Cookies & More

Introduction / Overview

For over three decades, Cookies & More has cemented its status as an iconic and beloved fixture in downtown Iowa City. Since its founding in 1983, this bakery has been a cornerstone of the community, originally established in the heart of the University of Iowa campus within the Old Capitol Mall. Today, the tradition continues at its accessible location at 201 S Clinton St, IA 52240, USA, providing a comforting taste of nostalgia and homemade goodness to generations of Iowans.

This is more than just a cookie shop; it is a family operation. Founded by Ed and Jane O'Brien and Jane's mother, Marge Miller, the business remains proudly family-owned and operated by their son, Alex O'Brien, and his wife, Angie O'Brien. This deep, multi-generational connection to Iowa City is what makes Cookies & More an authentic local gem. They adhere to the time-honored commitment of making everything fresh from scratch every day, using the finest and freshest ingredients—a practice that ensures their cookies are always soft, chewy, moist, and delicious, living up to their reputation as an Iowa City staple and favorite.

Location and Accessibility

Cookies & More is perfectly situated at 201 S Clinton St, Iowa City, IA 52240, USA, placing it directly in the dynamic downtown district. This prime location makes it an extremely convenient stop for students, faculty, local professionals, and shoppers enjoying the heart of Iowa City. Its historical presence in this area has made it a memorable landmark for decades.

The bakery is designed for ease of use, making it ideal for a Quick visit. The building features a Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring all members of the community can enjoy their treats. While downtown parking can sometimes be challenging, the location provides a nearby Wheelchair accessible parking lot, and customers will find various nearby parking options common to the bustling core of the city. The service model supports busy lifestyles with options for Delivery, In-store pickup, In-store shopping, and Takeout, allowing patrons to integrate a visit seamlessly into their daily routine. For payment, the store accommodates modern methods, accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Services Offered

Cookies & More specializes in high-quality, made-from-scratch baked goods, offering several key services to meet the diverse needs of the Iowa community:

• Retail Cookie Sales: Selling freshly baked cookies throughout the day. Customers can purchase them individually, by the Half Dozen Cookies, or by the Dozen Cookies, with the flexibility to mix and match flavors.
• Specialty Frosted Cookies: Offering the Individual Frosted Sugar Cookie ($3.60) and other sugar cookie varieties for a sweet, decorated treat.
• Bulk Cookie Orders (Party Cookies): Providing a smaller, approximately 2-inch version of their regular cookies, ideal for large events, meetings, or parties. These require a minimum two-hour advance notice, with larger orders needing more lead time. Available as 1 Dozen Party Cookies.
• Party Trays: Offering convenient, ready-to-serve cookie assortments for events, including the Small Party Tray, Large Party Tray-5 Dozen, and Large Party Tray- 6 Dozen.
• Custom Cookie Cakes: Baking made-to-order Cookie Cakes for special occasions. Options include the 8" Round, 9" Heart, and 12" Round. These are personalized with a message and an alternating color border (minimum two hours advanced notice required).
• Beverage Service (As per customer review): Providing complementary drinks such as coffee or soda to pair with their baked goods.
• Delivery and Pickup: Facilitating convenient remote ordering through Delivery and In-store pickup services.

Features / Highlights

Cookies & More stands out in the Iowa City market due to its history, product quality, and versatile offerings:

• Generational Iowa City Staple: The bakery has been operating since 1983 and remains in the O'Brien family, giving it deep historical roots and a strong nostalgic appeal within the Iowa City community. It’s a cherished spot, with customers determined to carry on the tradition across generations.
• Made-From-Scratch Commitment: A core feature is the promise that every item is made fresh from scratch daily using high-quality ingredients, resulting in cookies that are notably soft, chewy, and moist.
• Signature Cookie Selection: The menu includes beloved classics and specialty items that are favorites among Iowans. Key flavors include the Monster Cookie (an extremely popular item featuring oatmeal, peanut butter, chocolate chips, and M&M's), the classic Chocolate Chip Cookie, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, and the White Chocolate Supreme (a mix between a sugar and chocolate chip cookie).
• Dedicated Event Planning Solutions: The specialized Party Cookies, Cookie Cakes, and various Party Trays make the bakery a one-stop-shop for corporate meetings, university events, birthdays, and other local celebrations.
• Distinct Cookie Texture: A consistent highlight noted by patrons is the perfect texture—soft and chewy with slightly crunchy edges—a characteristic of a truly well-made, fresh cookie.
• Customer Nostalgia and Loyalty: The high customer loyalty, demonstrated by families maintaining a 30-year tradition and frequent dreams about the cookies, underscores the bakery's special emotional place in the Iowa City collective memory.

Contact Information

Address: 201 S Clinton St, Iowa City, IA 52240, USA

Phone: (319) 337-5596 (Also accessible via Mobile Phone: +1 319-337-5596)

What is Worth Choosing

For local users in Iowa, especially those in the Iowa City area, Cookies & More is worth choosing because it offers an authentic, high-quality, and reliable product backed by decades of local history. This is not a fleeting trend but a community tradition.

The primary reason for choosing this establishment is the unparalleled consistency and flavor of its cookies, which are truly made with homemade goodness. For many, a visit to this Clinton Street location is a ritual, a tangible connection to fond childhood memories within the downtown landscape. The Monster Cookie, cited by customers as an "absolute favorite," is a legendary local treat that alone justifies a visit, representing the rich, complex flavors the bakery is known for.

Beyond the individual cookie, Cookies & More is the ideal choice for planning and events. The customization and convenience of ordering a personalized 12" Round Cookie Cake or selecting a Large Party Tray with 6 Dozen Party Cookies demonstrates their specialized capacity to handle local catering needs with ease and professionalism. The requirement for only a two-hour advance notice on most custom orders is a major convenience in a busy university town.

In choosing Cookies & More, Iowans are supporting a multi-generational, family-owned business that has faithfully served the heart of Iowa City for over 40 years. This local loyalty and commitment to a superior, made-from-scratch product make it an essential and highly recommended downtown Iowa City gem.

Cookies & More

201 S Clinton St, Iowa City, IA 52240, USA