pesto and homemade mozzarella.
Chicken Cordon Bleu Press Sandwich US$13.00
Breaded boneless, skinless chicken breast, Swiss cheese, prosciutto, roast tomato, lettuce, paprika, mayo and a pickle.
Pressed Chimichurri Beef Sandwich US$10.00
Chimichurri marinated roast beef with sauteed red onion and pickled mango.
Pulled Pork Sandwich US$11.00
Carolina style BBQ with pulled pork shoulder and pickles on a bun.
Roast Beef Sandwich US$10.00
With melted pepperjack cheese, onions, avocado and green goddess dressing.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich US$13.00
With cheddar cheese, roasted peppers, avocado and paprika mayo.

Grandma's Muffins and Pastries
Chocolate Chip Muffin US$4.00
Vanilla Chip Muffin US$4.00
Blueberry Muffin US$4.00
Cranberry Muffin US$4.00
Lemon Poppy Muffin US$4.00
Daily Muffin US$4.00
Rainbow Cookie US$4.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$4.00
Raisin And Brand Oatmeal Cookie US$4.00
Sea Salt Brownies US$4.00
Cupcake US$2.95
Crumb Cake US$4.00
Slice Of Cake US$3.95
Oreo Cheese Cake Bite US$3.50
Cranberry Scone US$4.00
Raisin Scone US$3.00
Slice Apple Pie US$3.95

NEW ITEMS
NITRO ORGANIC COLD BREW
Hals Potato Chips US$2.00

Weekly Special 9/23-9/29
Beef Chilli And Rice US$7.95
Chicken Wings US$5.00
6 pieces

Catskill Bagel Co. Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible car park

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Catskill Bagel Co. Photos

Catskill Bagel Co. Location

Catskill Bagel Co.

New York Kings County Flatbush Cortelyou Road

1416 Cortelyou Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11226, USA

Catskill Bagel Co. Reviews

An average rating of ★3.6 from 603 user reviews.

iced coffeeordercashiersouptofurespectjuiceownersellmuffin

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

We visited this place for breakfast, and it exceeded our expectations. The portion sizes were generous considering the price. We got two BLTs with cheese and added turkey. I can’t lie, I was ready for bed after we ate. We got one BLT on a wrap and the other on a plain bagel. The bagels here are freshly baked daily and have a warm, soft interior with a delightful crisp exterior. Every bite was packed.As for the food, I’ve dined here a few times and never had any disappointing experiences. They have a well-rounded menu and a variety of drinks to choose from. Additionally, they offer some delectable baked goods and fresh juices at the counter.If you’re in the area, I highly recommend stopping by for a bite.Food: 4 | Service: 4 | Atmosphere: 3Seating type:The offer indoor and outdoor seating. It can get packed here during the morning rush, but I go late in the morning so there always seating available.Vegetarian options: there are plenty of vegetarian optionsDietary restrictions: the staff is very accommodating. They will do their bestParking space: there is no designated parking for this establishmentParking options: plenty of street parkingKid-friendliness: all the kids I see in there love itWheelchair accessibility: they are wheelchair accessible
June 28 · Ian Ellison
Love this place! The bagels and food are excellent and the staff is great.
July 12 · D L
One of the better bagels in this part of town, and the bagel did not disappoint. Chewy with a bit of crust and warmth. Staff was friendly and sandwiches came out quickly, but a little under seasoned and bacon undercooked. Not bad, but not great either - about how I would sum up the overall experience.
May 17 · Chris Dornfeld
Seriously, these guys are awesome. Been there in person and the service was incredible.. ordered delivery and the food is always on point. Soup of the day never disappoints and the Lox bagels are some of the best in BK. Can’t take a photo because I ate too fast.
May 02 · Crane Tecce
Love getting my salads from here. Nice and fresh food
April 17 · Brianna Melissa