Gem's House of Bagels Highlands NJ: Fresh Bagels, Signature Breakfast, and Deli Lunch

Gem's House of Bagels Introduce

## Gem's House of Bagels in Highlands, NJ: Your Shore Stop for the Perfect Jersey Bagel

In New Jersey, a great day starts with a great bagel. For those located near the beautiful Monmouth County coastline, **Gem's House of Bagels** in Highlands has quickly become the essential stop for this morning ritual and much more. More than just a simple bagel shop, Gem's is a full-service local deli and bakery known for its fresh-baked, authentic bagels, generously portioned breakfast creations, and robust specialty lunch sandwiches. Situated conveniently near Sandy Hook, it serves as the perfect fuel-up spot before a beach day, a quick visit for commuters, or a cozy place for a satisfying meal.

The atmosphere at the Highlands location is often described by local users as **open, sunny, and cheerful**, making it an inviting space to grab your morning coffee or enjoy a substantial lunch. Gem’s prides itself on delivering not only delicious bagels but also a genuinely friendly customer experience, cementing its reputation as a true neighborhood gem along Bay Avenue. They understand the New Jersey palate, offering classic spreads, quality deli meats, and those signature over-the-top breakfast sandwiches that define our local food culture.

---

## Location and Accessibility

The **Gem's House of Bagels** location is perfectly positioned in the heart of the community at **208 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732, USA**. This prime spot is "near the middle of town," making it a central and easy-to-reach destination for Highlands residents and visitors heading to the Jersey Shore.

Accessibility is a strong point for this bagel shop. Customers benefit from both a **free parking lot** and **free street parking**, eliminating the common hassle of finding a spot in a busy shore town. For all patrons, the store provides a **wheelchair accessible parking lot**. As a designated spot for a **Quick visit**, the focus is on efficient, high-quality service, prioritizing options like **Takeout** to get you on your way quickly. However, the cheerful space also provides places to sit for those who wish to dine in.

---

## Extensive Services and Offerings

Gem's House of Bagels goes far beyond a plain bagel with cream cheese. Their menu is comprehensive, covering all three major dining options—breakfast, lunch, and catering—with high-quality ingredients and creative flair.

**Fresh Bagels and Spreads**: Available individually, by the **Half Dozen Bagels** ($13.00), or a **Dozen Bagels** ($25.00). Customers can choose from a huge variety of spreads, including gourmet flavors available in **Gourmet Spreads 1/2 Lb** ($5.95) and full 8oz or 16oz containers of Gems Cream Cheese.

**Signature Breakfast Sandwiches**: Creative and popular choices are their specialty, such as **The Rocket** (Pork roll, bacon, egg, cheese, and a hashbrown on a roll, $12.50) and the spicy **Angry Smurf** ($9.15). Healthier options like the **Hazlet's Finest** (Turkey, egg whites, cheese, and hot sauce on a wrap, $10.95) are also available, alongside a standard **Breakfast Sandwiches** option ($7.50).

**Specialty Lunch Sandwiches**: A full deli menu featuring hefty creations like **The Titan** (Chicken cutlet with Muenster, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onions, ranch, and BBQ, $14.95), **The Italian** ($13.95), and **The Brooklyn** ($14.95). They also offer a **Create Your Own** option ($13.95).

**Fresh Salads**: A variety of large, healthy lunch options are available, including the **Gem Salad** ($18.00) with honey turkey, walnuts, and raisins, or classic options like the **Chicken Caesar** ($16.50).

**In-House Bakery Items**: Beyond bagels, the bakery features sweet treats like **Crumb Cake** ($4.15), **Muffins** ($4.25), **Croissants** ($3.15), and the **Black & White Cookies** ($3.15).

**Grocery & Deli Items**: Selling products like **1LB PORK ROLL** ($12.99), **Dozen Eggs** ($6.99), and **1LB AMERICAN CHEESE** ($8.99), allowing customers to stock their home pantry with high-quality ingredients.

**Beverages**: A full selection of drinks, including fresh **Coffee & Tea** ($4.00), **Iced Coffee** ($4.75), **Pure Leaf** ($4.75), and **1/2 Gallon Milk** ($5.00).

---

## Key Features and Highlights

What truly sets Gem's House of Bagels apart for local New Jersey customers is the combination of its quality food and dedicated service, making it an ideal choice for both quick trips and weekend indulgence.

**Iconic Jersey Breakfast Sandwiches**: Items like "The Rocket" and the customer-favorite "Incredible Hulk" (mentioned in reviews) represent the pinnacle of New Jersey breakfast culture: stacked high, flavor-packed, and perfectly satisfying.

**Fresh Lox Selection**: Catering to the classic bagel and lox enthusiast, they offer **Fresh Lox & Cream Cheese** ($14.50) sandwiches and **Lox 3oz** ($12.99) for purchase, affirming their commitment to high-quality deli offerings.

**Ample Parking and Accessibility**: The provision of a **Free parking lot** and **Free street parking**, alongside accessible features, ensures a smooth and stress-free visit—a significant plus in the busy shore environment.

**Diverse Menu for All Dayparts**: The ability to serve everything from classic bagels with toppings to savory grilled items like **The Gem Burger** ($11.00) and large deli wraps makes it a one-stop shop for breakfast, lunch, or even an early dinner takeout.

**Positive and Cheerful Atmosphere**: Customer feedback highlights the **friendly staff** and the **open, sunny, and cheerful** space, indicating a pleasant environment for both quick takeout and a more relaxed visit.

---

## Contact Information

To order your dozen bagels, call ahead for a morning sandwich pickup, or inquire about catering options for your next beach gathering, please use the following contact details:

**Address:** 208 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732, USA

**Phone:** (732) 204-2058

**Mobile Phone:** +1 732-204-2058

---

## What is Worth Choosing Gem's House of Bagels

For New Jersey residents, especially those traveling to or living near the Highlands/Sandy Hook area, Gem's House of Bagels offers a superior choice for several compelling reasons. Firstly, their commitment to providing authentic, freshly baked bagels—a fundamental requirement in the Garden State—is constantly praised. Customers note the deliciousness of their bagels, including specialty varieties like the French Toast bagel, which speaks to their quality and creativity.

Secondly, the quality and generosity of their prepared food, specifically the **Breakfast Sandwiches** and **Lunch Sandwiches**, is a major draw. Signature items like “The Rocket” are widely beloved for their substantial size and perfect blend of classic Jersey flavors (Pork Roll, egg, cheese, and a hashbrown). These sandwiches offer excellent value and satisfaction, perfect before a long day on the sand or a busy commute.

While the menu prices are reflective of the premium quality and generous portions, the ability to also purchase essential items like **1LB PORK ROLL** and large tubs of their homemade **Gourmet Cream Cheese** makes it a convenient, all-in-one deli experience. Choosing Gem's House of Bagels means choosing a friendly, efficient local business that is dedicated to upholding the high standards of New Jersey bagel and deli fare. It’s the perfect place to start your day or satisfy a midday craving with food that is always fresh, flavorful, and made with a local touch.

Gem's House of Bagels Food & drink

Kids Menu
School Special $4.75
A bagel with a slice of ham and American cheese.

Salads
Chicken Caesar $16.50
Cut up chicken cutlet with Mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions and Caesar dressing with our homemade bagel croutons.
Howard Salad $16.50
Cracked pepper turkey, lettuce, Muenster cheese, tomatoes, onions, sweet peppers, and Italian dressing.
Chef Salad $16.50
Ham, turkey, American cheese, lettuce. Tomato, onions and sweet or hot peppers.
Gem Salad $18.00
Honey turkey with chopped walnuts and raisins on a bed of lettuce with creamy onion vinaigrette dressing and our homemade bagel croutons.
Sub Salad $16.50
Ham, salami, and Provolone with lettuce, tomato, onions, sweet peppers, balsamic vinegar, oil, salt, pepper, and oregano.
Tuna Or Chicken Salad $16.50
A scoop of either tuna or chicken salad on a bed of lettuce with tomatoes, onions, and sweet or hot peppers.
Roasted Chicken Salad $16.50
Boars head roasted chicken breast and Cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, tomatoes, onions and ranch dressing over a bed of shredded lettuce.

Grocery To Go
1LB PORK ROLL $12.99
Dozen Eggs $6.99
1LB AMERICAN CHEESE $8.99

Breakfast
Hazlet's Finest $10.95
Turkey, egg whites, cheese, and hot sauce on a wrap.
Breakfast Sandwiches $7.50
Create Your own sandwich
Angry Smurf $9.15
Sausage, bacon, egg, and cheese with spk, cream cheese, and hot sauce on a blueberry crunch bagel.
Meat-A-Tarian $12.50
Pork roll, bacon, sausage, roast beef, cheese, and hash brown.
The Texan $11.95
Roast beef, scrambled egg, Pepper Jack Cheese and jalapeno peppers
The Rocket $12.50
Pork roll, bacon, egg, cheese and a hashbrown on a roll.

From the Grill/Sides
Pork Roll $5.00
Hash Brown $3.00
Grilled Cheese $7.50
Bacon $7.00
The Gem Burger $11.00
1/3 lb burger on roll unless specified

Beverages
Pure Leaf $4.75
Brewed using freshly picked tea leaves so every sip is as sweet as the last.
Quick $3.95
chocolate, strawberry or vanilla
Yoohoo $3.95
Juice (12oz) $4.15
1/2 OJ $8.50
Pepsi 2 Liter $6.00
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
Iced Coffee $4.75
Gatorade (20 Oz.) $3.50
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
1/2 Gallon Milk $5.00
Snapple $3.95
lemon, diet lemon, raspberry, diet raspberry, peach, diet peach
Chocolate Milk $3.25
Chocolate,
Coffee & Tea $4.00
Soda (20 Oz.) $3.95

Bagels
Buy 1 Dozen Bagels $25.00
click 12 bagel types if you need more then one of any kind place in notes
BAGEL With TOPPINGS $3.75
You can only do one bagel at a time
Fresh Lox & Cream Cheese $14.50
You can only do one bagel at a time
1/2 Dozen Bagels $13.00
choose 6 bagels if you need more then one of any kind please write in note

Bakery Items
Croissant $3.15
Strawberry Cheese, Cream Cheese
Brownies $4.25
Strawberry Cheese, Cream Cheese
Filled Croissants $3.15
Strawberry Cheese , Cream Cheese
Muffins $4.25
Corn , Blueberry, Chocolate Chip ,
Gems Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.15
Strawberry Cheese, Cream Cheese
Muffin With Butter $5.75
choc chip blueberry corn
Black & White Cookies $3.15
Strawberry Cheese, Cream Cheese
Crumb Cake $4.15
Strawberry Cheese, Cream Cheese
Apple Turnovers $3.15
Strawberry Cheese, Cream Cheese

Lunch Sandwiches
Giuseppe $14.95
Chicken cutlets with Mozzarella, roasted peppers and balsamic.
The Rancher $13.95
Grilled chicken breast and melted Cheddar cheese with bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing.
The Vegetarian $10.75
Swiss, American, Muenster and jalapeno cheese with lettuce, tomato, onions, sliced pickles, and Honey mustard.
The Brooklyn $14.95
Prosciutto, salami and hot capicola with Provolone cheese, roasted red peppers oil/vinegar salt, pepper, and oregano.
The Gem $13.25
Our homemade chicken salad and Provolone cheese with lettuce, sweet peppers and balsamic vinegar on one of our freshly baked bagels.
The Titan $14.95
Chicken cutlet with melted Muenster, lettuce, tomato, onions, crispy bacon with ranch and bbq.
Create Your Own $13.95
Lunch Sandwich
The Philadelphia $14.95
Grilled roast beef smothered with jalapeno cheese, hot or sweet peppers, onions, and mayo.
The Italian $13.95
Ham, salami, and Provolone with lettuce, tomato, onions, Italian seasoning oil, and vinegar.
The Irishmen $14.95
Grilled corned beef and pastrami with melted Cheddar gems homemade coleslaw, thousand island, and horseradish sauce.
The Middletown $12.95
Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, and balsamic glaze.

Butter, Cream Cheese, Gourmet Spreads
Gourmet Spreads 1/2 Lb $5.95
Your choice of Veggie , Scallion , Walnut Raisin, Jalapeno , Strawberry
Gourmet Cream Cheese And Bacon $7.75
8oz Gems Cream Cheese $4.50
Bagel With Gourmet Cream Cheese $6.75
your choice of veggie, scallion, walnut raisin, jalapeno or strawberry
Breakstone Butter 8oz $6.99
16oz Gems Cream Cheese $8.50
Temp Tee 8oz $5.18
Philly Cream Cheese 8oz $6.99
Lox 3oz $12.99

Gem's House of Bagels Details

Service options
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Gem's House of Bagels Photos

Gem's House of Bagels Location

Gem's House of Bagels

New Jersey Monmouth County Highlands Bay Avenue

208 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732, USA

Gem's House of Bagels Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 22 user reviews.

sandwichesmenuitalian subspreadsbagel with cream cheeseprice

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Very pleased with this new bagel shop in the highlands! Great selections of bagels, spreads, sandwiches, and pastries. The staff was friendly and the space was very open, sunny, and cheerful with places to sit. I got an egg everything bagel with cream cheese and a French toast bagel and it was delish. Ill be back :) I have one suggestion, maybe to add some fresh squeezed orange juice to the menu 😊
May 25 · Emily Miller
We stopped by Gems bagels on a day headed for a sunrise at Sandy hook.our two favorites are the incredible Hulk and The rocket sandwiches. This place never disappoints and love the staff at Gems. Thank you for a great breakfast!!
September 08 · Art Fernandez
A fantastic deli with a ton of breakfast and lunch options. The staff is friendly and helpful and the owner was a pleasure to speak with. We will definitely be trying their other locations!
August 14 · Tony Malda
We got two bagels with cream cheese and a muffin. Bagels were great. Muffin - meh. Spent $12Friendly service and welcoming space. Open layout, ample seating, nice and clean.The only thing that made me feel uncomfortable- not one price listed ANYWHERE. Transparency keeps us honest and accountable. If you don’t want to list them because it’s a hassle to update signage and printed menus - we live in a time where you can scan a QR code. Easy peasy.What’s to stop them from arbitrarily charging what they want from person to person.I tried placing an online order prior to our visit to get an idea of pricing - same order was $5 more than our in store order.Not sure what’s what.Good bagels though! If you have money coming out of your ears and don’t care what you pay - go to town 😜
August 17 · Carol Vanessa
Gems is absolutely amazing! Our production crew made a stop there only to be met with the kindest staff! Even the owner, Donna, was amazing! We loved the atmosphere. Can’t help but feel like family.They have the best Italian sandwich and we’d recommend trying the bagel with the scallion cream cheese. This was such a great spot — especially with us not being from around here.
March 31 · Rachel