GEMMIES, INC. — BAKED GOODS. ONLINE STORE. PICK-UP ONLY. LONG ISLAND, NY Introduce
Welcome to the sweet world of GEMMIES, INC. — BAKED GOODS, a local gem that has been delighting taste buds across Long Island, NY. In a city where bakeries are a dime a dozen, GEMMIES stands out not just for its exquisite flavors but for its unique, customer-focused approach. This isn't your average walk-in bakery; GEMMIES operates as an online store, providing fresh, made-to-order baked goods that you can conveniently pick up. This model ensures that every item you receive is as fresh as possible, baked with care and precision, just for you. Whether you’re planning a party, celebrating a holiday, or simply craving a delicious treat, GEMMIES offers a perfect blend of quality, convenience, and unforgettable taste.
The bakery has quickly become a local favorite, with a growing reputation built on rave reviews and word-of-mouth recommendations. Customers consistently praise the professionalism and kindness of the owner, noting the personal touch that makes every transaction special. The commitment to quality is evident in every bite, from the light and fluffy ricotta cookies to the rich and satisfying chocolate cookies and the classic, comforting apple pie. It's a place where the focus is on creating baked goods that are "just right"—not overly sweet, but perfectly balanced in flavor. This dedication to craftsmanship and customer satisfaction is what makes GEMMIES, INC. more than just a bakery; it's a part of the community’s festive and celebratory moments.
In an age where quality can sometimes be overlooked, GEMMIES proves that a passion for baking and a commitment to using high-quality ingredients can truly make a difference. The bakery's philosophy revolves around taste and ingredient quality, a fact that customers quickly notice and appreciate. This focus ensures that every item, whether a batch of cookies for a party or a pie for a family dinner, is made with the highest standards. The result is a product that not only tastes incredible but also feels homemade and wholesome. For New Yorkers in the Long Island area, GEMMIES, INC. is quickly becoming the go-to destination for exceptional baked goods, a place where you can trust that what you're getting is nothing short of amazing.
---
### Location and Accessibility
GEMMIES, INC. is strategically located to serve the Long Island community with ease. The bakery's pickup location is at 734 Franklin Ave Suite 753, Garden City, NY 11530, USA. Garden City is a well-known area in Long Island, and its central location makes it easily accessible for residents from various surrounding towns. Franklin Avenue is a major thoroughfare, making navigation straightforward whether you're driving or using public transportation. The suite is part of a commercial building, and while the bakery itself is an online-first operation, the designated pickup point is designed to be convenient and hassle-free for customers.
Given that GEMMIES operates on a pick-up only basis, accessibility is key. The location in Garden City offers ample parking opportunities nearby, making it simple for customers to quickly swing by and collect their orders. The process is streamlined to ensure minimal waiting time, allowing you to get your fresh baked goods and be on your way. For those using public transit, the area is also well-served by local buses and is not far from the Garden City LIRR station, making it a viable option for those without a car. This thoughtful consideration for accessibility highlights GEMMIES' commitment to providing a seamless and enjoyable customer experience from the moment you place your order to the moment you take your first delicious bite.
The choice of a central Long Island location underscores the bakery’s dedication to serving the local community. It positions GEMMIES as a truly local business, deeply embedded in the rhythm of New York life. This localized approach allows them to focus on the needs and tastes of their neighbors, fostering a sense of community and trust. For anyone living in or around Garden City, this convenient location is a huge plus, making it easy to grab a last-minute treat or pick up a pre-ordered special for a gathering without a long commute. The pickup-only model also helps in maintaining the quality and freshness of the baked goods, as each item is prepared specifically for its intended recipient shortly before pickup.
---
### Services Offered
Online Ordering: GEMMIES, INC. operates as an online store, providing a modern and convenient way for customers to browse and purchase their favorite baked goods from the comfort of their homes. This service is available 24/7, making it easy to place an order whenever inspiration strikes.
Pickup Only: The bakery offers a streamlined pickup service from its Garden City location. This model ensures that every order is fresh and ready for collection at a pre-arranged time, eliminating the need to wait in line and guaranteeing that your baked goods are at their peak freshness.
Custom Orders for Events: While the online store offers a fantastic selection, GEMMIES also caters to larger events and parties. Customers can place custom orders for festivities, holidays, and other special occasions, ensuring they have a generous supply of crowd-pleasing treats like ricotta cookies and apple pies.
Fresh Baked Goods: All items are baked fresh for each order. This commitment to freshness is a cornerstone of their service, setting them apart from bakeries that might have goods sitting on a shelf for hours. From cookies to bread and pies, you can be sure everything is baked just for you.
---
### Features and Highlights
Exceptional Ricotta Cookies: Described by many as "light and fluffy," these cookies are a flagship item. They are not overly sweet and have a delicate flavor that makes them a favorite among both new and returning customers.
Crowd-Pleasing Apple Pie: The apple pie has received high praise, with customers loving its homemade taste and quality ingredients. It’s a classic dessert done exceptionally well, making it a perfect centerpiece for any gathering.
High-Quality Ingredients: A key feature of GEMMIES is its unwavering focus on the quality of ingredients. This dedication results in baked goods that not only taste delicious but also have a clean, authentic flavor profile.
Professional and Friendly Service: The owner and staff are known for their kindness and professional demeanor. This personal touch fosters a warm and inviting relationship with customers, making the entire experience from ordering to pickup a pleasant one.
Perfectly Balanced Flavors: GEMMIES' baked goods are celebrated for not being "too sweet." This thoughtful approach to flavor balance ensures that the natural taste of the ingredients shines through, creating a more sophisticated and enjoyable eating experience.
Customizable for Celebrations: The online store model and personal service make it easy to place orders for special occasions, ensuring that your holiday parties and family gatherings are filled with high-quality, delicious baked goods that everyone will love.
---
### Contact Information
Address: 734 Franklin Ave Suite 753, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
Phone: (516) 226-7763
---
### Conclusion: Why GEMMIES, INC. is Suitable for Locals
For the residents of New York, particularly those on Long Island, GEMMIES, INC. offers a unique and highly suitable option for all their baked good needs. The shift from a traditional storefront to a modern, online-first model caters perfectly to the busy, on-the-go lifestyle of New Yorkers. This allows you to plan and order your baked goods in advance, ensuring you get exactly what you want, when you want it, without the risk of a favorite item being sold out. The convenient pickup location in Garden City makes it a simple stop on your way home or while running errands, saving you time and hassle.
The community-centric approach is another major reason why GEMMIES resonates with locals. The owner’s friendly and professional service creates a welcoming atmosphere, even through an online platform. This personal connection, combined with the overwhelmingly positive feedback on platforms like Google Reviews, builds a strong sense of trust and reliability. Locals know they are supporting a business that cares deeply about its craft and its customers. The emphasis on high-quality ingredients and perfectly balanced flavors ensures that every item is a treat, whether it's for a special occasion or a simple indulgence. For families and individuals in the New York area looking for a reliable, delicious, and convenient source for baked goods, GEMMIES, INC. is an excellent choice. It's not just about a purchase; it's about becoming part of a community that appreciates fresh, handmade quality, making it a new tradition for many households.
GEMMIES, INC. — BAKED GOODS. ONLINE STORE. PICK-UP ONLY. LONG ISLAND, NY Services
ARTISANAL BREADS
- Gemmies Morning Toast®️ US$9.71
Sourdough Loaf x1
- Sunday Dinner Baguette US$6.71
16” Salty Baguette Loaf x1
- English Muffins US$10.55
English Muffins x6
- Gemmies Rye US$9.71
Rye Sourdough Loaf x1
- Egg Challah Braid US$17.12
16” Egg Challah Braid x1
- Brioche US$17.12
Brioche Loaf x1
- Egg Challah Burger Rolls US$17.12
Egg Challah Burger Rolls X12
- White Sandwich Bread US$9.40
White Sandwich Bread Loaf x1
- Mama’s Tiramisu US$120.00
Serves 8-10 adults
- Double Crust Apple Pie US$35.60
Serves 8-10 adults
- Eggless Chocolate Chip Cookies US$24.73
Cookies x12
- Gemmies Whole Wheat US$9.71
Whole Red Wheat Sourdough Loaf x1
- Cinnamon Rolls US$22.79
Cinnamon Rolls x4
GEMMIES, INC. — BAKED GOODS. ONLINE STORE. PICK-UP ONLY. LONG ISLAND, NY Details
Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
- On-site services
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
GEMMIES, INC. — BAKED GOODS. ONLINE STORE. PICK-UP ONLY. LONG ISLAND, NY Photos








GEMMIES, INC. — BAKED GOODS. ONLINE STORE. PICK-UP ONLY. LONG ISLAND, NY Location
GEMMIES, INC. — BAKED GOODS. ONLINE STORE. PICK-UP ONLY. LONG ISLAND, NY
734 Franklin Ave Suite 753, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
GEMMIES, INC. — BAKED GOODS. ONLINE STORE. PICK-UP ONLY. LONG ISLAND, NY Reviews
ricotta cookiesapple piesour doughchocolate chipcinnamon rollsingredientsquality
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Gemmies bakery is amazing. They are very professional and kind. The owner is very nice. I love the ricotta cookies. They are light and fluffy and delicious. I am in love with the chocolate cookies, ricotta cookies and apple pie. I'm placing another order as I am typing this. My family loves these fresh baked goods. Everything is not sweet or an overpower of taste it is just right. Place your order for holidays and festivities!
October 25 · Tori WilsonI ordered a bunch of cookies and bread from Gemmies for a party I hosted and it turned out they were the most popular items there. People kept asking me where I got those delicious ricotta cookies from and they absolutely loved the apple pie. It’s rare to find a bakery that focuses on taste as well as the quality of the ingredients. I will definitely recommend Gemmies to all of my friends and family. Its going to be our go-to bakery from now on.
October 26 · Savannah LuoYou can just tell that these products are fresh with quality ingredients. Everything tastes AMAZING. My favorite is the ricotta cookie... one dozen of these cookies are just NOT enough. Chocolate chip is delicious too! The Nutella bread was soft and fluffy. I recommend you try everything this bakery has to offer!
October 24 · Malisa CollazoThe sour dough bread was the best I have ever tasted. It was so good even plain with nothing on it. Fluffy and full of flavor. We will definitely be making it a regular weekly order for our family. Just excellent!
January 01 · Marc PescatoreThe cinnamon rolls are AMAZING!! They are so fresh, warm, and deliciously gooey. They just melt in your mouth.
October 26 · Melissa Pinello DiPalma
More Bakery Near Me
The French Workshop4.0 (1379 reviews)191 7th St, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
Doz Bagels 7th Street Garden City4.0 (65 reviews)180 7th St, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
andu's0.0 (0 reviews)9 Brook St, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
Special Sweets5.0 (6 reviews)71 Clinton Rd, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
Wolferman Bakert1.0 (25 reviews)2021 1-800-Flowers.com, Inc, 1 Old Country Rd, Carle Place, NY 11514, USA
Panaderu00eda Sevillana Bakery Inc4.0 (871 reviews)372 Fulton Ave, Hempstead, NY 11550, USA
Mrs.Fields & TCBY5.0 (46 reviews)630 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
Baked by Melissa3.0 (41 reviews)Main Level across from Apple, 630 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
Be-Bop Bagel4.0 (83 reviews)35 Main St Unit C, Hempstead, NY 11550, USA
Cinnabon3.0 (60 reviews)630 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
Auntie Anne's3.0 (20 reviews)630 Old Country Rd Space #2020, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
BJ's Bakery3.0 (4 reviews)699 Stewart Ave, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Einstein Bros. Bagels3.0 (350 reviews)
By Tess5.0 (20 reviews)
Walmart Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)
Goldie’s Donuts & Bakery4.0 (211 reviews)
Best Donuts4.0 (133 reviews)
Sweet Detente | Organic International Desserts5.0 (12 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Make the Best Homemade Pecan Pie: A Step-by-Step Guide
How to Make the Best Homemade Honey Buns
How to Make Healthy Homemade Chocolate Fudge
How to Make the Perfect Fresh Strawberry Cake: A Step-by-Step Guide
How to Bake the Best Classic Chocolate Chip Muffins at Home
How to Make the Best Homemade Pecan Pie Step by Step
