Fortune's Cookies North Olmsted, OH: Gourmet Cookie Shop and Sugar-Free Bakery

Fortune's Cookies Introduce

Introduction / Overview: Where The Fortune Is In The Flavor

For residents across the greater Cleveland area, a trip to Fortune's Cookies is a must for anyone craving a truly exceptional, freshly baked treat. Located conveniently inside the Great Northern Mall in North Olmsted, this local gem is far more than your typical mall cookie shop. Fortune's Cookies specializes in creating traditional cookies with non-traditional, highly imaginative flavors, all made from scratch with love. Their philosophy, encapsulated in their clever catchphrase, “The Fortune is in the Flavor,” perfectly describes the care put into every single bite.

This proudly women-owned business has quickly become a favorite destination for its quality, creativity, and commitment to inclusivity. They don’t just offer the classics—though their chocolate chip cookie is lauded as "fantastic" by customers—but push the boundaries with over 25 rotating varieties. You can find everything from the buttery and simple to the adventurous, such as Blueberry Cardamom and Chocolate Tarragon.

A significant highlight for Ohio locals with dietary needs is their dedication to providing delicious alternatives. Fortune's Cookies features a substantial selection of Sugar Free and Keto-friendly cookies, alongside options for those with allergies, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a decadent dessert. Whether you're making a quick stop during a shopping trip or placing a large order for a local event, Fortune's Cookies offers a friendly, professional, and welcoming environment for all patrons.

Location and Accessibility in North Olmsted, Ohio

Fortune's Cookies is ideally situated within the Great Northern Mall in North Olmsted, making it a central and easy-to-reach location for customers across Northeast Ohio, particularly those in the western suburbs of Cleveland.

Address: 300 Great Northern Mall, North Olmsted, OH 44070, USA

Being located inside one of the region's major shopping centers guarantees excellent accessibility. For visitors driving from surrounding communities like Westlake, Fairview Park, or Berea, the mall is conveniently located near major highways, offering ample parking. The bakery benefits from the mall’s comprehensive accessibility features, which include:

Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Ensuring easy entry from the mall's concourse.
Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Designated spaces are readily available in the mall’s large parking area.
The store is set up for a Quick Visit, perfect for grabbing a fresh cookie and a coffee on the go while shopping or running errands.

Services Offered

Fortune's Cookies provides versatile service options to meet the needs of all local cookie enthusiasts, whether they are visiting in person or ordering from home.

In-Store Shopping: Enjoy browsing the full selection of freshly baked cookies and viewing the daily offerings.
Takeout: Ideal for a quick purchase of a few cookies or a box to take home or share with colleagues.
In-Store Pickup: Customers can place orders ahead of time—perfect for large assortments or special flavor requests—and pick them up conveniently at the North Olmsted location.
Delivery: For those within the local area, delivery options are available, making it easy to send a sweet treat to friends, family, or colleagues across the region.
Coffee Offerings: The bakery also serves Coffee, making it a great place to stop for a complete snack or a morning/afternoon pick-me-up.
Payment Flexibility: Accepts all major forms of electronic payment for a seamless checkout, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.

Features / Highlights

What makes Fortune's Cookies stand out in the competitive Ohio bakery scene is its dedication to variety, quality, and community.

Massive Flavor Variety: The shop boasts an incredible and ever-changing menu of over 25 distinct cookie flavors. These range from nostalgic and fruity (like Fruity Pebbles cookie and Strawberry Cream cookie) to rich and complex (such as Blueberry Cardamom cookie, Salted Caramel cookie, and Double Chip Mocha cookie).
The Keto/Sugar-Free Champion: They offer one of the most extensive and flavorful selections of Sugar Free cookies in the area, a huge draw for local customers following Keto, diabetic, or low-sugar diets. Flavors include Sugar free chocolate chip, Sugar free extra Chocolate Chip Cookie, and Sugar free Espresso cookie, which are noted for tasting genuinely delicious, not just like a substitute.
Dietary Inclusivity and Allergen Awareness: Beyond sugar-free options, they offer selections for customers with allergies, including Gluten-Free and Dairy-Free/Vegan options, showing a commitment to serving the diverse needs of the Northeast Ohio community.
Unique and Buttery Base: Customers frequently describe the base cookie as a "true buttery cookie," providing the perfect canvas for their creative flavor combinations, and confirming the high quality of their scratch-made process.
Community and Comfort Focus: Fortune's Cookies identifies as a Women-Owned Business and actively fosters an inclusive environment, noting that they are LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender Safespace. They also feature a Gender-Neutral Restroom.
Affordable Indulgence: With single cookies priced accessibly at $2.00, it's easy for shoppers to try multiple flavors or grab a small, budget-friendly treat for themselves or their family.

Contact Information

To place a pickup or delivery order, or to check on the current day's flavor availability, please use the information below.

Address: 300 Great Northern Mall, North Olmsted, OH 44070, USA

Phone: (440) 644-0188

What Is Worth Choosing Fortune's Cookies

For any Ohio user seeking a bakery that combines creativity, quality, and conscious inclusion, Fortune's Cookies is an unparalleled choice. What truly sets them apart from typical cookie shops is their ability to master both the classics and the wildly inventive. You can visit one day for a perfect Peanut Butter cookie and return the next for a unique Cherry Cordial cookie or Raspberry Cheesecake cookie.

The biggest reason for local customers to choose this North Olmsted bakery is their commitment to dietary-friendly options. Their selection of delicious, flavorful Sugar Free and Keto-friendly cookies is a game-changer for many in the community who often feel left out of the dessert experience. This inclusivity, combined with their friendly atmosphere—which explicitly welcomes the LGBTQ+ community—makes Fortune's Cookies a truly modern, community-focused business.

Whether you’re stopping in for a quick break from shopping, picking up a special gift, or satisfying a serious sweet craving, you can trust that every cookie is made fresh, from scratch, and with a buttery base that locals rave about. Stop by their convenient mall location and discover why “The Fortune is in the Flavor.”

Fortune's Cookies Vibe

Cookie
Blueberry Cardamom cookie $2.00
Soft baked cookie made with cardamom extract and dehydrated blueberries. It isn't too sweet and is subtle in the savory with the cardamom. This flavor can be made in a vegan option
Cherry Cordial cookie $2.00
soft baked cookie made with dried tart cherries and dark chocolate chunks. It reminds one of the cherry cordial chocolates. This flavor can be made in a Gluten-free version
Chocolate Chunk cookie $2.00
Traditional soft baked chocolate chunk cookie
Chocolate Orange cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is made with pure orange, orange zest and dark chocolate chunks. It reminds one of the popular holiday chocolate orange candy
Chocolate Terragon $2.00
this soft baked cookie is made like our traditional extra chocolate chunk but made more exotic with the added in house made terragon extract.
Chocolate White Chip $2.00
This soft baked cookie has a chocolate base with vanilla chips
Cinnamon Apple Cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is made with an apple cider flavoring and in house made cinnamon chips
Cocoa Pebbles cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie has a white bade and is filled with cocoa pebbles cereal. It has a similar texture to a rice crispy treat.
Double Chip Mocha cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie has a chocolate base with coffee and espresso powder. It includes plenty of dark chocolate chunks and vanilla chips.
Espresso cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie has a vanilla base with instant coffee and espresso powder,
Extra Chocolate Chunk cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is the extra chocolatey version of our traditional chocolate chunk. It has a chocolate base, cocoa powder and dark chocolate chunks.
Fruity Pebbles cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie has a vanilla base and includes Fruity Pebbles cereal and has the texture similar to a rice crispy treat.
Honey Oatmeal Raisin cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is a classic made with honey, instant oats and raisins.
Lemon Cream Cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is made with pure lemon flavor, lemon zest and vanilla chips. It is rolled in sugar before baking and is reminiscent of the old timey lemon drop candy.
M&M chip cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is made with mini M&M candies and mini chocolate chips.
Mint Chocolate Chip cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is made with both mini chocolate chips and mini mint chips and a shot of pure peppermint to make it extra refreshing.
Orange Creamcicle cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is made with pure orange flavor, orange zest and vanilla chips. It reminds one of an orange creamcicle ice cream
Peanut Butter cookie $2.00
traditional peanut butter cookie rolled in sugar. This cookie can be made vegan.
Raspberry Cheesecake cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is made with a raspberry emulsion and cheesecake flavor and filled with vanilla chips and rolled in graham cracker crumbs.
Red Velvet cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is made with red velvet and cheesecake flavors and filled with vanilla chips.
Reese's Peanut Butter chip cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie has a chocolate base, made with mini reese's pieces and mini peanut butter chips. This flavor can be made Gluten-free.
S'mores cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is made with crumbled graham cracker, chocolate chunks and mini marshmallows.
Salted Caramel cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookies has a chocolate base and includes salted caramel chips and caramel bits. dough balls are sprinkled lightly with pink salt before baking.
Snickerdoodle cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookies is made with cream of tartar, house made cinnamon chips and rolled in cinnamon sugar.
Strawberry Cream cookie $2.00
This soft baked cookie is made with strawberry emulsion, vanilla chips and colorful sprinkles.
Sugar free chocolate chip
Sugar free extra Chocolate Chip Cookie
Sugar free lemon cookie
Sugar free Espresso cookie

Fortune's Cookies Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Amenities
Gender-neutral restroom

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safespace

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Fortune's Cookies Photos

Fortune's Cookies Location

Fortune's Cookies

Ohio Cuyahoga County North Olmsted Great Northern Mall

300 Great Northern Mall, North Olmsted, OH 44070, USA

Fortune's Cookies Reviews

An average rating of ★4.8 from 52 user reviews.

veganflavorsblueberrygluten freebuttercardamomketocherrybakedselection

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Absolutely delicious cookies! I've had the opportunity to taste (we listen and we don't judge) many flavors, but there's something about a fantastic chocolate chip cookie. Fortune's nails it!! They also had a great variety for my friends with allergies. Highly recommend visiting this local gem :)
August 19 · Sharon Spychola
A friend shared these cookies and they were so good that I made the trip to Great Northern Mall to get some. The most popular is a true buttery cookie. Don't hesitate to try some of the other flavors like lavender lemonade and blueberry cardamon, these are really good too. My brother in law is doing Keto and this place has a good selection of of flavorful Keto/Sugar free cookies.
June 12 · Tam Olle
Saw a flyer upon entering mall food court area that caught my attention marked for Gluten free and vegan cookies😋 😀 They did not dissapppoint. Thanks for offering cookies for those of us with dietary restrictions/needs. Best GF cookies 🍪 I've had yet, can't even tell. Perfect cookie consistency and sweetness/taste. Cherry Cordial 🍒 💣 🔥 ohhh myyyy!!! Would drive to Great Northern just for these!
March 23 · Danielle M
Wish I could give a 10 Star!! I’m in Florida and Beverly & Mark shipped them to me. Insanely fast shipping, showed up on my door steps in the cutest box. I ordered the Vegan Blueberry Caradom 🤯 ridiculously good! And the Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies were on point! Baked to perfection, mouth watering cookies. Not to mention Beverly is the sweetest person ever! Go nowhere else for cookies!
April 06 · Jeremiah Little
We ordered 5dz for my wife’s 40th birthday party & these were a hit with everyone! We ordered the blueberry cardamom, orange chocolate, lemon, cherry cordial & Reese’s. All were delicious but the blueberry was the favorite of everyone. Can’t recommend these enough & look forward to ordering more in the future!
July 02 · Matthew Philips