Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie

Nestled in the picturesque landscape of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, lies a true icon of the region's rich culinary heritage: Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie. For generations of locals and visitors alike, this distinctive establishment has been synonymous with the beloved Pennsylvania Dutch dessert, the shoo fly pie. More than just a bakery, Dutch Haven is a landmark, instantly recognizable by its charming windmill and its unwavering commitment to preserving the authentic flavors of Amish Country. Since its establishment in 1946, it has stood as a testament to tradition, hospitality, and, of course, exceptionally delicious pie.

Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie offers a unique blend of bakery and cultural experience. It's a place where the aroma of freshly baked molasses pie fills the air, and where every bite transports you to the heart of Pennsylvania Dutch country. The friendly staff often greet visitors with samples of their famous pie, embodying the warmth and generosity characteristic of the region. This dedication to quality and customer satisfaction has solidified Dutch Haven's reputation as a must-visit destination, not just for those craving a taste of authentic shoo fly pie, but for anyone looking to immerse themselves in the genuine charm and heritage of this unique part of Pennsylvania. It’s a place where memories are made and culinary traditions are celebrated, offering a truly special experience that keeps people coming back year after year.

Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie is strategically situated along one of Pennsylvania's most historic routes, making it incredibly accessible for both local residents and travelers exploring the area. You can find this iconic establishment at 5849 Lincoln Highway East, Kinzers, PA 17535, USA. The Lincoln Highway (US Route 30) is a well-traveled road that connects many of Pennsylvania's charming towns and attractions, ensuring that Dutch Haven is an easy and convenient stop on any itinerary.

The bakery’s location in Kinzers, within Lancaster County, places it right in the heart of Pennsylvania Dutch Country. This area is known for its scenic farmlands, traditional Amish communities, and an abundance of local markets and shops. The distinctive windmill structure of Dutch Haven makes it virtually impossible to miss as you drive along Lincoln Highway East. For visitors traveling by car, there is ample attached parking available, providing a hassle-free experience. This ease of access, combined with its prominent location, makes Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie a frequent and beloved stop for those seeking an authentic taste of the region without venturing too far off the beaten path. Its presence on a major highway ensures that it remains a readily available source of delicious, homemade goods for everyone in the vicinity.

Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie specializes in a range of traditional Pennsylvania Dutch baked goods and offers a variety of services to enhance the customer experience. While their claim to fame is undeniably their signature pie, their offerings extend beyond just that.

• America's Best Shoo Fly Pie: Their primary and most famous product, made from an original recipe dating back to 1946. They offer free samples to visitors, allowing them to experience the delicious, molasses-rich flavor firsthand before making a purchase. The pie is renowned for its perfect balance of a gooey, sweet molasses bottom and a delightful crumb topping.

• Other Baked Goods: While shoo fly pie is the star, Dutch Haven also offers other traditional baked goods. Although specific varieties beyond shoo fly are not extensively detailed, their reputation for quality suggests a focus on authentic, homemade treats.

• Amish Souvenirs and Crafts: Beyond the bakery, Dutch Haven is also a large Amish crafts and souvenir store. They offer a wide array of items, including framed art, wall hangings, totes, wind chimes, candles, Amish hats and bonnets, t-shirts, dolls, hex signs, mugs, magnets, and more. This makes it a one-stop shop for both culinary delights and mementos of your visit to Amish Country.

• Jams, Jellies, and Canned Goods: In keeping with the local tradition of preserving fresh produce, Dutch Haven also sells a selection of jams, jellies, and other canned goods, perfect for taking a taste of Pennsylvania Dutch Country home with you.

• Online Ordering and Shipping: For those who can't visit in person or want to share the taste of Dutch Haven with others, they offer online ordering and shipping services for their pies and other products, making their famous treats accessible nationwide.

Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie stands out with several distinctive features and highlights that contribute to its lasting appeal and status as a beloved local institution:

• The "Place That Made Shoo Fly Pie Famous": Dutch Haven proudly bears the title of the original and most famous purveyor of shoo fly pie. Their recipe, used since 1946, is considered a benchmark for this classic Pennsylvania Dutch dessert, praised for its authentic taste and texture, often described as having a perfect gooey molasses bottom with a cake-like crumb top.

• Free Pie Samples: A long-standing tradition at Dutch Haven is the offer of free samples of their shoo fly pie to all visitors upon entering. This gesture of hospitality allows everyone to experience the quality and taste before committing to a purchase, making for a welcoming and memorable first impression.

• Iconic Windmill Structure: The bakery is housed within a distinctive yellow and white windmill-shaped building, making it a highly recognizable landmark on Lincoln Highway East. This unique architecture adds to its charm and helps it stand out as a memorable roadside attraction in Amish Country.

• Amish Heritage Immersion: Beyond the pies, Dutch Haven offers a comprehensive experience of Amish culture and heritage. The extensive gift shop features a vast collection of Amish-made crafts, furniture, and souvenirs, providing visitors with a deeper understanding and appreciation of the local artisan traditions.

• Warm and Welcoming Atmosphere: Customer reviews consistently highlight the friendly and accommodating staff. The overall atmosphere is described as warm and inviting, reflecting the genuine hospitality of the Pennsylvania Dutch region, making every visit a pleasant one.

• Historical Significance: Operating since 1946, Dutch Haven has a rich history as a beloved establishment. It has become a cherished part of many families' traditions, a place where generations have stopped to enjoy a slice of pie and soak in the unique local culture.

For those planning a visit or wishing to inquire about products from Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 5849 Lincoln Hwy E, Kinzers, PA 17535, USA

Phone: 717-687-0111

Additionally, Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie maintains an online presence, allowing customers to order their famous pies for shipping, which can be particularly useful for those not located directly in Pennsylvania or wishing to send gifts. It is always recommended to check their official website or call ahead for the most current operating hours, especially around holidays or for any specific product availability.

For residents of Pennsylvania, particularly those in Lancaster County and the surrounding areas, Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie is far more than just a place to buy dessert; it's a cherished local institution deeply embedded in the community's identity. Its long-standing presence since 1946 signifies a commitment to tradition and quality that resonates deeply with locals who appreciate authentic regional offerings. When Pennsylvanians think of a classic shoo fly pie, Dutch Haven often comes to mind as the definitive source, thanks to its consistent quality and its reputation as "the place that made shoo fly pie famous."

The accessibility of its location on Lincoln Highway East makes it a convenient stop for everyday treats or for picking up a special dessert for family gatherings and events. The fact that they offer free samples, coupled with the warm and friendly service, fosters a sense of welcoming familiarity that locals truly value. Furthermore, Dutch Haven's dual role as both a bakery and a comprehensive Amish crafts and souvenir shop means it serves as a go-to spot for unique gifts and local treasures, solidifying its role as a versatile community hub. Supporting Dutch Haven means supporting a piece of Pennsylvania's living history and ensuring that the authentic taste of homemade, traditional shoo fly pie remains a staple for generations to come. It’s a place where local pride and delicious flavor truly meet.

Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie

5849 Lincoln Hwy E, Kinzers, PA 17535, USA